Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01615 · Session 5

State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
7,236 online signatures with a country
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  2. 10 Nov 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  3. 8 Dec 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  5. 31 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  6. 28 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  7. 18 Apr 2017
    2 mentions
  8. 16 May 2017
    1 mention
  9. 23 May 2017
    1 mention
  10. 26 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  11. 28 Jun 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 10 Oct 2019
    1 mention
  13. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,236 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,092 42.7%
  2. England1,989 27.5%
  3. United Kingdom1,746 24.1%
  4. Wales115 1.6%
  5. United States53 0.7%
  6. Northern Ireland26 0.4%
  7. Australia24 0.3%
  8. France22 0.3%
  9. Ireland19 0.3%
  10. Netherlands18 0.2%
  11. 31 other countries132 1.8%

Comments

603 comments, oldest first
603 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Jonathan Stone 13 Jul 2016
    I am told that Scottish signatures are much more welcome than those from other parts of the UK. Although currently living in Wales, I am Scottish by birth and expect my signature to be given full weight.
  2. Mr Greer Hart, senior 13 Jul 2016
    I am a member of the John Muir Trust, Scottish Wildlife Trust, RSPB donor, Butterfly Conservation, Buglife, Plantlife, Scotland for Animals, Animal Concern Scotland, Badger Trusts, CPRE, and along with friends own land on which we protect Hen Harriers, Buzzards. This has given me plenty of knowledge as to what is going on in our Scottish countryside and in the rest of the UK. I am also a member of many international conservation and animal welfare organisations, which also has given me a world view of the cruel and deleterious effects of hunting on a beleaguered wildlife, of which many face extinction. The killing of Birds of Prey has shown just how lacking in concern our whole law enforcement and judicial processes have shown, with a feeble response to the poisoning, snaring, trapping and shooting of any creature that may affect grouse numbers. There is also the anomaly of large areas of land in Scotland being owned by outsiders (individuals, companies, syndicates), who have treated the environment of Scotland and the rest of the UK, as a playground for blood sports. The claims made for being good conservationists by shooting estates is nonsense, as are their being important employers and providers of wholesome food. I am sure that, if given the chance and the resources, there are plenty of experienced and well-qualified people and organisations, who could draw up a national plan for the Scottish countryside, involving its restoration and in creating better paid employment rather than the seasonal and poorly paid ones at present. A great explosion to turn Scotland into a massive attraction for humane tourism, and employment in industries that would add higher value to the economy For too long, the hunting stranglehold has held Scotland and its politicians in a vice grip, making them reluctant to change, using egregious and excessive powers of persuasion to influence what can live and die on the landscape.
  3. Bruce Buswell 13 Jul 2016
    So much of the landscape looks like a patchy heather desert as a result of burning. It's so far from natural in the National Parks
  4. Geoff Simons 13 Jul 2016
    The effect of raptor persecution and the sale of game meat with levels of pesticides and lead potentially well above the legal limits for non game food affects people on both sides of the border.
    I hope that the Scottish Government take note of sound scientific research and the continuing illegal persecution of raptors and the continuing faliure of the game shooting industry to effectively regulate itself to come to the correct decision.
    I hope that the British government soon review their policies in England as well!
  5. Amanda 13 Jul 2016
    I'm sick of hearing how the rich are killing our wild life . Yes ours , we share this great country with and it all deserves a safe home . Rich killing our fox are birds of pray just so thay can shoot or ripe it up . I say NO MORE
  6. mark hill 13 Jul 2016
    In the UK you need a game license available at main post offices why people just jump on a band wagon with out doing any research is unbelievable
  7. Matt brake 14 Jul 2016
    I live in new Zealand where we have a fish and game bird license. This seems to work very well and all party's are happy. All proceeds from the license go back into the well being of the sport ie protecting and or inhancing breeding habitat. Works fine and is a very small cost for a year's worth of fun.
  8. Mark Ward 14 Jul 2016
    Needs sorting!
  9. JohnnyBirks 14 Jul 2016
    I visit Scotland frequently for both work and holidays, and I value its wildlife, and especially its predators. There is an urgent need to allow protected predatory birds and mammals to thrive in the absence of illegal persecution linked to game shooting.
