Petition · PE01615 · Session 5
State regulated licensing system for gamebird hunting in Scotland
Signatures
0
Comments
603
Considered
13 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to implement urgent action to introduce a state regulated system of licensing of gamebird hunting, that addresses the potentially adverse environmental impact of gamebird hunting, provides for the revocation or amendment of licences where a licence-holder fails to comply with their terms and conditions, and to implement the recommendations of the Review of Wildlife Crime Penalties in Scotland.
What the petitioner did first
Since the advent of the Scottish Parliament in 1999, the SRSG has met with various Environment Ministers, as well as less frequently with the Chair of SNH, to highlight the impacts of wildlife crime on protected raptor populations in Scotland. Many individual SRSG members have also met with their local MSPs to highlight this problem. During these discussions, the SRSG, and its members, have repeatedly pressed the case for the effective licensing of "driven" grouse shooting in particular. Whilst we have received a "sympathetic hearing" in these meetings, and indeed some significant improvements to the legislation protecting birds of prey has followed (notably in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011), the impacts on some raptor populations from illegal killing remains a significant issue. During this period, the Scottish Government has also commissioned various reviews related to wildlife crime (including the latest one from SNH to look at gamebird hunting licensing systems in other parts of Europe). However this SNH review, as a good example, will apparently make no recommendations for further action, and therefore will likely result in no meaningful progress towards eliminating the illegal killing of birds of prey in Scotland.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
27 Oct 20161 mention
-
10 Nov 20161 mention
-
8 Dec 20161 mention
-
24 Jan 20171 mention
-
31 Jan 20171 mention
-
28 Mar 20171 mention
-
18 Apr 20172 mentions
-
16 May 20171 mention
-
23 May 20171 mention
-
26 Sep 20171 mention
-
28 Jun 20181 mention
-
10 Oct 20191 mention
-
23 Feb 20211 mention
Signatures by country
7,236 online signaturesComments
603 comments, oldest first603 comments · showing 301–350
-
Alan Hiddleston 11 Aug 2016Live target shooting just sums this up £££££
-
jane eades 11 Aug 2016Help Scotland restore the forest, revive the biodiversity and farm sustainably with genuine wildlife protection.
-
James Condliffe 11 Aug 2016I saw a golden eagle for the first time close to the Invercauld Estate. Unacceptable that such a fantastic creature could be put at risk for so called sport. Nature is all ours to enjoy and respect
-
Jane Finnigan 11 Aug 2016Save the beautiful golden eagle!
-
Chris Watt 11 Aug 2016There is still an alarming rate of birds disappearing mostly around Grouse driven moors. It is time a system was put in place to halt illegal behaviour and save Scotland's most iconic birds of prey.
-
Steve Harris 11 Aug 2016I visit the highlands of Scotland regularly and frequently to enjoy the magnificent natural environment. The criminal persecution of raptors and other natural predators of grouse is a huge concern to me.
-
Lisa Wood 11 Aug 2016We have a moral duty to protect our environment for our future.
-
KENNETH JOHNSTONE 11 Aug 2016As a keen mountain biker and roamer of the hills I have experienced this type of driven shoots in the Highlands...I strongly object to the unbalancing of natural wildlife and the heavily scarred countryside be by burning or increased scars by land rover access tracks
-
John Moore 11 Aug 2016I like to go to Scotland specifically for the wildlife and am seriously considering alternate destinations if this persecution persists, I no longer holiday in Cyprus or Malta for this reason.
-
Brian Lazzari 11 Aug 2016The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing. Do the right thing, and protect those who cannot protect themselves be it human or animal.
-
Judith Read 11 Aug 2016Birds should not be bred for slaughter and worse still involve the eradication of species of indigenous wildlife. Licences should be taken away away and the organisation closed down if there is any infringement of licence.
-
Douglas Robertson 11 Aug 2016I have serious concerns that a blind eye is being turned toward raptor persecution in this country and would like to see licensing in place with a burden of proof on those applying to demonstrate conformity before issue. This may also further pressure government organisations tasked with protecting our environment to take their role more seriously rather than folding before land owners using illegal traps.
