Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01615 · Session 5

State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
7,236 online signatures with a country
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  2. 10 Nov 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  3. 8 Dec 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  5. 31 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  6. 28 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  7. 18 Apr 2017
    2 mentions
  8. 16 May 2017
    1 mention
  9. 23 May 2017
    1 mention
  10. 26 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  11. 28 Jun 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 10 Oct 2019
    1 mention
  13. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,236 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,092 42.7%
  2. England1,989 27.5%
  3. United Kingdom1,746 24.1%
  4. Wales115 1.6%
  5. United States53 0.7%
  6. Northern Ireland26 0.4%
  7. Australia24 0.3%
  8. France22 0.3%
  9. Ireland19 0.3%
  10. Netherlands18 0.2%
  11. 31 other countries132 1.8%

Comments

603 comments, oldest first
603 comments · showing 251–300
  1. Moira Gibson 9 Aug 2016
    I fully support this position
  2. Graham Capper 9 Aug 2016
    Just do it...
  3. Dr Stephen Temperley 9 Aug 2016
    It should have been proposed and ratified decades ago
  4. John Cantelo 9 Aug 2016
    A minimum requirement to stop wildlife crime.
  5. Mr Greer Hart, senior 9 Aug 2016
    Many, many humane people are fed up with the shenanigans of the Government and those who shoot birds for sport. Time has come for greater public control and for politidicans to take heed. Time it was shown that greater economic benefit would accrue if our landscape, now used for shooting on, were to be used for more humane activities to create a better and more reliable employment structure for such rural areas, and ending the boast that the shooting estates give so much to the economy. Those that can toe the line and not kill wildlife, would of course, be exempt. Just stop breaking ghe law and conforming to the wishes of many and leave Birds of Prey and Mountain Hares etc alone.
  6. Simon Tucker 9 Aug 2016
    Voluntary arrangements have not worked: wildlife crime is rife on these estates. Licensing, with clear minimum targets for predator levels (weasels, stoats, foxes, as well as birds of prey) are essential. The killing has to stop.
  7. stevet macsweeney 9 Aug 2016
    I support this petition
  8. Roger Daniels 9 Aug 2016
    these "people" who kill for the fun of it are sick.
  9. Paul Thompson 9 Aug 2016
    I cannot understand why some people get pleasure by killing!!!
  10. Becky Austin 10 Aug 2016
    Fully in support of this petition.
  11. Alexander William Leslie Joss 10 Aug 2016
    I am not at all against game bird hunting per se, but it should only be carried out strictly within the laws in force which ban persecution of raptors. As self-regulation in gamebird hunting estates is not working, a state licensing system needs to be introduced.
  12. David Stewart 10 Aug 2016
    This must be a case to implement vicarious responsibility
  13. Mark Cant 11 Aug 2016
    Landowners need to be be taken into account should they be found guilty of systematically abusing commonly recognised conservation measures & laws.
  14. Lesley hughes 11 Aug 2016
    I do not agree with any ganebird hunting whatsoever. There is not a single situation where this is acceptable.
  15. John Cantelo 11 Aug 2016
    This is the minimum requirement if we are to stop wildlife crime and stop criminals being given public subsidy.
  16. Rob Ballinger 11 Aug 2016
    "Glorious" sick 12th tomorrw sigh
  17. Pauline09 11 Aug 2016
    It's time this outdated "sport" was consigned to the history books. It is a black cloud on Scottish heritage!
  18. Mark Johnston 11 Aug 2016
    As a teuchter and as a near neighbour of grouse moors (for the last twenty years) I have seen no decline in the persecution of wild animals by the employees of the estates. The same illegal practices I saw first hand in the 1970s in the Angus Glens continue to this day and the hills are now far more intensively managed and more of a monoculture than I have ever seen them before. Elsewhere in Scotland there are better examples of grouse moors being more sensitively and sensibly managed. These estates would have no difficulty complying with licensing conditions but it strikes me that until there is enforced licensing, those with the worst records will have no incentive to change.
  19. Sue Brodie 11 Aug 2016
    Please licence game bird hunting to protect our raptures
  20. Martin Turner 11 Aug 2016
    A good reason for pushing on with the land reform agenda.
  21. anne bourne 11 Aug 2016
    The greed of these shooting companies is beyond belief, to the extent that nothing else should exist should be allowed to exist on the moors, even the most precious and endangered wildlife, who might take a few grouse out of the millions they breed
  22. Liz Freitas 11 Aug 2016
    It seems that money making of a few is more important than protecting the natural heritage for the many. When will we wise up?
