Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (PE1637)

Thursday 12 November 2020 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:30 Petitions 86 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

86 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Good morning, and welcome to this meeting of the Public Petitions Committee.

The first and only item on our agenda today is consideration of continued petitions. The first continued petition is PE1637, which was lodged by Greg Fullarton, on behalf of Cromarty Rising. I welcome John Finnie, who is attending the meeting in relation to the petition. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that environmental legislation in Scotland is sufficient to prevent ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil in environmentally sensitive locations, such as the inner Moray Firth, and to enhance the accountability of trust port boards to their stakeholders.

When we last considered the petition in December, we agreed to invite the Minister for Energy, Connectivity and the Islands to give oral evidence, focusing on the accountability of trust ports. I am pleased to welcome the minister, as well as two Scottish Government officials: Michael McLeod, who is head of marine conservation; and Martin Ritchie, who is head of ports, shipping, freight and canals.

Before we move to questions, I invite the minister to provide a brief opening statement.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP The Minister for Energy, Connectivity and the Islands · South Scotland
link

Good morning to all colleagues on the committee. I thank you for the opportunity to give evidence today.

I take to heart the very real concerns of the communities that live around the Moray and Cromarty firths over the now withdrawn application from the Cromarty Firth Port Authority to undertake ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil at sea in the Moray Firth.

To date, we have written four times to the United Kingdom Government to seek devolution of the powers to determine applications for ship-to-ship oil transfer licences within Scottish waters. Furthermore, the Secretary of State for Transport undertook a light-touch review of the regulations in 2017 and amended them earlier this year, all without consultation with Scottish ministers. Sadly, therefore, an opportunity for devolving that function has been lost.

I have made it clear that the Scottish Government has no powers over the decision-making process for any application for an oil transfer licence, and the regulations under which such applications are made remain a reserved matter under the Merchant Shipping Act 1995. When consent is given for any regulated activity that takes place in Scottish waters, it is for the regulator to ensure that environmental legislation is complied with. In the case of ship-to-ship oil transfer licences, that responsibility currently sits with the UK Government.

Thank you for the opportunity to give some opening remarks. I am happy to take questions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you for that; we appreciate your attendance today.

I will ask the first question. In your written submission to the committee last September, you stated that

“Scottish Ministers expect Trust Ports to operate with reference to the Modern Trust Ports for Scotland: Guidance for Good Governance and our experience is that Trust Ports across Scotland do this.”

What evidence do you have for that claim?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I appreciate that that is an important point. The Scottish Government recognises that Scotland benefits from a diverse and successful ports sector that contributes significantly to local and regional economies and, in some cases, the national economy. Our trust ports have no shareholders or owners and, therefore, profits are reinvested in the ports. They make a significant contribution to local employment and economic growth. The “Modern Trust Ports for Scotland: Guidance for good governance” notes that

“interested parties”

who believe that a trust port is acting

“in breach of the principles of the trust port”

should raise the matter with the trust port board

“in the first instance”.

There are also routes for recourse related to specific areas of concern. For instance, there are well-publicised public consultations before any marine licence or harbour revision order is considered for approval, and queries around noise or light pollution or traffic congestion from a port should be directed to the local authority for investigation. Ultimately, there are the options of reporting matters to the police or of pursuing legal means, although that comes with a cost, which is an issue for the petitioners. However, the same arrangements apply to all ports in Scotland.

Thankfully, complaints against trust ports in Scotland are very low in number, despite many stakeholders regularly using or living in the vicinity of a trust port. That evidence suggests—although I appreciate that it is difficult to prove—that trust ports are striving to be good neighbours and have robust processes in place when matters are escalated. If it were otherwise, we would expect a much greater number of complaints and problems to come before Government.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There are quite a number of issues in there that members will address.

You were quite explicit in saying that, in your experience, trust ports across Scotland follow the guidance. With respect, you have not given us any evidence for that. You have simply said that it looks as if that is the case because there have not been a lot of complaints. I think that the petitioners would argue the opposite. Have you specific evidence that the guidance is followed?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

Yes, as I understand it, convener. I apologise if I have given the wrong impression. Our records show that, this year, we have received just five representations about trust ports, of which two related to CFP.

The volume of complaints about trust ports is not large. I appreciate that that is not quite the same as saying that we have evidence of good behaviour, but it implies that the levels of complaint about the activities of trust ports are, if anything, very limited.

Martin Ritchie might be able to comment further on the detail of the complaints that have been received, if that would be helpful. Given the number of trust ports in Scotland, the evidence suggests that there are relatively low levels of difficulty in their engagement with local communities and with their users.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay, so the evidence that it is working is the absence of evidence that it is not working, and the evidence that it is not working is simply that nobody has found a way to complain effectively. Again, that is something that we will look at.

Does Martin Ritchie want to come in at this point?

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

Protocols are in place for trust ports to deal with those issues. Certainly, the larger trust ports are required to have liaison groups with their local communities, so that they can deal with any complaints that they have received.

