Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Evictions Due to Underoccupation Deductions (PE1468)

Tuesday 16 April 2013 Public Petitions Committee About 10:00 Petitions 27 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

27 contributions
David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The second new petition is PE1468, by Mike Dailly, on behalf of Govan Law Centre Trust, on evictions due to underoccupation deductions. Members have a note by the clerk, the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing and the petition. I welcome to the meeting Jackie Baillie MSP, who has an interest in the petition, and I invite her to speak to it.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Thank you, convener. I thank the committee for the time afforded to me; I will be brief.Our positions on the bedroom tax are well rehearsed and a majority in Parliament are certainly opposed to it. The petition must be viewed in that context. When members stood for election to Parliament, we did so for different reasons. However, we are all here to exercise power. The truth, for me, is that if we are opposed to a particular tax or policy initiative and if it is within our gift to do something about it, we should exercise our power and not simply turn around at every opportunity and blame Westminster for it.The petition invites us to exercise our power in a particular way with regard to legislative protection for people who fall into arrears as a consequence of the underoccupation element of the bedroom tax. I think that members will recognise that seeking to make anybody homeless carries a huge cost not only for the public purse but for the individuals concerned. I think that the figure that was quoted was a cost of about £24,000 to rehouse a homeless family, so it clearly does not suit the public purse to go down that route.The petition’s proposal would deliver a consistent approach across Scotland not just for local authorities but for registered social landlords. Indeed, many local authorities have transferred all their housing stock, so it is imperative that the same approach is taken by different sectors. Some of us have argued that the approach should be accompanied by financial assistance. There are various estimates of what that could be.Whatever people’s position, the petition gives us something to consider, which we should do with some urgency. I note from the clerk’s paper on the petition the suggestion that it would be appropriate for the petition to be moved on to the Welfare Reform Committee. I support that and hope that this committee will do that quickly.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank you again for coming along and speaking to the petition.As Jackie Baillie indicated, I have been approached by Michael McMahon, the convener of the Welfare Reform Committee, who asked that we transfer consideration of the petition to his committee, which, as Jackie Baillie said, makes a lot of sense, given that committee’s remit. I invite suggestions from members, who I know have all taken a great interest in this important petition.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

Good morning, Ms Baillie. We all—well, perhaps not all—sympathise by and large with the situation that the petition describes, for which certain local authorities have taken decisions on a non-eviction policy. Is there a conflict of interest with regard to the petitioner and the Govan Law Centre Trust in terms of the actions that might be pursued? I do not have the answer, so I would like clarification.The petition rightly addresses issues for people who will be directly affected by the bedroom tax. What the petition proposes might mitigate some of the impacts, but the consequence would be that a burden would be imposed on the public purse. Clearly, we do not want evictions, and they should be fought against. What does Ms Baillie think the implications would be for the public purse if we were to pursue the suggested policy?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

What is clear and has been argued across the piece is that welfare reform will have an impact on repairs and maintenance budgets for housing associations and local authorities. That would be the case whether the petition’s proposal was implemented or not. Arrears are more likely to arise, not least because the UK Government has taken the view that individual tenants should have their housing benefit paid directly to them rather than to the landlord. There are genuine fears about arrears accumulating as a consequence of that.Leaving that to one side, I think that local authorities, irrespective of their political complexion, have by and large tried very hard to ensure that there is sufficient in their housing revenue budgets for repairs and maintenance. I know that some have added to those budgets because of the new situation; others have looked to the discretionary housing payments that are provided by the UK Government and have topped those up by the maximum of one and a half times extra. There is a real argument that that is insufficient based on anecdotal information about current demand, so the Welfare Reform Committee may want to look at what the demand for discretionary housing payments actually is.11:30

