Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

National Health Service (Tayside)

Monday 2 April 2001 Audit Committee Committee business 540 contributions · 26 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions
2 more speakers
  • Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
  • Mr Tony Wells Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust 1

The record

540 contributions · showing 201–400
Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

It may have been a small number of people, but a large amount of damage was caused. I am bothered by the fact that there were investigations and reports, yet no action was taken. Can we be assured that what happened will not happen again?

Mr Bates
link

As the new chair, I will answer. First, as I hope members will accept, I reserve my position until I examine the whole organisation and all current senior individuals. I am not in a position to comment one way or another on current or past individual employees, and I would not want to give that impression. I am looking critically at the issue, and I want to discuss it with Mr Jones and others. I assure the committee that the three chairs who will lead the new unified board are determined to establish a culture of accountability that will be part of the process of continuing the changes that have started.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I would like to hear of a similar commitment at national level, Mr Jones.

Mr Jones
link

I support everything that Mr Bates said, and suggest that it may be useful to the committee if we prepare a joint note on actions against individuals. Obviously, more investigation is required. We can come back to the committee.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

My question was on the same point and, up to a point, it has been answered by Mr Jones. However, surely the responsibility extends from here. I accept what Margaret Jamieson said. I hope that none of the individuals involved now works in the Argyll and Clyde Health Board area. Given that they are no longer in post, surely they will have requested references. Therefore, it is incumbent on us to carry out a full inquiry to make sure that references have not been given to those people, and that they are not creating mayhem elsewhere in the health service, either in this country or elsewhere. Can we have an assurance on that from Mr Jones?

Mr Bates
link

I apologise to the Audit Committee. I am not aware of any references that have been written for any individuals who were in the critical roles at the time. I associate myself with Mr Jones's comment that it would be appropriate for the two of us to come back to you with a note.However, I make the point that we are also talking about the way in which boards related to one another. That is a factor that has not been laid on the table, and it is the reason why I have emphasised that the three chairs of the acute trust, the primary trust and the new unified board have given a clear signal to the chief executives and others that we are singing from the same hymn sheet. We are not interested in people running with separate agendas. They all work for, and will be held visibly accountable to, a single NHS family. Equally, we will have to make some difficult choices. We are spending money that we do not have and we will have to explain to the public why we make the choices that we do. I certainly expect the senior managers to deliver them.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We shall return to these issues. The real nub of the issue is not past recrimination, but future progress.I will take a question from Keith Raffan, before one from the very patient Paul Martin.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Can I go one step further? You say that you will produce a joint note. That is all very well and I am sure that it will be helpful to the committee in relation to Tayside, but the important point—Mr Jones may be able to confirm that he has taken this on board—is that we need a uniform disciplinary and accountability procedure throughout Scotland, and not just in Tayside. As Mr Bates said, the situation has gone wrong here because of a few people and they should be disciplined, but that situation reflects on those who give good quality service. We want to ensure that the same thing does not happen again, and that there is accountability in every health board area.

Mr Jones
link

I agree entirely. Everything that we have said about the new accountability arrangements applies to the whole of Scotland. The arrangements have to be tighter and sharper, and they will be.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

This will be the last section before lunch. Questions will be asked by the very patient Paul Martin. We have stomped round your territory a bit, but would you like to address the problems inherited from the former trusts, and the reasons for the deficit?

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

My first question is for Mr White. In paragraph 29 of the report, the Auditor General recognises that many of the financial problems were brought about as a result of reorganisation. How many of those difficulties still have an impact on financial performance?

Mr White
link

We are still living with the consequences of some of the decisions that were taken. They have become part of the recovery plan, and it will take us time to get over the problems that we got into. To that extent, the difficulties are still present, but one could not attribute them to reorganisation per se, as that is some two years behind us now. However, we are still living with the consequences of decisions about services that were taken in the lead-up to reorganisation.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Can you be more specific? What sort of issues are you talking about?

Mr White
link

For example, there have been difficulties with the development of cancer services. I am not saying that those services are not good or that they are not needed, but the way in which those service developments would be funded was not clear at the time. Would something else not happen? Would something that was happening be halted or changed in such a way that resources would be freed up for reinvestment? Those difficult decisions were not taken. The legacy that has been left arose from a mixture of decisions that were taken and decisions that were not.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

My next question is for Mr Brett. Would you confirm for the record that you were the chief executive of Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust until December 1997?

Mr Brett
link

Yes, I was.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I refer you to paragraph 7.3 of the Auditor General's report, which says:"The Taskforce identified six examples of a lack of financial control".Do you accept that there were control weaknesses in the trust?

Mr Brett
link

Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust was about two thirds of the size of the new Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust. As Paul White indicated, during each of the four or five years when I was chief executive, we managed to achieve our financial targets. I accept that, when the new and much larger trust was created, Paul and his new team needed to review arrangements and make changes. However, at the time, I was satisfied that we had effective controls and that those controls allowed us to deliver our targets.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

That is a straight contradiction of the point made in the report. I am asking whether, during your time as chief executive—that is, before Mr White's time—there were examples of a lack of financial control. Yes or no would be an appropriate answer.

Mr Brett
link

No. There were problems with individual services, as there always are, but arrangements were made to cover those problems from other areas of the trust's activities.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Do you disagree with Mr Bates, who made the point that the Auditor General's report is fair, accurate and measured?

Mr Brett
link

No, I do not disagree with that statement.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

How can you possibly not disagree with the statement that the Auditor General's report was measured, accurate and fair in many ways, while, at the same time, you believe that you had effective financial control measures in place?

Mr Brett
link

You are going back to the time when I was responsible for the previous trust, which was more than three and a half years ago.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

So you do not disagree with the Auditor General's report.

Mr Brett
link

I do not disagree with that paragraph, because I think that it concerns a particular situation that occurred around 1998 and into 1999, which was after I left Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Can you comment on what happened during the period that followed your secondment?

Mr Brett
link

On—

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Would you comment on the period that followed your elevation to the health board?

Mr Brett
link

In what sense? Are you asking me to comment on what I perceived the previous trust's controls to be?

Mr Brett
link

I have already indicated that I was disturbed and concerned—in fact, I was annoyed—by what I discovered had been happening in Perth and Kinross. There were also pressures in Dundee and Angus during 1998-99, as we approached the establishment of the new trust. However, they were pressures that I was familiar with: pressures in renal medicine and cancer medicine. From experience, I knew that the new trust would find ways of dealing with those pressures. With hindsight, it is apparent that many factors came together and there was an accumulation of problems in all the previous trusts.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I refer you to paragraph 7.3 of the report. We are told that the outgoing Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust recruited some 200 staff in the final months of its existence, thereby contributing to more than £2 million in deficit, which was inherited by the new Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust. What do you think of the action that was taken by the former trust?

Mr Brett
link

Paul White and I will give you a joint answer. I was concerned about that action. It is my understanding that the trust had vacancies in a number of key areas during that year, for which it was unable to recruit. As Mr White has said, budget holders proceeded to fill them in the latter quarter of that year in the mistaken belief that there was funding for them. There was a serious problem in the fact that the senior management of the trust was not aware of the fact that filling those posts would exacerbate the problems that Mr White inherited the following year.

