Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01637 · Session 5

Ship-to-ship oil transfers and trust port accountability

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2016 Environment & Energy
Signatures
43
2,087 online signatures with a country
Comments
242
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that environmental legislation in Scotland is sufficient to prevent ship-to-ship transfers of crude oil in environmentally sensitive locations, such as the Inner Moray Firth, and to enhance the accountability of trust port boards to their stakeholders.

What the petitioner did first

We have raised the issue with MSPs and MPs including John Finnie MSP, Mark Ruskell MSP, Kate Forbes MSP, Gail Ross MSP, Drew Hendry MP and Ian Blackford MP.

In addition, since a specific proposal for ship to ship transfers of crude oil at anchorages in the Inner Moray Firth within the boundary of the Cromarty Firth Port Authority was announced we have undertaken a wide variety of actions to oppose the proposal. This has included, but is not limited to,—
· Formation of a pressure group
· Organisation of public meetings in communities around the Inner Moray Firth
· Raising the issue through local media and online campaigning
· Responding to consultations
· Lobbying the Cromarty Firth Port Authority, and
· Engaging in discussions with relevant bodies and individuals such as SEPA, SNH, The Highland Council, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Whale and Dolphin Conservation, Prof Paul Thompson and RSPB Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  2. 2 May 2017
    Meeting of the Parliament
    Ship-to-ship Oil Transfers (Cromarty and Moray Firths)
    1 mention
  3. 22 Jun 2017
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 27 Jun 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  5. 5 Dec 2019
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  7. 27 Jan 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,087 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,393 66.7%
  2. United Kingdom341 16.3%
  3. England259 12.4%
  4. United States27 1.3%
  5. Wales15 0.7%
  6. Canada7 0.3%
  7. Slovenia6 0.3%
  8. New Zealand5 0.2%
  9. Germany5 0.2%
  10. Northern Ireland4 0.2%
  11. 16 other countries25 1.2%

