Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01615 · Session 5

State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland

Closed Submitted 11 Jul 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
7,236 online signatures with a country
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  2. 10 Nov 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  3. 8 Dec 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petition
    1 mention
  4. 24 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  5. 31 Jan 2017
    1 mention
  6. 28 Mar 2017
    1 mention
  7. 18 Apr 2017
    2 mentions
  8. 16 May 2017
    1 mention
  9. 23 May 2017
    1 mention
  10. 26 Sep 2017
    1 mention
  11. 28 Jun 2018
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  12. 10 Oct 2019
    1 mention
  13. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,236 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,092 42.7%
  2. England1,989 27.5%
  3. United Kingdom1,746 24.1%
  4. Wales115 1.6%
  5. United States53 0.7%
  6. Northern Ireland26 0.4%
  7. Australia24 0.3%
  8. France22 0.3%
  9. Ireland19 0.3%
  10. Netherlands18 0.2%
  11. 31 other countries132 1.8%

Comments

603 comments, oldest first
603 comments · showing 201–250
  1. COLIN DOUGLAS 1 Aug 2016
    I fail to see the pleasure and entertainment that some people seem to derive from killing things for sport. These so-called sporting estates are missing a trick making money out of killing wildlife when so much more can be made from wildlife tourism. The thrill that can be had from seeing an osprey stooping and pulling a fish from the water sure as hell beats that of a few brace of grouse lying dead on a kitchen table as far as I am concerned.
  2. Fergus Crystal 1 Aug 2016
    High time everybody is made aware how much gamebird shooting adversely affects wildlife. It's time shooting clients were made aware of the harm their insistence on large bags causes. Shooting clients include royalty, boy band members and big business. They should all know what harm they cause when they are invited on a 'day'.
  3. Janice Mermikli 1 Aug 2016
    I feel strongly about this subject and would like to see the end of illegal killing of game birds in Scotland. (Ideally, I would like to see the end of all blood sports). These magnificent birds of prey belong in the majestic Scottish countryside. Please let us preserve them as well as we can.
  4. Mike Field 2 Aug 2016
    Please protect these beautiful wild creatures from these despicable types who set illegal and barbaric traps. Like many below I would also dearly love to see an end to all game and blood sports
    - it is a ridiculous, elitest activity for the privileged few and one which has no place in a modern, compassionate and civilised world.
  5. JOHN RAINEY 2 Aug 2016
    They would leave nothing for us to marvel at
    - I hope that they come to their senses
  6. Douglas McKean 2 Aug 2016
    It is long overdue to control wayward land owners
  7. Paul Croft 2 Aug 2016
    I am not against gamebird hunting as such, but illegal persecution of birds of prey is disgraceful as is the culling of mountain hares. There also needs to be regulation on stocking levels of non-native birds. The numbers of red legged partridge and pheasant that are now loose in parts of Perthshire all year round is ludicrous and they are very destructive in both gardens and countryside. Self regulation is obviously beyond the ability of the industry and some form of legislative framework needs to be introduced.
  8. Andrew Stewart 2 Aug 2016
    I would like to see this end, how has it come, that a sport played by the elite decimates the wildlife. Golden eagles have been in retreat across Britain and now only exist in Scotland. It fills me with absolute rage that people can kill these glorious creatures to protect a vile sport which occupies the few in this country, while these birds inspire the many and probably bring more into the economy! It is a no brainer the government needs to act now!!!
  9. Gwen Grant Clifford 2 Aug 2016
    We never learn from our mistakes these birds have a vital role to play in the Eco system. A thing of beauty must NOT be destroyed at will we must manage ALL forms of hunting.
  10. Phil Hyde 2 Aug 2016
    It about time alternatives to the slaughter of native Scottish wildlife was discussed. The mismanagement of moorlands by the grouse shooting fraternity needs to be put under the spotlight for what it is
    - environmentally devastating.
  11. Kenny Kortland 2 Aug 2016
    I am a resident of Daviot, South of Inverness. The scale of illegal persecution of Scotland's protected species in this area is massive. This statement is based on my own observations on the grouse moors in the area. Even more importantly, the land is being severely degraded by the associated management.
