Petition · PE01468 · Session 4
Evictions due to under occupation deductions
Signatures
0
Comments
712
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to amend Section 16 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 to prevent social landlords from using rent arrears caused by under occupation housing benefit deductions in eviction actions, and instead requiring such under occupation arrears to be pursued as an ordinary debt.
What the petitioner did first
This issue has been raised and discussed in local public meetings in Glasgow, and we have provided a full briefing paper on the proposal to Humza Yousaf MSP, Scottish Government Minister, who has passed same to the Housing Minister. The briefing paper was also forwarded to Johann Lamont MSP. Both Humza Yousaf and Johann Lamont were present at a public meeting of concerned tenants in Govan last month where the proposal was supported by 100 local tenants. Both Shelter Scotland, the STUC and the Glasgow Advice Agency support the proposal in this petition. We await the response from the Housing Minister, and Johann Lamont MSP.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Govan Law Centre defends a high volume of eviction actions in Glasgow, and specialises in the prevention of homelessness across the West of Scotland. We and are our partner agency, the Glasgow Advice Agency, which provides advice services across two-thirds of Glasgow City, have already had many tenants contact us concerned that they will be unable to pay the shortfall in their rents due to under occupancy deductions from April 2013. We, along with other civic and local bodies, have no doubt that unless measures are taken to mitigate the effects of the under occupancy deductions, Scotland will see a significant increase in eviction actions, which may be extremely hard to defend given current housing law.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Apr 20131 mention
-
25 Jun 20131 mention
-
12 Nov 20131 mention
-
19 Nov 20131 mention
Signatures by country
4,755 online signaturesComments
712 comments, oldest first712 comments · showing 101–150
-
Eileen FInlay 4 Feb 2013Barbaric ..unjust ..bill sneaked in and passed by those with mor than one home never mind a room... "most houses now you can't "swing a cat in "..even animals have social needs .. Is it a crime now ..after mab'y staying in your home for many years .. are we to leave our communities , friends , schools ,social circles ..to go whre ??...th reason that there are few sincle homes is that we moved away from that after the war ,,people needed space, better quality of lives .less crouding for a healthier life !.. we need to have children ..grandchildren ..friends stay over ! help if ill etc ... now people are to made feel like criminals .. we don't have extra money to pay this ..inhuman tax!..this was not on the manifesto then they were voted in ! .Alex Salmon.. now is the time to wine votes .. your people need justice .. stop this now !!.. depression "oh and that's ok there are free meds " ..and worse will follow .. worry stress .. suiside.. will follow . Save money on needless wars and all the Billions that costs .never mind lives ..I have worked all my days and paid taxes.I do object to abuse of the system but this is peoples lives ..Build us prison like cells and be done with it !.. disgusted ....and circumstances can change .. most people on housing benefit are on it not by choice! some may need it long term others until circumstances improve ... to say we need to leave our homes that we have invested in or pay up is to me criminal .. I am willing to march as protest and I suffer from Rheumatoid arthritis ...even if it won,t affect me ! .. already people are worried .. times are hard enough and health in this country . disease spread faster when we he crowded together !... stop the perks that mps get that's bound to save a few "bob" ! .....
-
sandra strachan 4 Feb 2013I was told by Aberdeen City council that l would be wasting my time getting on the housing list as theres no houses available! Private sector has the monopoly and the prices are sky high.
-
George McIrvine 4 Feb 2013The bedroom tax is just the latest assault on our poorest and most vulnerablt citizens. This right wing Government needs to demonise its victims as state dependent leeches to evidence this unjust tax.
-
Caroline Corfield 4 Feb 2013Willie Rennie, leader of the Libdems in Scotland once spent a night in a tent outside Paisley College of Technology to highlight the plight of the homeless, perhaps he could be asked what has changed his mind since then?