Mr White
link

There is not much that I can add to that. With hindsight, it was clear that the funds that were originally allocated for those posts were being used in other ways—the funding that was freed up by those vacancies was being used to underpin other areas of expenditure, which were not curtailed or stopped to allow the recruitment of those staff.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

We are talking about who was where in the organisation. Forgive me, but is the present director of nursing not the same individual who was in that post before reorganisation?

Mr White
link

She is, but she is not responsible for the direct management of nursing staff. She is the professional head of nursing staff, but in Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust she was not responsible for the budgetary management of nursing staff. There is no way in which she can be held to account for that.I would like to clarify, for the record, that the director of nursing who was referred to in an earlier response is not the current director of nursing. Also, the director who was referred to earlier was the director of nursing in Perth and Kinross Healthcare NHS Trust rather than Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

We have heard about Perth and Kinross Healthcare NHS Trust and Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. Can you tell us what the situation was in Angus NHS Trust, in terms of its financial management systems? Until Tim Brett spoke, I thought that everyone acknowledged that there had been a long-term culture of a lack of financial control, to the extent that people were making decisions outwith their competence. However, what Tim Brett said has confused me, and we are beginning to get mixed messages. Can you clarify what you are saying, Mr Brett? Do you accept everything that was said before you spoke, and that there was a long-term culture in Tayside of a lack of financial control? You seemed not to accept that that was the case. I am now confused about whether you accept it or not.

Mr Brett
link

No, I do not accept it. The difficulty is in determining the period that we are talking about and the period that the Auditor General has examined. In the four previous trusts, the financial targets were met. It has subsequently become apparent that, over the past year or two of their existence, a number of them—notably Perth and Kinross Healthcare NHS Trust—managed to meet their targets by using non-recurring funds. I am not saying that there were problems in all four trusts; however, when Paul White and his team came in, they rightly had to bring together three separate systems and address all the other problems of reorganisation, including people's uncertainty about what jobs they would have. There was a need to recast that situation, which they have done.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

The previous trusts could balance their books by bad budgeting practice. It strikes me that that option was inherited by the new trusts. It was therefore inherited by many of the officials who worked for the previous trusts, who were involved in the decision making that led to reorganisation. There has been significant continuity in those who make the decisions.We are talking about the present trusts and the finance and culture of the former Dundee trusts. Sir William Stewart, a former chairman of Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, became the chairman of Tayside Health Board; you were the chief executive of the former Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust and you became the chief executive of the health board; Mr Wells also came from Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. Many of the officials are the same. There was continuity of decision making at the top level, with accountable officers, and the problems that they inherited resulted from decisions that they took part in earlier. However, you are saying that you are not responsible for the situation. Can you clarify your position?

Mr Brett
link

First, I agree totally with what Mr Jones has said. If non-recurring funding is being used, that must be on the basis of an agreed longer-term plan. There is clear evidence that that was not the case in certain situations in Tayside. Sir William Stewart did not become the chairman of the health board, but the new chairmen of the trusts joined the health board—that was another change that "Designed to Care" introduced. There have been considerable changes in senior personnel in Tayside over the past three years. Three chief executives and three finance directors from the previous trusts are no longer in Tayside.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I refer you to pages 3 to 4 of the report, which underline the task force's findings:"Lack of effective financial control"and various budgeting procedures that are totally unacceptable, such as"Absence of corporate working and governance … Lack of effective communication … Overprovision of services".On page 29, we are told that the deficit was £11.1 million and that £1.7 million was given by Tayside Health Board to balance the situation that was created in Perth and Kinross Healthcare NHS Trust. Nobody can be blamed for the impact of changes in capital charges, but that still leaves about £10.9 million-worth of management decisions for which the present managers and accountable officers are responsible. Matters were inherited by many of the same people who now hold office. Who is in charge? Who is responsible?

Mr Brett
link

An answer has already been given to that question. The chief executives of the previous trusts were responsible and the new chief executives and I have been responsible over the past two years. The items that are listed on page 29 of the report were, as the Auditor General correctly states, factors that the new trusts inherited. The primary care trust also inherited some factors. Because Mr White brought in a new team, it inevitably took time for those factors to become apparent.

Mr Bates
link

This is clearly a matter of great concern to the Audit Committee, and rightly so. First, I state clearly on record that there is no question whatsoever but that there are significant lessons to be learned about past practice. Secondly, it was in 1995-96 that Tayside Health Board's auditors reported serious concerns, which led to the Kilshaw inquiry and its findings, thereby indicating—as the Auditor General has rightly said—that the problems are deep-rooted. As the newly appointed chairman of the unified health board, I do not want the Audit Committee to be in any doubt about that.I come from a local government culture that may not be considered appropriate to this debate. However, in that culture, if virement is used to transfer unspent money under one heading to another, it has to be done openly and transparently and those who are responsible are scrutinised and held to account. I want to explain clearly to Ms Robison that, without doubt, the Auditor General's report is fair, measured and accurate. We have many lessons to learn from past practice.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

A number of members want to come in at this point. With their permission, I have one further question for Mr Brett. I refer him to the heading on page 29 of the Auditor General's report: "Under achievement of cash releasing efficiency savings." Mr Brett was partly responsible for that underachievement. He asked for cash-saving measures to save £3 million, but a saving of only £2 million was produced, so £1 million was added to the deficit. He seems to be saying that that is not his problem. I would like to hear some responsibility being taken for those decisions. Many of the same people who were part of that decision-making process have continued in post.Clearly, problems were built into the system. One problem, which comes straight back to Mr Brett, was the unrealistic setting of cash-releasing efficiency saving targets that added £1 million to a deficit. Did you take part in that decision-making process, Mr Brett?

Mr Brett
link

Yes. At the end of 1998, we became aware of the scale and size of the problem that existed in Perth. In conjunction with the former trust and the new trust's officers, we prepared a financial recovery plan, which has been referred to. The plan was agreed jointly by the three chief executives at the end of March in that year, which was the beginning of the new financial year. The board made arrangements to fund both trusts for the recurring problem that existed in Perth and Kinross. However, that left a significant efficiency saving target for both trusts to achieve. That was the basis of a decision that it was not unusual to make at that time in the NHS. It is something that we have asked both trusts to undertake again this year. The weakness and the problem that I would put my hand up to is that, at that point, our measures were not as effective as they should have been in holding the trust to account for the achievement of that target. Last year and this year, we are much more precise and clear about where savings will come from and we check jointly that they are achieved.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I hope that Mr Brett will forgive me for saying that his evidence leads me to believe that he has a prejudice against Perth and Kinross. The Auditor General points out that it was Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust that hired the 200 nurses. I ask Mr Brett to confirm two things. First, if you had still been chief executive, would you have hired those nurses? Secondly, what controls that you had in place were relaxed to allow the trust to hire those nurses?

