Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01468 · Session 4

Evictions due to under occupation deductions

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2012 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
4,755 online signatures with a country
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.

What the petitioner did first

This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Apr 2013
    1 mention
  2. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  4. 19 Nov 2013
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,755 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,714 78.1%
  2. United Kingdom701 14.7%
  3. England240 5%
  4. Wales20 0.4%
  5. Northern Ireland13 0.3%
  6. United States12 0.3%
  7. Not given7 0.1%
  8. Australia6 0.1%
  9. Afghanistan5 0.1%
  10. Uzbekistan4 0.1%
  11. 27 other countries33 0.7%

Comments

712 comments, oldest first
712 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Alasdair MacPherson 12 Feb 2013
    This petition has my full support. The Bedroom Tax is a barbaric, draconian and unjust attack on social rented tenants.
  2. Jacqui Pollock 12 Feb 2013
    This is so hard for people to take and the stress on them is enormous, and what for may I ask?. There are not enough houses tp put people in, will people get compensated for adaptations they paid for to meet their needs,its private landlords who should be targeted as the government pays their morgage while whoever stays in their property gets housing benefit, who then owns the house?there is a lot of troubled people going to take this matter further.
  3. margaret fleming 12 Feb 2013
    They have to remember these house's are our home's we built a lifetime of memories in for to have it taken away it should be against the law to treat people so poorly when they can't fight back.
  4. Mary Alladice 12 Feb 2013
    I am not directly affected by this vile bedroom tax but I know people that are and their lives are being ruined. In my humble opionion this is the tory way of getting rid of social housing and kicking the poorest in the country
  5. rod 12 Feb 2013
    thanx govan law centre for caring
  6. guy 12 Feb 2013
    unbelievable
  7. guy 12 Feb 2013
    good to see some old familiar names backing this petition
  8. bernadette skivington 12 Feb 2013
    what will happen if a family is evicted from their home will social work take the children off the parents and rehome them
  9. Colin Anderson 13 Feb 2013
    We have to fight for what is right and what happens to the animals dogs cats ect
  10. Chris Bermingham 13 Feb 2013
    There is already a lack of social housing provision and this tax will only exacerbate this. We are asking people to do the impossible as even those willing and able to move have no options. Why would the goverment, with their vast array of ancestral homes, consider that the homes of people supported by benefits are any less important to them. Financially people are worse off on benefits that they have ever been and its about to get much much worse.
    All those who feel they are currently not affected by this legislation should think again, this will affect all of us, our families and our communities.
  11. Joy Codona 13 Feb 2013
    Many people will suffer because of these changes in housing benefit, the sick and vulnerable will be the worst affected. I volunteer at the Citizen's Advice Bureau so I have first had experience of the effects this change will have. Steps must be taken to support the most vulnerable
  12. Ian Cavanagh 13 Feb 2013
    Why does the Government make life difficult for people when they can leave peaple to live a good life.
  13. Stephen McAlaney 13 Feb 2013
    The DWP state that Jsa of £71 pw is what the law says I need to live on-this tax reduces my living expenses by £9.66. At least a contradiction, possibly illegal? Definetely a further impact on the poverty line.
  14. Rosemarie Czarnecka 13 Feb 2013
    People are finding it hard to feed their children and live without all this added!!!! just go's to show that the westminister does not care about the little people.... just cos they have the money, why not have a year living in our shoes, then come and we will talk bout the stupid tax.....
  15. karen mcguire 13 Feb 2013
    to me the government are contradicting themselves as they already give out what they deem to be the minimum that people need to live on so where are they expecting people to get the extra money needed to stay in their own homes, have they not thought about the consequences of this new tax, crime rates will sore and prostitution will increase in order for people to finance this rediculous bedroom tax, why not save money by making things more equal once again its a case of take from the poor in order for the better off to continue in their comfy life styles....shame on the UK government.
  16. sam 13 Feb 2013
    why should i feel a terrible burden and worthless better off dead everytime the conservatives are in power
  17. Darren brownlow 13 Feb 2013
    People who can't work or get about already have a hard enough life with their illness with out having to worry about this new policy coming out
  18. Les Hudson 13 Feb 2013
    Divisive, hitting poor hardest, prejudicial towards single parents and those in Local Authority areas where there is a deficit of single bedroom accommodation. Vulnerable particularly at risk, huge burden on Local Authority personnel and budgets.
  19. pete 14 Feb 2013
    if know one paid this we would defeat it
  20. steve 14 Feb 2013
    41years in the home i love will get arrears then eviction very unfair
  21. Eddie Murray 14 Feb 2013
    In the council block where I live 25 of the 56 tenancies will be forced to pay this disgusting bedroom tax or be evicted. In the North Edinburgh area almost 1000 council tenants will be hit
    - and that does not include private and housing asociation tenants. This tax is a Tory obscenity and must be crushed, just like its predecessor, the cursed Poll Tax, was crushed by popular resistance and a refusal to pay.
  22. Father Ross K Bell 14 Feb 2013
    This bill is iniquitous and bordering on evil, it will destroy communities, disrupt children's education and create social isolation. It must be stopped. NOW.
  23. Nick Telford 14 Feb 2013
    This is yet another badly thought out Tory policy that terrorises the most vulnerable in our society yet does not address the causes of poverty and deprivation.
  24. Andrew John Younger 14 Feb 2013
    Under occupation, bad luck or bad management?
    However those circumstance arrives making someone homeless is no way a progressive Scotland.

