Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

National Health Service (Tayside)

Monday 2 April 2001 Audit Committee Committee business 540 contributions · 26 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions
2 more speakers
  • Mr Robert Black Auditor General for Scotland 1
  • Mr Tony Wells Tayside Primary Care NHS Trust 1

The record

540 contributions · showing 401–540
Mr White
link

No, it would not. We have built into the plans for the cost reduction programme for this year capacity to allow us to deliver on our waiting list targets.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Paul Martin has covered the major point that I wanted to raise. Obviously, lengthening waiting times would compromise quality of patient care. The waiting time is an integral part of the quality of care. It is a complex issue and I am grateful for the reassurance that Mr White has given.Earlier, Mr Jones said that more than 50 per cent of health boards are meeting their budget. That means that 40 per cent are not. As usual, the glass is half-full or half-empty. However, 40 per cent is a large and considerable minority by any standards.

Mr Jones
link

I said that three of the six that were likely not to be in balance on 31 March just passed have a deficit of less than 1 per cent. That is as close to balance as you are going to get. Getting within 1 per cent of budget is good performance. The latest forecast for the NHS in Scotland is within 0.2 per cent of balance. I think that that is a success story.

Mr White
link

I would like to add something to the answer to Mr Martin's question about waiting lists. One area that could frustrate us in achieving waiting list targets is the degree of delayed discharges—having elective operating and bed capacity blocked out, in effect, by patients who are awaiting discharge. As Mr Bates said earlier, we have set in train a series of discussions with the local authorities to address that matter. However, it is slightly outside our direct control.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I am not too sure that we have received a clear-cut answer on the question of the accumulated deficit and its role or otherwise as a driver in the acute services review. The final year of the three-year recovery plan, 2002-03, requires a further saving of £4 million. We are told that in paragraph 8.5 of the report. We are also told that a notional over-provision for Tayside in terms of the costs—if that is the appropriate phrase—also happens to be £4 million. We have been told that there is duplication and triplication of services. The implication is that some services have been provided unnecessarily and most inefficiently.Given that, is it true that the acute services review is totally driven by a need to achieve a financial balance—given that the two figures that I mentioned are identical and that we are being told today that we have over-provision in the form of duplication and triplication of services?

Mr Brett
link

I will at least begin to answer that. We have a higher level of spend on acute services; I am not sure if you wish to return to that in a minute. We can tell you about some of the things that we are doing to address that. It is partly explained by the fact that we are delivering services on three sites in Tayside, for a population of 390,000. The acute services review will address that. The recommendations that are coming forward will also help us address that, and will lead to some savings.However, as Mr Bates has said, we also need to invest further in primary and community care, so that there is less need for patients to travel, and so that more care can be delivered locally. We began that process last year. If members wish to know more, Tony Wells can give you much information on what we are doing. They are innovative, exciting things, and are helping to support patients at home, to support their relatives, to keep them out of hospital, to get them home sooner and to provide one-stop clinics. We are taking a range of positive, exciting actions. We believe that they will allow us to reduce expenditure on acute secondary services.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

But can I get a straightforward yes-or-no answer to my question: is the acute services review driven by the need to deliver the £4 million—which is apparently the excess for Tayside—to achieve the final year's balance, which also just happens to be £4 million?

Mr Bates
link

May I answer that question in a straightforward way, convener? Mr Jones rightly said that cost is a factor that must be borne in mind—so must quality of care, and so must accessibility. When the acute services review process started, the agenda in Tayside, as it was understood, was quite different to the one that we are discussing now. It is worth reminding ourselves that the original intention was to create headroom at the top of the acute services pyramid to invest in primary care services.I have absolutely no doubt—and I have consistently said this to all the community groups, patients groups and elected members to whom I have spoken, whether in councils or in the Parliament—that we have to take cost into account as we consider options from the acute services review. Cost is not the only factor, but will be a factor. It would be absolute madness to sit here and tell you that we will be making decisions and choices without thinking carefully about cost and consequence. We have to balance three very difficult things at the same time that we are recovering a deficit. That is the management challenge that we and the chief executives have to deliver on. Cost is certainly a factor, but is not the only factor.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

In that case, the purpose of the acute services review, or rather its direction, has been subverted in order to address the matter of the financial deficit.

Mr Bates
link

My answer to that is no, I do not think that it has been subverted. The review has probably concentrated minds in a different way. That is a fair way of putting it. If there were no acute services review, I am sure that the three chief executives would conduct an acute services review by another name, because we are considering decisions that needed to be taken—several a long time ago. It would be unfair to say that the review has been subverted by the deficit. The review will concentrate the minds of top managers on ensuring that they reach the financial figures on balance but drive the new agenda of change.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Are you saying that the acute services review has not been pre-empted by cost savings?

Mr Bates
link

I do not think that anything has been pre-empted.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

What about today's announcement on Stracathro?

Mr Bates
link

Today's announcement was not really an announcement. Mr Brett honestly shared with the committee the fact that concerns that we must take seriously have been drawn to the attention of the trust's chief executive. The reason why we are here is that we are spending more money than we have on the books to spend. Regardless of whether we had an acute services review or anything else, we would have had to make choices about how we spent that money.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I will pick up on something that Mr Brett said. I was somewhat astounded by his comment. The service in Tayside seems to evolve for the sake of evolving, and whether it is being delivered in the right way and at the right level is never considered. It is as if Tayside had suddenly been dragged kicking and screaming into an acute services review, when most other health bodies in Scotland have been involved in such processes for a great many years. We now find that Tayside has a financial deficit. I am astounded that you are the only common denominator and that you can make such a statement.

