Petition · PE01468 · Session 4
Evictions due to under occupation deductions
Signatures
0
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.
What the petitioner did first
This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Apr 20131 mention
-
25 Jun 20131 mention
-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
19 Nov 20131 mention
Signatures by country
4,755 online signaturesComments
712 comments, oldest first712 comments · showing 351–400
-
catherine mclean 20 Feb 2013i hope those mps who recieve expenses for their second homes rent, are also going to pay for any extra rooms they may have out of their own pockets, they can afford to pay it with the money they made when they sold the house or flat (then rented back), following the expences fiasco
-
Mary Steel Scotland 20 Feb 2013not enough smaller housing for people
-
Ricky Skinner 20 Feb 2013This is pure madness.....to all the people we vote into power to represent us I emplore you....do not allow this to happen.......remember we vote you in and we can vote you out.......................
-
Mahri 20 Feb 2013one word it's a "JOKE"!!!!!
-
Thomas Lynch 20 Feb 2013This ( Unbelievable ) tax will create more hardship for people who are already strugglin' to make ends meet. What next, a window tax !!!
-
Sarah 20 Feb 2013Ridiculous ...
-
Stacey Moon 20 Feb 2013My mum is going to suffer so bad with this...she is so ill and works all she can...this is making her so ill...make the rich pay...the poor are already suffering !!
-
George Martin 20 Feb 2013This tax is theft, you already pay for your house through rent, Cameron and his public school boys, should'nt get away with this, If we get Independance the Scottish Goverment will do away with this tax, I have this on good authority, Vote Yes and get rid of this of westminster,
-
Kenneth Carmichael 20 Feb 2013I have 5 children and some have left home and 2 havent, but I want to be able to offer them a room or two to stay in if they wish to visit or if they need somewhere if things get awkward in their home lives.I dont want to be taxed on the basic right to give my family somewhere to stay if they need it
-
Les Hunter 20 Feb 2013I feel sorry for the English, Welsh and Northern Irish. Scotland has an answer to the rapacity of the Westminster government, vote YES in 2014!
-
Bruce Allan SInclair 20 Feb 2013Mggie Thatcher revisited , Cmerons poll tax he and his rich cronnies should be utterly ashamed of themselves, poverty is returning to Brittain1
-
Scot Wallace 20 Feb 2013Just another example of a government trying to bleed this country dry. They are an absoloute disgrace.
-
Gwen 20 Feb 2013My spare room is for my son in the forces how can i tell him he cant come home anymore as there is no room for him if we are forced to move
-
leeanne 20 Feb 2013this is a joke, absolutely ridiculous!
-
Joanne Miller 20 Feb 2013Am disabled and use my two rooms because of my illness its not right
-
Angela Doherty 20 Feb 2013Your rent is charge by size so you are already pay regardles of its occupancy and for lots of people its not just a house its a home were they have raised a family and now having granchildren to stay lots of people would happly move to homes that are appropriate in room size for them but for others its about family andhaving that extra room and thats for them to beside not every can aford to buy there Homes lots have to rent and even at that a Home is were your heart is and that mite be a councle house .
-
Carol English 20 Feb 2013Mansion Taxes!! Bring them on!
-
George McIrvine 20 Feb 2013Camorons Bedroom Tax is the 21st century Thatcher's Poll Tax. The people must say NO to this !!
-
D P Allison 20 Feb 2013Talk about treading on the poor and vulnerable. You should be ashamed of yourselves. I thought Scotland and Britain were meant to be places of democracy,freedom, equality and inspiration. Apparently not.
-
mark munro 20 Feb 2013I will be directly affected by this.
-
Richard 20 Feb 2013HOPE WE CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE AND STOP THIS.
-
fiona mcmurray 20 Feb 2013we have already been waiting almost 7 years for a smaller house (we are in a 5 apt and are looking for 2 bed bungalow).only me and hubby left now and I have a feeling we will still be here in another 7 years.we are being penalised as well .FAIR I don't think so
-
Jennifer Johnston, 20 Feb 2013This is terrible, not fair on all the people that have access to their kids, there not intitled to a room for them, to stay overnight. x x x
-
James Mitchell 20 Feb 2013Please amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001.
-
maureen mc curley 20 Feb 2013another unfair change that will have devastating impact on those with limited incomes
-
Tony 20 Feb 201328 years i have lived in my house brought 3 kids up in a 2 bedroom house what they call the family home, now im sharing my spare room with my grandkids 10 of on a weekly basis, to now find if i want to keep this going i have to pay a tax on the empty room for which i am un-employed through no fault of mine, i do not intend to give up my house so i will have to pay the amount it is to keep my house, if the goverment past and present had acted more responsible to not creating the decifit that we have i might not be needing to pay the bedroom tax and all the other tax,s they plan to instil. typical every one looses except the rich, just my feelings.
-
Hazel Lewry 20 Feb 2013Penalising the poorest in society is just business as usual for Westminster and Tories.