The minister is absolutely right to say that it is difficult to quantify the level of complaints that we have had about trust ports, but five is certainly a very low figure, given the economic activity around Scotland from those ports. As the minister said, two of those complaints are about the port that I think is the focus of the question. Certainly, our records show that there seems to be a willingness from communities to raise issues. We may return to that as well.

We need to bear in mind that the activities of some of those ports are very significant for the local economy, the regional economy and the national economy. As with any industry, there may be rub points with local communities about some of the activities that go on, but, from the information that we have on the Cromarty Firth port, protocols and procedures seem to be in place for the local community to voice any displeasure.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much.

My observation is that the submission from the Scottish Government and the minister asserts something for which they have no evidence, and there are clearly some concerns. Has any consideration been given to putting the guidance into law? Would that help to give people confidence?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

All ports are obliged to act in accordance with the local legislation that underpins their trust port status and with other relevant law, whether they are trusts or privately or local authority owned. Trust ports are established and empowered by harbour orders, which are made by Scottish ministers, and they are required to operate only within the powers and duties that are conferred on them by statute. Those orders are subject to public consultation before they are adopted.

We would certainly insist that trust ports should do all that they can to comply with the guidance. However, we recognise and acknowledge that not all trust ports will be in a position to comply fully with every provision in the guidance. In some cases, the size and nature of a trust port’s operation might mean that a particular stipulation does not apply or that compliance would be excessively burdensome or disproportionate.

We believe that trust port boards should exercise their own judgment on the essential elements of their operations. As and when necessary, they may also seek clarification on the guidance from Scottish Government officials if they are in any way unclear about how they should approach its adoption. However, we recognise and acknowledge that not all trust ports will be in a position to comply fully with the guidance.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So you will not put the guidance into law because you do not believe that people can comply with it.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

That is perhaps an unfair characterisation. All members, but especially those who represent constituencies with smaller trust ports, will recognise that fully complying with the guidance would be difficult in such cases. We are trying to take a proportionate, reasonable and pragmatic approach by not enforcing things through legislation and instead putting them in guidance.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Have you ever thought of having guidance that might match the scale of the ports, so that the guidance could differ, depending on their size? Has that ever been considered?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I cannot answer that question. If I may, I will bring in Martin Ritchie. Mr Matheson leads on trust ports, so Martin might be more familiar with the legislation that applies and the process that we went through to reach the position that has existed since 2015.

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

The minister has laid out the position well. The issue is the vast diversity of trust ports in Scotland. If we were to try to tackle all their activities in guidance we would have either a lengthier document than we have now or many iterations of it. In my time in the office, we have considered the guidance—and it is guidance—but, as the minister said, on top of that is legislation, including local legislation, to which all trust ports must adhere. We feel that the guidance is just that—we do not want to be too restrictive about all the different angles that our trust ports work from.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I welcome the minister and his team. I should say that I am the constituency MSP for the board that we are discussing. I declare an interest, in that I supported Cromarty Rising in its campaign against ship-to-ship oil transfers when the proposal was live.

The minister has explained that trust ports are independent statutory bodies. They are therefore governed by their own legislation and run by independent boards. He said that the fact that there have been only five complaints to the Scottish Government shows that they have been run in an acceptable manner. However, we have received more evidence from Cromarty Rising, which is a group that comprises people from all around the Cromarty Firth, including up to Nairn and round to Invergordon, where the port is situated.

On the subject of transparency and accountability, Cromarty Rising says that the Port of Cromarty Firth

“claimed that only 6 noise complaints had been recorded”

but that

“Highland Council has confirmed that”

it has had

“29 complaints”.

Therefore, there is—pardon the pun—a trust issue over how transparent the port is being about complaints.

A second protest group, which has been set up in Invergordon, is not happy about the lack of consultation with the community about, among other things, cruise ships, the use of public buses and the parking of private buses. What is your response to those concerns? If I was to say to all the members of Cromarty Rising and the protest group in Invergordon that they should get in touch with the Scottish Government, would that prompt action to be taken?

09:45

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I recognise the concern of Gail Ross, as the constituency member, when she hears those complaints from community groups. For what it is worth, I would be disappointed if there was any mismatch in the statistics that different bodies report. I will look into the matter that Gail Ross raises around complaints that have been raised with Highland Council and those that are being reported by the trust port. We need to bottom that out. I do not know whether Mr Ritchie or Mr McLeod has any insight into the difference or whether there is a technical reason for it, but it sounds odd that there is such a disparity. We will come back to the committee on that point, if that would be helpful.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

On the point about the second protest group and the lack of consultation on the issues with cruise ships and bus parking, those are matters on which we expect the trust port to undertake consultation and engagement with the local community. We expect all ports in Scotland to be good neighbours. The “Modern Trust Ports for Scotland” guidance, which was referred to earlier, clearly states the options that are available for interested parties who believe that the trust port in their locality is acting outwith its powers. I say to interested parties who are watching this session that we encourage any party with concerns about the Port of Cromarty Firth or any other trust port in Scotland, or who believes that their port is acting illegally or is

“otherwise in breach of the principles of the trust port”,

to follow the processes for having those concerns fully considered.

