Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01637 · Session 5

Ship-to-ship oil transfers and trust port accountability

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2016 Environment & Energy
Signatures
43
2,087 online signatures with a country
Comments
242
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that environmental legislation in Scotland is sufficient to prevent ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil in environmentally sensitive locations, such as the Inner Moray Firth, and to enhance the accountability of trust port boards to their stakeholders.

What the petitioner did first

We have raised the issue with MSPs and MPs including John Finnie MSP, Mark Ruskell MSP, Kate Forbes MSP, Gail Ross MSP, Drew Hendry MP and Ian Blackford MP.

In addition, since a specific proposal for ship to ship transfers of crude oil at anchorages in the Inner Moray Firth within the boundary of the Cromarty Firth Port Authority was announced we have undertaken a wide variety of actions to oppose the proposal. This has included, but is not limited to,—
· Formation of a pressure group
· Organisation of public meetings in communities around the Inner Moray Firth
· Raising the issue through local media and online campaigning
· Responding to consultations
· Lobbying the Cromarty Firth Port Authority, and
· Engaging in discussions with relevant bodies and individuals such as SEPA, SNH, The Highland Council, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, Prof Paul Thompson and RSPB Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  2. 2 May 2017
    Meeting of the Parliament
    Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (Cromarty and Moray Firths)
    1 mention
  3. 22 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 27 Jun 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 5 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 27 Jan 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,087 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,393 66.7%
  2. United Kingdom341 16.3%
  3. England259 12.4%
  4. United States27 1.3%
  5. Wales15 0.7%
  6. Canada7 0.3%
  7. Slovenia6 0.3%
  8. New Zealand5 0.2%
  9. Germany5 0.2%
  10. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  11. 16 other countries25 1.2%

Comments

242 comments, oldest first
242 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Judy Revell 30 Jan 2017
    Please help to prevent ship to ship transfers from happening here.
  2. Loreine Thomson 30 Jan 2017
    The Nature Conversation Scotland Regulations 2004 give full protection to Dolphins, as does the Habitats Directive. The Scottish Government must grant an EPS Licence if ship to ship oil transfers commence in an area of high conservation such as the Moray Firth. The Scottish Government should, without any equivocation, refuse to grant such a licence as they will be in breach of Scottish and European legislation.

    Cromarty Firth Port Authority is gamekeeper turned poacher and the Scottish Government should apply good governance and not allow CFPA to be the approval authority, who allows ship to ship oil transfers within its own harbour jurisdiction, applicant, and principal financial beneficiary. An independent arbiter should be nominated by the Scottish Government to assess whether the financial reasons being put forward by the CFPA are valid, whether an alternative location such as Nigg Jetty is more suitable, and whether there are any IROPI which could be applied. CFPA cannot evidence lack of bias, conflict of interest, financial incentive, or IROPI,

    he Maritime Coastguard Agency are not permitted to reject CFPA's Oil Spill Contingency Plan and can only keep returning it until it meets their regulations and requirements, which must include compliance with the Marine Scotland Act 2010 and Marine Consequential Provisions Order 2010, Scotland National Marine Plan, and the other regulations I have already mentioned above.

    Regardless of whether MCA grant a ship to ship oil transfer licence, this does not discharge either of them from their duties under Scottish and European legislation.

