Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01615 · Session 5

State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
7,236 online signatures with a country
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  2. 10 Nov 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  3. 8 Dec 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  5. 31 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  6. 28 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  7. 18 Apr 2017
    2 mentions
  8. 16 May 2017
    1 mention
  9. 23 May 2017
    1 mention
  10. 26 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  11. 28 Jun 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 10 Oct 2019
    1 mention
  13. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,236 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,092 42.7%
  2. England1,989 27.5%
  3. United Kingdom1,746 24.1%
  4. Wales115 1.6%
  5. United States53 0.7%
  6. Northern Ireland26 0.4%
  7. Australia24 0.3%
  8. France22 0.3%
  9. Ireland19 0.3%
  10. Netherlands18 0.2%
  11. 31 other countries132 1.8%

Comments

603 comments, oldest first
603 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Shannon Llewellyn 25 Jul 2016
    Degradation of uplands, and persecution of native species, for the enjoyment of a tiny minority of people really should be a thing of the past, and this would at least be a start.
  2. Tony Wesley 25 Jul 2016
    We need to protect our Raptors this shooting of them must stop
  3. Brian Whiteman 26 Jul 2016
    The murder of other creatures that we share this planet with, is a sad indictment of the human race.
  4. Mark Brain 26 Jul 2016
    They can't be allowed to do whatever they like any longer. Killin g national treasures to pander to rich playboys.
  5. Mark Henson 26 Jul 2016
    Protecting the natural predators MUST be part of any land management scheme.
  6. Brian Robertson 26 Jul 2016
    Licensing of hunting is absolutely necessary to help reverse the current situation of wildlife crime going unpunished. Any estate or individual who carries out their duties in a lawful manner have nothing to fear from this proposal. Wildlife crime exists because there never has been, nor ever will be, sufficient resources to police shooting estates. A new system of sanctions must be devised and a licensing system could be a major role in achieving this.
  7. Paul Murfitt 26 Jul 2016
    I go to Scotland 3 weeks per year to see birds such as Golden Eagle & Hen Harrier so please do not let them go extinct.
  8. Margaret Adams 26 Jul 2016
    The future of the planet is more important than how much money is made in Grouse shooting
  9. Michael Thornton 26 Jul 2016
    Scotland has one of the most unregulated game management systems in the world and a disgraceful history of illegal raptor persecution on grouse moors. Surely it's time to change this and introduce greater regulation.
  10. Eilidh McNab 27 Jul 2016
    The game industry has proven that it is entirely unable or unwilling to self-regulate it's activities
    - the time has definitely come for mandatory regulation.
  11. David Candlin 27 Jul 2016
    No shooter has the right to make a beautiful Raptor extinct to me in my own country! long jail terms are needed for the owners as well as the keepers! WE WONT GO AWAY!
  12. Shaun Wells 27 Jul 2016
    Time for Scotland to lead the way.
  13. Joseph Anthony Fleming 27 Jul 2016
    As a native born Scotsman, I am saddened by the criminal activities of estate owners and their employees who persistently break the law relating to birds of prey
  14. Joseph Fleming 27 Jul 2016
    Birds of prey will continue to be illegally killed until legislation is in place which makes estate owners vicariously liable for the actions of their employees who are instructed to kill birds of prey. A licensing system with the power to revoke such a licence if terms and conditions are breached is long overdue.
  15. Philip Cox 27 Jul 2016
    I have just read of the finding of illegal traps in Cairngorm National Park, why has the lease holder not had its licence immediately revoked?
    Come on Scotland get your act together
  16. T C King 27 Jul 2016
    The protection of all raptors is essential. The legal system much be more robust with larger penalties affecting the Estate owners as well as the keepers.
  17. Chris Moorhouse 28 Jul 2016
    They're all as thick as thieves, no point asking the law to get out there and catch the evil wrongdoing gamekeepers,they're too weak to confront the bad guys.
  18. Neil Bielby 28 Jul 2016
    The grouse shooting fraternity have been breaking the law with impunity and destroying Scotland's natural heritage for too long.
  19. Bob & Val Smith 28 Jul 2016
    Too many vested interests.
    MSPs should declare whether they go gamebird hunting.
    Time and time again hands are thrown in the air in dismay but nothing is done.
    Effective legislation is required.
  20. mac cook 28 Jul 2016
    I was appalled when pictures were posted on Facebook showing all the mountain hares that had been killed up near Cairngorm.
  21. Peter Heran 28 Jul 2016
    I regularly bird watch in Scotland it's a great place to go but the destruction of birds of prey is making avoid some places I do not see the necessity for it. It may ultimately put myself and other from visiting Scotland (although England is not perfect) with the resulting loss of income to many Scottish enterprises
  22. Valerie Campbell 28 Jul 2016
    Our wild heritage should be used for the benefit of all creatures.
  23. Dougy Fraser 29 Jul 2016
    Hope this petition works as these estates need to be controlled. Feel sorry for the grouse too, poor birds.
  24. Roger Dillworth 29 Jul 2016