In addition to ship-to-ship transfers, I understand that there have recently been complaints from the Cromarty Rising group on noise vibration from rigs berthing in the firth. Noise pollution issues should be directed to the local authority to investigate, which might indicate why Highland Council reports a high number. It is not good that the issue is happening, but it is good that folk are reporting it, because it indicates that that channel is active. However, I am concerned to hear that the trust port is reporting a much lower level of complaints.

As background, I understand that the port authority has said that more than 700 rig movements have been completed in the firth, which has hosted North Sea drilling rigs for more than 40 years. Despite an unprecedented increase in demand to store rigs, due to the collapse of the oil market earlier this year and the pandemic, I understand that, as I said, the port authority has received just six noise complaints. However, we will investigate why there is such a disparity.

The port authority has said that it investigates each complaint that it receives and, where possible, undertakes monitoring to measure and investigate the extent of noise pollution. With regard to the complaints that were investigated, the noise was within legal limits. However, Highland Council has received 23 other complaints, which I do not have similar reassurance about, so I am keen to explore that. I apologise that I do not have a response to that now, but we will get one to the committee as soon as we can, unless Mr Ritchie or Mr MacLeod has any insight on those larger numbers.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do Martin Ritchie or Michael McLeod want to say anything?

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

I cannot add a lot to what the minister has said, but we will follow that up. I am not sure whether those six complaints have been made directly to the port authority and the others have gone to the local authority, but there is no reason why we cannot follow that up with Highland Council, and we will do so.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I will also make a suggestion about contact with Cromarty and district community council. When it canvassed local opinion, 80 per cent of responses highlighted a shared “hate” of the noise. I believe that the port was asked to move noisier structures away from areas of population, but that suggestion was not taken up, which is disappointing.

I will ask a question about ship-to-ship oil transfers. From having made representations on behalf of Cromarty Rising and the community as a whole, I know that it is an issue for the Westminster Government. Can you tell me what input Marine Scotland had and whether it is a statutory consultee on any of those consultations?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

It is certainly important that NatureScot—formerly Scottish Natural Heritage—is consulted as a statutory consultee. The irony is that the Scottish ministers are not statutory consultees, which is why we have asked the United Kingdom Government to reflect on the difficulties that we have had with the application and to perhaps use this as an opportunity to devolve responsibility to the Scottish ministers or, at least, to formally recognise the role of the Scottish Government as a consultee in the process to ensure that we are always consulted on any such applications as a matter of course. I hope that there is room for collaboration on that between us and UK ministers. That has not happened to date, regrettably, considering the changes that took place in 2017, and we would like to have discussions with the UK secretary of state on the issue. The secretary of state to whom we most recently addressed the matter was Chris Grayling, which was before a recent reshuffle. We hope to pick it up with UK ministers in due course.

It is a long-standing issue and I know that it is of great concern to local communities. The Scottish Government has responsibility for the marine environment so, logically, it should follow that we have a formal role in the oversight of such applications. If we do not get full devolution, we should at least have a role as a statutory consultee, and our view should always be taken into account on these matters.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We know that the Cromarty Firth Port Authority has put a halt to its plans for ship-to-ship transfers in the form in which they were being proposed, but there is nothing preventing the port authority from changing its mind on that and coming back with another proposal. What would you say to the port and the community if that should happen? The community would be pretty much back to where it started and would have to start the fight all over again.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I have to be careful, because I do not want to pre-empt any formal consultation that takes place on a specific application. However, on the basis of the general principle of what was being proposed in the Moray Firth, we have concerns along the following lines: we know that ship-to-ship transfer can be done safely and with relatively little risk but, if there were an incident involving ship-to-ship transfer in the Moray Firth, we believe that there is certainly a considerable likelihood that there would be significant damage to the marine environment there. There is a combination of a relatively low chance of such an incident happening—ship-to-ship transfer procedures are well practised around the world—and the potential for a significant impact on a precious part of our marine environment if an incident did happen, so we have significant concerns. We took a sceptical approach to the proposal. I am not criticising the port authority or any of the operators that would have been doing ship-to-ship transfers, but we had concerns about that taking place in that environmental context.

We would be keen to have oversight of such decisions but, as I said, those powers are not yet devolved to the Scottish ministers. We will continue to make representations to UK ministers on the devolution of those powers to the Scottish Government, and we will consider each application on its merits if we are invited to do so. We have some concerns about the potential impact of such an incident on that precious environment, with key species such as dolphins and the wider marine environment at risk.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

On the issue of public funding, you have previously stated that trust ports operate in a commercial environment, usually with no direct public funding. The petitioners question that position, given that the Cromarty Firth Port Authority received Scottish Government funding worth £7.5 million for a new cruise hub development, which followed a £4 million grant from Highlands and Islands Enterprise in August 2014. Will you or your colleagues clarify the details around that funding—it appears to be public funding—and tell us whether other trust ports have received similar public funding?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

That is a fair question. Trust ports operate in a commercial environment and usually have no direct public funding, which means that a trust port must charge appropriate levels of fees from users of the port to cover the maintenance and running costs. However, it is also important to remember that ports, just like any other business, can apply to our economic development agencies for support for large-scale developments that are beyond their normal operations or are considered to be of wider economic significance. You referred to some of the figures but, as an example, the £4 million grant funding from Highlands and Islands Enterprise in 2014 was viewed as future proofing the port. It centred on the reclamation of approximately 10 acres of land to provide additional quayside with deeper-water capability. Although the port has continuity of access at all states of tide for large supply and cruise vessels, experience has identified that the scale of vessels serving the energy sector is increasing and the quay extension was intended to provide continuity of access as the energy and tourism markets change. Invergordon is also a deep-water port; it is the one that supports the Moray offshore wind farm projects, including those that are currently being built in Moray East.