Mr Brett
link

First, I will answer Mr Johnston's second point. At that time, the health board did not have any direct managerial responsibility for ensuring that the trusts achieved their financial targets. We received no information on detailed staffing issues in the way that he has described. The health board therefore had no knowledge that that was taking place. In the hypothetical situation that I had been in the trust then, I hope that I would have been aware that holding off on those vacancies would contribute to meeting our financial targets in that year. I would have stepped in, either to stop the posts being filled or at least to have agreed with my colleagues ways for funds to be provided to achieve that.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Brett has misunderstood the second part of my question. What controls that were available to you at Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust were removed to allow the trust to hire the 200 nurses?

Mr Brett
link

I am not trying to be difficult, as I was not there at the time. There was a gap of 15 months—

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yes, but you must have had controls to have stopped nurses being hired in previous years. What were the controls and how were they removed?

Mr Brett
link

The controls were that each of the group directorates that we had in place at that time had a staffing budget and received regular reporting information. The human resources department would not have been allowed to process the filling of posts unless it was clear that funding was available for them.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Are you saying that Mr Waldner, who I believe was your successor, removed those controls and allowed the nurses to be hired?

Mr Brett
link

I cannot answer that question, as I do not know whether that is the case. However, if I go back to an answer that I gave previously, it is my understanding that, in a number of cases, directorates were unable to recruit. They were then able to do so in the latter part of the year, when they believed that they had funds to cover those posts.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Mr Brett, I was intrigued that, when you were asked where the source of the problem was, you chose to highlight the hiring of nurses in Perth and Kinross at a cost of £300,000. I presume that that is the cost of between 15 and 20 nurses. Why did you highlight that figure rather than the 200 nurses and other staff who were hired without any authority in Dundee?

Mr Brett
link

I chose that example because I was aware that, as Mr White indicated, there was a disagreement between the then director of planning at the health board—for which I had responsibility at that time—and the director of nursing in the trust.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Does that mean that there was no disagreement about the additional staff that were employed in Dundee?

Mr Brett
link

The health board was not asked about that and was not involved in that decision.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

My next question is not solely for Mr Brett. Will you give me an idea of whether the University of Dundee was involved in some of the decisions that were made. I note that one of the areas where there was unfunded growth was in cancer services. The University of Dundee has excellent facilities for undertaking research in that area. Was the relationship between the university and the various health bodies in any way involved in causing those additional cost pressures?

Mr Brett
link

I will begin to answer that question although I suspect that Mr White, too, might like to comment. There is a close relationship between the University of Dundee medical school and the NHS. That needs to be so, as many of the staff work jointly for the two bodies. There is a great deal of collaborative work between them. The Ninewells hospital site is a quarter owned by the University of Dundee and there are some shared services on that site. It is vital that good joint planning arrangements are in place to deal with the sort of issue that Mr Adam has highlighted. Some years ago, discussions took place between the university, which—as members know—has excellent cancer research laboratory and scientific facilities, and the trust about the need to develop clinical cancer services. When I was at the trust, Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, the University of Dundee and the health board agreed on the appointment of additional professorial posts. The difficulties occurred when the individuals who were appointed disagreed about the pace of development of clinical services.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Perhaps we can now hear from the Scottish Executive health department as to whether the creation of additional professorial posts, not only in Dundee but elsewhere in Scotland, has led to unfunded growth in services.

Mr Jones
link

It is fair to say that there are additional financial pressures in any of the teaching board areas due to the type of research and development work that goes on there. That is not a reason for not having strong financial plans for the introduction of new services. It should probably encourage teaching board areas to have stronger plans to manage the introduction of new developments in their areas. It is not acceptable to allow new developments to grow in an area without that growth being planned and funded properly.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Will Mr Bates comment on the relationship between all the heath bodies and the University of Dundee? How will that be managed in future, particularly given the likely developments and pressures for developments?

Mr Bates
link

I will comment with some hesitation and apprehension because I am not as knowledgeable as I would like to be to answer that question properly. It is proper to preface my answer with that note of caution. I have had fruitful discussions with the university. I have also had important discussions with some of our neighbouring health partners, because that is an important part of looking to the future.We want to retain our standards of excellence and cutting-edge research in Tayside, but as Mr Jones says, that must be married to the reality of the financial envelope in which we live. We can do that through close dialogue with the key players in the university and our neighbouring health authorities. I assure the committee that Professor McGoldrick and I have embarked on those discussions. However, as Mr Jones says, accountability rests in ensuring that expenditure that cannot be properly identified is not committed to funding developments.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

Where there is a centre of not only national, but international excellence—as there is for oncology in Dundee—does the department not have a duty to allow the consequential clinical and service developments to be recognised and funded nationally, rather than merely as part of the envelope of finance that is available to Tayside?

Mr Jones
link

The additional cost of research and development is funded separately. It is not necessarily equitable for services in teaching board areas to develop faster or to a higher level than those for the Scottish population generally. The cost of the service content, rather than the research content, must be assessed against all the priorities. It would be wrong for teaching hospital services to develop faster than mental health services, for example, or for services in Edinburgh to develop faster than services in Fife, simply because Edinburgh has a medical school.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

It is difficult to separate the research and development function from the service function. If you are to continue to develop research and development, there will be consequential effects on services.

Mr Jones
link

We must address that issue when we think about specialist services, which tend to radiate out of the teaching centres. In the health plan, we have said that we will address how we fund specialist services around Scotland as part of the new finance regime. As Peter Bates said, it is critical to get all the partners and all the health boards that could use specialist services to agree on how the services should be funded in a planned way. That is part of the new finance regime that will be introduced for the next financial year.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Before I pass to Lloyd Quinan, I should say that two trends disturb me. While budgeted services were cut, unbudgeted services increased. Mr Brett said that Tayside Health Board did not receive information from the trusts. Can we be assured that such management practice will not continue?

Mr Bates
link

On your second point, I can tell you categorically that there is now a group that brings together the three chief executives and their directors of finance to monitor spend against budget from month to month, and a group that brings together the three chairs and the chief executives and which has recently commenced meeting every fortnight. Financial performance will be critical to that budget, and it will have a high profile.

Mr Jones
link

From the department's perspective, five clear points emerge from this morning's discussion. The first is the need to show that we have strong and effective financial management across a health board area. Secondly, as Peter Bates said, we need to get all chairmen and chief executives to manage the total health resource in that area and achieve the best mix of services from the resources that are available.Thirdly, we must have sustainable financial plans to demonstrate that health strategies are affordable in an area—I mean annual rather than long-term plans. Fourthly, we require an accountability and performance management system that allows us to demonstrate that what I have described is happening. Finally, the health department must have a stronger performance management function. I am working on all five points as part of our plans to put the new health boards in place by 30 September.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

One of Mr Jones's answers slightly concerns me. It is inevitable that there will need to be more service development in the teaching hospitals than elsewhere. You mentioned Fife. In the region that I represent, there are three health board areas, two of which do not have teaching hospitals. As a result, Fife looks towards Ninewells and Tayside. When specialist services are being developed in one place, it is important that all other areas have access to those services instead of there being an equal division of funding between a health board without a teaching hospital and one that does, such as Tayside.