    Why in this day and age do some weirdos still think killing creatures is a sport? Certainly all bird shooting areas should be licensed as all people who engage in this carnage should also pay a high price for a licence. After the Dunblane massacre and others guns were taken off the streets, ownership of certain weapons was made illegal, it's about time ownership of all guns was made illegal, after all isn't there something really perverse about a small section of society getting some sort of knee trembler out of killing birds?
  25. Michael Brookes 29 Jul 2016
    In May this year we had a wonderful holiday in Scotland spending a week on Coll watching your beautiful hen harriers which have been all but exterminated due to driven grouse shooting in England. In order to prevent this abominable criminality in Scotland and to maintain a wildlife refuge for us to continue to enjoy in Scotland we are offering our full support to this petition.
  26. Colette Robertson 29 Jul 2016
    Scottish raptors are significantly reducing in population size due to inhumane, selfish and completely unnecessary interference by humans. The people involved in this persecution held to account for things to improve.
  27. Graham Cooper 29 Jul 2016
    The protection of all raptors is essential. The legal system much be more robust with larger penalties.
  28. Graham Cooper 29 Jul 2016
    The Grouse shooting fraternity have been breaking the law with impunity, punishments need to be increased.
  29. Michael Sagar 29 Jul 2016
    Stop killing wildlife.
  30. C White 29 Jul 2016
    Huntsmen are evil, Scotland deserves to be rid of these estates where they get away with murder.
  31. David Broadhead 29 Jul 2016
    I am increasingly alarmed by the spread of gamebird deserts in Scotland through over-intense management.
  32. Roger Favell 29 Jul 2016
    I am appalled that there are still people in the British Isles that think it is acceptable to kill raptors that have been protected for 60 years. It's about time the majority of the people in this Island that do not approve, stop it. If it eventually leads to the outlawing of driven Grouse shoots & loss of jobs so be it! It's time to take a stand.
  33. Brian Waite 29 Jul 2016
    This of shooting and killing wild animals for sick pleasure and emotion felt when they squeeze the guns and watch the victim fall, is nothing less than obscene. Yet humanity has the arrogance to call itself the highest form of life on planet Earth, but history shows orterwise
  34. Alexandra Keith 29 Jul 2016
    The protection for raptors is a legally binding law. The protection needs to be reinforced against those who feel they are above the law.
  35. margaret Galbraith 29 Jul 2016
    We need biodiversity to maintain a healthy ecosystem and protecting all raptors from persecution is very important. Warnings are no longer good enough and fines aren't tough enough.
  36. Jennifer M Cameron 30 Jul 2016
    Birds of prey are an important part of the eco system. Gamekeepers are destroying what can be enjoyed by many, for the sake of the few. We need a balance.
  37. Pat Lawrence 30 Jul 2016
    Have always been totally against grouse shooting. It's disgraceful how many grouse and indeed pheasants, having just been bred for the 'glorious 12th' are released to just die in our country roads. Disgraceful
  38. Gordon McKay 30 Jul 2016
    We need to protect our upland moors and raptor species against irresponsible estates and managers now.
  39. S peer 30 Jul 2016
    It's time we put Nature first over the profits for a few wealthy land owners.
  40. Irene Smith 30 Jul 2016
    Illegal raptor killing has absolutely no place in a civilised society
    - the Scottish Government must act to control gamebird hunting through legislation.
  41. Louise Ramsay 30 Jul 2016
    I feel very strongly about this. We have an exceptionally unregulated game shooting sector in this country and it results in serious damage of much of our land. We need to try regulating this sector to prevent further environmental damage and public harm.
  42. Louise Ramsay 30 Jul 2016
    The game shooting industry needs to be regulated and licensed here as it is in other European countries and in the USA. Certain practices, especially excessive muirburn and illegal persecution of raptors have been damaging our land and wildlife for a decades and recently the situation has got worse. It is time to get this situation under regulatory control.
  43. Toby Green 30 Jul 2016
    Disgusted that in this day and age we have to petition to stop illegal persecution! Makes me angry to be forced to do this to stop a minority from "enjoying" themselves slaughtering our upland birds!
  44. Jon Mercer 31 Jul 2016
    Persecution of raptors by shooting interests continues to be a blot on Scotland's environmental credentials. Even our national bird is not exempt from the self-serving interests of the shooting lobby,
  45. p palmer 31 Jul 2016
    the young from Scottish bred Hen harriers come to visit us in England each winter. I would hate to lose them as we have already lost our breeding birds due to English persecution and the inadequacy of English law enforcers. Scotland Please set an example that will show how progressive you are and how you proudly you value your wildlife. English Parliament has failed us, please do not fail Scotland too.
  46. Adam Ogley 31 Jul 2016
    This people need stopping.
  47. SUE HURST 31 Jul 2016
    The killing of any bird is a total anathema to me
  48. Leslie Scott 31 Jul 2016
    License shooting estates in Scotland.
  49. matilda shadbolt 31 Jul 2016
    It is essential to protect these magnificent creatures.
  50. Jill Hadfield 1 Aug 2016
    The ruining of the countryside that should be shared between the us all and our wildlife, just so the few can have a nice day out. Absolutely disgusting.