Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01468 · Session 4

Evictions due to under occupation deductions

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2012 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
4,755 online signatures with a country
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.

What the petitioner did first

This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Apr 2013
    1 mention
  2. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  4. 19 Nov 2013
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,755 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,714 78.1%
  2. United Kingdom701 14.7%
  3. England240 5%
  4. Wales20 0.4%
  5. Northern Ireland13 0.3%
  6. United States12 0.3%
  7. Not given7 0.1%
  8. Australia6 0.1%
  9. Afghanistan5 0.1%
  10. Uzbekistan4 0.1%
  11. 27 other countries33 0.7%

Comments

712 comments, oldest first
712 comments · showing 651–700
  1. davey jones 10 Mar 2013
    scrap this tax
  2. Brian Smillie 11 Mar 2013
    The Scottish Govt MUST make a stance against this new tax imposed on Scotland via
    London !
  3. jeremy smith 11 Mar 2013
    i dont think anybody should pay this
  4. john Slaven 11 Mar 2013
    The bedroom tax is a act of unspeakible cruelty
  5. margaret mcenhill 11 Mar 2013
    my daufghter gave up her tenancy in rutherglen due to this tax being brought in. She now lives with my sister. Housing association stated that they did not have any 1 bedroom flats for her to move to, so basically they forced her to become homless.
  6. james dunn 11 Mar 2013
    your homes you castle defend it
  7. Andrew Findlay 12 Mar 2013
    45 year old male, unemployed! I will be affected by bedroom tax
    - already considered moving
    - no suitable one bedroom houses
    -

    OUTCOME
    - EAT LESS, HEAT LESS, WORTH LESS!

    NO MORE HOPE
    - NO MORE ASPIRATION! Want NO SYMPATHY just FAIRNESS and JUSTICE!

    Ian Duncan Smith
    - CENTRE FOR SOCIAL JUSTICE
    -
    - Welfare Reforms! Simple
    - DISCRIMINATION against the POOR!

    What about underoccupied homes in working households?

    Shame on you Ian Duncan Smith and SHAME ON this governement for attacking the poor in this way!

    Message to Scottish Government
    - BUCK THE TREND and FIGHT AND LOOK AFTER THE POOR!!!!!!!
  8. john spencer 12 Mar 2013
    had to give up my home of 39years im at my sisters waiting to move into a high riser with asylum seekers and vdrug addicts as my new nieghbours
  9. Edith 12 Mar 2013
    The bedroom tax is completely unreasonable. It is madness to impose this policy when there are not even enough alternative or suitable council homes to move to. Loads of people would move to smaller accommodation if they could, giving up all their social security and memories in the process, but you can not even provide that option. What on earth are you thinking with.
  10. Jacqueline 12 Mar 2013
    Mr Duncan Smith should be at the sharp end of his policy. A tax on the poorest in society.
  11. Mark Stewart 12 Mar 2013
    There is not enough 1 bedroom houses in scotland to house every single person when going for a house the turn over for 1 bedroom houses is at least a five year wait SHOCKING !!!
  12. Patrick O'Rourke 12 Mar 2013
    If you truly are a government for the people, you will protect them! No evictions due to bedroom tax arrears!
  13. helen wallace 12 Mar 2013
    I wonder how many rooms not being used in Ian Duncan smiths house
    - perhaps he could help by taken some peopl in and helping with the load that his goverment has given by opening the flood gates and letting everyone in!
  14. Margaret Gardiner 12 Mar 2013
    This has to be one of the most inhumane moves by any UK government, to date but then, the Tories are well practiced.