-
Barry Ross 20 Feb 2013The Bedroom Tax should not be allowed
-
Allison 20 Feb 2013This is truly disgusting, what a nerve putting people out of their homes. I cannot believe the so called government is even considering such an appalling
thing. They will need to build a vast amount of smaller houses and flats bearing in mind that it will on the whole be older people that will be getting evicted (no other word for it). So would it not make more sense to just build houses that people can actually afford instead of so called affordable housing which if we are honest no one can afford get a grip and look at what the housing situation really is -
G Somerville 20 Feb 2013we are already skint are they trying to put us out on the streets
-
joan devlin 20 Feb 2013sickening
-
david weir 20 Feb 2013can someone tell me 2 things 1 why does this help anyone 2 who benifits from the most unfair tax off all time
-
John Welsh 20 Feb 2013Hitting the poorer people again, people with disabilities will suffer, evictions will start when people cant scrape up the money to pay it because they are living on a shoestring already, not enough one bedroom houses to rehouse everyone with more than one room to move into. The old window tax springs to mind where the phrase "Daylight Robbery" was seemingly coined. Bedroom Tax should not come into force lest many shall suffer.
-
Laura 20 Feb 2013What is the government thinking snp need to get the finger out just an other pole tax that the torys came out with, I'm a snp member and I fed up with the way they're working lately the better ship up or ship out 2014 better hurry up. If they think that waiting so they have a full term in government will do them any favours guess what it's not!! Scots, English, Welsh and Irish time we stood together and stop letting this government do what they want power is the people THE people R The power.. No more taxing the working class to fill the riches pocket!!!!
-
Alistair McCabe 20 Feb 2013I want to inherit our family home we've lived in for near 60ys, under the BTAX I'll possibly be evicted. OVER MY DEAD BODY MR CAMERON
-
Lizzie Stevenson 20 Feb 2013Are we to be treated as cattle? Draining the soul out any form of community left in this country after the previous housing disaster when being born in a community stopped guaranteeing you a house in the same area, near friends and family and the wee old neighbours we grew up with. The Big Society? Nobody knows anyone living near them. Now this insult to people's dignity and memories
- people's lives, our lives.. we do not count in this Big Society. You who might suffer and voted in this government, yer getting what ye deserve! -
Tracey 20 Feb 2013Glasgow District Council doesnt have enough 1 bedroom houses to give people who are in 2 bedroom homes. This is so unfair as the only people this effects is the unemployed. So many people will become homeless due to the fact they wont be able to afford to pay this ridiculous tax. Come on folk its time to take a stand and tell this tory government its not on grrrrrrrrrrrr
-
Anne Gair 20 Feb 2013This Bedroom Tax should be unlawful and if it gets to go ahead it will take years to get all the cases seen to through the courts. What a headache this is going to turn into for everyone involved. Absolutely insane, this government hasn't a clue.
-
William Craig 20 Feb 2013What a mean-minded proposal by the Tories! It's short-sighted, at best, and shows a lack of understanding about ordinary people. Just like the Poll-tax.
-
David Chalmers 20 Feb 2013We voted for our Scottish government. Nobody voted in the current shower in parliament. They fiddled it between them. Lets hope our MSPs do the right thing.
-
Lisa elliott 20 Feb 2013Only had my council house 10 months orignally asked for 2 bedrooms but got 3 beds and 2 boys under 16, had the council around today ( I was out but my partner was in ) to discuss MY bedroom tax, I moved frm Scotland to newcastle but IF Scotland get there independence I have no second thoughts of heading back home, this torrie goverment are nothing but bk door theifs, this is there new poll tax with a clever name to try and disguise it
-
lou 21 Feb 2013brutality by the tories again
-
susan jack 21 Feb 2013People do not work all their days on the lowest wage available to try and make their houses etc nice for some stupid policy to be passed so that we can't afford to live in our homes and someone else will get all your nice fixtures and fittings and you will be left to start again in a home where you have no room to house your kids when they come home from colleges, armies or whatever! Their aren't enough 1 bed houses in the rent sector to moved to anyway so the lowest paid and the people on benefits will be pushed into debt and yet more poverty! A total farce!!!
-
elaine reid 21 Feb 2013it a joke anything to keep yourself in a job
-
Stewart MacGregor 21 Feb 2013this is a disgraceful way for any government to treat people
- worse for Scotland since we never voted for them
- let Mundell and his allies pay a heavy price for this treachery -
john 21 Feb 2013So mutch for the tories wanting fathers tobe more involved with their children.I have my son staying with me from sunday to wednesday since my divorce 13 years ago,but now i have to make a choice of taking in a lodger and not seeing my son , or having to find extra money to lt him sleep in his own room as a normal 15 year old boy should .
-
john 21 Feb 2013There is no 1 bedroom houses available in the social sector,the only ones are in the private sector .It will be these landlords who will be making huge profits out of councils as they start to turn their ex council houses bought under thatcher into bedsits to maximise profits .
-
mary roy 21 Feb 2013why shoud we pay tax on our emty rooms. ive lived in my council house for 50 years.
-
Tracy Roach 21 Feb 2013Disgusting, the poll tax fiasco all over again!!!!!
-
Thomas Jaap 21 Feb 2013Why are we allowing this to happen from a Tory government who is hell bent on taking us back to 18th century values and why is Scotland allowing this? David Cameron would you pay this COUNCIL tax because its not for people with their own house is it? Get this man out give us a government that works for the working people not the rich.