  10. Alison Greggans 14 Jul 2016
    Long overdue and imperative for improving a habitat that's fit for a whole suite of wildlife not just a single species, shot to line pockets of societies elite.
  11. Fiona Guest 14 Jul 2016
    A licensing system should be welcomed by all, managing land for game is, as we are often told by interested parties, a skilled profession. Skilled professions that impact on a wide range of people should be happy to be licenced and to have their professionalism endorsed. Those who do not behave responsibly should have their rights restricted. A licencing system would provide a framework for this and ensure that the species of plant and animal found on sporting estates that do not directly benefit the estate have improved, reasonable, enforceable protection.
  12. Anna Macfie 14 Jul 2016
    Gamebird hunting is a bloodsport and should be licensed to control persecution of red and other grouse as well as the wild raptors which naturally prey on them.
  13. Rose Williams 14 Jul 2016
    Vital for the future of Scottish wildlife. I visit Scotland frequently and value it's wildlife greatly. However finding dead raptors and other wildlife in areas of shoot is terrible and something must be done soon to redress the balance.
  14. James Irvine 14 Jul 2016
    There is an urgent need to allow protected predatory birds and mammals to thrive in the absence of illegal persecution linked to game shooting.
  15. Thomas David Dick 14 Jul 2016
    The issue of criminality on scottish shooting estates is a blot on the whole of Scotland's reputation...this is the very least that needs to be done...it also needs to be enforced, truly without "fear or favour", as a matter of urgency.
  16. Eileen McCann 14 Jul 2016
    We need to shift from indulging the rich and impoverishing the environment, to providing a rich and diverse natural environment for the many. Time for this to end now.
  17. Matthew Crighton 14 Jul 2016
    This needs to be done to bring Scotland into the 21st century
  18. Gary Watt 15 Jul 2016
    Barbaric and serves no real purpose.
  19. Scott Rogers 15 Jul 2016
    A licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland is absolutely essential. This small, and highly privileged sector has too long been allowed to regulate itself, despite disgraceful evidence showing a direct correlation between gamebird hunting and the illegal killing of birds of prey and other highly vulnerable species within Scotland. Licensing would increase accountability within the sector and allow for effective enforcement for crimes against endangered species. There should be no tolerance for the senseless killing of birds of prey, and the gamebird industry's complicity in the destruction of these birds has proven that they are unable to abide by even the most basic conservation goals.
  20. Colin Lamb 15 Jul 2016
    I strongly believe that Scotland's birds of prey and wildlife should take priority over the practice of hunting of gamebirds and regulations should tightly control the practice and reduce the impact that it has to a minimum.
  21. Black Sheep 15 Jul 2016
    Killing raptors is inexcusable
    - greed and ignorance are to blame. Education has failed
    - now is the time for tough legislation and enforcement.
  22. Gordon Holm 15 Jul 2016
    Raptor killing on game estates is currently at scandalous levels
  23. Gail Stirling 15 Jul 2016
    Raptors are essential as part of our healthy ecosystem. Our Government has a duty to protect all of the rich and diverse wildlife that our beautiful country is so famous for.
  24. Ric Lander 15 Jul 2016
    Self regulation is not working.
  25. Paul Coulthard 15 Jul 2016
    Wildlife Tourism brings significant income to Scotland and raptors are high on visitors' "Must see" lists. Illegal persecution of these magnificent birds damages this sector, quite aside from breaking the law. Bring in regulation
    - it is long overdue.
  26. Bruce Wilson 15 Jul 2016
    Keep fighting!
  27. Ranald Nicolson Matheson 15 Jul 2016
    I recently handed in a dead buzzard to the Police HQ in Dingwall, it appeared to be a suspicious death. They still, after six days, have not taken a statement.
  28. Debbie Shepherd 15 Jul 2016
    Ban immediately
  29. Stuart Graham 15 Jul 2016
    This is an area which is long overdue more rigorous oversight and regulation. Licences should be revoked where malpractice is found.