Mr Brett
link

I apologise if I misled you. Is it appropriate for me to go into some of the background of the acute services review?

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Yes, if you do so succinctly. We are about to ask questions on the acute services review, but you can respond immediately to the point.

Mr Brett
link

Clinical staff have been hugely involved in the acute services review and have bought into it, and the public have been engaged with it for the past two years. That has been done in a conscious and measured way. If I gave you any other impression, I apologise.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Much in medicine will change in two years. Something changes almost every day. You do not show me that an in-built natural process has operated in Tayside and that you have considered the nuts and bolts of every service as someone has asked for it to be developed, reduced or redesigned. You do not seem to have considered the impact of such changes or whether what you are trying to do is making the best use of the money that is available. You say that you have done that only in the past two years.

Mr Brett
link

No, I have been here for a considerable time, during which the process has continued.

Mr Brett
link

As part of the acute services review, all our acute services have been scrutinised by groups of clinicians from primary and secondary care. I am satisfied that they have considered all the options for delivering the services in the future.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I do not think that the process was as smooth as that from the consumer's point of view. Nick Johnston will discuss the acute services review process.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

From the evidence that we have heard, we can be in no doubt that the acute services review is integral to Tayside's financial health. Exhibit 7 on page 20 of the Auditor General's report shows the progress stages for the Tayside acute services review. All the witnesses must be aware that the perception in Tayside is that the review has been not clinically driven, but financially driven, and centred on moving services into Ninewells in Dundee.Bearing in mind the figures that are not included in the Auditor General's report which show the inequities in funding across Tayside, why has the review taken so long? What lessons can the rest of the health service learn from the three and a half years of misery that patients and staff have been put through? Finally, when will we see the finished report of acute services in Tayside?

Mr Brett
link

I regret that the process has taken so long. It has taken about two years to date. Although there was discussion about the review in 1998, it did not get under way until April and May 1999. After an intensive period during 1999, a phase 1 report was produced at the end of the year, which I and some others thought would allow us to move quickly on to public consultation. The report made out the case for change and listed a number of possible options; however, it was soon apparent at the end of the year that there had been no detailed work-up of the options and that, critically, the clinical groups in Tayside had not bought into the detail of the options, particularly in relation to the implications for primary care.That first phase was led by Professor Roland Jung, who is a senior physician at Ninewells; we consciously decided that phase 2 should be led by another clinician. In fact, it was led by two clinicians—Professor David Rowley and Dr Andrew Russell, who is a general practitioner—because we wanted to ensure that it was clinically led. That phase should have been completed by last December; however, the task force felt that we should spend more time, particularly in ensuring that the costings of the options were robust. We undertook that work, and the report was presented at a special meeting of the board in January this year.While it prepared the consultation document, the board decided that it wished to take a little more time to have further discussion with some of the interest groups, which is what we have been doing over the past eight to 10 weeks. A joint consultation paper from the three chief executives will come back to a board meeting in two weeks' time, and I expect that, as Paul White said, we will move to consultation during May, June and July. The board will then have a special meeting at the end of August to consider the comments with any recommendations being sent to the minister.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Perhaps Mr Jones can tell us when we can expect the report to emerge from the department.

Mr Jones
link

It is difficult to put a fixed time scale on that until we see the document. However, I would be disappointed if we could not turn a document around within two months.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Perhaps the length of time was exacerbated by the big uncosted options that were paraded before the public. Why were the options not costed right from the very start? At least then during the initial consultations—which seem to have happened a long time ago—people would have known what was before them and something could have been implemented. Parading big uncosted options at public meetings has helped nobody and is partly why the process has lasted so long.

Mr Brett
link

I readily acknowledge that we have learned many lessons as the process has gone on. From the word go, we were very keen to inform the public about what we were doing. We have had a total of three rounds of meetings across Tayside over this period. Furthermore, we have set up patient reference forums and have engaged consultants to help us get the public's views and play them into the process.We used the first round of meetings to explain the review and why it was needed. At the start, I certainly thought that there would be more detailed options at the end of phase 1. That was not the case, and we had to spend time ensuring that the options were properly worked up, that the implications were fully appreciated and that primary care—the other key people who will deliver the review's recommendations—were on-side, happy and understood the proposals.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

The words "lack of clear strategy" come to mind.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Bates, you are a fresh face in this situation and have already said that you want openness and transparency. You will be aware of the depth of feeling across Tayside on this issue. How will you develop the matter to ensure that the groups involved feel that they are involved and that they have contributed to the process?

Mr Bates
link

I am aware that much of the strength of feeling is from people who—understandably—passionately want and vehemently argue for services to be retained in their present form. While that should be understood and respected, it must be balanced against the agenda that we have spent the past few hours discussing. It is my intention to ensure that the 90-day consultation period is open, transparent and real and is carried out as imaginatively as possible. However, we must also be very honest with people throughout Tayside about what we can and cannot afford and about what the real choices are. I would not want to miss the opportunity today to try to convey, in a way that we have not done thus far, that there are many groups in our community whose voices are not articulated to the same extent as those of other groups. There is a huge agenda of need that we have to balance carefully. I am under no illusions—it will take more than 90 days to re-earn the patience and trust of the wider Tayside community. It will take us years to do that, but 90 days is the start of that process.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Jones, what steps has the department taken to advise local health bodies on how reviews should be carried out and on the evidence that you expect to underpin them? Are you satisfied with the process in Tayside? What monitoring systems do you have in place?