  12. David Ashford 3 Aug 2016
    Hunt shooters are animal terrorists who should, like their dogs, be brought to heel!
  13. Ashtroth 3 Aug 2016
    The birds were here long before us,just because you've bought the land the Wildlife cannot be owned,nor do you have the right to kill it.
  14. Don S Ferguson 3 Aug 2016
    I used to volunteer with the Forestry Commission as a Warden at the Huntly Peregrine Wildwatch where there were lots of Red Squirrels these were a great source of entertainment and amazement too.
  15. Dougoutcanoe 3 Aug 2016
    The game bird shooting industry is proving time and time again that it has not improved since the Victorian era when raptors were legally classed as vermin. It is now time to bring this archaic industry into the 21 century or better still close it down for the cruelty it inflicts.
  16. Dick Glasgow 3 Aug 2016
    As a former Gamekeeper myself, I know first hand how much illegal raptor persecution went on behind the scenes & was widespread & I fear that little has improved since my time. I have no doubt that crimes that come to light are only ever going to be the tip of the iceberg & feel very strongly that a more forceful system must be implemented as a matter of urgency, to prevent rogue Keepers & their employers from treating our precious Birds of Prey with such little respect. In the C21st our raptors deserve far better treatment.
  17. Walt 3 Aug 2016
    IF gamekeepers and estate owners cannot stop persecuting birds of prey on gamebird shooting land then we must revoke licensing for gamebird shooting on all estates where indescriminate poisoning, shooting and disturbance of birds of prey nest sites. Follow the rules to protect these magnificent birds of prey or loose the right to shoot game.
  18. Gregory McShane 3 Aug 2016
    I have recently written to several Scottish ministers on the issue. The recent discovery of illegally set traps on Invercauld Estate (on the other side of the glen from Balmoral) shows how a so-called 'respectable' shooting estate can try to get away with wildlife crime while putting on that sweet, innocent face so many of the Scottish Estates (and the Gamekeepers Association) put on. Time to licence estates
    - any wildlife crime, lose the licence: lose the licence for the estate
    - not the 'owner' (for a minimum of five years) and no guns to be allowed on it. Likewise gamekeepers must be licenced and, if convicted of wildlife crime, lose the Licence to Practise
    - so they'll not be able to work as a gamekeeper
    - for life.
    Time we Scots took some action!
  19. Mike 3 Aug 2016
    We want to see wild species living in their natural hsbitat for all to enjoy. Not control of nature for the entertainment of a few!
  20. Mike Forsyth 3 Aug 2016
    It is important to highlight to clients and owners the damage that is being done so everyone can work together to solve this appalling situation
  21. Mike w Sullivan 4 Aug 2016
    For over40 I have been holiday img in Scotland and have witnessed the Decline of HARRIERS in the Moorland areas of Scotland .This year only ONE was seen .Theif has to be a Very Big Problem which is causing this Decline ? ?A Major Survey needs to be carried out to ascertain What is causing the Decline of HARRIERS .I am a Brtd Watcher and changes like this are very Noticeable over such a long period .Thank You .
  22. Cameron McNeish 4 Aug 2016
    I'm becoming increasingly concerned at the "management" of grouse moors for sport shooting to the detriment of everything else. In particular the increase in the shooting of raptors have become deplorable.
  23. Ron Greer 4 Aug 2016
    it's time to move out of the Victorian-Edwardian era
  24. Eileen Holttum 4 Aug 2016
    I have been a hillwalker for 40 years. In the last 5 years I have seen increasing extremely inappropriate upland land management measures to increase grouse numbers: these numbers I believe have a natural rise and fall over the years. Measures I've seen include eradication of mountain hares over large areas, and intensive and ugly deer fencing and shooting out of deer over whole estates.
  25. jezkempston 4 Aug 2016
    I.m concerned about the environment ... and I'm vegetarian
  26. Pat Kelsall 4 Aug 2016
    Sustainability has to be the watchword and our environment is straining under so many impacts
    - shooting estates are not environmentally diversive as the end all is rearing birds to be shot. These estates need to find other means of income.
