Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01637 · Session 5

Ship-to-ship oil transfers and trust port accountability

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2016 Environment & Energy
Signatures
43
2,087 online signatures with a country
Comments
242
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that environmental legislation in Scotland is sufficient to prevent ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil in environmentally sensitive locations, such as the Inner Moray Firth, and to enhance the accountability of trust port boards to their stakeholders.

What the petitioner did first

We have raised the issue with MSPs and MPs including John Finnie MSP, Mark Ruskell MSP, Kate Forbes MSP, Gail Ross MSP, Drew Hendry MP and Ian Blackford MP.

In addition, since a specific proposal for ship to ship transfers of crude oil at anchorages in the Inner Moray Firth within the boundary of the Cromarty Firth Port Authority was announced we have undertaken a wide variety of actions to oppose the proposal. This has included, but is not limited to,—
· Formation of a pressure group
· Organisation of public meetings in communities around the Inner Moray Firth
· Raising the issue through local media and online campaigning
· Responding to consultations
· Lobbying the Cromarty Firth Port Authority, and
· Engaging in discussions with relevant bodies and individuals such as SEPA, SNH, The Highland Council, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, Prof Paul Thompson and RSPB Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  2. 2 May 2017
    Meeting of the Parliament
    Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (Cromarty and Moray Firths)
    1 mention
  3. 22 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 27 Jun 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 5 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 27 Jan 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,087 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,393 66.7%
  2. United Kingdom341 16.3%
  3. England259 12.4%
  4. United States27 1.3%
  5. Wales15 0.7%
  6. Canada7 0.3%
  7. Slovenia6 0.3%
  8. New Zealand5 0.2%
  9. Germany5 0.2%
  10. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  11. 16 other countries25 1.2%