Mr Jones
link

I am not aware of any guidance that we have issued on acute services reviews—Mr Aldridge may correct me on that. When we consider exhibit 7, I can say that I am not satisfied with progress in Tayside. It has taken longer than any of us would have liked to make progress on this. As part of the health plan, "Our National Health", we are creating a national expert group, which will advise NHS boards on how to develop issues such as this and to support boards in implementing reviews. NHS boards go through this only once every five or 10 years, but it is a continuous process throughout Scotland. There is a lot of experience throughout Scotland that we should be sharing; the expert group is being set up to do that.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

At the 1999 accountability meeting, the department was concerned about the lack of a clear strategy on Tayside. The review is still not complete. Are you satisfied that a strategy is now in place?

Mr Jones
link

I am satisfied that we have a process, which Peter Bates has just taken us through, that will get the strategy in place and that the department will work alongside the NHS board in Tayside to ensure that we make progress on that as quickly as possible.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We are reaching the end of an acute services review and it is still a process rather than a strategy. The Auditor General's report shows that one of the problems is that there is no strategy. Less than two years ago, at the accountability review meeting, the department expressed its concern at the continued absence of a clear service strategy for acute services in Tayside. I cannot see that strategy even yet. It all leads back to management, but I notice in paragraph 5.4 on page 19 that "Tayside Health Board's auditor's report on the 1999/2000 accounts concluded that the contracting arrangements surrounding the appointment of the consultant were not fully in accordance with the board's standing orders and standing financial instructions."Who was responsible for that?

Mr Brett
link

That is perhaps the one part of the report that has not been put as well as it might have been. I will explain. The health board at the time decided to appoint external management consultants to help with the process. We decided that there would be value in appointing consultants who had done previous work with the Angus NHS Trust and who therefore had a good deal of knowledge on the Tayside position. It was explained to the board that that was what we were doing and the board accepted that. The board has the facility to decide to put standing orders to one side, which I believe that it did on that occasion. The auditor quite rightly pointed out that the action was contrary to standing orders but we had pointed that out to the board when we asked it to make that decision.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

What are we to make of an accountable officer who does not act in accordance with standing orders and who is overseeing a system that has a lack of clear service strategy in the middle of an acute services review? It is not impressive.

Mr Brett
link

I am sorry, I—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

In the middle of an acute services review, there was a lack of clear service strategy, which still has not emerged. The accountable officer acted outwith the standing orders.

Mr Brett
link

I have done my best to explain that the board was informed of the position and made the decision in that knowledge. The decision was made when the process was beginning and we wanted to make urgent progress with it to ensure that the process got ahead.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have a point for Mr Jones. Tayside is not the only health board area that has encountered serious difficulties and delays with its acute services review. Two of the health board areas that I represent, Forth Valley Health Board and Fife Health Board, have encountered what the ex-chairman of Fife Health Board might call even more serious difficulties with their reviews. Can Mr Jones tell us whether the time that it has taken Tayside to perform its review is significantly longer than the time taken elsewhere? Does he agree that the acute services review in Scotland has caused serious problems?

Mr Jones
link

That is quite right. Acute services reviews are always the most controversial parts of strategy development and can take a while to perform. A detailed review is under way in Glasgow and, as you say, Forth Valley Health Board and Fife Health Board are conducting reviews. I do not know whether Tayside Health Board's review is taking longer but, in hindsight, it is fair to say that we need a smarter and faster system to move the processes forward. I have described the mechanism that we are setting up to do that.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is important, as the issue comes down to the department's macro-management—not its micro-management—and how it sets out the strategy. The department should not pass the buck. When acute services reviews are set out, it is up to the department to lay out the framework for them.

Mr Jones
link

That is right. Another important issue is the interface between health board areas. It is important that, when one is thinking about a strategy in Tayside Health Board, one also thinks about the strategy in Forth Valley Health Board. That will ensure that there is a national approach, which we are addressing through the health plan.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We will now deal with the unit cost of health care in Tayside and ask why it is relatively high.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

Paragraph 8.17 of the report tells us that the department maintains statistics on the unit costs of health bodies. How does your department use those statistics to fulfil its role in monitoring the performance of the separate health bodies?

Mr Jones
link

I will ask Mr Aldridge to handle that question as it is on his area of expertise.

Mr Aldridge
link

We collect a range of information about the comparative performance of organisations across Scotland and about comparative unit costs. One of the difficulties that we have faced is in being sure that the comparative unit costs are collected on a truly comparable basis. We have to be cautious in how we use those costs. They have been used in the performance management and accountability review arrangements to challenge local health systems on why their costs are higher than costs in another area or, indeed, on why they are significantly lower, as that, too, might be an indication of problems.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

You will be aware that Tayside Health Board's costs are much higher than the costs of any of the other parts of the NHS in Scotland. What action has been taken to address that?

Mr Aldridge
link

Such figures must be treated with some caution. It is true that costs are higher in Tayside but, if one takes into account the higher expenditure on hospital and community health services in Tayside—which results from factors such as the effects of the Arbuthnott formula on the area's funding—the excess is not as significant as it appears to be. That has to be taken into account.Accountability and performance management reviews were undertaken, especially when the financial problems of Tayside became clear. Tayside Health Board may wish to comment on that, as it has been identifying where its costs are higher than elsewhere and where it might make efficiency savings to come into line with the rest of Scotland.

