Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01468 · Session 4

Evictions due to under occupation deductions

Closed Submitted 18 Dec 2012 Housing & Planning
Signatures
0
4,755 online signatures with a country
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.

What the petitioner did first

This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Apr 2013
    1 mention
  2. 25 Jun 2013
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 12 Nov 2013
    1 mention
  4. 19 Nov 2013
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,755 online signatures
  1. Scotland3,714 78.1%
  2. United Kingdom701 14.7%
  3. England240 5%
  4. Wales20 0.4%
  5. Northern Ireland13 0.3%
  6. United States12 0.3%
  7. Not given7 0.1%
  8. Australia6 0.1%
  9. Afghanistan5 0.1%
  10. Uzbekistan4 0.1%
  11. 27 other countries33 0.7%

Comments

712 comments, oldest first
712 comments · showing 151–200
  1. morrison young 6 Feb 2013
    I consdier this to be uncivilised as is anyone who supports such a policy or government.Independence HERE I COME, Voting Labour elected this shower.
  2. maria johnston 6 Feb 2013
    discusted that yet again the most vulnerable in our sociaty are hit again,when will this government stop?
  3. Robert Jones 6 Feb 2013
    We at SAMH Outreach West support this petition.
  4. john 6 Feb 2013
    help
  5. G Morrell 6 Feb 2013
    If benefits are set at the minimum the government says we need to live on, how can they justify taking back as much as perhaps £20 or more from a single persons allowance?
  6. Mick Riley 6 Feb 2013
    Y
  7. Alistair McCabe 6 Feb 2013
    I'm a carer for my 83yr old mother, when she passes on I'll be evicted from the council house (presumably). It's been our family home for 63 years, I'm really sickened by the Torys and their lackeys, the liberals.
  8. David 6 Feb 2013
    The Tories caused this mess with Right to Buy and stopping replacement builds.However, those that stayed loyal to the council and had secure tenacies are now to be made to pay for it, if they have a spare bedroom, or face being evicted .. Truly wicked stuff!
  9. Susan Goldman 6 Feb 2013
    This is a very cruel tax which will affect the poorest and most vulnerable in society. It must not be allowed to go ahead!
  10. harry 6 Feb 2013
    mass non payment would work
  11. e darragh 6 Feb 2013
    shame on you cameron and shame on everyone who voted for him
  12. michael nugent 6 Feb 2013
    unbelieve, idiocy, from those who run the country, people must take to the streets
  13. Jacobite 7 Feb 2013
    This is part of "Agenda 21" Google it!
  14. Gordon Wardrope 7 Feb 2013
    It's just another form of oppression by a ruling elite looking after their own interests! People have the power, use your vote.
  15. Jamie MacNeil 7 Feb 2013
    Tenants should not risk loosing their home for a debt that is outwith their control. For most it will not be a case of wont pay it, but a case of cant pay it.
  16. M Anderson 7 Feb 2013
    Unfair on people who have low income and stayed in their home for years they should not be punished and have to worry about debt building up.
  17. Claire Christie 7 Feb 2013
    Rushed in, not thought through and very very dangerous.
  18. John McGuigan 7 Feb 2013
    CHAOS.
  19. Andy Donnell 7 Feb 2013
    This proposal is totally incompetent governance and shows a disgracefully irresponsible lack of care towards the less well-off sections of our community. It is not even half-baked as a proposal to solve a perceived problem. Just another sketch on the back of a cigar packet from m'lud.
  20. Ian Campbell 7 Feb 2013
    This is a typical Tory policy which will hurt the elderly who have brought up their family and are now alone. The Tories should remember that after a while a house becomes a home.
  21. Margaret Graham 7 Feb 2013
    Not enough thought or planning has been given by the Goverment
  22. MRS E CLARK 7 Feb 2013
    IT IS RIDICULOUS OLDER PEOPLE ARE BEING FORCED TO DOWNSIZE WHEN THERE ARE ACTUALLY NOT ENOUGH HOUSES TO DO SO .SO WHY PAY THE TAX WHEN YOUR WILLING TO MOVE BUT CANT BECAUSE THERE ARE NO HOUSES AVAILABLE?WE HAVE LIVED IN OUR HOUSE MOST OF OUR LIVES.HOW CAN WE AFFORD THIS TAX ON BENEFIT ?WE ARE BARELY GETTING ENOUGH TO LIVE ON AS IT IS! WE HAVE NO MONEY TO RE- HOUSE
  23. Caroline McCalman 7 Feb 2013
    These changes haven't been thought through, where are all these one bedroom flats? It could kill an elderly person to move out of their home leaving their neighbours, family & support system. If other people move into private accommodation they will have to claim more benefit because the rents are higher! These are some of the most vulnerable members of our society who are already struggling with higher food, energy & other rising costs, how are they meant to pay the extra costs they will be asked to pay? This Bill is nonsensical, unfair, cynical & perverse it has been written by multi- millionaire MPs who don't live in the real world & aren't affected by the reforms they put in place. They have came up with this because the Daily Mail wrote a story about a few families living in expensive properties in London & receiving thousands in Housing benefit. This is more about keeping Tory voters in the Home Counties & "chattering classes" happy than saving tax payers money or making the benefit system fairer. The Westminster Government have definitely taken a sledge hammer to crack a nut!