The national renewables infrastructure plan—or NRIF, as it is often referred to—identified the Cromarty Firth port as a support site to play a major role in the operation and maintenance phase of offshore wind developments, and the investment that took place allowed the port to fulfil its potential complementary role in that respect and also to continue as part of the integrated facilities within the inner Moray Firth cluster and what that has to offer for the renewable energy sector.

On the wider point about the number of trust ports that benefit, a number of Highlands and Islands ports are trusts, including Cromarty Firth, Inverness, Lerwick, Mallaig, Scrabster, St Margaret’s Hope, Stornoway, Ullapool and Wick. Many of those ports have received support over the past 10 years from the Scottish Government and our agencies. Highlands and Islands Enterprise investments have been made on a case-by-case basis, with each project assessed in terms of its value for money, the degree of certainty over user demand for the facility that is being built and net impacts at a local or regional level. It is important to point out that, if it is eligible, it is legitimate for a trust port, as a business, to draw down funding in the same way that any other business would apply. That impartial approach has resulted in regional infrastructure sites achieving high levels of tourism and other business activity, including major offshore energy products projects, as at Wick harbour, in Ms Ross’s constituency, which is doing excellently out of the Beatrice offshore wind farm. I hope that that is helpful.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I have one small supplementary question. Would you regard the £7.5 million of Scottish Government funding that was put in for the new cruise hub as match funding, following the £4 million grant from HIE in August 2014? Is it correct that, if one had not happened, the other would not have happened?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

On that specific point, so that I do not supply an inaccurate answer to Mr Corry, I will bring in Mr Ritchie; he might have some background knowledge on the £7.5 million.

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

I am sorry, but I do not know the finer detail of that. Enterprise agency colleagues would be able to confirm that, but we can confirm it in writing. Most cases of infrastructure support that I have been involved with have included some level of match funding from the industry body, so I assume that that is also the case in this instance.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Would funding from the agencies or the Scottish Government ever include conditions on how the organisation conducts itself?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

On the specifics about conduct, I am not certain about the conditions that were in Highlands and Islands Enterprise’s grant conditions, but it is normal—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

No, I take your point. I am just making the point that you said, as Maurice Corry has said, that these are commercial organisations, and it is not a matter for the Government. However, through its agencies, the Government is giving significant funding. Are conditions attached to that? It is slightly different from a straightforward commercial organisation doing whatever it wants, as long as people do not complain.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

You are right that it is normal these days, for example, for a fair work framework to be a core condition of that funding, and I would not be surprised if there were conditions in that case. If it would be helpful, we can come back to the committee with any conditions that were applied to the funding from Highlands and Islands Enterprise.

10:00

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Therefore, it would be reasonable to expect the Scottish Government, if it was concerned about the way in which ports were operating commercially, to attach those conditions. That is not something that is outwith your control; it would be normal.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, panel. Minister, you stated in previous correspondence to the committee that

“any party who feels a trust port is operating out with their powers as set out in their legislation should raise this with the Port in the first instance, but ultimately has the option to consider legal remedy”,

and you have reiterated that today. What advice would you offer to someone who has been unable to resolve their issue directly with the trust port, but does not have the financial means to take it to court?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

Mr Torrance raises an important point. Obviously, on the specific point that you raise, if anybody believes that a port, whether it is a trust port, a private port or a local authority port, is operating outside its powers as set out in legislation, they should raise that with the trust port board or alternative in the first instance. As we have maintained, there are potential routes for recourse for specific issues such as noise complaints. In this case, the route would be through Highland Council, and it sounds as though a number of complaints have already been made.

Ultimately, a community or an individual has the option to consider a legal remedy via the courts. Anyone considering legal action is of course advised to take independent legal advice. It may well be that support is available for individuals. We would need to look at whether legal aid covers such cases if it is an individual complaint.

Legal action would likely be the option of last resort, which we hope would not be required when other processes can be pursued. Ports and communities can, we would hope, live together and enjoy mutual benefits. Clearly, there are issues in relation to Cromarty Firth Port Authority, and we will look into the unresolved issues around noise complaints. We would hope that, in practice, ports can work in harmony with local communities, and that people would not have to go as far as court action if complaints are taken seriously by trust port boards.