Mr Brett
link

We have a small population base and a medical school with the smallest catchment population of any in the United Kingdom. We provide a number of services because we are a teaching centre and the costs are spread over a smaller population.We have high estate charges. We have a lot of estate, and Ninewells is a very expensive hospital in terms of capital charges. Tayside has a relatively elderly population, as the Auditor General states, which will bring our capital charge down in some respects, although our costs might be expected to be higher partly because of that. We have examined the issue intensively, and Mr White or Mr Wells may want to tell you what we have done.

Mr White
link

We analysed our capital charge burden in Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust relative to those that are borne by other acute trusts in Scotland. If our capital charges were pro rata to what other trusts are bearing, they would be some £4.3 million less per annum recurring. It appears that Tayside University Hospitals NHS Trust is using relatively more and more expensive estate buildings, land and equipment to deliver services than are being used elsewhere in Scotland, and that is placing a cost burden on the population. The funding that is tied up in paying those sorts of costs would otherwise be available to pay for some of the other things that we have been discussing.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

Why are the costs higher in Tayside than elsewhere?

Mr White
link

There are two factors. The first is the number of buildings that we have in both trusts and the value that has been placed on those buildings. Both Perth royal infirmary and Ninewells hospital are relatively new buildings and are valued accordingly. The capital charges that those buildings attract are therefore high relative to those of much of the estate elsewhere in Scotland.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

Surely other health authorities and trusts have new buildings. Being parochial, I point out that Queen Margaret hospital in Dunfermline is new.

Mr White
link

It is. I would judge that the valuation of Queen Margaret hospital is slightly less than that of Ninewells hospital. However, Fife Health Board is not running anything like the number of hospitals that are being run in Tayside, relative to its population. That brings a cost burden. Fife has community hospitals like those in Angus and Perthshire, but the volume of hospitals and the square metreage of estate that is employed in Fife is less for the population that it serves than the equivalent figure in Tayside.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Is it not also true that Tayside received proportionately higher amounts of money than other health authorities did? You were receiving more income.

Mr Brett
link

That is true. Similar to what you heard when you were in Glasgow, the previous Scottish health authorities revenue equalisation formula meant that Tayside, along with Glasgow and the Lothians, was relatively over-funded in comparison with other parts of Scotland. Over 15 or so years, we returned to parity. I give credit to the people in Tayside—we managed that process

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

Mr Aldridge gave caveats about why it is difficult to compare the unit costs and why the comparisons are not as straightforward to make as they first appear to be. Is there any purpose to using unit costs as a basis for comparison?

Mr Aldridge
link

Yes. Having unit costs remains helpful, but they should not be taken as absolutes. They should be used as indicators of where questioning would be appropriate and to start a conversation or challenge about the position. It would be wrong to put too much emphasis on the precise figures that emerge from that exercise.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

I am not sure whether my next question is for Mr Aldridge or Mr Jones—you can decide between you who will answer it. To what extent will the proposed performance management and accountability framework allow you to focus on comparative unit costs and quality of services?

Mr Aldridge
link

I will answer first. Mr Jones may want to expand on my answer. The new framework will allow us to do what you described, but will involve more than simply the relative unit costs of services. It will facilitate a much wider comparability exercise that involves different parts of the health service.

Mr Jones
link

I described the seven core elements of the new performance management framework, which concerns finance and efficiency. It also involves the rest of the core business and deals with the activity that is being undertaken on health improvement in a board area, partnership working with the rest of the public sector, involvement of community and patients in health service planning, clinical quality, clinical governance, access to services and staff governance. The new performance assessment framework focuses more widely than simply on the financial bottom line, which is what we used to use to run our business. The framework is more concerned with quality and how local communities are engaged.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

Will that framework allow us to make better comparisons between different areas and avoid the difficulties that Mr Aldridge mentioned?

Mr Jones
link

Yes. For each matter, we will have a range of subindicators, which will be analysed over time for a health board area, and across Scotland. We will be able to compare directly how we are involving communities around Scotland and pick out areas that are doing that extremely well and areas where more effort needs to be concentrated.

Mr White
link

I return to the broad issue of benchmarking. As well as considering financial benchmarking, which, as Mr Aldridge says, allows us to ask questions and probe any apparent differences, we have made skill-mix comparisons across a range of departments and staffing levels with similar departments in similar organisations. For example, Ninewells compares quite closely with Foresterhill in Aberdeen, but it would be inappropriate to make that comparison for Perth royal infirmary, so to build a comparison for that we consider other hospitals of a similar type. Comparison is taking place at several levels, not just that of financial benchmarking.

Mr Wells
link

I would like to balance the picture in Tayside a bit. It is not true that all unit costs of Tayside services are above the Scottish average. Most unit costs of primary care services are below the Scottish average. People should be aware of that balance.

Brian Adam SNP North East Scotland
link

I am rather concerned about the return on capital investment. Are you suggesting that there are too many sites, that the sites are not well utilised and that the formula is rather unfair on health authorities that have relatively modern premises, such as Ninewells and Perth royal infirmary? I would like to hear from the representatives from Tayside and the health department about whether that is an appropriate way of ensuring that a return on the money is made.