    Does the "under occupancy" tax mean that the government will be paying those in "over occupancy" situations?
  15. STAN 12 Mar 2013
    left a lot of my posessions as my new flat with bed in living room isnt big enough
  16. Isabella Goldie 12 Mar 2013
    This is one of our most concerning public health issues. Our unequal society will become even more so and both mental health problems and long term conditions will rise as a result. Not to mention the sheer misery and social injuries that will be endured by a large section of society.
  17. shirley fitzpatrick 12 Mar 2013
    mr duncan smith surely you could rethink how this is going to effect many people,or are you too thick skinned to care about your own people in your own country.how you sleep at night is beyond me.
  18. John 13 Mar 2013
    I am a construction professional and lost my job. I live in a council flat at the moment and I feel that this government is simply attempting to starve people into getting a job, when the job market is struggling. I had a very good salary and did not mind paying tax but this is a ruthless policy by a party who know the price of everything and the value of nothing. Cameron and IDS are totally ruthless and they will pay the price in the May elections. I hope the Scottish Government can mitigate the effects of this policy on the people of Scotland and this will have a domino effect in England and Wales.
  19. Marjory Smith 13 Mar 2013
    A tax on those least able to afford it, so unfair ...
  20. Franz 13 Mar 2013
    Try a spoonful of your own medicine Ian Duncan Smith.
  21. Franz 13 Mar 2013
    I am not saying it will happen here but the political theorist Hannah Arendt in her book The Origins of Totalitarianism warned that where people are regarded as superfluous governments may be tempted to do away with them. I wonder how far this government would go if we lived in a totalitarian regime?
  22. John 13 Mar 2013
    The bedroom tax has one purpose, to starve people into employment. Their work program is failing because there are not enough jobs so take the food out of people's mouths, that is the strategy. The head of a food bank in England told Cameron and Osbourne to visit and see we are not all in it together. They just want people off benefits. It is a policy of an extremely ruthless callous government. Hopefully they will be obliterated in the May elections.
  23. patricia 13 Mar 2013
    iain duncan smith litteraly makes me ill
  24. Grainne Rice 13 Mar 2013
    See Michael Mecher's letter to the Guardian re. taxation of the poorest. Proportionately we experience the biggest hit when rents, utility bills increase and with pay freezes and benefit cuts, adding the bedroom tax hits the same (large) group of people again.
  25. Christine Dumonceau 13 Mar 2013
    I saw on the net yesterday words of Ian Duncan-Smith saying that people will have to take on lodgers the frist £20 will be free ! My friend Susan on realised last night how bad things are, when I told her! Plus on radio yesterday evening I heard that the service men and their families were to be exempted! More separatism! £20! But that will not cover the extra heat, electricity, water! Plus you don't know who you are taking in! Beyond £20 you will be taxed! You are not gaining anything , they are just finding a cheap and easy way to fix a long term issue of lack of affordable social housing. It was the policy a few years ago to only build 2 bedrooms properties beacause people live alone more with friends and families staying for visits, and carers coming in , doing sleep-overs when needed! So logical really!
  26. Catherine McGowan 13 Mar 2013
    This is a down right injustice to people who are already struggling. I noticed in a newspaper they have voted against a mansion tax surprise surprise!! Take from the poor while helping the fat cats to get fatter. Unreal!!!!
  27. Maria Fyfe 13 Mar 2013
    What will happen if people are evicted? We know there is not a sufficient supply of smaller homes, and even if there were, the bedroom tax uproots people from their homes and disrupts children's lives.
  28. Veronica Bolan 13 Mar 2013
    Typical of this ConDem government to hit the poorest in society. the Scottish Parliament must get Section 16 of the Housing Act amended to prevent evicitions.
  29. Christy-Anne Surtees 13 Mar 2013
    Most like me have no choice I will not and cannot move away from here to somewhere miles away si I have only 1 bedroom I have already downsized to as small a property as is available near my family and friends whom I rely on for help each day So no choice I have to pay How fair is that?
  30. Franz 13 Mar 2013
    If people cannot pay this a few possibilities will manifest themselves. If their landlords take action against them Legal Aid expenditure will soar, as the courts will be involved. Another possibility is normally law abiding citizens resorting to crime which will give the Police more work. The new ideology of this extremist government is starve them out to work I have applied for three hundred and fifty jobs. I am a Quantity Surveyor who had a good salary before I lost my job. When I was employed I paid my taxes like everyone else but I think this government have shown a new ruthlessness and they are a party of the rich and detest the poor. Anyone can fall on hard times. In my view social cohesion will be affected. The David Cameron's of this world want a nightwatchman state, police to maintain internal law and order and armed forced for defence. They want to destroy all of the public services.
  31. Kim Scott 14 Mar 2013
    This is a despiratelly needed petition and PLEASE lets fight against such ridiculous measures......it is time to stand up against the trashing of the socialist systems which make britain so great!
  32. John 14 Mar 2013
    All governments are selective in who they help and this applies to the SNP too. People talk of Independence but the assumption is that things will get better if we are Independent, and this cannot be proven until it happens. The radical Tories are slowly hanging themselves. I am always wary with political issues, because there is a vast difference between an assumption and fact. Nicola Sturgeon wants more powers from Westminster but my question to her is what she will do with those powers? There are factions within Scotland who are only accountable to themselves.
  33. John 14 Mar 2013
    No doubt Mr Cameron and his government will feel the boomerang effect of their policies at the next election. They are trying to drive a wedge between the poor and the employed and anyone who is working can be ill tomorrow of lose their jobs. I had a good job with a reasonably good salary and a company car etc, but suddenly I become a target for their pernicious policy when no one complained when I paid my taxes. Its a blanket policy. Not all unemployed people are work shy. seventy one pounds per week plus rent and council tax of course but I earned six hundred pounds per week plus a company car. I would go back to my salary tomorrow and I would still vote against the Conservative Party. They steal off the taxpayer and call it expenses, but see the poorest in society as outcasts. They want to help themselves to expenses, ninety five thousand pound salaries and accept bribes from donors to shape policy in the donors interests. I wonder what these people would do to the most vulnerable in society if they could get away with it?
  34. Isabella Mooney 14 Mar 2013
    I waited 11 years for the Council to provide me with adequte housing to enable me to live independantly and Im so thankful for the fabulous house that I have, it has been well worth the wait, I still need assisstance to live that independant life in my fab house, but that costs money and unfortunatly, that is where the Government is going to kill me! they may not pull the trigger, but they loaded the gun and pointed to the targets, I could give you all sorts of woe's about Heating bills, taxi bills ( as I can't get on public transport with my powered wheelchair), so now I shall life independantly in my wee house, hardly ever to got out, afraid to put on the heating as I now have to re-assess my monthly budget so that I shall be able to stil eat healthy.......in the END, Iam very grateful for the help and support Iam given by the Gov and other agencies.........but I fear, I dont feel safe and secure in knowing that the Country that I love ( among one of the richest ) doesn't care about it's people, It's all about savig money.......Mr Cameron if my £44 extra a month into your purse, helps save this country from rack and ruin please I give you it willingly.............but if I've to give out of the little that I already have, yourserlf being a gizzillionare, what are you paying personally towards bring the deficit down you live in this country also??