We encourage trust port boards to engage with those who are making complaints and try to resolve them where they can. Ultimately, as I said to David Torrance, communities or individuals have the option of taking court action if they believe that their issues have not been appropriately dealt with by the trust port board.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Just to confirm, if someone does not have the financial means to go to court, they are advised just to see whether they can get legal aid. Is there anything else?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I was suggesting that we will come back to the committee with a definitive answer on what eligibility there is for legal aid, to help Mr Torrance and the committee know what the options are. I do not know whether Michael McLeod or Martin Ritchie would have that to hand, but we can have a look at what support might be available to low-income individuals who feel that their voice needs to be heard in that forum.

I appreciate that going to court is never a cheap process, so we would not want just to incentivise people—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The point is that one of the arguments for doing more on guidance is that it is difficult for people to enforce what they perceive to be their rights, because they do not have the financial means to do so. The question is more about what the Government could do if that was going to be a problem. Perhaps you can come back to the committee on that.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

Is it not the case that, in England and Wales, if stakeholders are dissatisfied with a trust port’s response to a complaint, they can appeal to the Department for Transport to intervene? In Scotland, as you have just stated, there is no such provision. Why do we have that situation?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I believe that the Harbours (Scotland) Act 2015 changed the status of the relationship between the Scottish ministers and trust ports. In part, that was because the borrowing of trust ports appeared on the Scottish Government balance sheet. The UK Government retains different powers in relation to trust ports, including the ability to request that they consider moving from trust port status to full private ownership. We do not have that power in Scotland and we are not convinced that we want it. “Modern Trust Ports for Scotland: Guidance for good governance” states that, if a complainant does not believe that the response that they have received from the trust port

“is reasonable in addressing the grounds of his or her concern, the matter should be reported to Scottish Ministers who may assist in resolving any dispute in their role as ‘honest broker’.”

However, we need to be clear that ministers still have no locus in regulating the commercial decisions or activities of a trust port, nor do we become involved in good-neighbour disputes, because those are matters for the board to resolve in the way that I described earlier. Our interest is in ensuring that the board does not take decisions in an arbitrary, unaccountable manner that is inconsistent with the spirit of the guidance.

Beyond that, I have outlined some of the options relevant to the areas of concern that we believe provide potential recourse for communities and which strengthen the need for accountability from the port in question. We have a role as an honest broker and we do what we can to try and influence, but we do not have a legislative route to enforce that action. I hope that that is helpful to the member. Perhaps Martin Ritchie can explain in greater detail the change in legislation that took place in 2015.

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

I will give it a try, minister, although it is before my time in the branch. My understanding is that trust ports were an anomaly after the privatisation of ports in the 1990s. They were operating in a commercial sphere and were required to show independence but still had the ministerial oversight that exists in England. The minister has outlined the reasons why we felt that trust ports should come out of that arrangement: it was counting against Scottish Government budgets, and the trust ports did not have that level of independence over their financial arrangements that would help with things such as borrowing. They could borrow before the arrangements came into place, but that borrowing would also count against Scottish Government budgets, so there would be a restriction there. The arrangements in 2015 gave the required extra clarity on the independence of the trust ports.

As the minister said, south of the border, for trust ports—or public corporations, as some of the trust ports are classified in England—there is still that ability for ministers to decide that privatisation is the best way to go. Thus far, there has not been an appetite for that in Scotland. That is my summary of the background to where we are now.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

I also understand that, in the England and Wales, the Secretary of State for Transport still appoints the chairs and some non-executive directors of the five largest trust ports. If you have no involvement in the process, how can you be assured that the trust ports in Scotland are appointing their directors transparently?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I recognise the point that Mr Mason makes. We do not have involvement in the appointments process for board members at trust ports in Scotland. The process for appointing board members is led by the trust port board, which utilises its skills and local knowledge to identify the gaps in its skills matrix and fill them with the talented individuals whom they find locally or further afield. That allows the port to continue to benefit the local community and ensure viability for future generations.

“Modern Trust Ports for Scotland: Guidance for good governance” provides the code of best practice for trust ports, including openness and transparency in trust port board appointments and port governance more generally. The core principle of the guidance is to

“encourage the continued development of an open and accountable relationship between all ports, their users and local communities.”

Obviously, if that is not working, we need to look at the matter. However, based on the information that has been supplied to me, I believe that the approach has generally been successful. The port sector has diverse interests and is continuing to adapt.

We have a changing economic context; many ports are showing an interest in the green recovery and in developing facilities that cater for ever-changing market demands. Offshore wind in particular, and cruise traffic—which might take a hit for some time to come, but has generally been buoyant in recent years—are supporting the more traditional markets and are cross-subsidising the cost of the ports.

A key responsibility for the trust port boards will be to ensure that they continue to have the right mix of skills and experience at board and senior management levels, so that their ports can compete in the UK and global markets. I hope that they do that in a way that is compatible with communities’ aspirations through providing good employment opportunities for local people and economic cohesion, and with their health and wellbeing—for example, in respect of issues such as noise pollution, which we discussed earlier. We do not consider those aims to be exclusive of one other—there is room for achieving economic aims while being in harmony with local communities, and we would certainly encourage all trust ports to take that responsibility seriously.

