Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01637 · Session 5

Ship-to-ship oil transfers and trust port accountability

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2016 Environment & Energy
Signatures
43
2,087 online signatures with a country
Comments
242
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that environmental legislation in Scotland is sufficient to prevent ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil in environmentally sensitive locations, such as the Inner Moray Firth, and to enhance the accountability of trust port boards to their stakeholders.

What the petitioner did first

We have raised the issue with MSPs and MPs including John Finnie MSP, Mark Ruskell MSP, Kate Forbes MSP, Gail Ross MSP, Drew Hendry MP and Ian Blackford MP.

In addition, since a specific proposal for ship to ship transfers of crude oil at anchorages in the Inner Moray Firth within the boundary of the Cromarty Firth Port Authority was announced we have undertaken a wide variety of actions to oppose the proposal. This has included, but is not limited to,—
· Formation of a pressure group
· Organisation of public meetings in communities around the Inner Moray Firth
· Raising the issue through local media and online campaigning
· Responding to consultations
· Lobbying the Cromarty Firth Port Authority, and
· Engaging in discussions with relevant bodies and individuals such as SEPA, SNH, The Highland Council, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, Prof Paul Thompson and RSPB Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  2. 2 May 2017
    Meeting of the Parliament
    Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (Cromarty and Moray Firths)
    1 mention
  3. 22 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 27 Jun 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 5 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 27 Jan 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,087 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,393 66.7%
  2. United Kingdom341 16.3%
  3. England259 12.4%
  4. United States27 1.3%
  5. Wales15 0.7%
  6. Canada7 0.3%
  7. Slovenia6 0.3%
  8. Germany5 0.2%
  9. New Zealand5 0.2%
  10. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  11. 16 other countries25 1.2%