Comments

242 comments, oldest first
242 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Lynn Birch 22 Jan 2017
    This proposal is wrong, an oil spillage would be a disaster to the fragile marine environment and tourism industry
  2. Alastair Field 22 Jan 2017
    I am against ship to ship oil transfers in the Moray Firth and any other environmentally vulnerable areas in Scotland
  3. Eric Craig 22 Jan 2017
    Risks outweigh the benefits
  4. Andreas Schulz 22 Jan 2017
    I have a 4 start B&B and this ship to ship would hurt my business and danger that guests don't come anymore . so I'm against this ship to ship transfer ... Thanks a lot Andreas Schulz
  5. Caroline Bray 22 Jan 2017
    I come to Scotland to see the amazing wildlife both on land and at sea. The value of the environment is beyond any financial amount and it must not be put at risk of pollution through accidents during ship to ship oil transfers. We all have a responsibility to care for the oceans and the creature that live in them.
  6. Loriana Pauli 22 Jan 2017
    Yes, I believe that environmental legislation should prevent ship-to-ship oil transfers in environmentally sensitive locations?
    Yes, I do agree that ship-to-ship oil transfers pose risks to wildlife and local economies?
  7. Claudia 22 Jan 2017
    It seems to be a time where in various places on our place real people power is grown more and more successful. Long may it last
  8. Verity Walker 22 Jan 2017
    I cannot believe that parliament or the Marine authorities are going to permit the Port of Cromarty Firth Authority to risk damaging our marine environment in order to make a £750K per annum. Are our dolphins worth that little to our Highland economy? Our little community café relies on a clean beach and a natural 'feel'. There are enough tankers out there already. Please help POCF look for alternative means of raising the investment they need in their cruise port, such as an Oil Rig Platform and North Sea Oil visitor centre which would attract tourists from Scotland an all over the world.
  9. Jennifer Rossa 22 Jan 2017
    It's outrageous to even consider this if you take into account the risk of possible damage to the environment. Companies just don't care, it's all about more!!!
  10. Gill Smith 22 Jan 2017
    We need to ensure that the fragile ecosystem of the sea is fully protected.
  11. Sandra Good 22 Jan 2017
    Do not do this protect our environment
  12. Kevin Goodwin 22 Jan 2017
    We went to see the dolphins last year and going again this year. My partner loves them. It's good for Scottish tourism eco friendly style. If there is a chance of even 1% of oil spill think better and say no. Not to mention traffic and water noise. These dolphins are unique to Scotland not to mention othe wildlife. Scottish politicians seem to be clever and care unlike cronies in London. Please do the right thing!
  13. Patricia connell 22 Jan 2017
    We should protect our waters
  14. Matthew Rose 22 Jan 2017
    This is a poor plan in a wholly inappropriate location.
  15. Gill Johnson 22 Jan 2017
    Was the centre of a recent 3 night stay in Inverness. Damage this and you damage tourist spending.
  16. Jane Kelly 23 Jan 2017
    it's important to achieve a balance between economic activity and conservation. Short term and short sighted options shouldn't be taken which put profit first whilst disregarding the potential to cause harm to sea life and the surrounding environment.
  17. Jane Dervish 23 Jan 2017
    I believe it is our duty to save the environment of our dolphins we have to protect them, all too many wild life are being threatened to extinction due to mans actions, we must take fight for them, their survival depends on it.......
  18. Irene Ross 23 Jan 2017
    I am very unhappy that these sort of applications can be pushed through by the uninformed few members of a Trust of a Port Authority, without a Local Council having the full implications of the negative effects of such an application before them while making their initial decisions, and on the final decision of one remote Westminster Minister. All this, against the interests of the local environment and the views of it's surrounding communities is completely unacceptable in my opinion and I ask that the Scottish Parliament take every step possible, within the law, to protect our precious shores, ecology, wildlife, tourist industry and employment against this negative, careless profiteering for short term gain, type of application.
  19. Ian Williams 23 Jan 2017
    This is a preventable tragedy in the making, the Scottish government must stop this now.
  20. Lily Byron 23 Jan 2017
    Please prevent ship to ship oil transfers in the inner Moray Firth.
  21. Duncan Murchison 23 Jan 2017
    spoil area of natural beauty
  22. Jacqueline Govier 23 Jan 2017
    There should be no ship to ship oil transfers, the potential hazards to wildlife, the environment and the local economies are enormous. Such risks should not be taken.
  23. Sheena Thompson 23 Jan 2017
    I really do not understand why this ship to ship transfer is even being considered in the Moray Firth and why we are risking the beauty and environment of the area at all.
  24. Edward Bamber 23 Jan 2017
    They always say it's safe until it goes wrong , then there's no way back,
  25. Debra Syms 23 Jan 2017
    Please think hard about allowing ship to ship oil transfers in the Cromarty and Moray Firths. Do we really want to risk the habitat of the marine animals that live in the firth, apart from the dolphins which bring a huge amount of interest from tourists to the area, we have recently had visits from humpback whales this past month. It would be criminal if ship to ship oil transfers were to go ahead and spoil one of the few remaining natural areas of Scotland. If oil leaks happen and the shores were awash with the bodies of dead dolphins and other marine life it would be a huge disaster to the local community and taint the image of Scotland. People come to the Highlands and Islands to enjoy it's natural beauty and wildlife, please don't risk spoiling our beautiful environment for future generations and the creatures who inhabit it.
  26. Diana Sidaway 23 Jan 2017
    Absolutely believe this should not go ahead.
  27. Iain Alistair Carlton Brown 23 Jan 2017
    The risk is too great to take.
  28. Alan barron 23 Jan 2017
    Common sense must prevail to ensure that ship to ship transfers of oil never happen in our beautiful firth.
  29. Francis D.McWiLLiams. 23 Jan 2017
    It is my understanding that should there be a Major Oil Spill then the Highland Council could go Bankrupt?
  30. Eve McEnally 23 Jan 2017
    I have been coming to the Moray Firth for the last 20 years to see these magnificent dolphins in their natural habit. Please ,please ensure that you do not allow any chance of pollution and harm to their environment!
  31. William Forrest 23 Jan 2017
    I believe that ship to ship oil transfers should be prevented in coastal waters and that environmental legislation should be of such clarity that this will nullify any need for UK applications for such initiatives in Scotland's coastal waters. In this scenario, permissions will be made a redundant process, saving a lot of time and money and securing the nstural world of wild life and securing the fish industry from oil spill disasters.
  32. Mrs.Dale Wallace 23 Jan 2017
    Please please leave this beautiful part of the U.K. alone. The dolphins are a huge tourist attraction (we come here every year, and have got to know a lot of the locals over the years). it never ceases to amaze me how many people come and stand on the shores for hours on end, hoping for a glimpse of these majestic creatures. Please don't take that away.
  33. Jenni milligan 23 Jan 2017
    There is too much at risk to our beautiful environment and dolphins and whales for this to be allowed to go ahead!
  34. Audrey Johnston 23 Jan 2017
    It is extremely important that we take steps to protect our shores and wildlife.
  35. Jackie Gorman 23 Jan 2017
    Should not be allowed
  36. George Brown 23 Jan 2017
    There a safer way to transfer oil. Much safer.
  37. James McPherson 23 Jan 2017
    The threat is also from the discharge of ballast water in tankers which contains alien species
  38. Fiona Ball 23 Jan 2017
    Any risk of environmental damage is not worth considering
    - stop this lunacy!
  39. Indra 23 Jan 2017
    The Scottish environment is much of what makes Scotland an attractive tourist destination. We have some of the most beautiful areas in the world, and some of the most unique ecosystems. These need to be protected from our industry. As a Green leader, a firm commitment to this endeavour is required.
  40. Sheila Murison 23 Jan 2017
    You must protect our environment and wildlife from the risk of spills and pollution.
  41. M Mackintosh 23 Jan 2017
    Important to preserve a natural haven,as yet unspoilt and not yet polluted. A haven of wild life and beauty
  42. Paul Chaplin 24 Jan 2017
    Don't let this go ahead, nobody but CFPA want this to happen
  43. vicky 24 Jan 2017
    Do not allow this
  44. Jean Frew 24 Jan 2017
    We need to stop this....the environment deserves our protection
  45. Jane Lancaster 24 Jan 2017
    Why?
  46. Steve Bramwell 24 Jan 2017
    This issue is so important. It challenges Scottish Government to show that it cares more for the environment than the prospect of a paltry profit at any cost. Come on Scot Gov show us that you really do care
  47. Laura Hansler 24 Jan 2017
    The potential here for a catastrophic environmental disaster to our prized coastline can never be underestimated, there is the potential to wipe out completely ecosystems and generations of sea mammals!
    Scotland is not a dumping ground , nor an experimental site for the UK !! Ban ship to ship transfer
  48. Elizabeth A Noon 24 Jan 2017
    Ship to ship oil transfer should be prevented by environmental legislation in locations which are environmentally sensitive.
  49. Diane Middlewick 24 Jan 2017
    Our environment is precious, we must take care of it. Enough of it is being destroyed as it is.
  50. Wendy Lambie 24 Jan 2017
    Ship to ship oil transfers will put wildlife including the dolphins at risk.