  27. A Ross 4 Aug 2016
    I am very unhappy with the level of wildlife crime associated with gamebird management and the lack of progress being made to prevent it. Incidents such as the first east coast born white-tailed eagle in 200 years mysteriously disappearing on a grouse moor in 2014 is an example of the shooting industry directly preventing pioneering conservation work. The lack of accountability and transparency in this case has furthered my support for stricter licensing. I am also concerned about other potentially negative and poorly understood management practices such as heather burning. I support regulated licensing in order to better address the environmental impact of gamebird hunting and ensure the landscape is managed positively.
  28. Julia Howe 4 Aug 2016
    We need to protect wildlife and their habitats.
  29. Melvyn Greenhalgh 4 Aug 2016
    I am a regular visitor to Scotland , to observe the bird life that I am unable to see in England. The track record of these shooting estates with regards to wild life crime is appalling. Something has to be done to bring these criminals into line with our society standards. If an outright ban is not possible, some form of licencing must be introduced.
  30. Margaret Ponsonby 4 Aug 2016
    The wildlife of Scotland must not be slaughtered to benefit a few landowners.
  31. John Edwards 4 Aug 2016
    It is a culture that needs severely restricting at least where birds are bred, shot out of the skies in the name of sport. For some it is part of the culture and it has to stop. In the name of this sport the environment is being changed and native non-sporting species not only lose their habitat, but their lives as well. The criminal process is far too slow and is loaded in favour of the killers.
  32. Nicola Callis 4 Aug 2016
    it should be banned completely but I suppose state regulated is a good first step to preventing these estates killing what they like to protect their home grown grouse to be shot on their land!!
  33. Philip Butler 4 Aug 2016
    The landscapes created by grouse shooting are an appalling desert of patchwork burning, a practice that does nothing but harm to the environment. Add to this the lack of accountability for wildlife crime, notably raptor persecution
    - many estates have beneficial owners based in tax-havens and they simply cannot be traced. It is time this sick activity (killing animals for fun) was registered and regulated. Land registration needs to be stiffened as well, so that those reponsible can be traced and held to account.
  34. Ken Michie 4 Aug 2016
    Raptors are part of our natural environment and must be given priority over those who take pleasure from killing for sport.
  35. Roger Cottis 4 Aug 2016
    It is regrettable that our indigenous wildlife, not only wild birds suffer at the expense of non-native species (pheasants). We need radical changes in an unregulated countryside.
  36. Susan Stewart 4 Aug 2016
    This is a small step in the right direction
  37. Kath Todd 4 Aug 2016
    I have every support for sustainable which is a legutimate part of integrated land management and when well run supports our biodiversity
  38. Caroline 5 Aug 2016
    Time to change
  39. Ross 5 Aug 2016
    Game bird hunting has and is continuing to destroy our fauna and flora. It is out of control, unregulated and those involved in it are free to carry out whatever misdemeanours against raptors and other predators. They are systematically destroying the natural environment.
  40. Paul 5 Aug 2016
    This legislation is long overdue. How is it that the Scottish government wildlife policy officer does not have an ecology but a business degree? No wonder how wildlife is suffering.
  41. Barbara McMillan 5 Aug 2016
    Not before time, we have waited, not patiently, for a long time. Now is the time.
  42. Craig Morrison 6 Aug 2016
    Gamebird hunting should be outlawed never mind be licensed. The Scottish Government are weak and are as guilty as their counterparts in Westminster in pandering to wealthy land owners.
  43. Frank McKay 7 Aug 2016
    This is the time for wild life,not gun fodder
  44. Zoe van Zwanenberg 7 Aug 2016
    This is an important step in the right direction
  45. Mrs Sheila williamson 7 Aug 2016
    stop it
  46. Gerry Houston 7 Aug 2016
    As is often the case and is further evidenced in this instance, self regulation and doing the right thing are often unhappy bedfellows.
  47. Robert Clarke 7 Aug 2016
    Save our wildlife.
  48. Michael Boyle-Ronaldson 7 Aug 2016
    Hunting Raptors should be banned
  49. John Manson 7 Aug 2016
    I think the hunting fraternity are a law unto themselves and it has been going on to long. Regulation should help.
  50. Jane Payne 8 Aug 2016
    Good luck with this petition, The killing of any creature for fun is abhorrent