Petition · PE01468 · Session 4
Evictions due to under occupation deductions
Signatures
0
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.
What the petitioner did first
This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Apr 20131 mention
-
25 Jun 20131 mention
-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
19 Nov 20131 mention
Signatures by country
4,755 online signaturesComments
712 comments, oldest first712 comments · showing 401–450
-
Pat Carroll 21 Feb 2013typical condem move. let's make it look like the poll tax protests were a walk in the park!
-
Caroline Carberry 21 Feb 2013Disgusting tories
-
Sandra Flint 21 Feb 2013If the UK Gov. had a bit of spare room in their brains we would all be better off.
-
morrison young 21 Feb 20132014 cannot come quick enough. Your date with destiny SCOTLAND
-
christine mcghie 21 Feb 2013i might live in england now but im scottish and proud of it and this bedroom tax is just another way to screw the poor again
-
Brian M Smith 21 Feb 2013This will mean a reduced income for the poorest people of Skye as there are NO alternatives to the houses that the people already have. It seems to be just a way of reducing their income. Onceagain the remote parts of this country get hammered.
-
neil gallacher 21 Feb 2013does that include damp rooms that you cant use? need to ask QC HOUSING
-
Stephen Smith 21 Feb 2013Disgusting! This is just a reincarnation of the poll tax. The people of rural Scotland will be most affected by a Torie government they did not, and never have, voted for. 2014 cant come quick enough
-
jennifer 21 Feb 2013utter disgrace! there are people out there that can find one bedroom flats due to the guarantor system. THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO CAN NOT AFFORD TO LOSE THEIR HOMES! FOR GOODNESS SAKE SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT MAKE THE BEDROOM TAX ILLEGAL!!! YOU HAVE THE POWER TO DO SO!! THERE ARE FAIRER ALTERNATIVES THAN THIS!!!
-
Robert Drummond 21 Feb 2013Stop this regressive tax before people come to harm because of it as I'm sure they will.
-
Lord Andrew D Loch 21 Feb 2013According to GHA 7,000 homes in Glasgow will have to pay the 'bedroom tax' myself included. Years ago the Government told local authories to make family homes. That's what they did, two, three, four bedroom houses.. they didn't make one bedroom houses. So if I did want to move, there are not enough, so people are stuck!
Can't remember the actual figure but my LHO has 95 one bedroom but 595 two bedroom homes, I asked for a one bedroom and I was told that there weren't any to get and if there was one it would go to an OAP before me. -
josephine mcphail 21 Feb 2013bedroom tax should be illegal
-
Tony Probert 21 Feb 2013Yet again it shows how lifetime politicians have no idea what life is like on the street for millions of people.
-
Clifford Main 21 Feb 2013I have been a Council tennant with Edinburgh Council for over 35 years and have lived in my current home for around 30 years, bringing up two children. I class this as my family home and feel disgusted that I am being forced to leave this house because someone has judged I am living in a house which is too big (three bedrooms) for myself and my wife. My two kids have grown up and have moved on. I have only just had an operation to have my Prostrate removed due to discovering I had Cancer. The extra stress of this 'bedroom tax' along with my recovery from the operation has really affected my home life. Yes I have three bedrooms, however due to my condition I now use a bedroom for myself and my wife uses another, as I need care either my Son or Daughter stay at the weekends in the 'spare' room to help with my care. Being forced to move has just added to the stress.
-
Colin Godfrey 21 Feb 2013Destroying people
-
mark 21 Feb 2013gha are not being helpful at all to there tennents affected especialy the new regime in pollok
-
Dorothy Mullen 21 Feb 2013This law will not have the intended effect while causing havoc in people's lives. My brother is disabled and must move because he has two bedrooms and cannot afford to pay the extra from his benefit. He has been offered a one bedroom apartment which will cost the taxpayer an extra 25%, this is ridiculous.
-
Izzy 21 Feb 2013We were surveyed some 6 years ago to determine size of house required for our needs. We got this two years ago, since moving in 4 kids have moved out. House now too big. On waiting list for smaller house in order to free up this one for a larger family. Given priority 1 for move but sadly no houses immediately available. Not our fault so why should we, like others be penalised. Does those who are over crowded get a rebate then!!!!!
-
donna mair 21 Feb 2013like tommy said resistence is required
-
fred tunn 21 Feb 2013spread the word about this petition
-
Dave 21 Feb 2013Surely this is discriminatory legislation on the grounds of Age , as it is targeted solely against Social Tenants of a certain age !
-
Patricia Ferguson 21 Feb 2013Bedroom tax must be stopped! Politicians have no idea what it's like in the real world, most of them were born millionnaires!
-
Sandra Walls 21 Feb 2013dont bring these taxes to scotland.
-
margaret devlin 22 Feb 2013The bedroom tax is disgusting. Who are these WEE people who sit in a WEE room trying to think of ideas to get more money from the tax payers who are already paying too much tax. They are taxed on wages, taxed on clothing, taxed on certain foods, taxed on fuel, taxed on drink, taxed on cigs it seems like before long people will be working for nothing as it all goes on tax for the greedy greedy politicians and fat cats in this country
-
D McM 22 Feb 2013We're getting penalised for being 3 generations of females in our house. We just got a (rotten with damp) house after being on the waiting list for years. We are actually overcrowded, but not according 'Thatchers new breed of children' in London. But this make the case for Indendence a winner...
-
colin robertson 22 Feb 2013yet another tax on the poor and vulnerable did the tory party not learn from the shambles that was the poll tax?! and are these multi millionaires who live in 10 bedroomed mansions paying bedroom tax of course not absolute disgrace!!