    The devastation to the marine and coastal environments are beyond price. The damage to the coastal communities in terms of Tourism, beaches, employment, scenic and visual beauty and landscape will mean the death knell in terms of economy to everyone who lives along the Moray Firth and in the Highlands in general. Our environment is priceless.
  3. David Thomson 30 Jan 2017
    To spoil the scenic beauty of the area with parked tankers, noise, oil wash and spillage, ballast and bilge waste would have a devastating effect on the tourism necessary to maintain the local economies of the area.
  4. ellie 30 Jan 2017
    I don't agree with the petition because ................
  5. Jessica Wolff 30 Jan 2017
    The implications of an accident are too harmful to the environment and the community.
  6. Francis D.McWiLLiams. 30 Jan 2017
    Correct me if I am wrong but the UK and Scottish Governments and All Council's have signed up for the Bioversity Plan?.
  7. Chris Whittingham 30 Jan 2017
    Why do we let greedy people destroy the things we love. What right does this company have to do so. I say NONE, well not in any fair society. So let us play fair and reject this dangerous proposal. Let us speak out for the environment, the sea and it's creatures and for the future visitors to this naturally beautiful coastline, it's about time we did before it becomes to late. For me saying NO is the moral and decent choice. NO SHIP to SHIP TRANSFERS.
  8. Jane cameron 30 Jan 2017
    Scottish parliament
    - dolphins don't have access to email
    - help them....
  9. Sandra Ross 31 Jan 2017
    Please keep our dolphin and other sealife safe
  10. henry Mckenzie Joihnston 31 Jan 2017
    I sign as the widower of a direct descendant of Cromarty's famous Hugh Miller who has contributed charitable donations to Cromarty and her people and believes this to be a very important issue.
  11. Denise Chappell 31 Jan 2017
    We implore the government not to go ahead with this proposal. Our wildlife needs continued nurturing not dismantling, particularly in this environmentally rich area.
  12. Colin Dunn 31 Jan 2017
    This is a completely inappropriate proposal for this location. Quite aside from the ecological issues that the application has failed to consider properly, the proposal threatens to seriously damage over £200million of local business which relies on the the area being clean and safe, and being perceived as such.
  13. Laura Whateley 31 Jan 2017
    Such a beautiful part of the country where the economy benefits from the dolphins. Why risk this with ship to ship transfers. It's a ridiculous proposition.
  14. Clare 31 Jan 2017
    Please don't do this, an environmental catastrophe would be too awful to contemplate.
  15. John Dickinson 31 Jan 2017
    It's so depressing that we have to have petitions like this. Clearly those in power are not protecting the environment, but are keen to promote big business at all costs.
  16. Mairi Duncan 1 Feb 2017
    Why ruin this beautiful part of the world with the threat of a catastrophic oil spill! Completely unnecessary! Think about the environment for a change Scottish Government!
  17. Paula Craib 1 Feb 2017
    Our precious wildlife must be protected.
  18. Kate McArdle 1 Feb 2017
    I am very worried about this proposal as the negative impact is far reaching and financial gain seems small. Constant noise (much louder than we have already from tankers and rigs) light pollution (no night sky left at all) odours
    - maybe, visually not pleasing for natives or visitors, then the potential negative impact on wildlife is huge and who will pay for spillage.....
  19. Donald Vass 1 Feb 2017
    As well as the potential damage to local wildlife and the natural environment, there is also the negative impact on tourism in this beautiful area of Scotland to take into account.
  20. Denise Waddell 1 Feb 2017
    Who in their right mind would even consider this proposal in such a beautiful stretch of water
  21. Lesley briant 1 Feb 2017
    Ballast water, noise and pollution
    - let alone oil spills, will destroy the Moray Firth marine environment for ever
  22. Mary King 1 Feb 2017
    What cost to the Moray and Cromarty Firths if the Scottish government allows ship to ship oil transfers. It only takes one spill to devastate one of the most beautiful regions of Scotland, ruining the environment for wildlife, in particular the bottlenose dolphins, and the tourist economy.
  23. Reg Stuart 1 Feb 2017
    Unbelievable how this government & politicians are hell bent on destroying the Scottish landscapes & views with industry & especially here with the resident dolphins & other such wild life.
  24. Shona 2 Feb 2017
    The devastating impact oil spills have on the environment is not worth the risk.. simply put, avoid the possibilities of it happening. Prevention is cheaper, safer and happier! Please make the right decision.
