Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01468 · Session 4

Evictions due to under occupation deductions

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2012 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
4,755 online signatures with a country
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.

What the petitioner did first

This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Apr 2013
    1 mention
  2. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  4. 19 Nov 2013
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,755 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,714 78.1%
  2. United Kingdom701 14.7%
  3. England240 5%
  4. Wales20 0.4%
  5. Northern Ireland13 0.3%
  6. United States12 0.3%
  7. Not given7 0.1%
  8. Australia6 0.1%
  9. Afghanistan5 0.1%
  10. Uzbekistan4 0.1%
  11. 27 other countries33 0.7%

Comments

712 comments, oldest first
712 comments · showing 301–350
  1. Tam Laird 19 Feb 2013
    Just,,disgusted.....
  2. david nelson 19 Feb 2013
    every person thats to pay this tax should get the addresses of every tory and lib dem mp and councillor and send them letters of petition,telling them that you will be campainging to vote them out at the first available election if they dont reverse this tax,come back robin hood and guy falkes we need you .
  3. Eileen McMurray 19 Feb 2013
    Time to fight back people....
  4. Marie Napier 19 Feb 2013
    I have lived in my house and been part of the community for over 20 years, I now have to be shipped out to who knows where...what is this country coming to??????????????????
  5. Patricia Taylor 19 Feb 2013
    This proposed tax beggars belief and is leaving people who are already on the breadline with the added worry of how they will fund this extra expense. Most have no choice in where they live and local housing associations do not have smaller properties to rent. It is an unfair tax on our poorest and most vulnerable.........NOT FAIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  6. Jennifer Broadhurst 19 Feb 2013
    This doesn't affect me or my family but it is very important that we understand that the reason for this problem reaching us in Scotland is in response to a London problem of rogue landlords raising rents to a ridiculous level and profiteering from the welfare state. Instead of this tax on the poor and vulnerable in social housing we should be addressing the issue of landlords raising rents above reasonable levels
  7. Eddie Cassidy 19 Feb 2013
    Don't forget it's the caring Lib Dems that are doing this to the neediest in our country.
  8. John Grant 19 Feb 2013
    An immoral, harsh and insensitive policy by the Tory led coalition government, let's get them out at the next election.
  9. Mark Destry 19 Feb 2013
    many people will be unknowingly affected by this legislation. i work in the welfare rights sector and people are still shocked when presented with this information! the DWP and local councils are still pursuing their policy of non-disclosure!
  10. Andrew Malcolm 19 Feb 2013
    New poll tax on the poor
  11. James 19 Feb 2013
    This is another reason why I believe that Scotland should be an independent country.
  12. margaret bean 19 Feb 2013
    another tax on the poor,build more social housing then people may want to move from a house that is now too big for them.Sometimes your home is the only secure thing in your life.
  13. Karen peutherer 19 Feb 2013
    This tax is ludicrous and unfair
  14. tam 19 Feb 2013
    mike dailly is a hero
  15. bernadette skivington 19 Feb 2013
    its a disgrace people will be home less and what are you going to do with the children a and elderly when parents and elderly people fall back in paying their rent
  16. bernadette skivington 19 Feb 2013
    disgusting why is the queen being allowed to live in a place while tax payers are paying for it get her to pay for her rooms as well
  17. theresa beattie 19 Feb 2013
    i think this will lead to many children suffering and i for one am sick of yhe way this goverment attacks the poor and the workers these ppl are in power because the working class put them there time to grow a back bone and go after the rich . ppl will lose their homes because of this
  18. allan thomson 19 Feb 2013
    sick to death of living under english rule
  19. kgray 19 Feb 2013
    tax the rich not the vulnerable in society. Cameron & Co have to go
  20. Lesley 19 Feb 2013
    In a house with 2 'spare' bedrooms, not gonna be able to afford to live in it but will struggle to afford to leave it as well. Very few 2 bedroom places left in the area I want to live in. Either been sold or created into homeless flats.
  21. Donald Macmillan 19 Feb 2013
    We have to stand up as a nation and reject this outrageous idea
  22. linda 19 Feb 2013
    why don't they reduce the wages of the prime minister and his cronies and charge them mansion tax and charge the queen for all the bedrooms she doesn't need or let homeless people use them!!!!!!!
  23. Brian H 19 Feb 2013
    Let's not forget David Cameron's mortgage claims of 2005-06 from taxpayers of £21,293.86.
    Assuming average of £12 per week "bedroom tax," would allow David to continue his tenancy in under-occupied home for approximately 174 years.
    We live in a very unfair society....
    Each and every Westminster MP should have "fallen on their sword" when found to overclaim their generous expenses.
  24. Drew Richardson 19 Feb 2013