-
Peter 11 Aug 2016Illegal. immoral and destroying our children's inheritance. The rest not printable
-
Sylvia Kemp 11 Aug 2016Yet more barbaric killings, and still no prosecutions, It is about time the Scottish Government took some real action against and not just lip service.
-
Sylvia Kemp 11 Aug 2016The Scottish SNP Government needs to do something about these barbaric killings and not just lip service.
-
Irene Williamson 11 Aug 2016It is a disgrace for people to be getting away with crime against wildlife and not being properly dealt with.
-
James Underwood 11 Aug 2016I'm not against people exercising their legal right to hunt or the right of those who provide their sport. I want to see an end to the illegal practises that seem to be associated with it. Protect Scotland's natural heritage for the generations that will follow ours.
-
Alistair J MacKichan 11 Aug 2016The correlation between the killing of large raptors and driven grouse moors is to be expected. I lived next to such a grouse moor, visited each year by German businessmen for their pleasure. They employed gillies to suppress predation on the grouse. While the raptors are the top of a food chain, that food chain is not confined to grouse, and more diverse land use would favour them just as well. The wealthy who invest in Scottish moorland for shooting are limiting the enjoyment of the Scottish landscape by the Scottish people, and limiting the development of rural infrastructure. The Holyrood government needs to look again at Land Reform.
-
Bernadette Griffiths 11 Aug 2016This has to stop we are in the 21st century not 19th, if we don't protect them who will??????????
-
Claire Gordon 11 Aug 2016Very concerned by the news today from rspb that eight golden eagles have gone missing over intensely managed grouse moorland. Tighter regulation is urgently needed.
-
Alice 11 Aug 2016As ever the rich hunters are 'protected from prosecution' by their cronies to facilitate the incomes from grouse breeding and shooting (cruel in itself!) so our beautiful wildlife suffers needlessly in the name of profit for exclusive rights etc. It sickens me and like minded 'ordinary' working taxpayers. Makes me so angry as I'm powerless to change anything
-
Calum Davidson 11 Aug 2016Please consider a total ban as this is such a crucial issue on many levels.
-
Rupert Pyrah 12 Aug 2016The illegal killing of protected species continues unabated. The shooting industry has shown itself incapable of self-regulation and there is no alternative to regulation by the Scottish parliament.
-
DAVID BRODIE 12 Aug 2016Appalled at our greed and destructive nature in the UK and across the globe. Sharks, Tigers, Rhino, Elephants
- the list is endless -
Fenbbie 12 Aug 2016Unbelievable!
-
Jan 12 Aug 2016It's important to work with countryside interests of course, BUT they have to realise they have a wider responsibility than their own commercial interests and it's now so serious and so obvious the law is being broken that strong sanctions must be applied. Licences must be revoked if raptors are killed
- that's the only way to force compliance with the law. -
Hazel Herd 12 Aug 2016Think about the bigger picture and the impact and damage caused by the grouse shoot. It is unethical. Go shoot some clay pigeons, not live birds.
-
Carolyn Hastings 12 Aug 2016i have never understood why someone would want to kill game birds (or any other living creature) in the name of sport. given the environmental issues surrounding this activity, the death toll of the animals living on the cleared moors, plus the illegal killing of other endangered birds ... this 'sport' needs controlling
-
Hazel Veitch 12 Aug 2016Shocking that so much damage is caused & cost involved for this so called 'sport' for rich folk.
Please protect our wildlife and stop this now -
Wildlife & Nature-Loving Citizen 12 Aug 2016Please, government, care as much and more for the precious wildlife and nature of the whole of the United Kingdom, as your pay packets and fatcat pension pots and expenses allowances, and maybe the Citizens won't find you as appalling, or too toxic to be selected at the ballot box.
-
Wendy Hart 12 Aug 2016How come guns dictate the lives and deaths of our wildlife?
-
Frank Watso 12 Aug 2016The people responsible for such actions are committing crimes against the planet.