-
Chris Daly 5 Feb 2013My landlord a housing association informed me in a letter of my options : Take in a lodger, move to a one bedroom property, get a job. Neither of these are viable for me as I have PTSD ,Depression and a Personality Disorder all related to Childhood Trauma. I can't even live with my own family and I think people will harm me. So no I can't get a lodger.. Get a job I'm in and out of the psychiatric hospital and have severe mental illness... I'm unfit for work. For the first time in many years I'm settled in a place I call home with neighbours and care workers (not my carers my neighbours) in the complex of flats who I have learned to trust. Social landlords tell me they don't have enough 1 bedroom properties to meet the new demand. In my view this was thrust upon them and tenants by an uncaring out of touch Westminster Government. Our MSP's and the Scottish Parliament need to be more than vocal on this issue they need to act NOW...... April is too late
-
GAYLE MILLER 5 Feb 2013Bedroom Tax is an abomination of basic human rights. Many people need the "extra" room for many reasons, i.e caring for disabled, sick, elderly, families with shared custody, would-be parents etc Protect human rights and stop the attack on the poor and vulnerable.
-
Maureen Grant 5 Feb 2013Where is the moral complience in forcing people to move out of homes that they have lived in for decades, by all means encourage people to downsize. Many local authorities do not have the housing stock to allow the movement within their tennants specific area. Where is this governments thinking process, is it still in the past the bed tax sounds like something out of the dark ages ie, window tax. I certainly will not give my vote again to either party currently in power.
-
joanne boyle 5 Feb 2013this is a good thing it stops the landlords given rights to kick tennants out right away
-
Janice Martin 5 Feb 2013Eviction because of under occupancy is abhorrent & yes this Act must be amended & yes action must be taken to ensure it does
-
Hugh McRoberts 5 Feb 2013I Think the bedroom tax will add to the excisting problem and feel that this will force people to move from tenancys that have been part of their live since childhood, god forgive them for they no not what they are doing.
-
Catherine Bradley 5 Feb 2013We have a number of clients who would gladly move to smaller properties and have their names on the waiting list. Like every other Local Authority there is a shortage of smaller properties her and huge waiting lists.
-
Karen M Campbell 5 Feb 2013It is time that we as a nation speak out against the rising divide that has become so obvious in this country. The poorest people in our society are being forced into homelessness with no hope whilst the top earners in this country are getting tax breaks.
-
Janice Mitchell 5 Feb 2013Great to see Govan Law Centre taking this forward!!
-
Gerry Boyle 5 Feb 2013People on benefits will find it impossible to pay this tax and should not be evicted. Everyone has got to make a stance so that people are not isolated. The Trade Unions and the Labour party should call for a mass organised no payment campaign they wont be able to evict everyone, an injury to one is an injury to all. Evict the Tories.
-
lorraine gibson 5 Feb 2013I have been in my house for 42 years my parents died wen a i was 17 and hae brought my kids up in this house i am being punished for circumstances out within my control
-
Pauline McDonald 5 Feb 2013Is this even legal, I am on JSA for which the government says I need £71.00 a week to live on, they are only giving a 1% increase in April, which takes me up to £71.71 per week, are we not being paid by the old rules but paying by new rules. I pay £71 per fortnight to heat my home, £8 for my tv liscence and the rest goes on food and clothing come April I will have £35 a fortnight for food and clothes to keep me going, not going to look very good when I go for a job interview, with tatty clothes and shoes is it. Also where do the government expect me to go have tried swapping from a two bedroom to a one bedroom but there are not enough properties out there. Then when I'm made homeless again how am I expected to get a job without a fixed address.
-
bernadette pollock 5 Feb 2013my nerves are shattered with the whole business!!
-
mick 5 Feb 2013awful worry will cause medical treatment and more to rehouse it will cost them money and a lot of sorrow and mental illness for people
-
stevie 5 Feb 2013god bless mike dailly
-
Teresa Sadler 5 Feb 2013How can the government target the most vulnerable of our society? Shame on you who voted this sham of a government in.
-
helen allan 5 Feb 2013where are are they going to get smaller houses for some people as most housing offices say they have none avaiable just a way to make ypu poorer
-
Elizabeth Lawson 5 Feb 2013This is unjust and unfair and hits the most vulnerable. I think we know better here in Scotland.
-
Margaret Anderson 5 Feb 2013IF there was money being put into a SENSIBLE building programme to provide enough smaller houses to which to move people to then this wouldbe a good idea. The cart is before the horse, the government needs to get things in the right order. Build the kind of houses needs THEN ask folk to move into them! But as usual, the 'haves' are telling the 'have nots' how to live their lives!
-
Anne Campbell 5 Feb 2013Unjust and yet another attack on the most vulnerable citizens in our country.
