Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01468 · Session 4

Evictions due to under occupation deductions

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2012 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
4,755 online signatures with a country
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.

What the petitioner did first

This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Apr 2013
    1 mention
  2. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  4. 19 Nov 2013
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,755 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,714 78.1%
  2. United Kingdom701 14.7%
  3. England240 5%
  4. Wales20 0.4%
  5. Northern Ireland13 0.3%
  6. United States12 0.3%
  7. Not given7 0.1%
  8. Australia6 0.1%
  9. Afghanistan5 0.1%
  10. Uzbekistan4 0.1%
  11. 27 other countries33 0.7%

Comments

712 comments, oldest first
712 comments · showing 251–300
  1. Alicia Murray 18 Feb 2013
    Man's inhumanity to man. I loathe the Tories.
  2. John Hamilton 18 Feb 2013
    Everyone in the country should rise up against this evil ConDem tax and say
    - Not to our people!! Roll on 2014!
  3. Ian Vallely 18 Feb 2013
    Disgrace,
  4. Mary Thom 18 Feb 2013
    This goverment has lied to the people they are preying on the disabled and poor people they are bring the people most needed down disgrace they should be ashamed off there selfs let them live that the poor for a month I don't think they would last a week lets get them voted OUT !!!!!!!
  5. Sandra Sullivan 18 Feb 2013
    I feel sorry for everyone even myself I have lived in my home for 23 years I have one spare bedroom
  6. David 18 Feb 2013
    Listened to the Scottish Lib Dem leader trying to defend this outrageous Tax and thought to myself, I will never vote for your party ever again !
  7. Susan 18 Feb 2013
    In a country where there was enough social housing to accommodate all those who needed it I would not be entirely against this tax, as long as it was enforced in a reasonable manner. However, during a period when the number of social houses being built has fallen off a cliff, how can this be justified? It is nothing short of victimisation.
  8. Michael McFadyen 18 Feb 2013
    This is just another proof of why Scotland needs independence. Most "Scottish" Labour MPs voted against this unfair and immoral tax but to no effect. Their votes were ineffectual and as with Thatcher in the 1980s any laws passed in Westminster no matter how detrimental to the health, wealth and well being of the people of Scotland it will be imposed upon us. Only an independent parliament with control over all its resources and spending will ever change that. Welfare reform may be a necessary process but due to the neo-liberal consensus at Westminster targeting the poor and the disabled is given a greater prominence than the tax avoidance schemes of companies and individuals who are able to pay taxes but who chose not to. A YES vote in 2014 is not about the SNP its about doing what is right, standing up for those who need help and be willing to share the burden of tax to enable better services to be provided.
  9. John Souter 18 Feb 2013
    This is an iniquitous tax of little use or purpose.
  10. Anna 18 Feb 2013
    I am ill enough without this hanging over my head
  11. James 18 Feb 2013
    My mother has been in the same flat for 20+ years. She needed this flat at the time as she was a single mother with 3 children. Why should she have to downsize? Her children visit her all the time, sometimes all at once. Where are we to stay? Everybody on the floor in the lounge? Are they going to offer her other accommodation and help her move? She is 53 years old and needs a knee operation! It's just making the poor poorer. How many people are going to die of starvation or cold when they really are going to choose between eating and heating? It's not about not paying it, they just take it from your benefits. Population control? Kill the elderly? Needs to stop!
  12. johnny 18 Feb 2013
    so glad govan law centre has started this petition
  13. john stark 18 Feb 2013
    this is nearly as great an attack on the consept of social housing as the right to buy
  14. Brian H 18 Feb 2013
    The UK(Con-Dem)Government has decided on this tax without giving consideration to the devastation it will cause to individuals and families throughout Scotland.
  15. joe mcgoldrick 18 Feb 2013
    taking more money of the poor to pay back money the rich lost
  16. Sally Cameron 18 Feb 2013
    How will this work for disabled people that have been housed by the council who have not requested a spare room but have been given a property that has an extra bedroom purely to have accessible facilities?? Will they be offered accessible housing with less bedrooms? I don't think so as there is not alternatives available!
  17. Stephen McMahon 18 Feb 2013
    A ridiculous attack on the poor while disproportionately affects the working class while the rich stay in homes with more rooms than they could ever possibly use.
    Any money made from this disgusting charade would be dwarfed by the revenue raised from tax-dodging corporations and mega-rich CEOs.
  18. Dominic Mcnellis 18 Feb 2013
    And did you notice there was no choice of Scotland available? yes to independence!
  19. Ann McAlpine 18 Feb 2013
    The Scottish Government should protect vulnerable people from this UK legislation.
  20. Robbie Pennington 19 Feb 2013
    Scotland did not vote for this. Resist this foreign interference.
  21. Catherine Hughes 19 Feb 2013
    Disgraceful!!
  22. vicky thomson 19 Feb 2013
    i think its disgusting :-(
  23. eve robinson 19 Feb 2013
    This is not in Manifesto.
  24. Colin Stein 19 Feb 2013
    im sick to death of these EU laws guissed as british law.........
  25. Pamela Herta Lumsden 19 Feb 2013
    This is so unfair to so many people, im surprised they havent started to build poorhouses as we seem to be going backwards in time!!!!
  26. Garry Maclachlan 19 Feb 2013
    Another attack on the worst off in society! We fought the poll tax and won, we will fight this too and win!
  27. Gerry Green 19 Feb 2013
    It's hard to believe a 'democratic' government would impose such an unfair tax on their most vulnerable citizens. Must not be allowed to be imposed!
  28. Anon 19 Feb 2013
    Heartless Government
  29. Louise brown 19 Feb 2013
    The sustained attack on the poor and vulnerable of society must end. Pennies will be scraped back with this legislation and to what end? A poorer, more polarised and damaged community
  30. peter dougal 19 Feb 2013
    how dare they, unite and fight dont let them away with this stand up and be counted, we are the people.
  31. Alan Wyllie 19 Feb 2013
    www.no2bedroomtax.co.uk

    Well done Mr Dailly.