Mr Jones
link

I did not say that teaching hospitals should cost the same as standard district general hospitals. My point was that we cannot have unplanned developments radiating out of teaching hospitals; we cannot disadvantage populations that are served by district general hospitals in favour of populations that are served by teaching hospitals. We require a planning mechanism that allows health boards to sign up for a national or regional strategy for specialist services.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am grateful for that clarification. However, the crucial point is that the teaching hospitals serve not just their areas but other areas. Ninewells hospital is important for Fife.

Mr White
link

I want to add a supplementary comment to the discussion between Mr Jones and Mr Raffan. It is right that Ninewells provides largely DGH-type services to north-east Fife, but the area also avails of tertiary services. The relations between Tayside and Fife—and particularly between our trusts and Fife—have developed very well over the past year to 18 months. For example, clinical networks have been developed, most notably in ear, nose and throat services. Clinicians from Tayside provide services in Victoria hospital in Kirkcaldy and likewise ENT surgeons from that hospital take sessions at Ninewells; they have a truly joint service with joint appointments of consultant posts. In that way, a non-teaching health board such as Fife can have very close and good access to specialist skills. Those services do not have to be delivered at Ninewells but can be delivered on an outreach basis.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

We have heard that in the final quarter of 1998-99 Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust recruited 200 nurses and other staff at a cost of £2.1 million without having enough money to do so. In February 1999—in that very same quarter—Tayside Health Board submitted a financial framework to the management executive, suggesting that there were no financial problems. That framework was drawn up with the co-operation of the outgoing and incoming trusts, which means that everyone must have met to discuss it. Are you saying that no one at any of those meetings mentioned the recruitment policy in Dundee and Perth and Kinross or the use of non-recurring moneys and unfunded developments? When all those trusts met to discuss their financial position, did no one mention what was happening then in Tayside?

Mr Brett
link

I will quickly run through what happened. As is normal practice, the director of finance contacted his colleagues in the four trusts in November of the previous year and invited them to enter into the preparation of the following year's budgets. As part of that process, they were all asked to identify cost pressures and other areas of financial concern. We were very much aware of the issues in Perth and Kinross, but we were also aware that there were issues in Dundee and in Angus. Those issues were pulled together. My memory is that we were aware of the Perth and Kinross staffing issue, because that had happened the previous year. I do not recall being aware of the Dundee situation, but the finance director of the trust had every opportunity to put whatever he wanted on the table so that we were aware of it.

Mr Brett
link

Yes.

Mr Brett
link

Yes. There is a record of the meetings and there is also the financial plan that was submitted.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

If those records are available, they should have been made available to the Audit Committee. If major problems such as this are occurring in the health service, it is quite significant that all the managers from all the trusts should come together to discuss the next year's budget without mentioning some of the most serious problems facing the health service in Tayside.

Mr Brett
link

I do not recall what happened, but it would be fairly easy to go back and check whether that was the case.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Can you make those minutes available to the committee?

Mr Brett
link

Yes.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Mr Brett has brought Angus into the equation by saying that there were problems there, but we have not heard any evidence this morning about those problems. Can you tell us about them?

Mr Brett
link

The problems in Angus were not on the same scale as the problems in Perth and Kinross and in Dundee. My understanding is that the Angus problems related more to the loss of the income that the trust had received from Grampian Health Board for the use of certain long-stay beds, particularly at Sunnyside royal hospital, now that Grampian Health Board was making less use of them.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Do you have a figure for the problems to which you refer?

Mr Brett
link

I will give you a figure in a moment, as I think that I have that information with me.

Mr White
link

The figure for the Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust aspect of that was about £500,000.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

I have another question for Mr Brett. Did Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, of which you were chief executive until December 1997, ever take out large loans that now have to be repaid?

Mr Brett
link

No—not in that sense. Because of the new developments, particularly the transfer of services from Dundee royal infirmary to Ninewells hospital, the capital stock at Ninewells has increased. More recently, in the past 18 months, the capital charges that the trust pays have increased, particularly in relation to the new build at King's Cross hospital.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

Would you expand on that a little? What impact did that have, and is that still having, on the financial situation in Tayside?

Mr Brett
link

I am not sure that I can give you the detailed figures. From memory, the new building cost £20 million to £25 million. As the Auditor General's report says, the NHS has to pay interest on those new developments. There is an element of interest and an element of depreciation. That is laid down as part of the financial regime. Those charges ensure that buildings and equipment are used fully and properly. The capital stock in Tayside is worth some £300 million, nearly two thirds of which is in Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust and just over a third of which is in Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust. Both trusts, like all other trusts in Scotland, pay capital charges on those amounts.

Mr White
link

In Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust, capital charges, covering the buildings and equipment that we use to provide services, account for about £22 million a year.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

Are all those figures and that procedure clearly known about by auditors and everyone involved in making up plans for the future?

Mr Brett
link

Absolutely. Those figures would have been taken into account as part of the development and agreement of the new capital developments that are taking place. They would be a key part of the financial plan for any such development.

Mr White
link

I would like to clarify that a revaluation of the estate in Tayside took effect from 1 April 1999. The revaluation figures were not known until they were confirmed in June or July 1999. As is indicated on page 28 of the Auditor General's report, additional capital charges were made because of the increased value that the estate was deemed to have.

Kate Maclean Lab Dundee West
link

I have a question for Tim Brett. Like the answers that have been given to some other questions, Tim Brett's answer to Paul Martin's second question is puzzling.Tim Brett said that he was chief executive of Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust until December 1997. Are you confident that there were no control weaknesses in financial management prior to December 1997 that contributed in any way to the current financial difficulties of the health services in Tayside?

Mr Brett
link

I am confident because each year our external auditor commented on those issues. Each year, there were pressures and problems, some of which came through into the problems that we have discussed this morning.

Kate Maclean Lab Dundee West
link

Balancing the books is one thing, but financial mismanagement is another. Were there no practices that I would classify as financial mismanagement in Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, such as the use of capital receipts to prop up revenue expenditure? Were there no such financial practices that contributed to the current financial difficulties?

Mr Brett
link

In 1998-99, after I had left the trust, Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust sought—and, I believe obtained—approval to use non-recurring funds to help with the bridging costs of moving from Dundee royal infirmary to Ninewells.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I am becoming confused. You indicate that you were totally satisfied with the procedures that were in place when you moved from the trust to Tayside Health Board and that everybody had clear accounts signed off by the auditors. However, we have heard that the audit reports were not robust and did not tell us the true extent of what was happening. How does that tally with the statement that you have made to Kate MacLean?

Mr Brett
link

The previous comment was in respect of the Kilshaw report's findings, which were highlighted by the Auditor General. Following that, as Mr Jones has said, the interim chief executive and then I took strenuous efforts to revamp, revise and update the health board's corporate governance arrangements. Those arrangements were commented on by external auditors. Those reports are available and indicate that significant progress was made by the board in addressing those issues.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Paragraph 8.9 of the Auditor General's report says:"Staff numbers in TUHT are 250 below their April 2000 levels."Is that another example of your holding back recruitment of staff to meet financial targets, Mr White? Can you give a breakdown of where those 250 staff are—Angus, Perth and Kinross or Dundee—and what grades and posts they are? I do not expect a breakdown now.