  25. Eileen Fraser 2 Feb 2017
    Let's not take unnecessary risks for our wildlife. Keep them safe.
  26. Simon Arnold 2 Feb 2017
    Total lunacy to proceed with these plans in such an important ecosystem for vulnerable wildlife and local tourism.
  27. Sharon Escritt 2 Feb 2017
    It is our duty to protect wildlife
  28. Ellen 2 Feb 2017
    We need to conserve and protect our wild dolphins and other wild animals from harm of any description
  29. Morag Forsyth 2 Feb 2017
    Doesn't need a major oil spill to impact Nairn and the Moray, with the present tanker moored opposite Nairn at present, we're subject to noise and fumes. And the current light pollution from the rig and ships. Also this whole Firth region on both sides depends on tourism, especially wild-life tourism.
  30. Cathy Train 2 Feb 2017
    Oil spill in other parts of the world have had catastrophic effects on both the environment and wildlife- Please don't let it happen in Scotland. Any risk even minimal is not worth it.
  31. Pauline Boyle 2 Feb 2017
    It would be a travesty to let these waters become polluted.
  32. Mary doonan 3 Feb 2017
    Must protect all these wonderful creatures from man's greed
  33. Michael Turriani 3 Feb 2017
    Please come clean on our water!
  34. Elizabeth Watt 3 Feb 2017
    Please protect our precious wild life
  35. Michael Ellison 3 Feb 2017
    The wildlife resource of the Moray Firth is a world asset that will provide pleasure for generations to come. It should not be destroyed by get rich quick shipping companies transferring oil in the Firth.
  36. Sharon Sonhurst 3 Feb 2017
    We must protect our seas from pollution & for the marine life to survive, this has a major environmental impact on the whole world we must save our planet from being poisoned. Prevention us the best cure. We have the technology to find a suitable solution to prevent pollution.
  37. Evelyne Adamson 3 Feb 2017
    This atrocity should never be allowed and I hope the government will stop this happening, is an event that's waiting to happen and our beautiful dolphins and other sea mammals have to protected by law
  38. Alasdair 3 Feb 2017
    A bad idea. Wholly unnecessary.
  39. D Q 3 Feb 2017
    We must protect the environment and the amazing wildlife that lives in it, so it is safe for many generations to come
    - not support short-lived human business interests. You wouldn't do a number two in your own bath but yet these companies think it is okay to risk polluting the habitat of many marine creatures, that benefit our lives hugely by their existence. The seas are precious! Wake up!
  40. Kathleen Dobson 3 Feb 2017
    They deserve a life!!
  41. Peter dobson 3 Feb 2017
    These animals deserve a life!!
  42. Mary Clouston 4 Feb 2017
    Our area in the Moray Firth should be a protected for all sea life , Dolphins are so important to mankind and to the well being of any part of the world.Don't destroy nature as that will destroy all humanity- it's not " money or your life ?" It's about looking after and caring For Our World !!
  43. Sheila struth 4 Feb 2017
    I live in a coastal town and feel strongly about this issue even though it's in Scotland which is still a part of the uk
  44. Angela Findlay 4 Feb 2017
    I am astounded that this may go ahead, ALL the animals including the Whales and Dolphinswill be affected, this could mean the end of all life in this area when an oil spill takes place and it's not an "if" it is a "when" as an accident is inevitable
  45. Thomas Leslie Marshall 4 Feb 2017
    If ship to ship oil transfers are inappropriate in the industrial seaway of the Forth how much more inappropriate are they in such an environmentally important, vulnerable and beautiful seascape as the Moray Firth with its vital importance to the tourist industry which is the economic backbone to this part of the Highlands and a vital heart of the local ecosystem.
  46. Julie 5 Feb 2017
    Leave nature at peace ! Do NOT put it at risk !!
  47. Anna S. King 5 Feb 2017
    Please introduce legislation to prevent oil spillage. Please introduce further sustainable power sources than hydro-carbon based ones, e.g. P.V. Panels on all new-build as standard. There must be sensible balance between humanity and Nature, for the benefit of all, not just profit for a few.
  48. Ellen Maxwell 5 Feb 2017
    As an accommodation provider with 2 cottages I am devastated that our wonderful beaches and wildlife will be put at risk. Tourism is vital to our economy and it will be devastating to put it in such jeopardy
  49. Liz Gould 5 Feb 2017
    What a stupid, dangerous idea !! The wildlife in this area is second to now & to take a risk like this is foolhardy at best
  50. david buxton 7 Feb 2017
    let's keep what we have