    regaurds Issy
  35. Fay Young 14 Mar 2013
    This is both immoral and bad economics. It will cause suffering without solving the housing crisis or cutting the deficit.
    Where people are able to move to smaller accommodation the government ends up paying more in housing benefits. The root of the problem (and the present economic crisis) is the UK's housing crisis. Displacing families, making people homeless or causing them to go hungry in order to meet the increased costs of their rent, will not solve the problem. Build more homes, build them well with energy efficient designs and then make it possible for people to make real choices.
  36. bennett 14 Mar 2013
    lets get a last push for signatures b4 this petition runs out
  37. cameron 14 Mar 2013
    what we need is a little more action and a little less talk, all these petirions and demos are getting us nowhere, We need to start going in the way of the arabs and creating some civil disorder to make these career polititions wake up and listen, they have no ideas what chaos they're causing as they are not experiencing the misery in their ivory towers so lets show them please......
  38. Dr Brigitte Anton 14 Mar 2013
    The bedroom tax is just wrong. Simple!
  39. Jay 14 Mar 2013
    If we have the power then use it
    - for goodness sakes, why should the coalition tell us (Scotland) what and what not to do. If there is a way out of this then stand up and say "NO"!
  40. nick 14 Mar 2013
    cmon lets not lie down and take this
  41. carol 14 Mar 2013
    #NO BEDROOM TAX#
  42. tom 14 Mar 2013
    desperately sad
  43. norman 14 Mar 2013
    PLEASE HELP
  44. Eileen Fraser 14 Mar 2013
    Simple...Please listen to the people
  45. John 14 Mar 2013
    Conservative Government RIP.
  46. John 14 Mar 2013
    Ian Duncan Smith, you should think of all of the implications of the boomerang effect before you introduce radical policies. This bedroom tax is over the top. You would all be lining your pockets with false expenses claims due to self regulation if you could. Resign before your are removed with your pernicious government by the electorate.
  47. Jonny Garner 14 Mar 2013
    Better late than never,Scrap the Tax!
  48. neil williamson 15 Mar 2013
    my son was on a waiting list for a good time because our local councils one bedroom properties had been converted for people with mobility problems(i.e wet rooms) yet when in the bidding process for a property he was not eligible for these due to them being converted which meant he had to take a two bedroom property for which he will now be penalised,but what in the future if he has a family, what would have been the chance of moving from a one bedroom to a two bedroom?Not very much due to lack of social housing.come on the tory government get your act together you caused this problem by the right
    to buy but don't penalise the tenants of today.I guarntee i WILL not vote tory ever again,although i have never voted tory.YOU will NEVER win my vote
  49. Christine 15 Mar 2013
    Once again the poor and sick are the easy targets while the fat cats get richer.
  50. Jack Ward Fincham 15 Mar 2013
    There is a kernel of a good idea here, but the approach is spiteful and angry.
    If we have a problem with single occupancy of 3-4 bedroom houses then granting incentives to promote movement. Eviction isn't an incentive.