    Core of Social Housing must be fundamental to charity status and removal of that from a magnet on commercial activity, effective spiffs parity to private sector is very wrong indeed and be very ugly to decent Scots.

    Cause of under occupation, too late once that is a situation, would you throw out a problem? Charity begins at home.
  25. Mairi Adkin 14 Feb 2013
    As usual they always taget the wrong people. The government certainly have no understanding of real life nor do they appear to want too.
  26. anne 14 Feb 2013
    im in tears every day with this i dont want to lose my home i love it
  27. Brian McNeil 14 Feb 2013
    I agree fully with the principles of this petition, and believe the Scottish government has a moral obligation to implement the proposal, or other measures with an identical effect.

    The 'bedroom tax' threatens to undermine Holyrood's stance on homelessness, to further line the pockets of grasping slum landlords, to break community and family ties, and to 'socially cleanse' areas where property values are high. In short, it's the sort of malicious fiscal attack on the poor that only Lord Snooty and the Bullingdon Club Thatcherites could dream up.
  28. mark mccaffer 15 Feb 2013
    Absolutely disgusted by this bedroom tax and I will likely be thrown out my flat. My '2nd room' is currently needing a carpet and furnishings. Do we get to let out the room? Do we get any financial aid to bring it up to scratch? Do we get financial aid to move house in the event that we may get evicted? Come live here for a while David Cameron and see how you like going without heating in winter just to pay for food. Another government we never voted for. Please vote yes to independence as we will probably get a government who care for Scottish peoples needs.
  29. William Donaldson 15 Feb 2013
    What I want to know is as of the moment as I am a jobseeker and have to pay 14% of my rent from April, if i return to work will I then be liable for normal rent or will I still have to pay this. if the case is that I have to pay normal rent then how can this tax be legal i.e. if i am unemployed I am classed as under occupier but if I am in work my property is no longer classed as under occupier.
  30. Craig Frew 15 Feb 2013
    I support this petition 100%, in this current financial climate it is not necessary to penalise already vulnerable tenants with an unfair bedroom tax.
  31. jodie 15 Feb 2013
    if they are going to do this sham of a bed room tax then they need to start building and providing people with what they need not charging them for the housing associations not having enough sutable houses to put people in ita a down right disgrace also i have 3 kids under 10 one of chick is disabled there is not chance my other 2 can stay in the same room as my disabled child for a number of reasons the main on being HEALTH AND SAFETY
  32. Robert Geelan 15 Feb 2013
    this is not a good idea at all.
  33. arlene macneiill 15 Feb 2013
    please sing this we all need halp some times and its me this time
  34. denise 15 Feb 2013
    I think this i just wrong all over the place boys and girls should not be made share a room the need there privacy and to charge people for wanting to give there children this privacy or keep a room for there children while they are away is just wrong the keep taking are money and spending it on crap like there 150 a month food allowence and there rent or morgage getting paid for them and all the other hard tax payers money they spend on them self instead of the things that matter like better housing and fixing the roads making better parks for are children improving hosptials ect they just want to make the rich even ritcher.
  35. Jeannie Benn 15 Feb 2013
    Not from Scotland but I fully support this petition and have signed for the sake of the poor and the working class who have been forced to 'go private' owing to the lack of social housing. A cap on private rents should also be placed to stop these greedy Tory voting landlords from ripping off both the poorest and the benefits system.