Comments

242 comments, oldest first
242 comments · showing 101–150
  1. Dee Webster 24 Jan 2017
    I can't bear the thought of what might happen if this is allowed
  2. Mary Bromilow 24 Jan 2017
    To allow ship to ship oil transfers in a location such as this would be environmental vandalism.
  3. Nancy Anderson 24 Jan 2017
    Please do not risk further pollution in this special silly sensitive area
  4. Jennifer Luscombe 24 Jan 2017
    Unbelievable to even think about It!
    Protect the dolphins
  5. Saille Mawson 24 Jan 2017
    I do believe that environmental legislation should prevent ship to ship oil transfers in sensitive locations. They do pose a risk to wildlife. Any risk in this unique location is unacceptable. I live by the coast in an area where untold damage could be caused by any pollution both to wildlife and the tourism it attracts in this area.
  6. Alan Aitchison 24 Jan 2017
    There has to be environmental legislation in place, backed up by appropriately heavy fines, including imprisonment, to protect environmentally sensitive locations from ship to ship oil transfers. Ship to ship oil transfers pose enormous risks to wildlife and local economies. This is the first time I have engaged in a campaign such as this, but as a former wildlife photographer and person taking part in beached bird survey, I have seen the horrific effects of pollution on our environment.
  7. Robert Sweeney 24 Jan 2017
    Ship to Ship must not be allowed because of the effect it could have on the environment if an accident did happen.
  8. Arthur Bird 25 Jan 2017
    Do not allow this to happen. This is the wrong plan in the wrong place.
  9. Ted Murray 25 Jan 2017
    Calling on Scottish Parliament to vote this crazy, unnecessary scheme down.
  10. Helen munro 25 Jan 2017
    Why risk damaging a beautiful part of Scotland which is home to dolphins which the local economy depends on for income from people coming to enjoy all we have to offer here ?
  11. Edmund Bewley 25 Jan 2017
    I was instrumental in bringing a successful prosecution of a shipping line for illegal discharge of tank washing by reporting them when operating a scheduled flight near Wick. Transfers are potentially hazardous should be prohibited.
  12. Debbie C 25 Jan 2017
    Please don't let this area be risked by ship to ship oil transfers. I'm a regular tourist to this area which generates significant income to this beautiful area. Please, please don't jeopardise it
  13. Rob Holder 25 Jan 2017
    Why would anyone even contemplate risking the destruction of such a delicate marine environment? And why are the Highland Council not fighting this!? ££££££
  14. Elzbieta Wojcik-Leese 26 Jan 2017
    It is vital for us to make sure that our waters and the animals that live there are protected. I visit Black Isle regularly and it's a privilege to watch dolphins (and the sea itself) there.
  15. David Williamson. 26 Jan 2017
    There are some things that money can't buy. Scotland' natural beauty is sacrosanct. No ship to ship oil transfers. Too much at stake to risk an accident!!!
  16. Janet Kewleyadam 26 Jan 2017
    Our marine life must be protected and never face the threat of ship to shore oil transfers
  17. Robert Manson 26 Jan 2017
    Dolphins are not the only sea life in the firth. There are migrating Atlantic salmon feeding the River Ness, Nairn, Findhorn, Spey etc. and are critical for wildlife, many jobs and so on. Additionally there are mackerel, cod, pollock, ling, crabs, lobsters ate. It is sheer madness to even contemplate ship to ship transfers.
  18. Hugh Webb 26 Jan 2017
    Myself and my wife have visited the Cromarty Firth many times to watch the dolphins and all the other wildlife that can be seen in this area. Please do not let this fantastic environment be destroyed.
  19. David Miller 26 Jan 2017
    Please do not allow this to go ahead.
  20. Carol gray samuels 26 Jan 2017
    Don't risk it .. one error could destroy the environment for yrs yrs if not permanently
  21. Barbara Lindsay 26 Jan 2017
    Urging the Scottish Parliament to do whatever they can to put an end to these proposals & protect our environment and dolphins from the risks these proposals pose.
  22. Ian brunskill 27 Jan 2017
    We holiday up there quite a bit and love going to watch the dolphins at chanory point this could quite easily end in an environmental disaster which would ruin a beautiful part of Scotland.
  23. walter innes 27 Jan 2017
    to borrow a quote
    - the pockets of a few, should not come before the good of the many...
  24. Kathryn Sonley 27 Jan 2017
    I do not believe that this delicate ecosystem and beautiful environment should be endangered by risking ship to ship oil transfers.
    It poses too big a risk and and should be prohibited in environmentally sensitive areas.
  25. Craig Maddock 27 Jan 2017
    Why risk the future existence of our wildlife for financial gain for a few people now?
  26. Margaret Smith 27 Jan 2017
    Please do not risk spoiling this beautiful area of my fathers place of birth.
  27. jacquie 27 Jan 2017
    choose jobs, choose marine life, choose oil transfer ships tied to the shore, choose NO to STS in the Cromarty Firth!
  28. Mary doonan 27 Jan 2017
    Protect precious wildlife
  29. Nigel Shapcott 27 Jan 2017
    It is about time the Scottish Government stood up for the people who would be adversely affected by this ill thought out proposal if implemented. It is frustrating to see the "big boys" with all their resources try to trample on the Cromarty Firth and Inner Moray Firth communities.
  30. Laura Manson 28 Jan 2017
    Why should our beautiful local area be threatened by this ship To ship transfers when the trust port board could provide a safe environment on shore.
  31. Karin Nichol 28 Jan 2017
    If you don't care for nature (which you should) think of all the people depending on tourism. Keep on destroying the beauty tourists come to see, it will stop them coming. Simple maths.
  32. Frank MacKenzie 28 Jan 2017
    I spent many years in the Moray area before I became an expat & settled in Thailand. If they want to do this type of operation, may I suggest somewhare down south like near the Isle of Man. The moray economy is very stable I beleive
  33. Lorraine Cran 28 Jan 2017
    Please do not destroy the habitat of dolphins fish and birds. It would be a crime
  34. Neil Meldrum 28 Jan 2017
    The potential for a leak in this Beautiful seascape
    Is too much Please get it stopped before an environmental disaster
  35. Ian Williams 28 Jan 2017
    It is with a great sense of disbelief that there people who are determined to destroy a natural balance, shame shame on them.
  36. Alison Macdonald 28 Jan 2017
    Completely inappropriate application that if it goes ahead has the potential to inflict devastating damage to the Moray Firth ecosystem which in turn impacts negatively on local businesses and individuals reliant on tourism. The economic benefit to the community from tourism far outweighs the economic benefit to the community of ship to ship oil transfers. Even without an oil spill. damage to the local ecosystem will occur according to expert testimony, and combined with visual, light, noise and air pollution when ship to ship transfers take place is bound to impact negatively on tourism in the long term. Trust ports were set up to serve regional and local interests and therefore Trust Port boards need to be transparent and accountable to regional and local stakeholders and operate to the benefit of the region as a whole.
  37. Karen mack 28 Jan 2017
    I am opposed to anything which endangers our environment and can damage our economy
  38. Fiona 29 Jan 2017
    Our dolphins are more important than the financial savings!
  39. John Glen Lloyd Stewart 29 Jan 2017
    In these routine functions there is inevitably risk. cannot believe this is even contemplated due to risk to wildlife, holiday activity, non industrial shipping, coastal fishing, migration of salmon and risk to beach rating plus enclosed nature of firth waters as opposed to open sea dispersal of any contamination.
  40. Diana Pullin 29 Jan 2017
    There should be Environmental Legislation to prevent ship to ship oil transfers in environmentally sensitive locations, especially those with established Wild andMarine life. Ship to ship oil transfers always pose risks to Wildlife and local economies, neither acceptable to Cromarty and surrounding areas. We need to be moving away from dependency on fossil fuels, fast.
  41. Grant Stewart 29 Jan 2017
    This plan is from the Donald Trump business school!
  42. Margaux Dodds 29 Jan 2017
    The area planned to allow these transfers is of significant environmental importance and the area surrounding the Port Authority designated area is protected by law. Even if no oil spills ever occur, during normal operations, noise, potential threats to the marine environment from ballast waters being dumped, the increase in boat traffic and size and the emission of hazardous gasses during transfers, all have potential to impact on the wildlife, marine environment, local residents and businesses. Ship to ship transfers have been taking place in Nigg for decades, there is no reason why this could not continue and there is no reason to expose the area to the dangers of ship to ship oil transfers at sea. The devastating impact on the environment and local economy is not worth the risk, with no-one standing to benefit from this arrangement but the Port Authority
    - adding nothing to the local economy and could potentially cost jobs. There is literally no worse area that could have been picked for transfers at sea to take place and I believe they should be shelved, and the Port should use the existing facility at Nigg.
  43. Graham. Vine 29 Jan 2017
    There is a perfectly satisfactory jetty based ship to ship facility inside the Cromarty Firth, where waste water discharges from tankers can be treated before release into the sea. There are NO waste water treatment facilities available for ships anchored in the Moray Firth, and all waste water and discharged ballast water, complete with it's foreign parasitic organisms , can only go direct into the waters of the Moray Firth.