Mr Brett
link

The number of sites is largely a fact that we inherited. Some years ago, Tayside had more hospital beds per head of population than any other part of Scotland, partly because we had two EMS hospitals—Stracathro and Bridge of Earn—that were built during the second world war and were carried into the national health service. We can take action on the situation. The biggest capital charge element that we face is the Ninewells site because it is difficult to knock bits off Ninewells. However, we can still have discussions, particularly about whether the university will use parts of the site in the future. The trust is considering that possibility. In the longer term, as newer hospitals are built in other parts of Scotland, the situation will gradually balance out.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

The committee hates acronyms. Will you clarify EMS?

Mr Brett
link

EMS is emergency medical services. There were wartime hospitals at Bridge of Earn and Stracathro.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We have been happily acronym free so far.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

My question is to Mr White. Paragraphs 8.14 and 8.15 of the Auditor General's report record the action that the trust took to benchmark its costs against those of others and the resulting savings that have been identified. Why did that work not commence until 1999?

Mr White
link

I think that we did well to commence at that time. We started that comparison in the first few months of the trust's existence. We have made progress that has informed some of the efficiency savings that we made in the year from which we have just exited. The work to which paragraph 8.14 refers allowed us to formulate robust plans on which we were able to deliver. We did not delay when the new trust was created. We started that work well within our first year.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Is there evidence that the previous trusts used that system of benchmarking?

Mr White
link

The trust's director of nursing was instrumental in helping to take forward that part of the agenda, because she had been director of nursing in Dundee Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, where she did such work. She had been with that organisation only about a year or less before the restructuring got under way in 1998.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Did the medical director follow a culture of benchmarking, consider service costs and how services should be delivered and study best practice throughout Scotland?

Mr Brett
link

If you will allow me to return to my previous role, I can say that such processes existed. The previous trusts were involved in a benchmarking club with teaching hospitals in other parts of Britain, so we compared our performance against those of Addenbrooke's, Leeds and other hospitals in England, because I was concerned that we should be efficient compared with UK hospitals and not just Scottish hospitals.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

If you undertook that process, why are your costs still high?

Mr Brett
link

That is a fair point. The issues need to be continually revisited, but for year three of our recovery process, we are about to set up clinical review teams that will study in depth those clinical areas where we are significantly above the Scottish average. We plan to do that in the next six months, using such information, redesign and other techniques. We hope to have proposals to put to the unified board in October this year that will generate our efficiency savings for our final year.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

The redesign techniques that you talk about have been tried and tested in other areas of the country. You are not showing me that you will reinvent them to suit the needs of Tayside. I still have concerns. If you are so adamant that you had the process in place, why did it not work?

Mr Brett
link

That is partly because the trust is now configured differently and we can now consider services—

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

But a hip replacement is a hip replacement—it does not matter whether there are one, two or more trusts. A hip replacement is a hip replacement, irrespective of the number of hospitals. That is the bald fact that individuals are concerned about.

Mr Brett
link

That is correct. We compared our hip performance pathway with that of other hospitals in Britain. We discovered that we were keeping patients in hospital longer than did other hospitals and that there did not seem to be a good reason for doing so.

Mr Brett
link

We visited other hospitals to understand what they were doing that was different. New practices were introduced as a result. Medicine does not stand still—

Mr Brett
link

People need to revisit their procedures.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

Margaret Jamieson has elicited a queue of responses. Mr White and Mr Bates want to come in at this point.

Mr Bates
link

It is important that we convey clearly to the Audit Committee that, without doubt, the Auditor General has put his finger on something that we can and must do better. Improving performance is not a bolt-on extra but a continuing process that becomes part of the culture. All managers, clinical directors and clinical leaders in Tayside have to think constantly about their performance and to ask why they are doing things in a particular way. If someone is performing to as good or to a better quality anywhere else at a cheaper cost, they have to ask how that is so and what can they do to fast-track improvements in Tayside. The Auditor General's point is fair. I assure Mrs Jamieson that the three chairmen of the unified authority regard performance improvement as an important priority for managers and for all the clinical leaders. It is one of the things we in Tayside need to get motivated about, so that it is seen as part of everybody's responsibility. It is absolutely true to say that we have a way to go to get better at that.

Mr White
link

I want to reassure Mrs Jamieson that we are not reinventing the wheel. In 1999-2000, we looked at redesign in the Leicester royal infirmary, the Royal London hospital, the Royal Shrewsbury hospital, Edinburgh royal infirmary and the Central Middlesex hospital. We have applied what we learned from looking at all those hospitals. In November 1999, we gave a presentation to clinical staff to set out the examples of good practice and service change that we had seen at each hospital site.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

The issues that you have described will be way up the clinical governance agenda. Individuals will have to answer to that agenda in terms of their clinical performance. If we are talking about benchmarking, something that will be new to the service is point of partnership. Mr Bates referred to that earlier. The primary care trust has not been questioned very much today, but in any redesign of service, the most important partners are the primary care trust and the local authorities. Can we be given an assurance that those groups are on board? If they are not, whatever you implement is going to fall down like a pack of cards. I get the impression that Mr Bates and Mr Jones are talking about NHS Scotland or NHS Tayside; I do not get the same feeling from Mr White or from Mr Brett. I do not feel that they are buying into the new ways of working.