Mr White
link

I can give you a breakdown, but not at the moment. We have adopted a different process, which was referred to earlier in respect of Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust. Rather than simply holding posts vacant and using that funding to support other areas of expenditure, we have made fundamental changes to service delivery patterns so that staff who were employed to deliver services in the way in which those services were originally configured are now no longer required. There has been a change in how wards are configured and services are designed that allows us to continue to provide those services safely, to appropriate quality standards and to the right volumes, but to do so more efficiently. The staff reductions have come about through sustainable changes in how we organise services.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I take it that you can provide the committee with the information for which I asked.

Mr White
link

On where the posts are?

Mr White
link

Yes.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Paul Martin wishes to speak, but the Auditor General would like to intervene at this point, so I call Mr Black, to be followed by Paul Martin.

Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland
link

A number of comments have been offered in the course of the last couple of hours about the proper role of audit and about the extent to which audit engaged in the various issues that have been mentioned. To assist the committee, I will quickly run through the three issues that have been raised in the course of the morning. Early on, reference was made to qualified or unqualified accounts. The issue of the certificate on the accounts and the signing of that certificate is simply a matter of looking at the numbers on the face of the accounts against accounting and auditing standards. It is simply a question of saying that the numbers are properly presented. In a sense, it would be inappropriate to conclude that a clean certificate by itself means that all is well in a body that has been audited. That is why the code of audit practice, under which all auditors whom I appoint must operate, goes much wider than simply providing a certificate on the accounts, and provides a report to local management on governance, financial stewardship and issues concerning performance, so far as that is appropriate. The second issue is the role of audit in relation to governance. The committee has been informed this morning—quite rightly—that the auditor appointed in the case of Tayside Health Board started expressing concerns at a very early stage. Those concerns were drawn to the attention of the department—or the management executive, as it then was—as they emerged. In later years, the auditor commented favourably on the improvements that were taking place in the governance arrangements of the health board, and also said that further work needed to be done. In other words, it was a matter of work in progress rather than a problem solved. The third point on which I wish to advise the committee relates to the auditor's responsibility to identify something as fundamental as the use of non-recurring funding. I emphasise that it is not the role of audit to take over the role of management. Mr Jones said that it might occasionally be appropriate to use non-recurring funding if management were confident that it had a long-term, sustainable solution. That means that non-recurring funding is probably being used to smooth over a short-term period of inadequate financial resources to reach a stable state. That is entirely appropriate. It is not the role of auditors to look forward and second-guess management on the policy issue of where managers will find the required resources. In my previous role as Controller of Audit, I produced an overview of the health service in Scotland each year. In my overview report on the 1997-98 accounts, I referred in one paragraph to concern voiced by a number of auditors that the 1998-99 financial targets could be difficult to meet in a number of bodies because of the use of non-recurring funding in 1997-98. We provided an early indication to NHS management that that issue should be examined. I repeat, however, that it is not the role of the auditor to pass a judgment on that; we simply provided an indication to the health service that we thought that there was an issue in that regard. I think that that was right and proper.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

And it is the role of managers to manage. Paul Martin is signalling to me that his points have now been covered, and there appear to be no further questions. We have had a fair session. Lunch time now approaches, so we can all rest a little. I advise members of the public who are intending to come back for the afternoon part of the meeting that they must retain their tickets. Anyone not intending to return should hand over their ticket to the main reception desk, which will allow others to take their places. That also applies to the public in the overspill room. Members of the public will be allowed back into the building from 1.45 pm, for a 2 pm start. I thank everybody who has participated so far.

Meeting adjourned.

On resuming—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I reconvene the meeting. I remind everybody to turn off all mobile phones and pagers—the bane of modern existence.This afternoon, we will consider the elimination of the deficit, the acute services review and the unit cost of health care in Tayside, as well as leadership, governance and communication in Tayside health bodies. I ask members of the committee to stick to that programme as tightly as possible.I call on Lloyd Quinan to start us off this afternoon and to examine whether there is a clear picture of how and when financial balance will be achieved and financial deficits eliminated in Tayside health bodies.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I refer Mr White to paragraph 8.6 of the Auditor General's report, which makes it clear that the results of the acute services review are an essential component of achieving financial balance and eliminating the trust's financial deficit. Can you explain how you expect the review's results to impact on the trust's financial performance?

Mr White
link

In Tayside, there is a patently unaffordable configuration of services and level of service provision. That has been demonstrated clearly by the excess costs that have been incurred over the past two years. The acute services review takes place against that background. The brief that has been set for that review by the health board is to produce a set of clinically sustainable and financially affordable options.The acute services review reported to the health board at the end of last year. The health board is leading a process to prepare a consultation document, which will go out to public consultation in May for the statutory period. Following that, the health board will make decisions in conjunction with the trusts about which range of options can be recommended to the Minister for Health and Community Care for implementation.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I accept that, but I asked what you expect the impact of the review to be on the trust's financial performance.

Mr White
link

I believe that out of the review will come a series of recommendations for significant change in clinical services, which will allow Tayside health bodies collectively to reprofile the way in which services are set across Tayside. Looking round the country, I would cite Lothian Health as being some way ahead of many other health boards in Scotland in having reviewed its acute services. Lothian Health is considering a different blend of services between the acute trust, the university hospitals trust and the primary care trust and, of course, the significant change that will come with the new royal infirmary. That is an example of the type of major service change of which Tayside is just on the threshold.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I understand that. I refer you to the last sentence of paragraph 8.6 of the Auditor General's report, which says:"Until the findings of the Review are finalised and the impact of any changes to the delivery of acute health care is quantified, it will not be clear when TUHT will be able to eliminate its accumulated financial deficit."Do you have any comments on that sentence?

Mr White
link

One of the features of Tayside is the extent to which services are duplicated or triplicated. In today's world of medicine, and with the population base in Tayside, there is not a case for that duplication and triplication of services. That issue has been addressed in the acute services review and has, understandably, raised much concern among the public. There has been much public reaction to the issues that have been discussed in different forums in the past 18 months. I find it difficult to think of any other health area in Scotland that provides for a similar population to Tayside and has the extent of duplication and, in some cases, triplication of services that exists in Tayside.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Has that duplication or triplication contributed heavily to the deficit situation you find yourselves in?

Mr White
link

It is a significant factor. The way in which services are configured makes them more expensive to run.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

That suggests that, in effect, the health board's policy is being controlled or dictated by the financial deficit. Is that correct?

Mr White
link

I can understand why that perception exists, but Tayside has a responsibility, which we take seriously, to get back into financial balance. We need to find a way of configuring the services that we provide in Tayside—in terms of geography and quantity—that will fit within the funding that we have. That is different from saying that cost is driving the service. It is perhaps a moot point. The review, which I am sure we will come to, was heavily populated by clinical staff from Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust and Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust. All the sub-committees were jointly chaired by a GP and a consultant. To that extent, the options that have been derived are heavily clinically led.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

So how do you expect the results of the acute services review to impact on the trust's financial performance?