I hope that the information in the code of practice that guides appointment of board members is helpful, but we do not have direct involvement in appointing boards, nor do we have oversight of the process.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Have Government ministers ever been called in to act as honest brokers?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

In relation to the discussions around the Port of Cromarty Firth, we have been engaging with local stakeholders including Cromarty Rising, and with local community representatives and elected members, including Gail Ross and others. We have tried to calm things down and get to a place where there was some resolution to the issue. Obviously, the port ultimately dropped its application. That was its decision.

I do not know whether there are other examples. Perhaps Mr Ritchie or Mr McLeod are aware of similar issues arising where my predecessors or other ministers have had to intervene in that way.

Martin Ritchie Scottish Government
link

No, minister, I am not. It is fair to say that, in my time in the office, Cromarty Firth is the issue that we have been taking an interest in.

It is worth pointing out that our interest lies in circumstances in which we consider that a board is acting outwith its powers. As was mentioned earlier, it is not about trying to solve good-neighbour disputes, because there is a process that needs to be followed. It is more about a board acting unaccountably or, to take it to the extreme, there being a suggestion or evidence of illegality.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So, you do have a role and you can intervene if you think that boards are acting outwith their powers.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

Yes, but in the context of the application that was made, there was nothing to suggest that the Port of Cromarty Firth was acting outwith its powers, so I think that is just to—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

If it had acted outwith its powers, you have the power to do something about that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Would you make an assessment if a port was acting outwith its powers?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I refer to my earlier remarks—we would act as an honest broker. In responding to Mr Mason, I was pointing out that we do not have powers to intervene in board appointments; we act as an honest broker, where we can and as we have tried to do in the Cromarty Firth case. However, as I also explained to Gail Ross, we do not have a direct role in the application process for ship-to-ship transfers, which is what prompted the petition.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

With respect, we have just been told that if a port is acting outwith its powers, you have the power to intervene.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I think that the use of the word “power” is inappropriate, convener. We have the ability to try to come in as an honest broker, but we do not have, as I understand it, powers to intervene in the way that you suggest.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Right. Mark Ritchie said that, if a trust port is operating outwith its powers, the Government has a role; you are saying that there is no such role. That might just be a statement of fact. We would like to know which one is fact.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I disagree with that. What we have tried to say is that we would act as an honest broker to try to bring resolution to an issue, but we do not have formal legal powers to intervene. That is not to say that we have been inactive in situations when we have felt—

10:15

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

There is a big difference between Gail Ross carrying out her functions as a constituency MSP and the Government coming in. You said that your role is as an honest broker. I asked you when you have been an honest broker and you said that there is no example of that. When did you last write to all the trust ports to remind them of the guidance and their responsibilities?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

That is not part of my role, because I am not responsible for trust ports.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

When did a minister of the Scottish Government last write to the trust ports to remind them of the guidance and their responsibilities?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

We can get a written response on that to the committee, unless Martin Ritchie has an answer to the question.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will get it in writing—that is fine.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

You stated something incorrectly, convener. You said that there had been no instance of us acting as an honest broker, but I already stated, as did Martin Ritchie, that we have tried to act as an honest broker in the Cromarty Firth situation. I want to correct the record, so that there is no misunderstanding.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It might just be me who is missing the distinction, but it would probably be useful for the committee to get a wee note on what acting as an honest broker means with regard to the particular issues that we are considering.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I want to move on to the subject of free ports. The petitioner highlights that the introduction of the UK Government-led free ports initiative raises important points, including whether there would be any requirement for the UK Government to consult the Scottish ministers, given that they have no legal, fiscal or governance control of the ports. What is your response to that? Has the Scottish Government had any conversations with the UK Government on free ports?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

There has been engagement between the UK and Scottish Governments on free ports. For the Scottish Government, work on that area is led by Ivan McKee, the Minister for Trade, Investment and Innovation.

We have welcomed the engagement and we continue to have regular dialogue with the UK Government on the matter. I understand that the UK Government has made it clear that any process for selecting free ports in Scotland would be agreed on and undertaken jointly by the UK and Scottish Governments.

The Scottish Government has not yet taken a decision on free ports. We remain open to exploring the policy and its potential benefits, but we are aware of its potential detriments, such as economic displacement, because a free port potentially displaces activity away from other ports and harbours.

Unfortunately, key information that we have requested from the UK Government, including on the tax and finance levers that the UK Government intends to apply, has not yet been shared with us. As a result, we are unable to make a full assessment of the risks and opportunities of the policy for Scotland, or to calculate the likely impact on Scotland’s economy and finances. That information might be forthcoming at some point in the near future, and we will continue to press UK ministers for more evidence.

We will also continue to engage with stakeholders, such as the British Ports Association, that have an interest in the issue, to assess the risks and opportunities that free ports bring. However, we are clear that free ports cannot and will not undo the damage that is being caused to Scotland’s economy by the UK Government’s decision to take us out of the world’s biggest single market, especially if no deal is the outcome.

