Good morning. We were delighted to receive 7,600 signatures from across the UK, which demonstrates the public feeling on the issue.
Scottish raptor study group members are volunteers with day jobs ranging from lawyers to conservation workers to council workers. Duncan, Andrea and I are fairly typical of the 270 members that we have across Scotland. We are passionate about raptors and their conservation. Annually—outside survey years—we monitor about 6,000 sites. We are guided by Government licences and a scientific approach. We are accredited by Scottish Natural Heritage and are subject to a code of practice and annual returns. All the data that we collect is supplied to Scottish Natural Heritage. We are patient and reasonable people who are guided by sound science, informed by debate.
Persecution black spots are in Angus, Inverness-shire, Donside and parts of the southern uplands. Scotland has an international reputation for expert raptor workers.
We are not against game bird shooting and have no wish to ban it; we are just against the illegal elements of it. We understand the importance of game bird shooting as part of the rural economy. We work with crofters, farmers, stalkers, shepherds, landowners and gamekeepers. However, our patience with the criminal end of the game shooting industry is at an end. Over years, we have seen prevarication, obfuscation and leadership failings by the landowning and game representative interests.
The Government’s review, which was conducted last year by SNH, admitted that there is a serious problem with moorland management and grouse shooting. I will give a quick explanation of the two forms of grouse shooting, which are walk-up and driven. The former is where guests with guns will walk up a hillside and shoot at grouse flushed from at their feet. It is low intensity and does not feature too much of the criminal activity on driven grouse moors.
Driven grouse moors as a business depend on having huge numbers of birds at the end of the breeding season to be shot by guests. The driven grouse shooting industry’s problem is that it cannot rely on having those big bags of grouse to shoot unless it undertakes illegal raptor persecution, because raptors would eat the surplus. The driven grouse shooting industry needs to continue the killing, because otherwise its business model is flawed.
The Scottish Government should be congratulated on the many steps that it has taken in the past few years to try to reduce the killing. The key steps have been the introduction of vicarious liability, the tightening up of general licences and two poison amnesties.
Birds of prey have been protected since 1954. The killing is cultural and an entrenched part of sporting estates that goes back to Victorian times. It is seen as an extractive business rather than a sustainable one, and we need to move to a model that is more in harmony with the environment.
10:30
Since the early 1990s, there have been a series of initiatives, including partnership working, the partnership for action against wildlife crime in Scotland, the raptor working group, the Langholm moor demonstration project, a police thematic review of wildlife crime and Scotland’s moorland forum, but the killing continues.
It is difficult to bring a prosecution due to the geography, the burden of proof and the wall of silence after a crime is discovered. Crimes that occur in remote places are easy to conceal and difficult to detect. Under Scots law, corroboration requires two witnesses. As we know well, we also have limited police resources.
There is an overwhelming body of science from the RSPB and SNH, the Government’s statutory conservation body. There is also compelling evidence and intelligence on where the crimes are occurring. In addition, our members’ experience on the ground shows that, in many cases, in ideal habitat certain key species are absent.
Tactics that our members find being used but that are not necessarily illegal are gas bangers, gas guns, inflatable scarecrows, ice, guns discharged over birds, the burning of nests in heather banks and the torching of golden eagle eyries. Although those things are not illegal, they certainly do not help or encourage birds of prey to breed.
In parts of Scotland, the situation is getting worse because of the intensification of management, such as the killing of deer and mountain hares, draining and burning on deep peatlands, the creation of hill tracks without planning permission and the burning out of scrub and juniper.
The golden eagle is the equivalent of Scotland’s tiger, and it is being grubbed out on grouse moors, which damages Scotland’s image in the world and affects green tourism and the wider rural environment.
Our patience has run out. We need a step change. In a civilised country, we do not tolerate a business sector that conducts its affairs outside the law. We maintain that no other land use or industry is allowed to behave in this way. We have established that, in countries where game bird hunting is better regulated, intensive game bird hunting systems are not permitted and there is far better compliance with wildlife and environmental protection laws. That is why we are calling for the licensing of game bird shooting to be introduced.
Perversely, a licensing approach may save the grouse shooting industry from itself, which it has patently failed to do over the decades.