Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 201–250
  1. David Ritchie 18 Dec 2014
    Protecting the rivers must only be the first step. On shore netting must reviewed. Then genuine international cooperation for the protection of migratory fish at sea.
  2. Ross Wood 18 Dec 2014
    Hopefully this will raise awareness of the plight of the Atlantic salmon and go some way to maintaining future stocks.
  3. Sean Franklin 18 Dec 2014
    Plus: Catch and speedy release. Keep the fish in the water where possible.
  4. Ken Cutting 18 Dec 2014
    This species is clearly imperiled the world over. It is up to each of us to encourage localities throughout their range to do their utmost to protect this precious resource. It is my sincere hope that you will do what you can to save this magnificent species and return it to its abundant glory.
  5. steven meech 18 Dec 2014
    Apply this to all countries
  6. Nick Semple 18 Dec 2014
    Hopefully at last some real protection for salmon stocks will be introduced and enforced.
  7. Malcolm Huton 18 Dec 2014
    Curtail netting and cull seals on the east coast
  8. Paul McNeill 18 Dec 2014
    Keep up the road good work, not everyone isputting there fish back. They are the wons that shout no fih
  9. Jody MacKay 18 Dec 2014
    Seal cull on east coast and end the horrendous netting as well . Catch and release should be determined by each rivers numbers
  10. Rory Aird 18 Dec 2014
    If we want our children to be able to fish we must do something NOW
  11. Tim pilcher 18 Dec 2014
    Please ban the killing of such a valuable asset
  12. mr brian stewart 18 Dec 2014
    scotlands salmon and seatrout fishing is one of the countrys greatest assets and should be protected and preserved above anything ,especially industrys like fish farming ,failure to do so will be complete failure for the various goverments that have been in charge and who have championed environmental issues .!
  13. william bartholomew 18 Dec 2014
    Please look after this wonderful species, asset and iconic Scottish symbol.
  14. David Dick 18 Dec 2014
    Better late than never. Doing nothing is not an option.
  15. Frank Clark 18 Dec 2014
    This is only worth doing if as well as a rod ban on killing any salmon before the 1st July there is a total ban on any type of netting at sea or river mouths till the 1st July
    This is only part of the solution much more should be done by the Scottish Government to help find the causes of the massive losses of smolts and salmon at sea and to be much more proactive in curbing over fishing of all species in the North Atlantic
  16. Manuel Lopez Pereira 18 Dec 2014
    Estoy de acuerdo con todo lo que haga Ian Gordon en pro del Salmón Atlantico. Entiendo que es un gran benfactor en pro de la conservación de esta maravillosa especie.
  17. Thomas Johnson-Smith 18 Dec 2014
    Extrapolating from current data indicates that the Atlantic salmon will be extinct from British waters in 20 years time. This is the least we can ask for.
  18. Mike Pearce 18 Dec 2014
    We owe it to future generations of fishermen and women and the salmon specis to do all we can to protect them
  19. Christine Hall 18 Dec 2014
    So good that someone is being pro active and gathering support to help protect the salmon.
  20. Ian Stewart 18 Dec 2014
    Keep up the great work well done on this long journey
  21. Roger Geary 19 Dec 2014
    The only way to ultimately have a sustainable fish stock.
  22. Dr. h.c. Heribert Hahne 19 Dec 2014
    Look to the fishing regulation of BC Kanada
    - eg Steelhead:
    Anglers have to do something for the preservation of salmon: 1. single hook, 2. barbless hook, 3. keep only 1 fish per day, 4. stop fishing for the day of collection of a salmon on this particular river.
  23. Jochen Moehr, M.D., Ph.D. 19 Dec 2014
    I m a fly fisher in British Columbia, Canada, and I profoundly empathise with the plights of our Scottish friends
    - and even more so with the plights of the Scottish salmon. We have the same problems in Canada
    - for instance with the Skeena River Steelhead
    - and the same promising solutions. A lot will be lost
    - not merely for us flyfishers, but for the local culture, the local wild life and environment, and lastly for those who make a living on the attraction of fishing and wild life.