Mr White
link

They will help us to get back into balance. For full implementation of the acute services review, in terms of the development proposals that are contained within it—for example, a new-style hospital in Angus—we will need to have a balanced financial position. That will enable us to progress to that new way of delivering health care for the population base.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Thank you.My next question is for Mr Jones. Paragraph 7.14 of the Auditor General's report tells us that, as a result of comments made by the task force about the monitoring arrangements, you advised the Minister for Health and Community Care that your department would take a greater role in performance-managing the Tayside situation. What form has that greater role taken? More important, especially for the public, what benefits have been achieved by that intervention?

Mr Jones
link

We stood down the task force around Christmas. Since then, I have been meeting the chief executives in Tayside regularly to review progress in addressing the deficit and implementing the recovery plan. Before that, the first phase of the recovery plan was successfully implemented, with more than £6 million being saved in the first year of recovery. There are now plans for a further £6 million to be recovered in the current financial year—2001-02. We have much closer involvement in that recovery plan.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

How will the acute services review impact on the trust's financial performance?

Mr Jones
link

What is important is that the NHS in Tayside's plans for all its services are within the resources that are available to it. We need to consider all service provision and the best distribution of the total pot against the whole of Tayside's service provision. There must be debate around the amount to be spent on primary care and consideration of the impact that investing in primary care will have on the need for acute services.Paul White mentioned Lothian Health's acute services strategy. Its plan was to invest heavily in primary and community services, which would reduce the need for hospital-based services; the service that would be achieved would be more accessible to the general public and not based on the institutions as much as would be the case under traditional plans. That would allow reconfiguration of the acute services.I want consideration of the integrated service rather than a specific examination of acute services in isolation.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

My final question is for Mr Brett.Paragraphs 8.7 and 8.8 of the Auditor General's report start with the fairly encouraging news that the trusts are on target to achieve planned savings in 2000-01, but go on to highlight emerging difficulties. Can you explain what those difficulties are and, more important, how you intend to deal with that emerging situation?

Mr Brett
link

Yes. My understanding is that the committee—following its meeting in Glasgow with senior managers—will be familiar with the situation. During the past 12 months, several additional external pressures have come to light, which have changed the situation that we faced last summer. Some of those pressures are listed in paragraph 8.8. The additional cost of junior doctors' hours is likely to amount, in this year alone, to an extra £2.5 million in Tayside. That figure will double over the next couple of years if we cannot rearrange rotas. Another pressure is the European working time directive. Such external pressures amount to about an additional £7 million.This year, we—the three of us, with our finance directors—took the target figure that we had agreed and through our joint management forum, which I suspect we will discuss later, developed a plan for next year. The health board signed off that plan at its March meeting. The plan involves both trusts in producing detailed proposals for cost savings, which went to the respective boards or committees last week and will come back to the board in two weeks' time, so there is a further round of detailed efficiencies. We have already given thought to how we will tackle the final year in 12 months' time.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

You must have been aware of the European working time directive, yet you suggested that it was an unforeseen circumstance. Would not it have been possible to plan for the directive?

Mr Brett
link

Both trusts advised us what the cost would be, but the directive is one of the matters that this year's settlement must cover. That was one of the givens that we—along with all other health systems in Scotland—received. We have taken it into account, but—to return to Mr White's point—that is made more difficult by the number of sites that we have. For example, it is necessary to provide on-call teams, so the more sites that are covered, the more the problem is exacerbated.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

But you were aware that the European working time directive was coming into force?

Mr Brett
link

Yes.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Barring, or rather excluding, your ability to close down those sites and sack staff, you must have been able to project, on the correct numbers, what the cost of the working time directive would be to the trust.

Mr Brett
link

Yes. We have done that. The cost has been factored into this year's financial plan. All health systems in Scotland are facing that issue.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You mentioned two significant pressures—the European working time regulations and junior hospital doctors' pay—but there are others. There are clinical pressures, for example the hepatitis C epidemic that Scotland faces and the cost of combination therapy treatment, which is £7,000 to £9,000 per person. I ask about that to seek an assurance—as far as you can give one—that there will be no treatment rationing to meet the stringent financial saving plans.

Mr Brett
link

Last year, we reached agreement to develop an approach for the introduction of new treatments and therapies based on advice that we would be given by the area drugs and therapeutics committee. The hepatitis C issue is current and will need to come back to the board through the joint management forum. The costs of treatment for hepatitis C are considerable, as I am sure you know, and we will need to decide what priority we give to that. Some treatment has been provided in the past, but if we are to provide new treatment, we will need to establish where the funds will come from rather than, as might have happened previously, just going ahead and providing the treatment.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

We talk about efficiency savings, but the real issue is defining them. We have had so many efficiency savings, over the years, that they are no longer savings in administration, but clinical savings.

Mr Brett
link

Yes. I shall elaborate on what Mr White has said and Mr Wells may want to comment. There are many different ways in which services can be delivered. You will be familiar with the way in which many treatments can be administered on a day-case basis, for example. There is still much scope for that. One of the other issues that we face in Tayside is delayed discharge. We have 270 patients in Tayside hospitals whose clinical condition means that they do not need to be there. That is a major problem for us to work on with our colleagues in the local authorities. If we could make a significant impact on that, that would go a long way in alleviating the financial pressures on both trusts.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I accept your point about the over-provision of services. As a regional member, I would be concerned if, to meet financial targets, we went in the opposite direction and there was under-provision compared with other health board areas.

Mr Brett
link

Clearly, we would not wish that either. Through our joint forum and the new, unified health board, everybody should see the whole picture—be it of primary or secondary care or whatever. Those are not easy decisions to make.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

On the acute services review, Mr White said that there must be financial balance to achieve new health plans and health provision in Angus. Given that there has been no financial balance for some years, and no real guarantee that we are even close to that, and given that today we have heard of further reductions in services at Stracathro hospital in Angus, is it possible that, purely because of continuing funding difficulties, Angus will have little or no acute provision even before the outcome of the acute services review?

Mr Brett
link

Huge amounts of acute provision are delivered in Angus and will continue to be delivered there. For many years, a comprehensive range of clinicians and specialists has been based either locally or at Ninewells hospital and there is no suggestion that that will change. It is proposed that there will be a new hospital that will concentrate on rapid diagnosis and straightforward treatments that can be administered on what is called a day-and-stay basis.A couple of options will come out of the acute services review, concerning whether the services will be concentrated in one centre or dispersed throughout the existing community hospital network. That is the choice. We cannot afford to continue with the present pattern of services.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

Is it not the case that, according to the figures that we have, we cannot afford the new proposal either? Given that reductions are taking place in the provision of services in Angus, will not the people of Angus, in the short to medium term, be left with a reduction in what was available previously and no prospect of new, improved, long-term provision? No one here can say when the deficit will be eliminated and when the financial balance will be sufficient to allow investment of £20 million in any new provision in Angus. In the short to medium term, will not the people of Angus be left with little or nothing—or at least with a reduction, not an improvement, in services?

