Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Former MSP

Nick Johnston

Con Was MSP for Mid Scotland and Fife (region) 1999–2001

Distinctive phrases: state project · auditor general's · masts · general's · enterprise lifelong · grice · cost plan · cost reporting · general's report · integrated business

597 contributions · showing 1–50
  1. 10 May 2001
    Question Time
    Chamber

    What plans does the minister have to review the status of the provisionally free area so that the provisional tag may ultimately be removed? What is the likely impact of the removal of that tag on the movement of stock and animal products into the area, shoul…

  2. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    At the 1999 accountability meeting, the department was concerned about the lack of a clear strategy on Tayside. The review is still not complete. Are you satisfied that a strategy is now in place?

  3. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Mr Jones, what steps has the department taken to advise local health bodies on how reviews should be carried out and on the evidence that you expect to underpin them? Are you satisfied with the process in Tayside? What monitoring systems do you have in place?

  4. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Mr Bates, you are a fresh face in this situation and have already said that you want openness and transparency. You will be aware of the depth of feeling across Tayside on this issue. How will you develop the matter to ensure that the groups involved feel tha…

  5. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Perhaps Mr Jones can tell us when we can expect the report to emerge from the department.

  6. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    From the evidence that we have heard, we can be in no doubt that the acute services review is integral to Tayside's financial health. Exhibit 7 on page 20 of the Auditor General's report shows the progress stages for the Tayside acute services review. All the…

  7. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    And on the grades.

  8. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    I take it that you can provide the committee with the information for which I asked.

  9. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Paragraph 8.9 of the Auditor General's report says:"Staff numbers in TUHT are 250 below their April 2000 levels."Is that another example of your holding back recruitment of staff to meet financial targets, Mr White? Can you give a breakdown of where those 250…

  10. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Are you saying that Mr Waldner, who I believe was your successor, removed those controls and allowed the nurses to be hired?

  11. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Yes, but you must have had controls to have stopped nurses being hired in previous years. What were the controls and how were they removed?

  12. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Mr Brett has misunderstood the second part of my question. What controls that were available to you at Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust were removed to allow the trust to hire the 200 nurses?

  13. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    I hope that Mr Brett will forgive me for saying that his evidence leads me to believe that he has a prejudice against Perth and Kinross. The Auditor General points out that it was Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust that hired the 200 nurses. I ask Mr Brett t…

  14. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    So I think that we can assume that no disciplinary action has been taken.

  15. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Would you expect to be aware of any action that was taken?

  16. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Has any disciplinary action on those matters been taken against any of the individuals in the previous trusts?

  17. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Is that information available?

  18. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    Why was that mechanism not put in place when the realignment of the trusts took place?

  19. 2 Apr 2001
    National Health Service (Tayside)
    Audit Committee

    My question is for Mr Jones. You said at the start that relationships are changing; that the accounting officers used to answer to the management executive; and that accounting officers now report directly to the Parliament—presumably, they have done so since…

  20. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    In my eyes, the arrangements that the Parliament has put in place to scrutinise this particular project are not robust enough and I think that many would share that view. However, I sense that the committee does not wish this matter to go to the conveners gro…

  21. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    That will be for a future Audit Committee to decide.

  22. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    That would have to be the subject of a new inquiry by the Auditor General. At some stage, we could write to him to ask about value for money. It would then be up to him to decide whether his resources would allow him to conduct an inquiry and whether that wou…

  23. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    If we are writing this letter anyway, there will be no problem in asking for that information for the historical record.Conclusion 9 concerns the last paragraph on page 2 of Paul Grice's letter. It is fairly clear what we are doing. I know that Scott Barrie b…

  24. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Can you wait a minute, Margo, while the frantic search for the errant mobile phone concludes?

  25. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body had nothing to do with the original spec.

  26. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    That issue was fairly well covered in the Auditor General's report. I am not sure that we will get any more information than the Auditor General did. With respect, I think that you are asking for that information because you were not involved with the committ…

  27. 20 Mar 2001
  28. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    That is a good recommendation.

  29. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    He is the chair of the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, is he not?

  30. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Okay.The substantive point in relation to conclusion 6 came from Paul Grice, who said:"the Committee has under-estimated the financial effect of the re-design of the chamber."We could ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what its estimate of the fina…

  31. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    I think that we accept that the Auditor General exists to say that such actions have not been taken.Paul Martin and Lloyd Quinan both suggested that we might have to revisit conclusion 4.Does the committee want me to draw up a letter on conclusions 6, 9 and 1…

  32. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Members will be aware of my background in building. I would not have approached the project in this way, but we must accept that this is the way in which it has been done, and that both the Auditor General and the Audit Committee have reported on that approac…

  33. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    It has given us as grudging an acceptance as it could possibly have been expected to.Recommendation 3 refers to the evidence that the chief architect gave us. If we allow excessive figures for risk, there is no incentive for managers to try to come in on budg…

  34. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    We recommended that the accountable officers should"consider carefully their responsibilities to answer to Ministers and to the Parliament".The Executive is saying that it tried to address that point. When people look back at our report, it will be judged in …

  35. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Members' comments have been noted.I think that recommendation 1 deals with the point that Paul Martin made earlier.

  36. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    With respect, that matter is really nothing to do with what we are talking about. We will suggest that another committee is needed to examine the Holyrood project.What are we saying about the response to conclusion 11? Scott Barrie thinks that that answers th…

  37. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Sorry, what was the last bit? I missed it.

  38. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    With respect, Margo, the SPCB was not asked that question.

  39. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Our report said that we felt that the SPCB's response to the Spencely report was encouraging. We said that the progress group added an element of independent scrutiny. It is noted that there is now a settled design and cost plan in place. All that Paul Grice …

  40. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    I am not sure that the corporate body has ever reported to Parliament.I shall certainly ask Paul Grice what he bases the statement on, if we decide to write at all.

  41. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    It was not withheld from the public. It was withheld from the corporate body. That was the point; it was not reported to the corporate body.

  42. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Is there a specific question that we want to ask the Auditor General? I think that we are probably getting into areas that are more speculation than evidence-based. I am quite happy to go back to Paul Grice and ask questions based on his letter, but I am not …

  43. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    I do not know. I cannot really answer that question.

  44. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    Do you mean in the paragraph that begins"Following the Auditor General's report"?

  45. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    I am sorry, Margo: where is that in Paul Grice's letter?

  46. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    I wonder what checks and balances there are to ensure that such things are reported. That is just my individual musing. It does not really refer to the Auditor General's report.

  47. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    The project was not the Executive's responsibility.The only thing that I picked up on conclusion 8 was that"the SPCB proceeded with the project on the basis of Parliament's instructions."That brings us back to Margo MacDonald's point about what the Parliament…

  48. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    We move on to the response to conclusion 8. Do not worry: there are only 53 conclusions; there are not many more.

  49. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    If the committee wishes, we can take up that point with Paul Grice.We move on to the Executive's response to conclusion 7. The conclusion and response are a bit he-said-she-said. The Executive regrets that we do not have confidence in the former accountable o…

  50. 20 Mar 2001
    “The New Scottish Parliament Building”
    Audit Committee

    It is interesting but not particularly relevant. The Auditor General's staff will no doubt correct me if I am wrong, but I think that the report says that the redesign of the chamber happened to have significant financial effect.

Search matches debate headings only. For the words spoken, use the Official Report search filtered to this MSP.