    OK SNP, show us how different life would be in an indy Country. You have a responsibility to stand up for the most vulnerable. DO NOT LET US DOWN.

    YOUR ACTIONS WILL BE REMEMBERED IN 2014.
  32. Rob Allan, Edinburgh 19 Feb 2013
    Thats the Tories for you.
  33. Mrs Helen Carstairs 19 Feb 2013
    This is the most ill thought out policy any government has introduced
  34. andrea caird 19 Feb 2013
    people are givin houses that a required for there needs and family sizes. children grow fly the nest. this tax is unfair
  35. Lucy Graywoollf 19 Feb 2013
    If the govt chose to peruse say the Edindex (Key to Choice) Housing Guide provided free in the Evening News each Monday evening or pick up a copy of the above guide in all libraries within the Edinburgh region he and his Tory chums would realise the ONLY one bedroom flats and houses automatically are ALLOCATED to tenants aged 60 and over (on a few occasions they have reduced the deficit by 10 years). In other words an individual can be 50 years of age and apply for the above one bed property. However this does NOT mean they will be granted the exchange! What of the other age groups who own insufficient criteria in which to apply for a one bed flat? What do they do? Cameron does not care! He's swanning it in Delhi discussing 'cyber crime' what next!
  36. John Mulholland 19 Feb 2013
    The eviction of tenants due to arrears in the vast majority of cases is simply wrong the eviction of tenants due to size reduction is immoral
  37. Annamarie Theresa Causer 19 Feb 2013
    If Cameron and his Tory chums chose to peruse the (reduced to fewer every week) available properties advertised in every local Housing guide throughout Scotland and England HE and THEY would come to realise, if it sinks in of course, there are NO 1 bedroom properties on the housing tenant 'market.' The few available are ONLY for 60 years old and in the upwards age group! Very occasionally they reduce the age gap by 10 years (to 50 years) but more often than not it is individuals who earn pension credits and pensions who are applicable for 1 bedroom flats and single story sheltered housing! ! What happens then to every other age group then? 18-59 year olds?
  38. frances kimmet 19 Feb 2013
    this is an unfair tax because of the housing situation there is no houses available for people who wish to downsize, so they will be taxed on this through no fault of their own which is another reason why it is an unfair tax
  39. Anna Ross 19 Feb 2013
    So what about the grannies on housing, will they no longer have a room for their grandkids? And what about those that are unfit to share? And how do you plan to re-house all those currently living in a 2 bedroomed flat with a 1 bedroom when there is a shortage of 1 beds? Another example of Tory ineptitude as a result of being completely removed from the normal population!
  40. Dave 19 Feb 2013
    I will be voting Yes in 2014 , if the SNP take this petition and put it into action and also scrap the Spare Bedroom Tax as they have promised to do !
  41. Donna Clark 19 Feb 2013
    only the torries could come up with this .Just because families grow up & set up there own houses does not mean that they never need to go back home plus sometimes it can be ill health & you need a family member to look after you if you don't have it you can't help them then the state needs too
  42. fiona 19 Feb 2013
    R the government going to compensate the people that r overcrowded or that have a son and daughter in the same room. I bet not.
  43. Ann Marie Richards 19 Feb 2013
    People have asking for smaller houses and being told there is none.....how can tax someone for the extra room they don't even want!!
  44. John Wilson 19 Feb 2013
    Thought up and brought forth by people that never have and never will need to live in social housing. The Tories are more out of touch than ever!
  45. neil mackay 19 Feb 2013
    vote yes for independence and you will never have a tory goverment again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  46. gerry kane 19 Feb 2013
    if we do nothing about it the tories will introduce the tax and the low paid will suffer.
  47. fiona 19 Feb 2013
    This tax is disgusting, i work with the elderly and i know several of them are sat in large houses they no longer want to be in because they are too big, they are begging their local authority for a smaller house and are being told there is'nt any, so these people are going to be penalised through no fault of their own, while struggling to live now. I have happily signed the petition not just for them but for all of us, if we let the government get away with this whats going to be taxed next. We have to stay united.
  48. Heather Mackintosh 19 Feb 2013
    It's the most ill thought out policy in a long time and that's saying something. It's more to do with the situation in London, but everyone is being penalised. Absolutely shocking. It targets the most vulnerable, once again.
  49. G.williamson 19 Feb 2013
    when i was first on the housing list i kept getting given 2 and 3 bedroom flats as there was no one bedroom flat's .. thats not my fault yet i'd lose out
  50. Pat Ward 19 Feb 2013
    If they want me to live in one room they can send me to jail cos I ain't paying. Jail would be great, no rent, free food, no bills and visits twice a week. That'll do me.