Mr White
link

Let me try to reassure Mrs Jamieson. Most of the questions have been specific to the trust. Mrs Jamieson is opening up an important area of questioning about the interface between the trust and local authorities. In the redesign work that we have done, we have invited primary care trust staff into the redesign projects. Indeed, we are going further than that, as the joint management forum that embraces all three health bodies is overseeing the whole redesign programme in Tayside. Mr Wells and I have an imminent meeting of the redesign team to talk about creating even closer joint working than exists at present. Perhaps Mr Wells could talk about the nationally recognised project in Perth that is drawing the health authorities and local authorities together into a redesign of services in a more fundamental way.

Mr Wells
link

A working partnership is extremely important. The main partners for us in the primary care trust are the local authorities and our acute trust colleagues. Indeed, the primary care trust has been structured to reflect the three local authority areas in Tayside. The project that Paul White has just referred to—the care together project in Perth and Kinross—starts life this week and brings together all the health and social care services in Perth and Kinross under one joint board structure. We are paying particular attention to partnership working arrangements.The service redesign issues are extremely important if we are to move on from where we are now. The formation of a joint service redesign team in Tayside is an important cornerstone of that process. We are keen to work with our colleagues in the acute trust, not least because whatever the acute trust does impacts directly or indirectly on the primary care services that we provide.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

I would like you to clarify exactly what savings are achieved as a result of benchmarking. Paragraph 8.14 refers to the benchmarking of medical and nursing pay and goes on to say that that "has led TUHT to reappraise its nursing establishment with a view to establishing more appropriate numbers of nursing posts."I take it that that means that you have cut the number of nurses.

Mr White
link

Yes, we have reduced the number of nursing posts.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

It would be nice if the report said that rather than hinted at it. Mr Jones assured us that the quality of patient care cannot be compromised. Paragraph 8.14 tells us that you are reducing the number of nurses in Tayside and paragraph 8.16 talks about the scope for a reduction in bed numbers in Tayside. I cannot see how the quality of patient care can be maintained while you are cutting the number of nurses and the number of beds that are available. I do not think that that adds up.

Mr White
link

I will use an example to explain how such a change would take place. Some of the wards that we inherited at the beginning of April 1999 were not used to their full capacity, by which I mean that they did not have occupancy rates of 85 to 90 per cent, which would be the generally accepted upper levels of occupancy. Some of the wards that we inherited had occupancy rates of 40 or 50 per cent. That is clearly not a good use of resources. We examined the possibility of combining some of those wards and closing beds that were being inefficiently used. Thus, the nursing posts were not filled as they fell vacant. In that way, the number of beds and the number of nurses were reduced without compromising the quality of care.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

You are increasing the use of beds in hospitals so that more patients go through the beds week after week. Does not that make more likely the possibility of hospital-acquired infections, which are now a problem in Tayside?

Mr White
link

The situation that you describe should not make that more likely because the staffing levels and the skill mix of nurses should be appropriate to the number of patients in a ward and the dependency of those patients, which will include their susceptibility to infection.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

However, if the nurses are expected to tend to far greater numbers of patients than they were in the past, surely their ability to perform as nurses is compromised because they will be more tired and stretched than they used to be—they will not be as good as they were when they were not under such fierce pressure.

Mr White
link

The nurse staffing levels that we have

applied in the wards and departments across the trust are based on nationally recognised formulas. That is part of the benchmarking exercise. Tayside is not filling wards to a higher level or staffing them to a lower level than is happening elsewhere in the country. We are ensuring that the practice in Tayside follows the best accepted practice across the country.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Everybody tries to give positive answers and pretend that nothing bad is happening in the health service. Earlier, I believe you said that waiting lists would not increase in Tayside as a result of the attempts to balance the budget, but the report refers to your financial recovery plan from February 2000, which talks about not carrying out non-emergency elective surgery. That must lengthen waiting lists.

Mr White
link

That is not part of our recovery plan at this point.

Mr White
link

That is correct. We deliberately reduced the amount of elective activity because, at the end of December, the trust was 3,600 cases ahead on activity compared with the same period in the previous year.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Waiting lists must have increased at that time as a result of your decision not to carry out non-emergency elective surgery.

Mr White
link

That is correct—waiting lists increased.

Mr White
link

As a result of our trying to maintain a cash balance for the end of the financial year. During this year, we have brought waiting lists down. As I said in response to an earlier question, we are back on target. I stress that for most of last year we had no patients breaching charter guarantees. We had some at the beginning of the year but, since the summer of 2000, we have not had any patients breaching charter guarantees. We are back on track with our waiting list performance.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to follow on from Mr McAllion's point. We have talked about efficiency savings or cuts—whichever phrase one uses—but there is also the question of funding the development of new services. I am concerned that that may be stalled.I understand that the health department does not monitor the balance between the provision of services within a health board area because that is up to the health boards themselves. I would like to pursue that point with the department on another occasion. There is already a gross unevenness of service in different health board areas in, for example, tackling drug misuse. Even if you achieve the targets that you have mentioned, and even given the reassurance that you gave Mr McAllion, is there not a danger that new services, or the development of existing ones, will not be funded as they might be in other health board areas that have balanced budgets? Is there not a danger that Tayside will fall behind?