-
Christopher Patrick 12 Aug 2016Having worked as a gamekeeper I know the pressure from employers to maximise game bird numbers. The onus should be on landowners to ensure wildlife is protected and be punished if it isn't. If the landscape cannot support commercially viable numbers of game birds then it shouldn't be licensed for commercial shooting. Licensing is the most rational way of managing the unnecessary persecution of wildlife that, in the eyes of the shooting community, competes with their desire to overpopulate then decimate game birds.
-
Chris Betts 12 Aug 2016One has to ask
- are the police genuinely under-resourced to deal with this, just ignorant
- or complicit? -
Mike Boyce 12 Aug 2016I know that the grouse shooting industry brings in much needed revenue to country areas, but surely there's room for these majestic birds in our skies too
-
Lawrence Sutton 12 Aug 2016Birds of prey must be protected. The full force of the law should be used to stop these people killing them.
-
Wendé Anne Maunder 12 Aug 2016The Scottish government has a responsibility and duty to protect the majestic birds of prey that make their home and breed in and around the game parks. Please make sure that these beautiful creatures are valued and given the full protection they obviously need from those who would destroy them.
-
Sandra Morrish 12 Aug 2016Now is the time to look in to all the destruction of wildlife that goes on because of Grouse Shooting as well as environmental destruction . We can go on allowing Raptors, Foxes Hares and all manor of Wildlife that are needlessly killed purely for just existing on the same Moor as the Grouse . You do not have the right to destroy life to line your pockets you do not have the right to deplete populations to line your pockets you do not have the right to destroy the moors to just fill them with just with Grouse these Moors are a place to support many types of wildlife and it is not your right to decide what exists there no right at all it is a natural habitat and should exist as one .
-
Veronica Liddell 12 Aug 2016Those in favour of grouse shooting claim it supports many jobs. Don't think the rearing and shooting of birds for pleasure should be praised as a job creation scheme.
-
Connie Stanley 12 Aug 2016Landowners know this is happening, and let the gamekeepers take the blame.
-
Dr Dermot J O'Brien 12 Aug 2016A most glorious member of our faune and irreplaceable. Please protect it.
-
Anne Harwood-Stamper 12 Aug 2016It is time to stop the persecution and wilful destruction of a protected species. It will not stop until prosecutions are made on the perpetrators who are both known and pleaded guilty. Let the natural order of animals remain to keep Scotland beautiful.
-
Judith Kelman 12 Aug 2016Golden eagles are a spectacular and special part of Britain's wildlife. They should be encouraged, not discarded in favour of shooting another species
-
Lennox Mackenzie 12 Aug 2016The time is long past for the Scottish Government to enforce a gamebird hunting licencing system for our moorlands our moorlands and to revoke these licences where raptors have been killed or mysteriously disappear along with their tracking devices as in the recent past. If such systems are good enough for other countries in Europe then they must be perfectly acceptable here in Scotland. The Government must act and not be intimidated or held to ransom by these 'landowners'
-
christopher james dobson 12 Aug 2016Apply the law equally to everyone. Simple
-
Tim Addinell 12 Aug 2016Golden Eagle is an iconic bird. I invite you to consider the statistical likelihood of 8 satellite tagged birds disappearing in one small area or the tags ceasing to transmit in just one small area in just 5 years ( bearing in mind eagle longevity). Then consider whether just possibly the birds- all 8- might have been illegally killed and the evidence "removed". Then consider whether licensing might just possibly be appropriate. Your conclusion?
-
Professor Phillip Evans 12 Aug 2016All raptors should be protected by law.
Narrow commercial interests destroy the benefit for the Nation. -
Frederick Anthony Lewis 13 Aug 2016The Scottish government has already set a good example with the vicarious liability legislation. Introducing a licensing scheme would continue to set a good example to the rest of the UK.
-
Allyson Smith 13 Aug 2016I don't want to be one of the last people to say they have seen eagles in the wild. These magnificent birds need to be saved. Illegal killings must be investigated and prosecutions must take place.
-
paul noakes 13 Aug 2016the shooting industry has showed it cannot abide by the law so must be regulated in oder to protect Scotland's iconic species