Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 151–200
  1. Chris Loftus 17 Dec 2014
    This constant decline of stocks has to be halted and the trend reversed before it is too late.
  2. Phillip Jordan 17 Dec 2014
    The Scottish government must take steps to protect the resource of wild salmon now as it will be a tragedy if stocks become so depleted they become unsutainable. The wild salmon is an icon of Scotland and must be protected.
  3. Lloyd Garvie 17 Dec 2014
    i can't believe the Scottish Government issues netting licences for salmon and sea trout. Absolutely bonkers.
  4. Colin Sharp 17 Dec 2014
    Soon all salmon stocks will have gone forever
  5. robin vasey 17 Dec 2014
    Not only do I support the cessation of indiscriminate killing of spring salmon I believe that the review's recommendation of April 1st should be extended to 1st June as spring salmon are still entering their natal rivers beyond April and May.
    The legislation must consider the financial impact of allowing coastal netting to continue on the rural economies.
  6. JOHN SIMPSON 17 Dec 2014
    Protect the future runs of wild Scottish salmon.
  7. Francis Sandison 17 Dec 2014
    The SG's proposal to prohibit the killing of salmon before April is inadequate and would preserve very few spring fish, some of which may be caught and killed later in the spring. I fully support the proposals in the petition.
  8. Colin Sharp 17 Dec 2014
    Salmon stocks WILL disappear if we do not act
  9. Bob Burbidge 17 Dec 2014
    It is shear lunacy to allow the nets to continue the indiscriminate killing of salmon. The SNP wants to be a party of the Scottish People but when all the salmon are gone so will all those peoples jobs and lively hoods.
  10. David Mclaughlin 17 Dec 2014
    Everyone needs to sign
  11. Alfred Pope 17 Dec 2014
    The Scottish Government should ban all netting of Salmon and make it mandatory for all salmon fish farms to be sited on land.
  12. Sandy Addison 17 Dec 2014
    time for action
  13. John Brownlie 17 Dec 2014
    There is a dire need to take action now. The message is clear.
  14. malcolm campbell 17 Dec 2014
    Make it no Salmon to be killed before end of June as on Tweed bring every river into line and all nets
  15. Erin Hunter 17 Dec 2014
    Best cause I've ever supported by far!
  16. Regan little 17 Dec 2014
    Look after the fishing stock for the future!
  17. Malcolm Brown 17 Dec 2014
    As a keen angler, and a lover of our Scottish countryside and Scottish rivers I fully support this petition
  18. John Ellicock 17 Dec 2014
    We must act to save the wild salmon
  19. fergus glynn 17 Dec 2014
    regrettable but essential step. Well done, Ian and keep up the good work
  20. Peter Austin, MRCVS 17 Dec 2014
    The Scottish Ministers must note that while the numbers of rod caught salmon may seem substantial, the number killed is a small fraction in contrast to the net caught where 100% are killed regardless of their breeding potential. Most accept that the main problem of non returning salmon lies somewhere at sea and so Government should focus on filling our knowledge gaps in order that an effective protection programme may be instituted. We anglers are doing what we can to support the species at this state of current understanding and realise that we cannot object to Greenlanders killing large numbers when netsmen here do the same. In river predation by birds in particular must be significant and should be managed more effectively. I also believe that supplementation of migrating smolts with hatchery protected stock timeously released will significantly improve the chances of survival when running the gauntlet of whatever is waiting in the estuaries and the open sea. I know that some scientists have been led to believe in a contrary theory but I suspect their funding masters have influenced them erroneously. Again, only proper evidence based research will light the way forward.
  21. David Harvey 17 Dec 2014
    As someone who is passionate about and returns almost all his fish I am completely appalled that netting of salmon- and open sea fish farming come to that, I am not against closed containment fish farming incidentally- is scandalous. If other species were so affected there is no doubt that such practices would be banned.
  22. Eoin Trill 17 Dec 2014
    No spring salmon to be killed and make it catch and release after that.
  23. Christopher Harry Noble 17 Dec 2014
    Not for my benefit, but for those who follow.
  24. David Henderson 17 Dec 2014
    I fished Dee 5 years after voluntary c&r was introduced and the difference was quite unequivocal.
  25. James Mc Erlean 17 Dec 2014
    This is a knee jerk reaction from a goverment who has supported and still allows the increase in salmon farming under the auspices of employment but actualy does not bring real employment to the table. See the Econimist December 2012. In its inability to manage netting it is now going to make the legitimate rod fisherman who has contributed to so many hatcheries and has abided by catch and release suffer even further. What about the tourist trade which is already reeling from the impact fromdeer decimation of the iconic red deer and are now getting the double whammy with the fishing. No wonder we voted to make sure you did not run the country!!!
