Petition · PE01615 · Session 5
State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland
Signatures
0
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.
What the petitioner did first
Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
27 Oct 20161 mention
-
10 Nov 20161 mention
-
8 Dec 20161 mention
-
24 Jan 20171 mention
-
31 Jan 20171 mention
-
28 Mar 20171 mention
-
18 Apr 20172 mentions
-
16 May 20171 mention
-
23 May 20171 mention
-
26 Sep 20171 mention
-
28 Jun 20181 mention
-
10 Oct 20191 mention
-
23 Feb 20211 mention
Signatures by country
7,236 online signaturesComments
603 comments, oldest first603 comments · showing 101–150
-
Frank hughes 18 Jul 2016Its about time something was done to save our wild
Life. -
Alan Short 18 Jul 2016Driven grouse shooting,for the pleasure of killing, seems completely incompatible with most modern views on the need for empathy with and respect for wild birds and animals.The Scottish government needs to investigate alternative economic uses for upland grouse moors with a view to banning this activity completely.
-
James Reynolds 18 Jul 2016Some estates have made great strides in terms of cleaning up their practices and 'going straight', and should be rightly commended and recognised for their efforts in this regard. But there are still many that continue to undertake illegal activities in pursuit of ever larger bags, particularly of driven grouse. Those who do this are still of a significant number (certainly significant enough to have negative national population-level impacts on some species such as golden eagles and hen harriers) , and their actions tarnish the industry as a whole. Regulation of the sort proposed here would provide a simple solution to this problem. Those estates which operate within the law have absolutely nothing to fear. At the same time such regulation would provide a rapid and significant boost to the industry's image
- something of which it is in dire need. Indeed, the industry itself should surely welcome such proposals as a progressive step to improving public trust and its working relationships with many other sectors that have an interest in good custodianship of the countryside. -
Sandra M Taylor 18 Jul 2016It's time that game shooting is subjected to regulations as some estates seem not to have conservation interests in place at all. To an outsider it seems as if there's a lot of cruelty in estate management these days and it has to stop.
-
james mcguigan 18 Jul 2016about time!!!
-
Andrew Sandeman 18 Jul 2016The vast majority of European countries require estates to be licenced
- why don't we? Is it because we are the most 'feudal' country in Europe? -
John McInnes 18 Jul 2016It is essential to stop raptor persecution on driven Grouse moors. A clear financial deterrent or custodial sentencing must be applied to persistent offending estates, their owners and appropriate staff. Licensing monitoring and review on an annual basis should be done and offending estates be subject to licence loss if found to be involved in raptor destruction
-
Mark Wright. 18 Jul 2016Good move done for rapter group you have my full support.
-
Yvonne Slater 18 Jul 2016I am opposed to all hunting, but if people must for sound reasons then it should be tightly regulated and controlled.
-
R Stuart Craig 18 Jul 2016Why can the people concerned in policing the Estates not get satisfaction when lawbreakers are brought to court....can justice be bought???
-
John Manson 18 Jul 2016All responsible Estates should have nothing to fear, and should benefit in the long term.
-
Erica Hudson 19 Jul 2016Regulation is needed to protect wildlife from irresponsible and malicious acts.
-
Valerie Forbes 19 Jul 2016Over the last 10 years I have noticed a decline in variety of species and fall of numbers of each species when I have been on bird and general nature walks in the Lothians and Borders. Some further conservation measures are needed and monitoring in the most affected areas. Good and well managed Estates have nothing to worry about under stricter licensing laws.
-
Claire Druett 19 Jul 2016Please do.
-
Allan Brown 19 Jul 2016This is the 21st century yet huge swathes of the Scottish countryside are misused for the continuing Victorian pleasure of killing for fun which has major impacts upon other wildlife that dares to impact upon this so-called sport, as well as other environmental consequences. Such activity needs to be strictly controlled and the promoters of it educated as to how to better use their land for the benefit of a greater range of wildlife and the tourist benefits this would bring to local economies. A shooting for fun based economy is no longer acceptable.
-
Vicky Cole 19 Jul 2016I have seen so many images of slaughtered Mountain hares, Foxes and even Lynx and Eagles, trapped, snared, poisoned or shot to keep the preserved landscape of the shooting estates, which receive a lot of subsidies yet often devastates the wildlife which attracts tourism and maintains part of the great reputation of this country. Many have been impressed by the recent actions of politicians here to maintain the Hunting Act yet still wildlife is persecuted for country sports, something has to be done to counteract this
-
Steven blackley 19 Jul 2016As a keen shooting man and bird ringer I think it's time some of the shooting fraternity come out of the dark ages it's ruining all the good work the decent people who manage shoots do
-
Alexander Keith 21 Jul 2016Make a voluntary licence a condition of receiving state (including EU) subsidy. The estate has to provide evidence of compliance with conditions and provide evidence of their efforts to improve biodiversity and offset negative effects of shooting land management. Have a system of random inspections. This move is long overdue.
-
Paul Haire 21 Jul 2016Long overdue. Get it done Parliament.
-
Sandra Keith 21 Jul 2016Enough is enough.
-
Stuart Wilshaw 21 Jul 2016The time for talking is over, time to walk the walk.