  24. Jacqueline Doyle 8 Feb 2013
    In a civilised society we cannot allow this type of draconian measure to pass without challenge. To see the worry and anguish etched on people's faces when the subject is raised is heartbreaking!!! Can you look anyone in the eye and wish this on them to pay a debt they did not create?
  25. Douglas Pearson 8 Feb 2013
    Is there anyway this can be taken to court as there is not enough smaller housing available so how can we be charged for the governments mistakes in not having a proper building program it is just another way to get money from poor and keep the rich rich is that this governments policy it looks like it
  26. billy Winton 8 Feb 2013
    so if a client comes in for help with a debt that has arisen from bedroom tax that is being pursued as a normal debt, in particular people who will never work again ,what options would this leave a money adviser because of the continuing liability would das td or sequestration be a realistic option.should it not be the case that if a landlord is not able to supply suitable alternative accomodation bedroom tax should not apply.
  27. elma sutherland 8 Feb 2013
    reminds me of stories of the Highland clearances forceing people out of their homes
  28. sam 8 Feb 2013
    brutality is what it is
  29. Tressa Burke 9 Feb 2013
    Glasgow Disability Alliance welcomes this petition. We are concerned that two thirds of households affected have a disabled person living in them. Disabled people are being unfairly targeted and this is on top of community care charges and cuts to other benefits and services. These are targeted measures which unfairly affect those for whom we should provide a safety net. This used to be called the welfare state.
  30. Rachel Bowles 9 Feb 2013
    Another shameless attack on the disabled by the government.
  31. Sue Downie 9 Feb 2013
    I think this is shocking piece of legislation that will punish people simply because their family circumstance change or because there are health or disability issues which require them to have an extra bedroom. It is blatantly discriminatory against people who are reliant on financial support to meet their housing costs, and could lead to the wholesale uprooting of people from their families and communities.
  32. Jan 10 Feb 2013
    Never thought that me and my disabled husband would end up on the street at our age, but it's a possibility, just feel sick everyday
  33. K. Edinburgh 10 Feb 2013
    Approached, Fri 8th Jan, by housing officer for Housing Association, was given two choices...Pay or Move! Callous and Heartless, I have arthritis, Rhumatoid and Poly, pain is 24hours, waited over 20 years for ground floor and only option last year was two bedroom, now I'm being told I will have no options as no ground floors available, flat with stairs or if Im really lucky I may get a lift. At this point I was then told I could not be fussy at this time. Thanks to ToriesLibs I now face the prospect of either moving back to a flat and never getting out the house or ending up homeless. REMEMBER O.A.P's are exempt, will not be forced to pay, and Disabled will more than likely be means tested every few months for exemptions for carers, because you may be cured over night thanks to a miricle, another form of harrassement from this farce of a government. THIS IS NOT A BEDROOM TAX IT IS IS A BENEFIT CUT AGAIN
  34. Sheilagh Douglas 10 Feb 2013
    Concerned that yet again the most vulnerable people
    are being targeted with this unjust tax.
  35. Ian Carle 10 Feb 2013
    Community action stopped poindings in the Poll-Tax era and it can stop evictions in the Bedroom Tax era
  36. gav 10 Feb 2013
    the stress is unbearable with this
  37. gavin 10 Feb 2013
    know one seems to be able to give any answers to this
  38. Nicky 11 Feb 2013
    I think this is dreadful. I don't see how it will help anyone. I think punishing the most disadvantaged only marginalises more and more. I think more people will become more and more ill because of lack of money and will have to use NHS services and Social Services. I think less money will go into the local economy because more people will have less money. I think Councils will have less money because less people will be paying into their systems and they will have to pay more in services.
    On the other hand, if people are able to find places of which will be very difficult considering there's a National Shortage of Housing and unfit housing for those with extra needs, the extra in rent will be covered.