  26. Bjorn Rygg 17 Dec 2014
    Have been flyfishing in Scotland one week the seven last years and I'm delighted to see this petition coming. It's time for action and I hope we will get there in Norway as well.
  27. Peter Henk 17 Dec 2014
    We must preserve salmon stocks and help save the tourist industry
  28. Sara Kirkby 17 Dec 2014
    This desperately need to go ahead to improve the future runs of salmon in the future
  29. Neil Stephen 17 Dec 2014
    The future is not ours to destroy we hold it for our children and future generations.
  30. jondi laurence O Byrne 17 Dec 2014
    Save our salmon, catch and release for future fishing
  31. Caroline Greene 17 Dec 2014
    I can't believe this situation has been allowed to get to such a desperate state.
  32. Brian Barron 17 Dec 2014
    Shared
  33. Graeme Niewiadomski 18 Dec 2014
    Does this stupid government not realize what a valuable asset these fish are to the Scottish economy. Then again, suppose not. Total ban on netting would be the solution.
  34. brett richings 18 Dec 2014
    save wild atlantic salmon stocks
  35. Gordon Mills 18 Dec 2014
    The only way to do this with any measure of success, is to stop fishing for salmon for twenty years. Salmon fisheries boards have been messing about with them for way too long and achieved nothing, other than to make them practically extinct. Problem with salmon is it's a rich mans sport, and these "gents" will pay large to fish for them, and want to take them home for the table.
    A few years back I heard a tale of an English salmon angler who spent a very successful day on Loch Faskally. Three bars of silver, actually three baggots well on their way back to the sea.
    I was fishing for grayling a few winters back, on the Tay, at Stanley Mills when a gillie had a gent out harling for salmon. The gent hooked into a decent size kelt so the gillie landed the boat to land the fish. He was speaking to a passing couple with a dog, and offered them the kelt "for the dog". They turned down the offer and the kelt was released.
    This was in a tidal part of the Tay so every chance the kelt made a full recovery. I reported the gillie to Dr D Summers, who carried out an investigation.
    Turned out the gillie was "only kidding".
    If you fish for salmon, you are part of their demise.....
  36. Denise Johnstone 18 Dec 2014
    Need to look after stock now for our future generations
  37. John kelly 18 Dec 2014
    I agree with the netting being stoped but think maybee only fifty percent of anglers rod and line would be ok thank you johnk.
  38. Steve Beddows 18 Dec 2014
    Commercial overfishing has already killed the majority of our coastal fish stocks, Protect our rivers...
  39. Geoffrey allen 18 Dec 2014
    this is disgusting, and they encourage the rod angler to return their fish. It is the nets that are reducing the fish numbers
  40. Guy Gibson 18 Dec 2014
    Action needs to be taken urgently.
  41. Charlie Taylor 18 Dec 2014
    It is vital that fish stocks return again. Something has to be done!
  42. anthony Dempsey 18 Dec 2014
    Go For it Ian, thanks for taking this fight on my behalf
  43. colin pape 18 Dec 2014
    Why not bring all rivers, estuaries and coastal waters throughout the UK into line on the same date.
  44. Gareth Headland 18 Dec 2014
    Rod and line anglers are returning alive most salmon these days,
    coastal netting companies need to stop fishing or do the same to save the future of wild salmon.
  45. Norman J Duguid 18 Dec 2014
    The very best of luck Ian.
  46. Dave Cowie 18 Dec 2014
    Keep up the good work Ian, the poor salmon need as much help as we can give them.
  47. David Morton 18 Dec 2014
    Action certainly needed
    - let us hope common sense prevails.
  48. Garry Watson 18 Dec 2014
    Everyone has to help to make the change or our salmon will be fine for good
  49. graham lovatt 18 Dec 2014
    I see no reason for any one angler, to take more than, say three fish per year.
    That would be in the region of 20 meal portions, who needs more ?? A tagging system, as per Prince Albert Angling Socsiety of Macclesfield Cheshire, would be a help. Tags could be obtained from Tackle outlets ! or other convenient outlets, at a nominal cost to cover the supplier, and could include a small extra cost towards stocking funds.
  50. John Buckland 18 Dec 2014
    Crucial to conserve salmon:not only catch-and-release, but the careful management of the entire river system under ONE careful ownership,