I hope that that is helpful to Gail Ross. We are waiting for further detail. It may well come through, and we will not prejudge it. We might get the information that we are looking for, but we do not have it yet, which makes it difficult for the Scottish ministers to assess any benefits or risks that arise from having free ports in Scotland.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

That is interesting, because the proposal that has been put forward by the Port of Cromarty Firth suggests that a free port will be absolutely wonderful for the area. In the proposal, there is no estimate of the likely number of jobs, there is no guarantee of workers’ rights and there are no specifics on community benefits. There is also the tax issue that you just mentioned. The proposal has been put forward with, again, little or no community consultation, and the local MP and MSP—me—were told about it only after it was made public. Yet again, there is an issue with transparency.

It has been put to me recently that putting most of your economic eggs into the free-port basket would be an astounding race to the bottom on wages, conditions and environmental regulations. Can you respond to that?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I am disappointed if there has not been engagement. I stress that for something so important, my hope is that there would be engagement between the port authority and key stakeholders, including local members.

However, on the principle of the issue, we are trying to assess whether there are risks of the kind that Ms Ross describes, in terms of there being a race to the bottom. Obviously, there is a displacement risk of potential damage to neighbouring ports and other ports around the coast. How many free ports would be allocated to Scotland? We have no idea whether it would be one or three or another number, so Mr McKee is striving to get that kind of information. It may well come through, so let us not prejudge it, but at this moment we have little, if any, detail on what this all means, so it is difficult to assess whether free ports are a welcome or unwelcome development.

In either case, we would argue that it would not be as good as the deal that we have now, or had up to March, in the European Union’s single market. There is clearly a concern about the wider impact of that decision on Scotland.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for letting me join you, convener. I declare that I previously lent my support to the petitioners.

As others are, I am keen to understand the accountability issue. I have a question for the minister about the relationship between the Scottish Government and the port. Will you please respond to the widely held belief in the community that the decision to abandon ship-to-ship oil transfer was the result of a deal—an inducement—that was brokered by the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Tourism, Fergus Ewing? I am talking about the £7.5 million of Scottish Government money, rather than Highlands and Islands Enterprise money. Can you comment on that? Perhaps concerns that you feel are unjustified could be allayed if you were to publish details of the discussions regarding the money and ministerial engagement?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I do not have the information about ministerial engagement at my fingertips, Mr Finnie. I apologise for that, but we have undertaken to come back on the £7.5 million, on which we can provide more information about the process of that application being taken forward by Highlands and Islands Enterprise. When I was up in Inverness I had one meeting with the port authority about its aspirations for cruise traffic and renewables, which was the issue that was of most interest to me. That meeting was at the Highlands and Islands Enterprise headquarters. I do not have to hand the details on Mr Ewing’s engagement, but we can write to the committee and Mr Finnie with any details of engagement that we can share.

Other things were happening in parallel in relation to the timing of my meeting. I also met Global Energy Group along the road at a neighbouring facility and had a meeting with Cromarty Firth Port Authority to understand the potential for the port in relation to decommissioning and renewable energy development. I was aware that there was a parallel line of discussion going on around its aspirations and its desire to invest in cruise facilities. If Mr Ritchie has no further insight into the matter, we can get back to the committee with as much information as we can provide.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

I will ask a more direct question in that case, minister. Did the Scottish Government offer an inducement to the port to withdraw or not to proceed with ship-to-ship oil transfer? That is a closed question—yes or no.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I believe that the answer to that is no, but that is based on my own information. I am not aware of any such inducement being offered in that way. I hope that that is a helpful answer. Perhaps Mr Ritchie has a closer view on that. My view of what happened is that we did not, to the best of my knowledge, offer an inducement of that kind, although I will stand corrected if Mr Ritchie is aware of anything that I am not sighted on.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

A frustration that many of us have is that the port should be a tremendous community asset, as it is in the ideal location and has deep water, as you said. It should be, but it is not viewed as a community asset. In fact, it is viewed as being in the control of commercial cowboys—I am being very gender specific with that term.

How would you respond to the view that the Scottish Government is complacent about community concerns about the operation of the port? I have to be blunt, minister: nothing that you have said about guidance for good governance and all the rest has reassured me that the Scottish Government takes seriously the concerns of the community regarding the operation of the port.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I would certainly be concerned if that was the view that people have locally. Obviously, we want communities to have faith in the process and to be able to trust that, when they have complaints, they will be heard. I hope that that goes without saying.

I assure you that the Government takes ship-to-ship oil transfers seriously. I appreciate that we are not always able to give the answers that a community wants, but I assure you—and Cromarty Rising, if its members are watching the meeting—that I, first as environment minister back in 2014, and then, ironically, as energy minister since 2016, have been involved in a number of attempts to take forward our demands for devolution of powers so that we can take such decisions locally ourselves. It might appear that we are not listening or taking action on behalf of the Cromarty Rising petitioners regarding ship-to-ship oil transfers, but that is because we have very limited powers to intervene in that instance, as I explained to Ms Ross and in correspondence with the committee. It is frustrating for me, because I have outlined what we think the risks are in relation to that activity.

On matters such as noise pollution, obviously there is a route that can be taken, which is devolved to local authority level. There is local legislation for local authorities to consider complaints against trust ports, and we would not want to intervene in that process unduly.