Mr Bates
link

The answer to that question is central to why we are sitting here in front of committee members today. Mr McAllion is right: my answers are positive because I feel that we have to take a positive approach. In NHS Tayside, we have outstandingly good staff who are providing good quality services. They deserve strong and positive management and leadership.If we continue to do everything we do at the moment in the same way and do not have the courage to make the sorts of decisions that need to be made—which the Auditor General has quite properly said we need to get on with making—not only will we not be able to make the investment in primary and preventive services that Mr Raffan rightly mentions, the deficit will simply grow and we will not achieve what we need to achieve. It is in the interests of the overwhelming majority of the Tayside population that we be allowed to get on and make those changes. Mr Raffan is absolutely right to raise the point. To go back to Mr McAllion's point, if we stand still and say, "We can't do anything about what we are doing at the moment, we've just got to get on and keep doing it in the same way," we will never move ourselves out of this position—and we have to move ourselves out of this position.I would like to add one other thing to the answer to Mr McAllion's question. Mr White made the point that we have 270 beds that are currently taken by people who do not need them. Going back to the point that Mr Barrie raised, we must secure real partnerships and build on the links that we already have with local authorities to get that number down. A number of those beds will be needed to make progress on some of the other agendas, such as waiting lists. We have to get on and make those decisions. Without doubt some people will feel, when we make those decisions, that we are letting them down: we will not be able to please everybody all the time.

Mr Brett
link

To reassure Mr Raffan, I would say that as part of the use of additional funds last year, the joint management forum agreed to invest £2.7 million in primary and community care services. We were conscious of the need to invest in those services across Tayside and we did so in conjunction with our four local health care co-operatives and our three local authorities. You could ask, "Why did you not just offset more of the overspending on the acute side?" We did not do that, quite consciously, because we believed that the priority was to put right some of the long-standing deficits.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I am aware that this particular market day is wearing late, but Peter Bates's positive view of a management worthy of the dedication of its staff neatly leads us into the last section, which will examine whether Tayside health bodies have improved leadership, governance and communication and look to the future.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Mr Jones, the ministerial task force identified an absence of health leadership, corporate working and governance and a lack of effective communication as important factors contributing to financial and other problems in the NHS in Tayside. Paragraph 8.12 of the Auditor General's report sets out what were the latest in a list of weaknesses in governance in Tayside health bodies. How do you satisfy yourself that the guidance that is listed in exhibit 5 of the report is being followed?

Mr Jones
link

I met the Tayside task force only relatively recently, just as we were bringing the task force's work to a close. Members of the task force spoke positively about the changes that have taken place in Tayside over recent months. Those changes have addressed issues including leadership and communication. As a result of the changes, significant improvement has been made in those areas. The department will review formally all those areas as part of the performance assessment framework that has been referred to on a number of occasions today. It is absolutely critical that the NHS has strong, able leadership in each NHS board area. That leadership starts with the chairmanship of the boards and has to cascade through all the organisation's structures. The performance assessment framework, which we will use to review directly a board's performance, will pick up on the areas that need improvement. As I said, we will publish the results of those reviews.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I will direct my next question to Mr Brett. Paragraph 8.9 of the Auditor General's report summarises the new protocols that have been introduced to control the approval of service developments. Do those protocols overcome the previous weaknesses?

Mr Brett
link

Yes, I believe that that is the case. There is now a much firmer grip on that. There is a clear understanding between Mr White, Mr Wells and me. Major issues are brought to the joint management forum that was set up soon after the task force arrived. We have recently reviewed the forum's role and remit. That means that any key decision is taken in that group prior to its coming to the board. I am confident that we have the mechanisms in place to deal with the matter.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

That is an interesting reply, given the reference that is made in paragraph 8.9 on page 35 of the report to the protocols that would "help control the approval and use of additional resources for service developments." Those protocols created major problems in the past. Do you believe that those protocols are a product of the relationship between the trust, the university and the teaching hospital, or are they a product of the unfortunate circumstances of additional staff being brought on board in Perth and Kinross and in Dundee?

Mr Brett
link

Mr White might like to comment. We have come a long way since that time. Mr Quinan is highlighting the events of two years ago, and the situation now is much more positive. The £2.7 million that I mentioned was the outcome of joint decision making between the local health care co-operatives and the three local authorities. The decision-making process is much more open. I must also stress that we now have a much greater involvement of staff in all our processes. That has been a positive development.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I ask Mr Brett to give us an absolutely straightforward assurance that it is no longer possible for anyone in Perth and Kinross or in Dundee to decide to employ 200 extra nurses or other staff without anyone in the finance department knowing anything about those decisions.

Mr Brett
link

I am happy to give members that assurance.

Mr Bates
link

For the record, I want to correct an earlier error that was made in a reference to the external auditor's comment about the letting of the contract to the consultants. I want members of the Audit Committee to be assured that I am aware that there can be no room for complacency.I have said that I want the review of the board's standing orders to be completed urgently. That is a continuing piece of work that we will have in mind for the unified board. As the new chairman, I want, as part of that work, to see a careful reappraisal of the scheme of delegated powers to senior managers because, in any organisation, one of the key things to do is to identify who believes they have what power to make what decisions. I feel strongly that, although we have to have freedom to manage and to get on with things, there has to be a proper and transparent recording of decisions that have been made. I intend to have that review of standing orders and delegated powers completed by the summer, ready for implementation by the new board.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

I detect that your past experience is now standing you in good stead.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I would like something clarified. Mr Brett said to me that the protocols would prevent the situation of someone being able to employ upwards of 200 staff—either in Perth and Kinross or in Dundee—without reference to anyone else. However, you appear to have just said that you require a change in the standing orders and a clarification of the delegated powers to guarantee that such a circumstance would not arise again.