  23. Pete Younger 11 Aug 2016
    Please urgently introduce severe penalties up to estate forfeiture.
  24. NJ Cassidy 11 Aug 2016
    Closer regulation of grouse moors clearly needed.
  25. Ash 11 Aug 2016
    such great birds... these guys with money should be protecting them for the future of their children...
  26. dennis 11 Aug 2016
    Land owners clearly connected to the very people who should be prosecuting them. Stop this killing of wildlife for profit. stop any land subsidies.
  27. phil crennell 11 Aug 2016
    time for humanity to grow up
  28. LesleyS 11 Aug 2016
    Why do people want to kill living things, there are better ways of proving what a good shot one is.
  29. Andrew McCuaig 11 Aug 2016
    The current legislation has been an abject failure. It's time to get a real grip on this issue.
  30. Hedd angharad 11 Aug 2016
    Better laws and regulations should be made for game shooters, plus harsher penalties!
  31. Susan Hunton 11 Aug 2016
    I strongly agree with the idea of licensing
    - it will not stop some but I feel that it will raise awareness, not only of the illegal killing of raptors, but also the importance of these magnificent birds to our wildlife surroundings. On a personal note, I find it quite horrifying that some of the birds are poisoned or trapped causing painful deaths to these beautiful birds
    - please help
  32. Camelia Leveridge 11 Aug 2016
    I support this petition.
  33. Ros McDade 11 Aug 2016
    We can't let this carry on, please protect our beautiful birds of prey.
  34. Sheila Meadows 11 Aug 2016
    Iconic birds, they must be protected, the Highlands is their home....
  35. Martin Finnigan 11 Aug 2016
    I support this petition and agree with the four points set out below
  36. Frederick Baty 11 Aug 2016
    Why is Scotland missing from choice of country?
  37. Gordon Wilson 11 Aug 2016
    We need a solution that will definitely deter killing of raptors. If there is no such deterrent then ban the activities that estates think they are trying to protect.
  38. Robert 11 Aug 2016
    Mankind can't live without nature, so please show it some respect for all our sakes.
  39. Ernie Scales 11 Aug 2016
    For far too long income has ruled this argument and Fergus is still making sure the 'value' of shooting to the Scottish rural economy is highlighted. A proper balance needs to be struck between shooting income and tourist income. Without its iconic wildlife will tourists still visit Scotland in number?
  40. Mandy 11 Aug 2016
    Having just returned from Scotland and having seen the Osplets it is saddening to think that these beautiful birds together with all other raptors have such an uncertain and dangerous future thanks to the rich, greedy people who hunt. This has to stop now!
  41. Sean 11 Aug 2016
    Raptors are part of our ecosystem and should be respected by us all. Shooting is a sport for the few and although considered important to the livelihood of some it is no excuse for destroying our native species.
  42. Sidney Burnett 11 Aug 2016
    For million's of years all these animals existed side by side in perfect harmony . One day and I hope it's soon mother nature is going to shrug mankind off the planet like the cancer he has become.
  43. Suzanne simpson 11 Aug 2016
    Please, we beg you. Please do something to stop the persecution of our wildlife. You can make a difference.
  44. Jan montgomery 11 Aug 2016
    Shocked by the knowledge of killings of raptors to facilitate game bird shooting. Love our wildlife!
  45. Suzanne simpson 11 Aug 2016
    Please do something to protect our wildlife.
  46. Karen 11 Aug 2016
    I am fortunate to go out to work each day as a wildlife tour guide, this includes watching golden eagles, sea eagles, hen harriers and buzzards. Raptors are majestic birds and still a rare and wondrous sight. I have a responsibility to educate the public on their importance both intrinsically and as part of the wider food web, and really explaining just how rare and special it is that we are seeing these birds and the negativity that still surrounds them. We have come a long way through country-wide extinction, the plights of reintroduction and now we must fight to end persecution.
  47. Roy Clarke 11 Aug 2016
    livestock reared for the shooting fraternity must NOT have priority over our native wildlife. Please bring an end to the illegal persecution of our Raptors and other wildlife. Say NO to Grouse moors.
  48. Andrew Lane 11 Aug 2016
    A good idea. Grouse moors should be consigned to the 19th century.
  49. Sylvia Collingwood 11 Aug 2016
    I cannot understand the mentality of people who actively kill these fantastic birds all because they might take a few grouse chicks
    - surely a drop in the ocean compared to the thousands of birds that are reared all for the "sport" of game shooting.
  50. John Gay 11 Aug 2016
    Environmental management of the red grouse sporting areas must promote a sustainable future for the terrain and communities. Sporting estates need to be held accountable for their methods.