-
Duncan Orr-Ewing 21 Jul 2016Regulation of gamebird hunting in Scotland to protect the public interest is now long overdue. This would simply bring us into line with common practice in other European countries.
-
Adam Craig 21 Jul 2016Its time to take this country out of the Victorian era and have a modern look at how our countryside is run. For too long a small percentage of our population have powers and control away above their numbers. Namely landowners and farmers. We pay huge amounts of our taxes subsidising this group and it is time that the rest of us are heard.
-
David Parkinson 21 Jul 2016Sad thing is that money talks. Grouse shooting brings in millions.
-
Steven Gillespie 22 Jul 2016Sustainable rural development can never be achieved in Scotland until land is in the hands of communities rather than the landed elite. Hobby landscapes are no longer acceptable and land owners should be charged for preventing a range of ecosystem services that could benefit society. A license system is a good start.
-
Maria Dawn Hemingway 22 Jul 2016Politicians need to be aware that the general public care about wildlife and look to them to ensure it is maintained and protected.
-
G Chronowicz 22 Jul 2016Time for decisive action.
-
Stuart Rivers 22 Jul 2016Raptor persecution and indiscriminate poisoning persists on and around shooting estates.Self-policing clearly doesn't work, it is time for licensing and closer monitoring of estate practices.
-
Mr W Watson 22 Jul 2016Delighted to support this cause.
-
steve macsweeney 22 Jul 2016They say a wild salmon is worth £5000.00 to the Scottish tourist industry. What price would you put on protected birds? A handful of grasping landowners benefitting at the expense of the country. Does that remind you of anything Scotland?
-
Wesley Amadeus Glock 22 Jul 2016Supporting this man...
-
Adam Craig 22 Jul 2016Get rid of these things and the criminals that deploy them.
-
Harry 22 Jul 2016As an environmentalist and hillwalker for forty years, I am alarmed at the acceleration I witness in the industrialisation of our countryside.
Bulldozed tracks, not marked on any map, extensive muirburn, drainage channels are all symptoms of this. A less obvious, but equally pernicious result of gamebird 'hunting' is the persecution of any species not regarded as game. I use parenthesis as I do not recognise an activity where the quarry is driven toward the guns as 'hunting'. This is merely amusement park coconut shy shooting, mechanised slaughter, on a grand scale. An entirely abhorrent pastime that should go the same way as bear baiting, cock fighting and throwing Christians to lions. -
Sandra Scott 22 Jul 2016Time to hit these people where it hurts, in their pocket. The SG must take action to protect our wildlife
-
catherine duncan 22 Jul 2016Why should other species of mammals be killed for the benefit of the shooting fraternity e, g stoats weasels, raptors foxes , everything that threatens a shoot
-
Liz Balharry 23 Jul 2016If our uplands were a rich and varied landscape for wildlife with industries attracting high wages and water holding abilities which prevented flooding downstream, and someone suggested replacing this type of land use with what we know today as driven grouse shoots ........it would be greeted with cries of derision and hoots of laughter. Until we get rid of driven grouse shoots we will not be able to release the potential of the uplands to bring benefit to the many rather than the few....
-
Brian Sutton 23 Jul 2016It is appalling that these people who pander to a pastime supported by a tiny minority feel that they can get away with crimes that the vast majority of people find abhorrent. If traps are found on a shooting estate the estate should be closed for a minimum of a year ad heavily fined.
-
tom ross 23 Jul 2016We have to live by the laws of the country,so should these people
-
D Constantine 24 Jul 2016This issue needs to be more prominent in the media so that more of the general public are aware of these awful crimes.
-
Ian Bell 24 Jul 2016VERY long overdue
-
Stephen Heath 24 Jul 2016Time to get tough with the shooting industry a prison sentence is well overdue!
-
Douglas Malpus 24 Jul 2016After the estates have dined and wined some Scottish MP's to get over their conservation lies then illegal traps are found to show their real intentions. Illegal poisons are in use. Shooting, trapping and poisoning of protected species is rife. It must be stopped. If the shooting industry cannot stay within the law then they must be banned.
-
Anna McOustra 24 Jul 2016It would be a good start to controlling game shooting
Why is it a new pheasant shoot, with hundreds of birds released, where they haven't been before, and this is not regarded as "change of use" and the landowner does not have to apply for "planning" consent? So no mitigation plan has to be done to evaluate the effect on the existing wildlife in the area. -
DAVID JEWELL 24 Jul 2016IF THESE TRAPS ARE FOUND ON THESE ESTATES THEN SUBSTANCIAL FINES SHOULD BE LEVIED
-
William Barber 24 Jul 2016Raptors need protection.
-
David Stewart 24 Jul 2016Now has got to be the time to implement vicarious responsibility
-
John Adair 24 Jul 2016Licensing of shooting is long overdue.
-
Nick Hill 25 Jul 2016Stop killing beautiful creatures
-
Grace McCarron 25 Jul 2016We need to protect our wildlife. Nature is our future! Please stop this atrocity.
-
Joe Cooper 25 Jul 2016Licensing has proven successful in other countries and should be adopted for many situations such as this in order to better establish a sense of importance and security both for the sport and protected species involved.