Mr Bates
link

My exact words, I think, were—and I have them written down in front of me, so I am sure that the Official Report will show this—about a review of the standing orders and the scheme of delegation. I want to be clear, and this is an important point. Understandably, we have concentrated on an awful lot of things that have gone wrong. However, during the past nine months or a year—and I think that Mr Jones referred to this in response to the debriefing from the task force—an awful lot of things have been put in place in Tayside. For example, the way the three chief executives and three directors of finance are having to work together to manage the agenda, and the introduction of a much tighter system of accountability, are positive things. It is important that we get that over. This is not a case of our saying, "We've done that now and it's okay." My job is to ensure that we continue to scrutinise. There is always room for improvement. I have not been involved in public service organisations for more than 30 years, knowing all the mistakes that I have made as a senior manager—and there have been many of them—without knowing how easy it is to make mistakes.I did not say what Mr Quinan suggests I said. There may well need to be changes, but what I have instructed is a proper review.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

Thank you, Mr Bates. That makes things clear for us—although inferences may be drawn from a comparison of what you said with what Mr Brett said.My final question is to Mr Brett. Paragraph 8.11 of the Auditor General's report refers to the "Recovery through Modernisation and Investment" report and it addresses a range of measures that are aimed at addressing the task force's criticism of leadership, governance and communication. Those measures include enhanced performance management to ensure that information is shared among the Tayside health bodies. Is such information now available? What benefits has it achieved?

Mr Brett
link

Information is available on a number of fronts. The measure that would probably be of most interest to the committee is that, for the past six months or most of the past financial year, we have had a joint monthly financial report. That is prepared by the three finance directors. It comes to the joint management forum and goes to all three health bodies in Tayside. That was commended by the task force. I believe that something similar will be commended to all other health systems in Scotland.Having such a report means that we can all see clearly what is happening, where there are pressures or problems, and whether efficiency targets are being met. It is an open document, available to everybody. We need to build on that and include other shared information. We want to improve on a number of other areas.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I want to ask Mr Jones about the ministerial task force. We had the interim report of that task force in June 2000. Then, on the department's advice, or probably his own advice, the minister decided to stand down the task force in November. The interim report therefore became the final report. That is rather ironic, and perhaps Mr Jones will agree. One of the criticisms in Tayside has been to do with communication. Would it have been in the interests of reassuring the people of Tayside if the task force had actually made a final report and said very clearly and very publicly at that time—it has been said since—that real and good progress was being made and that the task force was therefore being taken out?

Mr Jones
link

It may not have happened as well as it should have, but it did happen. The minister came to Tayside as she was closing down the task force and when she announced the appointment of Peter Bates and another chairman in Tayside. She said that the task force work was complete and had been successful. There have been significant changes as a result of the work of the task force.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

There is always a danger when interim reports become final reports—

Mr Jones
link

I take your point.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We have covered a lot of ground and have acknowledged some problems in regard to confidence in health management in Tayside. We have looked at management continuity; one thing that bothers me is that change seems to have been forced by outsiders—including task forces—in many ways as well as by bad budgeting practices and major public disquiet. We have looked at some of the problems in some detail.To finish, I would like to give Mr Bates the opportunity to look ahead. Given the latest list of weaknesses set out in paragraph 8.12 of the report, what assurances can you give that the NHS in Tayside is now being managed in the best way?

Mr Bates
link

I genuinely want to thank the Audit Committee for taking us through some important matters in a way that helps to explain to the wider world the fact that the roots of many problems go back a long way. It would not be prudent to mislead the Audit Committee into believing that someone such as a new chairman can come in with quick fixes, wave a magic wand and everything will be fine. There are new arrangements for the unified board, and there are now three chairs in place in Tayside who are absolutely determined and committed to working together and to be open and transparent with the citizens. We have an outstandingly good work force, with trade union leaders and staff-side leaders who have made clear their interest and willingness to work in partnership with us. The new board will bring the local authorities round the table in a new way. Those factors are good for the future, but there are major challenges that the committee has exposed today and choices that will have to be made quickly so that progress can continue.It would not be flippant to say that, in the next 18 months to two years and onwards, we will need a great deal of support from MSPs and others in the wider world to help us see changes through. I am extremely positive, but I am also realistic. We have started a long journey in the right direction. We know where we have to go, but there will have to be changes. The culture of accountability in the organisation and the real governance agenda of building on our strengths but waking up others to the culture that needs to be in the organisation will be a continuing challenge for me. You can be assured that I will meet that challenge to the best of my ability.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Convener · Angus
link

We are dealing with services that affect us all and our wider communities. This meeting is not the end of the process. The committee will now consider the evidence that we have received. We will decide what further evidence or information we need and we will produce recommendations for action. A report will be produced as soon as possible within an appropriate time scale. I thank all the witnesses. The session has been long, but important information has been given to us. That decision makers are accountable very publicly and openly is an important part of the new Scottish democracy. I thank members of the public who have attended. I know and share their concerns and very much appreciate their presence today. They have helped to make this the best attended meeting of the Audit Committee to date. That is a good sign. I thank the staff of Dundee City Council for their hospitality and efforts in facilitating this meeting and the Parliament staff who have helped to make the meeting possible.

Meeting adjourned until 16:05 and continued in private until 16:20.

  1. Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Monday 2 April 2001 Committee business · 2
  2. National Health Service (Tayside) Committee business · 540

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.