-
Frazer Campbell 5 Feb 2013If ever there was a clearly unjust policy under occupancy is it! In many areas there are no appropriately sized houses so people are placed in houses that have too many bedrooms
- not their fault. And what about the right to a family life this policy deprives parents who no longer live with their children of their right to be a part of their lives. It's a disgrace. -
Terry Turton 5 Feb 2013How can you penalise somebody for having a property that is larger than they need when there is a shortage of 1&2 bedroom social housing
-
ALLISON WARD 5 Feb 2013Why on earth are the government putting the most vulnerable people in such a position that they could potentially get into rent arrears, with the very real possibility that they could get evicted? what then? its absolutely unimaginable that our government could even consider this let alone implement it.
-
joe 5 Feb 2013good on you govan law centre
-
sharon rankin 5 Feb 2013i live in a 3 bedroom flat with my 8 yr old daughter and my 6 yr ols disabled son , i whated for a yr and a half for a sutable property for my family , i am now been told i have to pay for my disabled son's room or mover to a 2 bed which would leave my family in a very difficult position as my son will need major open heart surgery though out his young life and it sickens me that i'll have to move again , as my son has settled well in our new home . i will be consulting a lawyer on this matter as my disabled son has the right to have his own room due to his disability.
-
Jane isles 5 Feb 2013Of course it's unfair
-
Richard Quinn 5 Feb 2013There are no one bedroom flats available for people to downsize to. This is the craziest policy yet introduced by this Government which will cost much more to implement than any money it might save.
It is also inhumane and will make many thousands homeless causing devastation up and down the country. Soon you will quite literally have to step over the homeless just to get to the shops. The only answer to this policy is Independence from Westminster, so that we can make our own country fit for humans to live in. -
joe 5 Feb 2013help
-
brian daly 5 Feb 2013disgracful piece of legislation,flies in the face of tenancy laws and tenancy agrements,
-
Graeme Young 5 Feb 2013The Scottish Parliament should be fighting tooth and claw against this reprehensible attack on the poor and vulnerable. David Cameron has twenty spare bedrooms that are bank rolled by the tax payer.
-
joe 5 Feb 2013keep up the good work mike dailly
-
Susie Arnott 5 Feb 2013Time to be different from Westminster. Let's have some social conscience here please.
-
Gordon Copland 5 Feb 2013This bedroom tax is draconian in nature and is attack on the most vulnerable in society which this government has no liking of. They cut benefits then they decide to add tax that costs more money . It is ok for these millionaires with money but don't attack the vulnerable who need these benefits or indeed evict the people fromtheir homes.Shockingly discriminatory
-
Just a Number 5 Feb 2013We need investment in one bedroom properties in the social rented sector. Holyrood are you listening????
-
George Blockley 5 Feb 2013It's always those who are the most vunerable on the poverty line of our society who suffer the most.
-
David Paterson 5 Feb 2013Crazy spiteful policy... Action needed now
-
Sandy Black 6 Feb 2013Bedroom tax is complete madness. There simply aren't enough smaller properties to fill the demand. Single people are already paying more by having to heat homes that are bigger than their needs.
-
Lisa B Kay 6 Feb 2013And yet the majority of MP's have 2nd homes and are given all sorts of tax relief. Stop unfairly hitting people who can least afford these ridiculous penalties!
-
Kitty W 6 Feb 2013How about MPs with empty second and third homes give them up to those being evicted?!
-
Carol 6 Feb 2013completely unfair to pay your rent throughout your life to be evicted as a pensioner
-
Mairi Sutherland 6 Feb 2013This will only penalise the most vulnerable in society yet again.
-
Sherry Byrd 6 Feb 2013Possibly the most regressive and harmful tax since the poll tax..this cannot be allowed to stand.
-
Anne McLaren 6 Feb 2013Unrealistic.
This claus will destroy families already struggling to stay together and will make many homeless. How will these things improve employability or increase the quantity of council houses? -
Douglas Campbell 6 Feb 2013When MP's get a home allowance because they are from outside London are they restricted to a 1 bedroom flat? Or are they just better than ordinary people?
-
JOE 6 Feb 2013MY RENT IS 84POUND A WEEK IF IM FORCED INTO A PRIVATE BEDROOM ITS 105POUND COSTING THE GOVERMENT MORE
-
donna 6 Feb 2013spread this petition in every way possible