    The solution is there! It just has to be followed.

    I fully support the recommendations and that "This must apply to both netting and angling."
  24. Graham Burns 19 Dec 2014
    It has to be reduced. Thanks
  25. Brian McManus 19 Dec 2014
    At last the problem is getting some recognition.
    Coincidentally, since the start of the Salmon Farms on the West Coast was just before the start of the downfall of the Salmon on the West Coast..
    Why when the research into The Scottish Salmon Decline in recent years, was it conducted on the East Coast Only? The problem has not really affected the East Coast it is on the West Coast that the decline of the Salmon is making them near extinction quicker than ever? It only takes going into the local clubs of the West and ask to see their "Catch Returns Book", and you can see when the decline in numbers being recorded and it coincides with the start of the Salmon Farms. As the number of farms increased and spread up the coast the Salmon numbers decreased. Personally I don't see it being coincidental event.
    We have known that the concentration of the Sea lice around the farms was an obvious problem to the Salmon that were entering the rivers of the sheltered sea lochs had to "Run the Gauntlet", of Sea lice ridden area around the areas of the Salmon cages,
    With the salmon in the cages being 'fertile', and at the numbers of them getting released into the wild by storms etc, they were in turn breeding with the native indigenous fish and depleting the genetic build up of the off spring. This happening every year since. With the general integrity of the Salmon being depleted they cannot survive as well as needed like the true wild fish can and therefore once again a drop in numbers aand a weaker strain of fish in the rivers. It would be a very good idea if the Salmon Farms were to make all Salmon Triploids, ie, Barren, infertile and unproductive in the wild, thus any Salmon left to spawn will gradually breed out the genes of the Farmed fish. Farmed Salmon are being selectively bred for different qualities than the wild ones. They are being bred to be good survivors in the confined conditions where
    No room left for me to finish my comment,
    thank you.
  26. Alan Cummings 19 Dec 2014
    We must take action to preserve our salmon stocks and can't procrastinate over this any longer.
  27. Laurence Brown 19 Dec 2014
    The income generated by visiting sporting anglers, like myself (ex-pat), must massively outweigh any income generated by netting to the Scotland's GDP.
    After a dreadful season like this year, if you don't do something to reduce the decline in numbers of fish in the rivers, you soon won't have a salmon fishing tourist industry!!
    However I do think fish farming is a probably a bigger threat to natural salmon & sea trout levels, but that's another fight!
  28. John Melville 19 Dec 2014
    Yes, I can get behind this, those poor unfortunates in salmon farms should be used instead. They are treated no differently from chickens, and whether you like the idea or not, some good can arise from the farmed Salmons plight. :)
  29. Gregory Dixon 19 Dec 2014
    I fish and release Atlantic salmon on the rivers of northern NB and the Gaspe Peninsula of Quebec, Canada every summer from May to Sept. We are experiencing the same decline of this world class fish as other parts of the World and would do anything to ensure its survival. Without this fish there would be no work for a good portion of the working population as the numerous lodges, most of whom support catch and release, employee hundreds of guides, cooks, handymen, wardens, etc. It is a way of life for many, a great one I might add. Without this fish we all would be doomed to a life of misery. I remember each fish as if it was yesterday and the same joy comes to me at 60 now as it did when I hooked my first Atlantic salmon at 16. Please help Ian and his followers to ensure this tragedy does not befall your beloved rivers of Scotland. Sincerely, Greg.
  30. Mark Mahoney 19 Dec 2014
    There has been much talk and little action over recent years. A full ban on the killing of wild salmon is only one measure. The second measure, that will upset the general public, is the reduction in seal numbers and river predators, as their numbers are out of control. The third measure should be the removal of all Salmon Farms within a minimum 20 mile radius of any river estuaries. We need immediate action across all areas for the stocks to recover
  31. Brian D'Arcy Clark 19 Dec 2014
    Its doubtful that the decline in river catches is soleley due to rivermouth or coastal netting
    - deep sea trawlers must be responsible at least in part
    - but to kill the spawning few that evade all nets is clearly madness. The sooner this proposed ban comes in the better.