    The Moray Firth is not merely the home to it's own subspecies of bottle nose Dolphins, but is also the "Highway" for migrating wild salmon returning to the Ness, Nairn, Findhorn Lossie and Spey salmon rivers. Once contaminated by foreign parasites, these will be there for ever as they are not capable of being removed. This could devestate, or destroy the wild salmon native to these rivers.
  44. Corrina Godsman 29 Jan 2017
    This is too great a risk to take. The damage could never be undone.
  45. Markstevens 29 Jan 2017
    Just NO
  46. Paul Aarden 29 Jan 2017
    Better safe than sorry! Don't let it happen, please!
  47. Lorraine Ewing 29 Jan 2017
    I go here every year for my holidays and cannot believe they are going to do this. Please stop it x
  48. Frances Tilbrook 29 Jan 2017
    MSPs should be aware that the Port Authority keep stating that they have safely been undertaking ship-to-ship transfers for years. This is disingenuous (to put it politely). The transfers have been within the calm waters of the Cromarty Firth, with both ships made secure up against a jetty with all facilities including ballast water treatment. Why can't they continue using this facility, rather than their incredibly risky and potentially disastrous proposal?
  49. Lindy Cameron 30 Jan 2017
    An extraordinarily inappropriate proposal. There is far too much irreparably at risk if it goes ahead.
  50. Helen 30 Jan 2017
    Protect our wildlife!