    I also feel local Government have been slow to act, my own advising these are just proposals so we don't need to train or inform our staff.
    Aberdeen Council was only a few months ago approaching bankruptcy
    - I'm unsure if they can afford any more mishaps....
    On the other hand, many charities are unable to support people, the worst being Lynn Hendry of the STV Appeal who advised me that they could not be seen to criticise the Government who could withdraw funding
    - she had to begged to share the information privately!
    Marie from Save the Children advised me that they felt the same way. I asked Save the Children directly through email but never received a response.
    Over the last month, I was advised of an article from the Guardian regarding this matter of charities not wanting to be seen to speaking out because their funding would be withdrawn.

    I would like to offer my full support and would also like you to contact Stewart Hunter of the SNP Parliamentary Office in Dundee who is very interested in hearing about your thoughts.

    Many thanks,

    Nicky P

    PS

    I have emails in support of my conversations with the two ladies in question and am happy to share them with you.
    xxxxxxx
  39. dawn 11 Feb 2013
    I am exempt because my partner is 76 i am 59 if my partner dies before I'm pensionable I will join the BT .. please this is a terrible thing for everyone and I'm scared ,,,
  40. Julie Semple 11 Feb 2013
    Many individuals on low incomes manage their budgets to the penny in order to prevent the anxiety that comes with beng in debt. This situation may push individuals, through no fault of their own into ever increasing debt. Already advisers are being told that the poorest in society are choosing whether to heat their home or feed themselves. The added burden of stretching their income to pay the bedroom tax will make their situation untenable.
  41. jason williams 11 Feb 2013
    reminds me of the 80's what a sham
  42. Lorraine Dearie 11 Feb 2013
    Many people will be put in impossible positions by the westminster policies, it's only right for Scotland to try to mitigate the affect where it can until we can be rid of this once and for all. Vote YES for a fairer Scotland who can rule itself so we never see the likes of this abhorrent tax or other draconian cuts all aimed at the poor, the disabled and the low paid workers.
  43. Lynsey Dawson 11 Feb 2013
    What a ludicrous law! It's basically forcing people into homelessness
  44. john spence 11 Feb 2013
    its an unavoidable retaliation from the public on an issue that effects us all, this petition however is democracy in action.
  45. Julie-Anne Morgan 11 Feb 2013
    As the mother to a disabled son who has Asperger's I find this new law unacceptable and think the government should have thought of the impact it would have on disabled and low paid families before they implemented it as law
  46. Ben Wray 11 Feb 2013
    The Scottish Government have a responsibility to at the very least prevent evictions because of this backward, regressive tax policy
  47. Michael O'Connell 11 Feb 2013
    I consider the evictions occurring as a result of this tax unjust morally.
  48. Tommy Sheridan 11 Feb 2013
    Resistance is necessary.
  49. Mark Connelly 11 Feb 2013
    Another example of Tory "democratic" rule.
  50. margaret lorimer 11 Feb 2013
    Typical Tory government, punish the poorer class