Local authorities recognise that the cost of evicting people ends up being borne by the public purse. I have given the committee the figures; rehousing a homeless family, at £24,000, will cost the public purse far more.Without a shadow of doubt, this is not a campaign about non-payment. If you speak to the petitioner, you will know that they recognise the responsibilities that local authorities and housing associations have. People are still in debt today as a consequence of poll tax arrears, so non-payment is not the purpose of the petition; the petition’s purpose is, in very limited circumstances, to achieve protection on a consistent basis across Scotland. I hope that we all aspire to that.It has been suggested that the petition be moved on to the Welfare Reform Committee, which is probably the most appropriate place for it to be considered.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I understand why you might want that to happen, but I would like more information before we talk about passing the petition on. I do not think that we have got all the information that we require from the petitioner.We have talked about local authorities. There is also the position that housing associations are taking in relation to the matter and the point that Jackie Baillie rightly made about direct payments. At the most recent meeting of the cross-party group on social enterprise, the convener of the Welfare Reform Committee talked about £800 a fortnight being paid directly to one tenant who said, “There’s no point in giving me that because I’ll drink it before the next lot comes round.” I understand the aspiration, and we certainly share your compassion around this particular issue. However, we must look at tenants as a whole and ask a lot more questions of the petitioner before we consider passing the petition to the Welfare Reform Committee.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Before I open the discussion up to further questions, I remind committee members that Jackie Baillie is not the petitioner, so I will not countenance her being asked to answer on behalf of someone else. The committee agreed not to invite Mike Dailly to the meeting. Maybe we should have invited him so that we could have asked him those questions.We must consider whether we want to continue the petition and have a debate on it, which is perfectly proper, or whether we should refer it to the Welfare Reform Committee, as its convener has requested. The first step is to decide whether to refer the petition, which would be perfectly appropriate. If we decide not to do so, it is then open to us to have a full debate on the issues. We need to get that right, first.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

It would be unusual for us to refer a petition without taking any further information. The petition identifies a theoretical provision, but in so far as it is potentially a reality it is a concern. I do not think that any committee member would want anybody to suffer an eviction as a result of section 69 of the Welfare Reform Act 2012 and the Housing Benefit (Amendment) Regulations 2012, as opposed to the so-called bedroom tax. Nonetheless, the first and most appropriate action for the committee would be to follow our normal practice and seek the views of the Scottish Government on the implications of the petition and the issues that it raises. I recommend that we also consult COSLA and the Department for Work and Pensions; I would like to know what estimates have been made of the likelihood of evictions occurring in Scotland or anywhere else in the UK as a result of the provisions of the 2012 act.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Jackson Carlaw is correct that our normal practice is to do a bit of homework before deciding to move a petition on. It is unusual to get an early request to transfer a petition, so I did my duty by ensuring that everyone was aware of that.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I would be very surprised if the Welfare Reform Committee has not already discussed the implications of the introduction of the legislation by the UK Government. Like other members, I am keen to seek further information before we pass the petition to any committee, if we decide to pass it on to a committee.Jackie Baillie has raised some clear issues. The issue of the £24,000 cost of dealing with a family eviction is very emotive and it is worrying when such figures are quoted for local authorities. That presupposes that local authorities will move to evict someone who falls into arrears because of the legislation. It will be up to local authorities to make decisions on a case-by-case basis.However, I have wider concerns about the changes that are coming through from Westminster under the welfare reform legislation, as this is just one of a number of changes that the UK Government has proposed. The question is whether the Scottish Government or local authorities should be asked to pay for welfare reform changes that are made by Westminster, and how far they can afford to offset the impact of welfare reform policies from Westminster. Members must ask themselves whether it is the duty of the Scottish Government or local authorities to continue to pay for proposals from Westminster that impact most severely on those on the lowest incomes.Other benefit changes are about to come forward, including the cut to the maximum level of benefit that will be payable to a family. Although the Scottish Government and local authorities in Scotland have attempted to offset the worst impacts of some of the changes, the difficulty is that their budgets are restricted. If we continue to use those budgets to offset the benefits changes that are coming from Westminster, we are denying the inevitable—that the Scottish Government and local authorities might be asked to continue to pay for changes that are coming from Westminster. We must find the best possible method of protecting the people of Scotland against the benefits changes. It is not always a remedy to ask either the Scottish Government or local authorities to step in and bear the brunt of the costs.There has been a suggestion that we write to the Scottish Government, COSLA and others. I suggest that we also write to the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations, because the point has been made this morning that many of the organisations that provide social housing in Scotland are housing associations and co-operatives. It is only right to ask those organisations about the impact of the provisions, along with others that have come from Westminster on things such as the housing benefit cap. There are serious concerns about the on-going financial viability of housing associations if such changes to benefits keep on being made. Some housing associations operate in the most vulnerable communities in Scotland, and the changes might have the severest impact on them.Another concern around the underoccupation issue—sorry about this, convener—is the availability of alternative housing. I have said previously that I find it somewhat mystifying that the same political party that introduced the right to buy introduced the underoccupation benefit cut that many benefit claimants are facing at present. Those of us who were around just over 30 years ago and dealt with the right to buy issue could have foreseen a situation in which a subsequent Conservative Government would penalise people for living in social housing.