    This tax is wrong and ill thought out. It shouldn't be enacted.
  25. Kathie Berg 19 Feb 2013
    think it is very unfair some people have been in their "homes" since birth or from a bery young age and their parents probarly paid enough rent on these "homes" to pay for it 10 times over and they are being punished because they dont have jobs what kind of a goverment can do this
  26. Graham Langmuir 19 Feb 2013
    The only escape from this Westminster govt is independence
    - Vote YES in 2014.
  27. linda strachan 19 Feb 2013
    Sometimes, hard working, decent people find themselves in circumstances beyond their control and have to make the choice.......do I feed my family or pay the rent? People HAVE to eat......nuff said. Give help to people at home before we send billions in foreign aid.
  28. Thomas Harvey 20 Feb 2013
    This is yet another tax directed at the poorer sector of society, why dont the rich and wealthy just honestly pay their rightfull taxes instead of dodging the tax and projecting the responsibility on to the poor.
  29. rosemary thomson 20 Feb 2013
    i am disabled and my husband is my carer and my sleep pattern is out of this world so we need two bedrooms are you thinking about the hardship this tax is going to cause
  30. Mrs J Menzies 20 Feb 2013
    My mum has already downsized from a 3 bedroom to a 2 because she understands people are waiting on houses with kids, but she has 2 to allow her grandchildren
    to come visit and stay with her overnight. Must she be deprived of this too. It's bad enough that she's losing her heating allowance as its been scrapped as well. Is t it about time we looked after our own instead of making life harder for them in their old age.
  31. Simon Peter Macaulay 20 Feb 2013
    Such a poorly conceived policy made with no regard, let's hope the Scottish government can mitigate some of this Tory madness!
  32. Mr steven hamilton 20 Feb 2013
    Government gone crazy again
  33. Paul Leslie 20 Feb 2013
    This is a most divisive tax on people and will split family units. How awful it would be to see people who are not prepared to move from their homes rounded up and shifted into hotels and hostels. There is a shortage of smaller accommodation. It is also unfair on young people ( boys & girls ) having to sleep in a same room. LIke most coalition policies this has been poorly thought out and there will have to be another U turn!
  34. hannah mackie 20 Feb 2013
    People shouldnt have to pay extra, david cameron doesnt! !!
  35. stewart 20 Feb 2013
    we should not have a government as we have a royal family ??????????
  36. David Kirkwood 20 Feb 2013
    It is just another tax on the poor
  37. Suzanne McCash 20 Feb 2013
    Boys and girls being expected to share up to the age of 8 while their is another room that then will then be taxed !! It seems like madness to me.
  38. colin warnock 20 Feb 2013
    Its disgusting that the Scottish government are willing to this to fellow Scots,where would the point be of home rule when we are just going to end up with the same type of treatment that Scotland and the Scots have been put under by an English Government....Money grabbing where they can instead of positive changes.Fair to say that if this goes through,all the monies will disappear to Edinburgh and not used for ant type of improvement ,not een in housing.....You the Scottish Government should hang your head in shame.
  39. John B Bushnell 20 Feb 2013
    Tory plus liberal equal Monsters
  40. Simon Peter Macaulay 20 Feb 2013
    Hey there Colin, unless I'm mistaken the 'bedroom tax' is not a devolved matter and is coming from the dark heart of Westminster. Perhaps a good argument for further devolution or Independence?
  41. maggie smith 20 Feb 2013
    i work for the government and need my extra bedroom to do my job and still i have t go cap in hand to ask for a discretionary payment allowing me to continue my job???
  42. Michelle Callachan 20 Feb 2013
    Again this is a tax soley aimed at the poorest in our society. I have 2 daughters who live with me and a 7 year old stepson who stays with me every Wednesday and every 2nd weekend. Should he be sleeping on the floor of my daughters' bedroom? Outraged.
  43. Gary Fraser 20 Feb 2013
    I smell a revolution! oh no its just the smell of the camp fire im having to feed the kids from now we will be living in a tent, it has 3 rooms no dowt get a tentroom tax next.
  44. lynn mcmillan 20 Feb 2013
    i think its rediculous what the government is doing to the families on a low income.
  45. colin coupar 20 Feb 2013
    just another way to rob people that can't afford it
  46. Marie McDonald 20 Feb 2013
    This is the worse government we have ever had how can they bring this bedroom tax in when they put all these people in houses with more than 1 bedroom in the first place also as per usual it will affect all the wrong people
  47. John Nisbet 20 Feb 2013
    There are not enough one bedroom flats in the country for people to downsize.
  48. David Redpath 20 Feb 2013
    Exactly the type of thing we should expect from a Govt akin to the top table at Eton. Pathetically out of touch to the point of discriminatory to the less well off. Their attitude to the working class is an absolute disgrace.
  49. bill oneill and Harley Guide Dog 20 Feb 2013
    would some 1 tell me where is the glasgow demo leaving from thanks Harley guide dog
  50. mrs sandra cox 20 Feb 2013
    No to bedroom tax unfair on most vulnerable