We will listen to any recommendations that the committee makes on the petition. If there are concerns about how the process functions, we can take on board any points that Mr Finnie or the committee makes in that regard.

We are trying to act in good faith. We do not want to jump in where it is inappropriate for us to do so. We do not have the legal power to intervene as a statutory consultee or to intervene directly in the decision on any application for ship-to-ship oil transfer. That is the position that the Scottish ministers are in. I appreciate that that might be frustrating for Mr Finnie and others to hear.

John Finnie Green Highlands and Islands
link

My frustration is that there is the potential for exactly the same arguments to be replicated in relation to the proposal regarding free ports. I heard the replies that you gave to Gail Ross, which are welcome. Environment is a devolved matter. Can you give an assurance that the Scottish Government will not only have regard to the alleged commercial benefits—the Scottish Green Party does not support the concept, which involves a race to the bottom and the worst of the free market—but engage with communities affected by the port’s operations on the potential environmental implications?

I will conclude there. I think that there are a number of unanswered questions and I respectfully suggest that the committee needs to keep the petition open.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

On the environmental implications, it might be appropriate to bring in Mr McLeod in a second on what formal role we would have in the event of any free port proposal. I will relay to Mr McKee the concerns that you have about the principle of ensuring that such decisions are not purely commercial. I am not the lead minister, so I do not want to overstep the mark and tread into Mr McKee’s territory. I am sure that he would be sympathetic to the points that have been made but, ultimately, it is for Mr McKee to decide how he would consider them.

On free ports, I reassure Mr Finnie and other colleagues that although there is a lead minister, the implications of the concept are being discussed across Government. I am sure that Ms Cunningham, Ms Gougeon and other ministers are well aware of what is being discussed and have opportunities to relay their concerns about environmental impacts, should there be any.

I do not know whether Mr McLeod has any insight into what Marine Scotland might be doing on free ports that might be helpful for Mr Finnie to hear.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will just wait for Mr McLeod’s microphone to come on.

I think that you might need to unmute your microphone yourself, Mr McLeod.

10:30

Michael McLeod Scottish Government
link

Okay. Can you hear me now, convener?

Michael McLeod Scottish Government
link

At the moment, we are not doing any work on the subject, largely because it is still a developing concept. Given that it is a matter of strategic importance, I would expect the responsible authority, which is the UK Government, to undertake a strategic environmental assessment to properly assess the potential environmental impacts and to look at all the possibilities in terms of ports that could be used as free ports. I am not aware of any moves to do that as yet.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you very much.

I am conscious that we have spent a bit of time on this. I seek confirmation of two things from the minister. First, I seek confirmation that although it is Mr McKee’s responsibility, the Government across the board is engaged with the issue and that Mr McKee would not have a veto and would not be able to drive this through without it being confirmed by—I see that the minister is nodding, so I assume that he agrees that Mr McKee could not simply do what he wanted. Perhaps it would be useful to find out in writing whether there is a cross-party Government committee or group that has oversight of such an initiative.

Minister, you said that we do not currently have powers to intervene. Is that because you have chosen not to take those powers or because those powers are reserved? There is an argument around all such issues, for good or ill, but when you said that the Government does not currently have powers to intervene, is that because the issue is reserved or because the Government has chosen not to take those powers?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

It is both, in a sense. Certainly, when it comes to ship-to-ship oil transfers, it is because the powers are still reserved. We have asked for those powers to be devolved. In relation to the wider trust ports issue that has been raised by a number of members, the legislation that was passed in Parliament in 2015 sets out the relationship there, so the Parliament and the Government have made a conscious choice to limit our role in intervening in trust ports’ operations, but we will reflect on any concerns that the committee raises in its report. At the moment, we do not have powers to intervene directly in relation to board appointments, for example. It is a mixed situation.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

So on the issues around guidance and so on, it is an active choice by the Government that it does not want to take those powers, but there are certain issues around ship-to-ship transfer that continue to involve reserved powers.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I am conscious that we have spent a bit more time than we expected to on this. I will bring in any colleagues who want to speak, but my view is that we need to reflect on the petition at a further meeting and that it would be useful, ahead of that meeting, to get the information that the minister has indicated that he will give us and to hear from the petitioners or others who have watched today’s session if they have some observations to make. An area that was highlighted by Gail Ross and others is the fact that there is a gap between the minister’s perception of how well things are going and the scale of complaints and where those go, and the whole question of how people can complain if they do not have the financial means to do so.

I appreciate the time that the minister and his officials have spared us. If any member indicates that they do not want to take that approach, I will bring them in.

It seems that people are content to look at the petition at a further meeting but, in the intervening period, we will get from the minister the advice and information that he has offered, and it will perhaps afford an opportunity for others who are interested to reflect on the session. Is that agreed?

Yes, it is. In that case, I will briefly suspend the meeting to allow for a change of officials before we consider the next petition. I thank Michael McLeod and Martin Ritchie for their attendance, which is very much appreciated.

10:34 Meeting suspended.

10:37 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 86
  2. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 39
  3. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  4. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.