-
J brown 22 Feb 2013This tax is for people on benifit , why should we pay for this . I say get out and get a job pay your own way then you can have luxury of large house .
-
Lorraine Kielty 22 Feb 2013Cameron and Clegg just prove that like Thatcher they do not care about people. This is not about saving money it's about feeding off the poorer people to supplement the fat cats
-
Graham McLaren 22 Feb 2013if i have to pay this tax i will not be able to heat my house and feed my self, wife and daughter properly. I am on job seekers allowance getting £21.50 weekly and my who is working 14 hrs per week only receives £89 week, my daughter is a student on a bursary. With gas electricity water charge food and mail order catalogue payments not including tv licence i find it very difficult to survive, add this tax and i will flounder.
-
William Duthie 22 Feb 2013Sooner we are in control of our own country the better
-
J Bell 22 Feb 2013Spare bedroom is used as dining room. In open plan loung kitchen there is no room for table and chairs. Flat is really 2 bedroom not 3 as per housing association.
-
J. R. Mitchell 22 Feb 2013Another Tory idea not thought through that is going to cause mayhem and misery for hundreds if not thousands of families and unfortunate single people.
-
Matthew Ritchie 22 Feb 2013Cameron & Clegg risk alienating and discriminating against a considerable section of society by implementing this legislation. We in Scotland cannot accept this is the way we want to treat the most vulnerable in our country. We must fight against this and stand with those who might be facing eviction. This is Cameron's 'Poll Tax' moment. My only concern is that the fabric of our society might be compromised as a result.
-
June Osborne 22 Feb 2013I have worked since I left school and at 51yrs old am lucky enough to be still working. I am a single parent with 1 child still at school and I pay my Morgage which means I have to pay out for all my repairs and also pay out for dental and glasses. I pay my taxes to my country and have done for the last 35 yrs without a say in what it is spent on, I do not agree with this bedroom tax. I feel you's the government are trying very hard to destroy our country. Stop giving what I and billion of other people pay to other country's HELP Britain!!!! Please
-
cheryl young 22 Feb 2013this will affect me and my disabled daughter spare room is used to store equipment and medical supply. and no one has a clue about this in the job centre, council or housing assocation. stressing me out
-
leigh doherty 22 Feb 2013I just think what is going on is a joke???the rich get richer n the poor suffer,aint fair at all!!!
-
Tommy Crocket 23 Feb 2013Pernicious! A crime against those in our society who are already downtrodden. Scotland is better than this.
-
gina burke 23 Feb 2013this country is a joke,,if the government want to save money on housing,,why dont they start by cutting the 2nd home subsidy paid to mp,s,,its a total farce !!! what really riles me is the fact that out of the 29 mp,s who are the members of this governments cabinet,,23 are millionaires !!!,,,they do not have a clue about having to live on a budget....what,s the next thing they,ll start charging for ,,,,,, fresh air maybe ???...people should stand up to them
-
Roddie Lumsden 23 Feb 2013no wonder people commit suicide
-
JAMES MONAGHAN 23 Feb 2013DISGRACEFUL
-
angela chesney 23 Feb 2013This is a crazy tax which is to me an infringement on peoples human rights. Someone living in council housing would need to move a number of times as their family grows changes etc. The housing is not always readily available for thos even willing to move.I'll give it a couple of years and it will be all change again once reality sets in.
-
john 23 Feb 2013dont pay
-
Paul Reid 23 Feb 2013This is shameful by this Government of millionaires, I have two children of 5 and 6 which would mean they would be made to share a room, As it stands just now we have three bedrooms,1 for my wife and i,my 2 children in the other 2 rooms,there is no end to what this lot will do.
-
mark 23 Feb 2013fight it
-
cath mcmanus 23 Feb 2013A cynical and shocking attack on people, many of whom are vulnerable. A "mansion tax" would be much more just.
-
Helen 23 Feb 2013I remember when I was a little girl in the early eighties ,watching a family being evicted from my street sherrifffs officers throwing all their wordly possesions over a veranda four floors up .It made me sick to my stomach even then ,and instilled in me a flame of fighting soacial injustice .I am the mum of a soldier and also a child with complex medical needs .I have been told I must pay for keeping a bed for my son and my 16 year old disabled child now has to share a room .Totally disgusting from a government full of inherited wealth.
-
Niall MacDougall 23 Feb 2013This tax won't wont affect me personaly...but it's down right disgusting for people that it does.Out with this Tax,and in with and Independent Scotland.
-
Stefanie Mackie 24 Feb 2013Regardless of whether the residents are living off of benefits or working full time, all this is going to is create more debt, resulting in another round of recession that we are only just starting to come out of. The already poor will have to get high interest loans to subsidise their income in order to pay this tax , and why should they? We all know that this is going to benefit the already rich who own their homes and therefor have no worries. it makes me sick. This country's government seem to to be there for everyone but their own people and thety have the cheek to wonder why no one votes for them
-
J.Robertson 24 Feb 2013Why do conservative governments always hit the worse off in our society. They never have a social policy and have the attitude that if you are unable to work, either due to health or lack of jobs, you dont deserve anything from the more fortunate. They never mention the huge amount of grants that land owners receive which would be as much, if not more than the welfare budget. Like business, industry, the strongest asset are the people. What makes Britain great is the people, so why is this government determind to destroy that. Bring in the mansion tax and get that class of people paying.
-
Maree MacRae 24 Feb 2013Stupidest Idea they have had to date. Never mind, looking at the unrest from this, I would say their time in government is over along with Lib Debs. Did they really think the people who voted them into power and who they are meant to be looking after would stand for this ludicrous change?