Comments

242 comments, oldest first
242 comments · showing 201–242
  1. Anne Brown 7 Feb 2017
    This must not happen the potential for disaster is obvious
  2. Sandra Kennedy 8 Feb 2017
    To spoil one of the most beautiful parts of Scotland would not be how anyone would want to be remembered!
  3. pamelaa munro 8 Feb 2017
    I don't agree with this proposal
  4. Thomas Harper 8 Feb 2017
    Ship to ship oil transfer was not allowed in the Firth of Forth. Why would it be ok for the Moray Firth? The risk to wildlife and the environment is too great to allow this to go ahead.
  5. Alasdair Joyce 9 Feb 2017
    We have a Scottish Parliament that claims to be looking after Scottish interests, and all they are interested in is business and banging on about independence. Come on, do your job for once and protect the Scotland you claim to care so much about.
  6. John Phillips 9 Feb 2017
    As a lifelong mariner I consider the proposal to undertake ship to ship transfers of crude oil in the inner Moray Firth to be totally irresponsible, posing a severe risk to local wildlife, fisheries and other activities which support the local economy.
  7. Diane Lunan 9 Feb 2017
    I feel strongly that we need to protect our wildlife and environment and that our government should be at the forefront on our behalf. Am feeling disappointed as well that we have to resort to petitions. It appears to a have taken a year to have rooted out any public response from our government, but I hope that recent comments in the media mean that they are keeping their eye on this threat to the Moray Firth and will take the lead in protecting our environment.
  8. Simon Noble 10 Feb 2017
    I live in Nairn. Until Cromarty rising brought this to the attention of my community council I knew nothing of these STS transfers. It is dreadful that the port authority claimed to have consulted widely and not encountered objections when I and the rest of my community are directly affected by the proposals and the risks.
  9. Bruce Farquhar 10 Feb 2017
    I would urge everyone to sign this petition we need action now
  10. Iain Fairweather 10 Feb 2017
    ship-to-ship oil transfers pose unacceptable risks to wildlife and local tourism economy
  11. Simon Giles 10 Feb 2017
    On the subject of big business, just think Scottish Government for one moment what this could mean not just to the environment but to the local area and its tourism....you cut off your nose to spite your face if you approve this.
  12. Will Coull 10 Feb 2017
    Not only is the potential for disaster enormous but the process of this oil transfer will impact the environment and the local wildlife as well as the local population with the invasive 24hr noise alone not to mention low grade pollution from tank discharges.
  13. Jacqueline King 11 Feb 2017
    Let's think about the future, shall we? So many plans, such as this one, are short term with awful long term effects.
  14. Thomas James Bradshaw 11 Feb 2017
    Wrong place for STS transfers more appropriate sites already avaliable
  15. Caroline Morris 12 Feb 2017
    Knowing the area and the weather conditions that can prevail the possibility of an oil spill must be greater that 50%.
    We are losing too much of our pristine and natural heritage to risk anymore being lost just for profit.
  16. David Morris 12 Feb 2017
    I have visited this area several times and was impressed by its pristine condition. Any operation that could case irreparable harm in the area should not proceed especially given the weather in the area is not conducive to a safe transfer of oil from ship to ship. We are humans and we make mistakes and in this case the resulting damage could be catastrophic
  17. Morag Forbes 12 Feb 2017
    The Moray Firth should not be spoiled like this.
  18. Jacqueline Crill 13 Feb 2017
    Is the Scottish Government all words? This is really terrible. How can anyone even think of allowing something that might have such long term effects on marine life
    - and the fishing industry therefore.
  19. Bill Martin 13 Feb 2017
    Scottish Government lets keep Scotland beautiful and listen to the people who love this land of ours.
    NO SHIP TO SHORE OIL TRANSFERS
  20. Liz Broumley 13 Feb 2017
    This will not bring any economic benefit to the local community and risks both economic and environmental catastrophe.
  21. Alan Tissiman 14 Feb 2017
    This is a very sensitive area indeed. Great care must be taken and risks avoided.
  22. Howard Davenport 14 Feb 2017
    A full environmental impact assessment should be undertaken prior to a decision on whether to go ahead with these operations, as with most other onshore or offshore developments.
  23. Richard Newmark 14 Feb 2017
    I don't trust the operators of these oil transfers to behave responsibly. Offshore spills can and will easily be hidden from authorities.
  24. Clive Moore 14 Feb 2017
    Fuel Transfers at sea always cause spillage. In the Inner Moray Firth this would be irresponsible, dangerous and the worse of all options available.
  25. Gordon Ross 14 Feb 2017
    An accident waiting to happen, if this crazy request is granted. Driven by pure greed.
  26. John N Hart 14 Feb 2017
    S2S transfers in this environment is not the best idea for protecting the environment.
  27. Jennifer Nalder 15 Feb 2017
    If these transfers were to go ahead the north of Scotland would be ruined beyond belief.Denying that a leakage would never happen is not the truth it is only a matter of time.Pay attention parliament and support US !!!!!!!
  28. Ian Nalder 15 Feb 2017
    To place the dolphins and our amazing coastline at risk is quite simply utterly unwarranted. Oil transfers between ships can only be achieved under strictly controlled conditions and these can only be achieved under supervision such as applies in port.
  29. Marie (Mary) Cruickshank 15 Feb 2017
    Nairn's main industry is tourism of which I am part. If this ship to ship transfer goes ahead and there are oil spills
    - that is going to kill our tourism and the ecology of the area. Not only that but do tourists, who enjoy the seaviews and walks along our beaches, really want to view a lot of huge tankers? I wouldn't! That smacks of the oil vessels off the coast of Singapore and Sentosa Island! The sea smells of oil, it isn't pleasant to bathe in and the views
    - horrendous
    - why do we have to put up with this as tourism is our main economy in the Nairn area? I am a tour operator (and do B&B) and send lots of tourists to stay in Nairn from all over the world
    - I persuade them to come to Nairn where we have wonderful sandy beaches and clean air
    - is that going to last? I certainly hope so or if not, then I will have to send clients to other parts of Scotland where there are sandy beaches and no oil pollution nor queues of tankers waiting for their ship to ship transfers!!
  30. Christine Briggs 15 Feb 2017
    Surely one of the most important things Scotland has to offer is the relatively clean environment. Even with extreme caution accidents happen. Please prevent this by not allowing S2S transfers.
  31. Blair Cruickshank 15 Feb 2017
    We do not want another tragic oil spill like the Alaskan tragedy some years ago which adversely affected the wild life.
  32. Joanna Nowicki 15 Feb 2017
    Safeguarding our environment should always be a first priority.
  33. Marie (Mary) Cruickshank 15 Feb 2017
    We do not want this "facilty" or eyesore out in the Moray Firth to view from Nairn. Oil spillages like in Alaska and a killer for local tourism and our local economy. We need tourism in the area and this will ruin it
    - especially if there are oil spills and smells polluting our shores. No thank you!!
  34. Sue-Ellen Welfonder 15 Feb 2017
    Know and love Nairn, have (and do) visit regularly. Please do not let this happen. Thank you.
  35. Mike Cruickshank 15 Feb 2017
    I can't believe they are even contemplating this ridiculous idea. It's a disgrace
  36. Aurora A Mata 16 Feb 2017
    Coastlines all over the world need our protection! The good of the seas is essential for our survival.
  37. Pam Hartje 16 Feb 2017
    Haven't the oil companies screwed up our oceans and beaches enough?!?! Our world enough?!?! Don't they know that transferring oil from ship to ship is DANGEROUS?!?! They should be doing everything they can to insure that our oceans, beaches and lands are protected from the oil spills and leaks that always seems to happen no matter what they do. To me it seems it's a VERY BIG RISK to be transferring oil from ship to ship and should be STOPPED AT ALL COSTS!!!
  38. Pam Hartje 16 Feb 2017
    Hi again! I forgot to add that if the oil companies want to say accidents don't happen just ask the people who live and work along the Gulf of Mexico in the US about how they feel about little or no chance of an accident and oil spill!!!
  39. Howard Davenport 16 Feb 2017
    A full environmental impact assessment should be submitted to Marine Scotland, and open to public review and comment, prior to this type of proposal being given approval, as with other offshore developments.
  40. John Dolan 16 Feb 2017
    With Nairn just 4.5 miles south of one of the proposed anchorages any oil spill could be catastrophic for Nairn's beaches and local economy
    - and for those east of us. This is a totally inappropriate location for crude oil ship to ship transfers.
  41. Joanna May 17 Feb 2017
    The risks surely outweigh any possible benefits to the local area and its outstanding beauty...
  42. Mo 17 Feb 2017
    This area is supposed to be a tourist area, that is what the Moray Council keep telling us and the Moray coastline is definitly going to be affected. So stop sending mixed messages.