Mr Brett
link

First, what appeared in the local press this morning is an issue that is not driven by finance. It has been raised with us by senior physicians who are expressing concern over the continuing safety of the health service in Angus. The board will consider that issue in two weeks' time, but it is not being driven by finance. Over the past two or three years, we have done our best to try to sustain the Angus service until the acute services review has been completed. The advice that we have received, over the past few weeks, is that clinical staff are worried about the situation and believe that, on the grounds of safety and best modern practice, acute emergency patients in Angus would be best looked after at Ninewells hospital.Secondly, the future provision of services in Angus is dependent on our getting back into balance. We have plans to do that over the next two years. We also have an understanding that, subject to public consultation, capital funds will be provided for a new hospital in Angus. I would like that to be provided within five years. I hope that we can proceed quickly with the detailed planning of that in conjunction with both trusts. The siting of that facility would be a matter for discussion with the people of Angus.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We are straying well away from the issue.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Let us return to the emergency situation that is described in paragraph 8.8 of the report. You mentioned that health bodies in Tayside have identified an additional £19.2 million and additional commitments of £9.7 million, which gives a total of £28.9 million of new expenditure. Is that unfunded at the moment?

Mr Brett
link

The £18 million to £19 million in additional funds that the board has received this year will go a long way to meeting that.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

You have received £18.7 million, but you have identified £28.9 million in potential expenditure. That leaves a deficit of £10.2 million. It seems as though a new deficit is emerging.

Mr Brett
link

That is being addressed in the detailed plans that we have agreed with both trusts for efficiency savings in the current year.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

So, the gap of £10.2 million will be met by more local cuts?

Mr Brett
link

It will be met by more efficiencies, yes.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Is that in addition to the cuts that are described in paragraph 8.3 of the report? Efficiency savings were set at £6.8 million last year, £10.8 million this year and £14.8 million next year. Are the cuts that you mention additional to those figures?

Mr Brett
link

Yes, they are additional to those figures. Some of the savings that were made last year will roll over and contribute to this year's figure.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

So, in total, what kind of cuts are we talking about in Tayside over the next three years?

Mr Brett
link

I invite Mr White and Mr Wells to provide some details of our current proposals.

Mr White
link

I shall indicate some of the additional cost pressures. The fuel tax levy will add about £750,000 to costs within Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust in this financial year. There are other issues such as junior doctors' hours and the intensity payments for consultants, which have been mentioned. There are additional costs of around £350,000 in the current year for maintaining maternity services at Perth. Pressures are also identified in a range of clinical services because of the increase in patient numbers—I do not mean new services being developed but, for example, new patients being identified who would benefit from renal dialysis. As those patients begin treatment programmes, there is a cost pressure in renal services of around £400,000 in the coming year. Those are all recurring costs.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

I am trying to get a handle on the kind of figure that we are talking about regarding cuts in the health service locally in Tayside over the next three years. Those figures are greater than the figures that are presented in paragraph 8.3 of the report.

Mr White
link

The figures in paragraph 8.3 are about addressing the inherited deficit. In addition, like every trust in the country, we are facing other cost pressures that arise year on year.There are two ways in which the NHS, in Scotland and in the UK, deals with such cost pressures. The first is through additional funding—Mr Jones made reference to the 5.5 per cent uplift that Tayside received in the current financial year. In addition, every health care system is expected to change the way in which it provides services and to make those services more efficient year on year, in order to release resources for meeting some of those other cost pressures.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

If you add up the figures in paragraph 8.3, they come to more than £30 million of cuts. If you then add the deficit of about £10 million that is outlined in paragraph 8.8, we are talking about £40 million being cut from the health service locally. Is that what we are talking about?

Mr White
link

No, I do not think that the figures are as dramatic as that.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

In that case, can you explain the figures to me? That is the figure that I get by adding up all the figures in the report.

Mr White
link

We touched on the inherited deficit, which is the extent to which the trusts in Tayside are spending over their allocation. The other cost pressures, some of which are identified in paragraph 8.8, are in-year cost pressures that are common throughout the health service. Clinical staff flag up some of those cost pressures. For example, they might say that a new drug is coming or that a new type of treatment is available or has been approved for use. Each local health care system must then make a choice about how it prioritises those treatments.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Can you tell me what efficiency savings you will be trying to achieve over the next three years across the health service in Tayside? How much is involved?

Mr White
link

I can speak only for the Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust. Between now and achieving financial balance in two years' time, we are probably looking to try to reduce costs by, or make efficiency savings of, about £14 million to £16 million.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

But you will need to go beyond that amount.

Mr White
link

I am sorry—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

You will have to go beyond £14 million to £16 million, as there will be other burdens.

Mr White
link

In part, the total is dependent on the financial settlement for the health service in the financial year 2002-03, which is not yet clear. For example, it depends on the amount of new money that comes into the health care system and on which there will be cost pressures—some of which have yet to be identified—in 2002-03. We must find ways of managing those cost pressures to stay within our overall resource.

Mr Brett
link

I want to try to clarify the figures in paragraph 8.3 for Mr McAllion. The savings figure of £6.8 million rises to £10.8 million, which rises to £14.8 million. That is not an accumulator—you should not add the figures together. The figures are for savings of an additional £4 million and then another £4 million.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

I am just trying to get at the global figure; it would be helpful if someone could give me that figure.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I hear words such as reconfiguration and readjustments, but the reality is that there is a deficit, plus another accumulated deficit to take care of, plus the massive new burdens that the trust is facing. In response to that, we are hearing proposals for cost savings and efficiencies. How efficient will your organisation have to become to cope with all those proposals? Does not it mean that there will be cutbacks and closures of services, rather than efficiencies? I would like to get at what the witnesses mean when they use those words.

Mr White
link

In a descending hierarchy, the approach that we have adopted is to consider the efficiency of the service at one level, effectiveness, duplication and volume of services before we get anywhere near the quality of care. We are looking to preserve safety and quality of care. It is a truism that applies to any part of the health service: the more expensive the systems for delivering health care, the less actual health care can be delivered via those systems. We are trying to make our systems as efficient as possible, so that the maximum amount of funding goes into direct patient care.