  32. Nicholas William Smith 19 Dec 2014
    All netting on rivers in the United Kingdom should be banned!
  33. william mair 19 Dec 2014
    I commend you in all your efforts , well done keep it up . Jim
  34. Colin mcfadyen 19 Dec 2014
    Sawbills must have a major impact on salmonoid juveniles in rivers,why is there not more done to control these birds!
  35. David Brew 19 Dec 2014
    Cconservation of salmon at sea and their feeding grounds, together with protection of the wonderful rivers in Scotland is required . Let's not mess it up for the future. Stopping netting, pollution, abstraction of water , and limiting predators are feasible issues we can tackle. Let's keep the rivers a special places to visit. Act now.
  36. Paul Fisher 19 Dec 2014
    I catch very few (only 1 in the last 2yrs) but this season I have hardly seen any never mind caught any , something has to be done to preserve stocks sooner rather than later. Later may be too late !!
  37. Charles Jardine 19 Dec 2014
    The Resource is Finite and Precious.
  38. Yvonne Kelly 19 Dec 2014
    Shouldn't need to sign a petition for this to happen!!
  39. Andrew Smith 19 Dec 2014
    There is no need to kill msw salmon before July or across the season. That applies to both anglers and nets. We need legislation to protect the bigger fish in our rivers all season. And mixed stock fisheries are something that makes no sense. We should be buying out the nets as part of a joined up programme.
  40. kevin anderson 19 Dec 2014
    should have been stopped years ago
  41. Philippe Koehler 19 Dec 2014
    i agree to sign with M. Ian Gordon
  42. Garry Bettridge 20 Dec 2014
    In support of all Fly Fishers all over the world, protect wild fishes of all species because once they're gone, THEY are GONE!!
  43. Alan Coad 20 Dec 2014
    There is simply not a sustainable surplus on western European rivers to harvest. While rods and coastal nets are only contributing to salmon declines, everyone needs to do their part to save this precious species. Lets hope this effort extends to offshore netting and by catch also.
  44. Peter Horsburgh 20 Dec 2014
    I'd echo the comment below:
    The income generated by visiting sporting anglers, like myself (ex-pat, also), must massively outweigh any income generated by netting to the Scotland's GDP. After a dreadful season like this year, if you don't do something to reduce the decline in numbers of fish in the rivers, you soon won't have a salmon fishing tourist industry.However I do think fish farming is a(n) equal (robably a bigger) threat to natural salmon & sea trout levels, but that's another fight!
  45. David Leaver 20 Dec 2014
    I fully agree
    - the two other major problems are excessive seal numbers and intensive salmon farms. It is now almost impossible to find areas of the Hebridean islands without fish farms. A prior proposal to dart seals with a contraceptive to reduce numbers would be both humane and effective. Anyone going into loch scavaig on Skye to walk into coiruisk, will have seen over 300 seals at the mouth of the river!
  46. James Garvie 20 Dec 2014
    all fish to be released back to water !!
  47. james campbell 20 Dec 2014
    Signed
  48. Gareth jones 20 Dec 2014
    As a tweed fisherman we have practiced catch and release for the last 10 years yet nets have decimated wild stocks, together with Scotland's inability to control fish farmed salmon and the approval of fish farm licences, how long before rod fishermen decide enough is enough and join me in fishing abroad, better rivers, better management and a lot cheaper.
    Wake up as this is a point of no return, if we have not already passed it
  49. Howard Evans 20 Dec 2014
    Give what is truly wild a fighting chance to complete its epic journey and fulfill its basic needs to survive.
  50. Neil McNeill 20 Dec 2014
    26 attempts later!