  36. Gillian Grochla 15 Feb 2013
    As a support worker for a mental health charity, I am only too aware of the devastating effect the mere prospect of this tax is having on the most vulnerable members of our society.
  37. J.Easson 15 Feb 2013
    I depair for the future of our society. I work in local authority customer services and am already aware that the poorest most vulnerable are already suffering with the stress of this tax and will suffer when it takes effect. We are heading towards a Dickensian poorhouse future unless an amendment is made.
  38. Jean Rattray 15 Feb 2013
    Another daylight robbery. God help us all if we allow this to come about.
  39. chris 16 Feb 2013
    dont pay it
  40. CJNicolson 16 Feb 2013
    This tax would only be justifiable in the slightest if there were enough one bedroom properties in all areas to enable folk to downsize within their communities. There isn't, therefore it isn't.
  41. GCFalkirk 17 Feb 2013
    -----William Donaldson----
    You only have to pay anything if you are receiving housing benefit. The idea is that you should get what you actually need if paid for by the rest of the workforce or you should pay for what you want if your in employment.
  42. Dorothy Watson 17 Feb 2013
    How many extra rooms is the Queen going to be taxed on? How many rooms are the millionaire MP's going to get away with not declaring that they are allegedly sub-letting?
  43. Irene Fleming 17 Feb 2013
    We didn't vote conservative but are having this act imposed which is essentially a tax on the poor.
  44. Cllr Patrick Hogg 17 Feb 2013
    This legislation is perniscious Tory persecution of the poor and must be repealed in the first week of SCottish Independence as no nation should ever treat their poor in such a disgraceful manner!
  45. Francis Fallan MBE 17 Feb 2013
    This particular legislation is purely based on a right wing government cementing a policy of people control the likes of which has never been seen since before the signing of the Magna Carta, remember it only applies to the dwellings owned by public authorities with exception of police, armed forces and other citizens on work associated to government or crown occupations, it's a clear attack directed at controlling purely working class people.
  46. allan rutherford 18 Feb 2013
    dont be scared of independence vote..... Torieshave already used propoganda by announcing the holding back navy contracts for yarrows bae systems. As they are unsure of independence for scotland. The changed scottish north sea to english channel border to steal our rights to gas and oilin 1999. But...... Scotland has all rights to gas and oil exploration in arctic...... A mistake by parliment signed wrong paper to us... Thats their appeal to the UN.
    We are all under UN rule of depopulation Agenda 21 in UN papers. All countries are to reduce population by imposing imunizations that are poisons... Bill gates congratulates depopulation for world programme. All sponsored by major countries n leaders of the world for nwo aka UN....
  47. Drew Brown 18 Feb 2013
    utter madness
  48. Alex Davidson 18 Feb 2013
    This is an appalling piece of policy, which directly illustrates how nasty the 'nasty' party has become, with the support of the Liberal puppets. You should be ashamed of your attack on the poor, the disabled and the elderly, but enjoy your tax concessions, large houses with duck houses, and stables for the police horses you get a wee loan of when times are hard.
  49. Andrew Pearson 18 Feb 2013
    The Tories have conveniently forgotten how many council houses they removed from the social housing stock through the right to buy scheme, leaving a shortage of suitable properties. The bedroom tax is utterly repellant and is punishing people who have no accommodation to move to even if they wanted to.
  50. Maureen Bonner 18 Feb 2013
    A Snowflake is a wondrous beautiful sight, no 2 are the same.On its own it is fragile but look what they can do when they stick together.