  30. Gregor Davidson 15 Jul 2016
    Mon the Raptors.
    Clever girl.
  31. Donald Stevenson 15 Jul 2016
    Not a crow, raptor or gull to be seen in upper Glen Isla on a recent visit
  32. Diane Littlejohn 15 Jul 2016
    Long overdue. These are magnificent birds, why shouldn't they be able to survive without persecution.
  33. Steven blackley 15 Jul 2016
    I shoot regularly but even I can see that SOME big estates need to sort them selves out and they ruin it for the ones that do it the right way
  34. C. McLeod 15 Jul 2016
    Sadly, the continuing level of wildlife crime and mismanagement of our uplands show that a new approach is needed to encourage estates to adopt legal and sustainable management practices.
  35. Lawrie King 15 Jul 2016
    Why destroy such beautiful birds for the sake of a few people who pay to shoot other birds?
  36. Mick Marquiss 15 Jul 2016
    Our moorlands in Scotland are too precious to be trusted to narrow vested interest. We need proper regulation to protect the public interest.
  37. Michael Groves 16 Jul 2016
    Time & time again we read of illegal activities by those involved in the game bird shooting industry with little being done to deal with those crimes. This outdated so-called sporting pursuit which only survives on the destruction of other wildlife needs to be regulated with appropriate sanctions available to keep it within the law.
  38. Amy Brown 16 Jul 2016
    Please stop this, it seems like no matter how many times these people are caught and evidence is produced they just continue to flout law and decency and continue along their merry (murdering) way.
  39. Tim Aspden 16 Jul 2016
    Raptors are often at the top of the food chain and may therefore give an indication of ecosystem health. Scotland's wildlife is not only intrinsically valuable but contributes to rural economies and has an ambassadorial role for the nation.
  40. Jack Riggall 16 Jul 2016
    Long overdue. I await the result of this petition with interest.
  41. Ann Ingham 16 Jul 2016
    We have the same problem in Wales. I was lucky enough to see a pair of Hen Harriers passing through heading for safer territory.
  42. Frances Jones 17 Jul 2016
    People tell me their dogs have been poisoned eating bait put down for birds of prey in big shooting estates near Dunbar
  43. Raymond Henry Hogg 17 Jul 2016
    Game shooting interests have surely had more than enough time to put their house in order regarding raptor persecution. How much longer do we need to watch the continual flouting of wildlife legislation by a privileged few?
  44. Jacqui Welsh 17 Jul 2016
    The way the land is managed by Game Estates is not acceptable in a modern Scotland. Moor burning is terrible for the environment and their attitude to wildlife is unforgiving and unforgivable.
  45. Ciaran Cronin 17 Jul 2016
    Like any industry with the potential for significant social and environmental damage, the shooting industry needs to be regulated for the benefit of ALL the people of Scotland. You have a wonderful, beautiful country with warm hearted people and incredible wildlife
    - you dont deserve the stain of the widespread and illegal killing of birds of prey and other species.
  46. David Jones 17 Jul 2016
    Industrial farming of our uplands denies a place for key wildlife species and must be curtailed.
  47. Phil Shaw 17 Jul 2016
    Those committing wildlife crimes
    - and their employers
    - should not be permitted to continue hunting. A licensing system would help achieve what voluntary measures have patently failed to do: to eliminate raptor persecution in Scotland.
  48. Colin Norman 17 Jul 2016
    Its the LAW
  49. Michael Steward 17 Jul 2016
    Driven shoots disturb all manner of wildlife. Any animal that may be considered a predator could be killed on the drive, or location of breeding site recorded & come back later to control the predator. Birds of prey are also sometimes shot flying over the guns intended for grouse. This "Victorian Sport" is out dated and should be stopped.
  50. Claire Smith 18 Jul 2016
    Game it's shooting is a business and should be subject to regulation, with consequences & deterrents in place to prevent environmental damage occurring. I work with several excellent estates in Perthshire whose reputation suffers when persecution continues on other estates. Licensing should help raptors and estates and increased transparency should increase trust and working relationships between estates, conservationists and the wider public.