Maureen Watt SNP Aberdeen South and North Kincardine
link

I am convener of the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee, which held an inquiry into how the homelessness legislation was working 10 years on. Evictions are not the main cause of homelessness. The petition states:“Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow”.Maybe it does, but that was not my experience when we took evidence in Glasgow. Eviction is the last resort for all the housing providers that we interviewed and took evidence from and I am not sure whether that sentence in the petition is true. As I said, that was not the experience of the committee. As John Wilson said, it is important that we get the views of the SFHA, because in other parts of the country eviction is utterly the ultimate action. I am not sure that what is said in the petition is correct and I do not think that we should go further without taking more evidence.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

A number of members have suggested that we follow normal practice and seek advice from the Scottish Government, COSLA, the DWP and the SFHA rather than refer the petition to the Welfare Reform Committee at this stage. Can I confirm that the majority view of the committee is to take the petition forward?Members indicated agreement.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I note that, as a committee, we did not ask for Mike Dailly to be present today and also that some emotional concerns have arisen. I want to ask whether housing is a matter for the Scottish Government, as the petition is about a housing matter. It is also about welfare reform, which the Welfare Reform Committee is dealing with, so why not refer the petition to that committee? I am thinking about the duplication of work.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is right to say that the Welfare Reform Committee has discussed the issue. My experience is that the normal practice of this committee is to do a bit more digging and investigation before referring a petition. That is a fair comment about the custom and practice that we follow.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I hope that we would be able to pursue—Interruption. Sorry, does Jackie Baillie want to comment?

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Perhaps I can make a helpful suggestion. If the committee is going to investigate the issue further, then that is what it will do. However, it struck me that there were questions from Chic Brodie and Maureen Watt that only the petitioner could clarify. I wonder whether it would be appropriate to have the petitioner here to provide that clarity when the petition is next considered by the committee, because I take the point about time marching on. Perhaps that would be a helpful way of dealing with the petition.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

That is a reasonable point, but I raise the issue of the conflict of interest. As is pointed out in the petition,“Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention”—Ms Baillie screws up her nose at that, but the promotion of the petition when there is potential—I am not saying that this will happen—for the petitioner to benefit from the action that is taken is quite an important issue and I seek clarification on that. I am not saying that the petitioner should not be here, but I seek clarification.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will bring Jackson Carlaw in, but I am conscious that we could spend the next couple of hours debating this. I want to concentrate on what we agree on, which is that we will continue the petition to seek advice from the four groups that I mentioned earlier. I want to confirm that before we open the discussion up, because we could have a two-hour debate on a couple of points of law, which we are not here to do. Do we agree to take that course of action?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

My second point is that there has been a helpful suggestion that we have Mike Dailly along to the committee. Although we did not feel that that was necessary last time, there is an old cliché that, as the facts change, so do our opinions. If the committee would find that useful, I have no objection, but I want to sound out all the committee members on that point.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I am always very grateful for noises off-stage contributing to our consideration of the action that we might take. However, the purpose of writing in the first instance is to inform us further as to what we will then do. It would be premature to invite anyone along in anticipation of what we might do on receipt of the information that we have now requested.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

If members want any information from the petitioner at this stage, the clerk can write to Mike Dailly.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I agree that we should hold off inviting the petitioner until we have some information back from the four organisations we have agreed to write to.I am sorry about this, convener, but I would like to add a fifth suggestion, which is that we ask the clerks or the convener of the Welfare Reform Committee whether they have considered this change and, if they have not done so, what their timetable is for doing so. Although Anne McTaggart is quite right that the Scottish Government is responsible for housing, it is not responsible for housing benefit. The Westminster Government still has control over the benefit system on which the people of Scotland rely to survive. The wider question is whether we can continue to allow Westminster changes to impact so severely on the people of Scotland.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do members agree that we should contact the Welfare Reform Committee? It has discussed the issue, but we should get a detailed timetable from it so that we can avoid any duplication. Do members agree?Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. I know that this is a difficult area, so I thank members for keeping on about this particular issue. Finally, I thank Jackie Baillie for making a contribution as an honourable non-member of the committee.

  1. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 10:00 Current Petition Petitions · 96
  4. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 63
  5. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 27
  6. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  11. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  12. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  14. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
  15. 10:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
  16. 10:00 School Bus Safety Committee business · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.