Mr Bates
link

I will try to give a straightforward explanation. It is absolutely right to say that there are three parts to the process. First, over a period of three years, the NHS in Tayside is expected to get its budget into balance. There was a plan in place to achieve a target figure in year 1, and that figure was achieved. Plans are in place to achieve year 2 targets, and year 3 will involve further savings to balance the budget. Convener, you are absolutely right. To be clear, for the record, the discussions that we are having with our colleagues in the health department are extremely supportive and helpful. It is important to convey that point. I am having, as are my colleague chairs, many discussions with Mr Jones and other colleagues about managing years 2 and 3.The second point is, assuming at the end of year 3 or thereabouts that the budget is back in balance, you are right that sitting in the books will be an accumulated deficit. The Auditor General has referred to that. My priority, which is the right priority, is to balance the budget. We will then have to face, after another two years, further discussion with our colleagues in the health department about the accumulated deficit.The third point is service redesign. It is important to get that on the record. I appreciate the concerns that members have raised, but simply because things have always been done in one particular way does not mean that they can or should continue to be done in that way for ever. Huge changes are taking place in the health service in the development of expertise. While I must be extremely sensitive to public concern, and will be, at the end of the day, we cannot continue to do everything that we are doing at the moment in the same way. That is the reason we are sitting in front of you this afternoon and why we find ourselves in this position.As I said in my opening comments, and as the Auditor General said in his report, we have to get on with the job of making the changes. If some of the decisions that should have been taken five, four and three years ago were taken then, we would not be in the position we are in now. We have to get the budget in balance, then we have to discuss the accumulated deficit with our colleagues in the health department, but at the same time, to achieve the changes, we are going to have to make significant decisions.There will be consequences of those decisions, and we will have to live with them, otherwise not only will the budget not balance, but we will continue to spend money that should be being spent more wisely on those groups in the community who do not have a voice and cannot shout loudest—for example, people whose inequality drives up their ill health, people with mental illness and learning difficulties, and frail and vulnerable older people. We need to ensure that their needs are addressed, otherwise we will lose the game. I am determined that that is not acceptable, so we have to make some very difficult decisions.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

It is not just about the way that things are done. People are concerned that things are done and continue to be done. Can the joint chief executives get together and provide a letter listing all the cost pressures that are anticipated for 2001-02 and 2002-03? Could you indicate the likely efficiency targets?

Mr Tony Wells Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust
link

For the financial year that just passed last week, Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust had a savings target of £2.4 million. We have a high level of confidence that we will achieve that target. We also had a £2 million repayment of end-year flexibility from the previous year's problems with generic drugs, which has been repaid. We are confident that the primary care trust will be in balance for the past financial year. We have a target for this financial year of £2.9 million, which is part of the figure that you just heard. We have plans in place to address that figure in-year.I consider service redesign to be an important part of the recovery agenda. The primary care trust is working in partnership with the acute trust on a number of service redesign initiatives. Medicine does not stand still. It is important that we look at patients' journeys through the system and make them as efficient as possible, so that they receive the best service that they can expect from us in Tayside.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Can you assure us that your budget will be balanced without the use of one-off resources, because I believe that last year it was one-off resources that allowed you to balance the budget?

Mr Wells
link

We were allowed end-year flexibility with the agreement of the health department. It is considered to be good accounting practice for the health service in Scotland to meet one-off costs from the increased price of generic drugs. That was a UK-wide in-year problem for one year. We looked at one-off capital receipts to repay that overspend on drugs in that year. Our auditors and the health department were satisfied with that treatment.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

My question is directed to Mr Jones. We have heard over the last few minutes about the extent of the deficit. Paul White said that there were a number of measures to go through to clear the deficit, such as the avoidance of the duplication of services and service redesign. At the bottom of that hierarchy was the quality of patient care, which, it was indicated, would be the last thing to be affected by the efficiency savings.In response to questions about that, the Minister for Health and Community Care has consistently said that the quality of patient care will not be affected by the situation in Tayside. After what Mr Jones has heard over the past few minutes, can he give us that assurance today?

Mr Jones
link

The minister and the health department are absolutely clear that addressing the deficit must not affect the quality of patient care. Yes, I can give that assurance.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

Are you saying that, if everything else has been gone through but further savings are required and we come to the bottom of the hierarchy that Paul White described, the health department will not allow the quality of patient care to be affected?

Mr Jones
link

We will not have the quality of patient care compromised. That does not mean to say that we will provide additional funds. It is a matter of addressing the problem differently.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

If everything else has been done to address that problem, what other response can there be? If all other options have been taken, what other possible action could be taken?

Mr Jones
link

Allow me to take a step backwards. We fund the NHS based on an amount per head of population. That is weighted to reflect issues connected with rurality and to reflect health need. Every health board in Scotland receives the same amount per head of population, subject to that weighting. At the end of the financial year 2000-01, nine of the 15 health board areas are managing within their resources and six are running deficits. Three of those deficits are less than 1 per cent—they are almost in balance. It would be difficult to argue that, if Tayside is receiving a fair share of the national resource and well over half of Scotland is living and providing services within that resource, Tayside would not be able to provide services of a safe clinical quality in that funding formula.I do not believe that the scenario that you are describing is correct. The critical thing is for the health system in Tayside to examine how it uses its fair share of the national resource to provide the right balance of services. All those services must be clinically safe. It is not acceptable to compromise safety in addressing the problem.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Can you clarify something that bothers me? We appear to have high-level services in Tayside that the area cannot afford. I think that we are being told that there are low-level services that the area cannot afford. When you say that you want top-quality services to be available to people, everybody agrees, but what you are missing is the location of those services. It appears that there must be a level of services appropriate to an area that may not be supplied to that area; it may be centralised. We have noticed that services beyond this area were supplied, which you cannot afford, and we notice that fundamental services now have to be shifted and people have to travel to them. Where does that take us? That situation is not driven by service but by finance and past decisions.

Mr Jones
link

When we consider how to plan health services, we have to strike a balance between three factors. We have to consider access to services, clinical safety—we talked about that in connection with some of the Angus health services earlier—and cost. We spent the morning talking about how to ensure that there is proper financial management in the system. Health care planning is about balancing those three factors. My point is that, if we are funding health boards based on a fair share of national resource for their population, the only way that we could allow one health board to spend more than its fair share would be to reduce the fair share of another board area. That is the issue that has to be addressed.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

If there is an area for which the report says there is an over-provision of services, that must attract funds, which would be taken away from other services that would otherwise be allowed to go ahead. There may be a fundamental imbalance that has to be addressed.

Mr Bates
link

The fundamental imbalance is exactly the issue that I was referring to. Choices need to be made and investment needs to go into expanding our primary care services. If we do not get ourselves into a position to do that, we will continue to suck money into sustaining things as they are now for ever.I am concerned about issues surrounding locality, distance and travel. However, competing needs have to be balanced and we have to consider our ability to react to modern medicine as it develops and our capacity to generate as many quality and clinically safe services as we can to as many of the Tayside population as we can. That means that we have to make choices. The Auditor General has said in his report—absolutely rightly in my judgment—that we have to get on with that and that we should have been doing so over the past two or three years.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Will Mr White clarify that, as a result of cost efficiency savings, there will not be any increase in waiting times?

Mr White
link

That is one of the other targets that the trust has to meet. As at the end of March just finished, we are on target for our waiting times and waiting lists. We have plans in place for delivering on our component of the national waiting list target for March 2002. I confirm that that is one of our targets.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Can you guarantee the people of Tayside that, as a result of cost efficiency savings, they need have no concerns that waiting times may increase?

Mr White
link

I can guarantee that, short of anything exceptional happening, such as a consultant going off ill. I can assure you that we have plans in place to deliver on our waiting list target and to maintain waiting times. We have had no chartered guarantee breaches in the trust since last summer.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

So it would not be as a result of cost efficiency savings if there were to be an increase in waiting times.

  1. Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Monday 2 April 2001 Committee business · 2
  2. National Health Service (Tayside) Committee business · 540

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.