Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 3 November 1999 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 123 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Showing Michael Russell only · show everyone

Michael Russell’s contributions

23 contributions
Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I gave notice to Gillian Baxendine and to you that I would like to have an investigation into the national funded arts companies in order to assist in the process of deciding which companies should be funded. I know that that topic is on the work programme already, but the matter has moved on since it was first included, so we should address it in the near future.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

It is important that the minister discusses the national companies, and particularly Scottish Opera, with us next week. Cathy is correct: the crisis surrounding Scottish Opera, on which the committee and others should have more information, is one issue in a complex web of issues, such as the merger and the possibility that debt will be carried into it. Brian Monteith is right to say that there is an active debate on a national theatre. The Scottish Arts Council and the companies constantly complain that there is a shortage of money for the national companies. Cathy Peattie is right that the committee should take formal evidence over a couple of meetings on those issues and produce a report on the national companies. That would help the debate, and open up the issue of what has happened at Scottish Opera, in the hope that it does not happen again, because members will know that this is the third occasion on which the company has faced such a crisis.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

It is absolutely right that a briefing by Parliament researchers on the national companies—on the present status, the history, the funding, and the issue of a national theatre—should be circulated to the committee.I notice that the committee is due to meet on 17 November and 23 November. Those two meetings might allow us to take evidence and draw up a report that could be ready for the beginning of December. However, I make a truly personal plea that, as the meeting on 23 November is scheduled to be at the same time as the Parliamentary Bureau meeting, the timing of our meeting be changed.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Perhaps we can give Gillian Baxendine information on people to whom we might want to talk. For example, I am sure that Equity will want to be heard on the national theatre, and we must be certain to ask the trade unions to be part of the inquiry. The Broadcasting, Entertainment, Cinematograph and Theatre Union has expressed great concern. There is concern that trade unions and those who work in the cultural industries are often the last to be consulted. I want to hear representatives of a variety of unions, including the Musicians Union, on all those matters

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Fiona is right. There is no doubt that the lack of information has been scandalous. Essentially, next week is the last chance for the minister to provide us not only with the information that we need, but with the information that the public need. The creation of a debentures millionaire is the latest thing about which people in Scotland are stunned. There might be a case later on—but I am not making a formal proposal—in the light of the Scotland v England ticket sales fiasco, for us to examine the whole question of the running of Scottish football. I am sure that we would be greatly assisted by Ian Welsh, who is an expert in the matter. There is much public concern about football, and the football authorities seem, as it were, to be kicking themselves in the shins.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

We have been meeting since May. We must get to grips with what a committee is for. Why does this committee exist? It exists because it has a number of defined roles within the Parliament. Those roles can be broken down. The first role is legislative. As the improvement in Scottish education bill is scrutinised by this committee, it will need serious attention; we will need to take evidence at the pre-legislative stage. When the bill is introduced, it will be our responsibility to produce a stage 1 report. We must request from the minister his proposed time scale for introducing the bill and we must find the time for our work on it. Let us call that role A.Role B is to instigate legislation. We can produce committee bills. At any time, a proposal for a bill can be referred to us by any member of this committee and we would have to consider it. In those circumstances, we should have a constructive discussion about any legislative change that we think that we could bring about as a committee. To do that, we might have to inquire into certain areas, rather than simply have a seminar on this or a briefing on that. The question is this: what change could we bring about as a committee? If we can focus on that, the topics for inquiry will become self-evident.Role C is to right wrongs—to look into things that are difficult and to discern whether we can help. It is wrong to define our task as this paper does—although I am grateful to have the paper—as some sort of short or medium-term inquiry. That is all about inputs. We should be examining the outputs for which this committee has responsibility.Our main task, between now and next summer, is to scrutinise the bill. We must examine it clause by clause. As some people have said, it may have deficiencies. We might want to pre-empt our work by talking to some of those people about what they think. We are receiving the information. We should consult some of the people who are providing information now, to get ahead of ourselves. That is the first timetabling priority.Our second task is to inform the Executive about priorities, if we think that we can make a difference. The most important issue on the list is school infrastructure. Nobody has really taken on the task of saying to the Executive how it could address that. We could suggest new thinking, new ideas—I hesitate to say it, but modern ideas and a modernisation of the issue—and we could take evidence in a way in which the Government never could. People will talk to us, and we can visit people. That seems to be a way in which this committee could make a difference.No member of this committee has yet produced any legislative ideas. We should ask members whether there is something that we can do. That will entail an inquiry. In terms of shorter inquiries for the righting of wrongs, we have already agreed to hold an inquiry on the national arts companies. That is good. We could also have an inquiry into special needs. That would allow us to make an impact in that area, as we all want to do. A shorter inquiry need not be limited to two or three meetings; it would just not be the main work that we are doing. In the context of the bill, we can consider the Gaelic language. Some organisations might be happy if we were to assist in that matter.There are one or two other areas within our remit. We have a role in monitoring what the Executive is doing. We must examine issues such as the national cultural strategy to determine whether we can jolly the Executive along, make comments or give assistance. If those issues become the subject of legislation, we must get involved in that process. We can also send members away—with a bit of research help—to look into issues that might inform the committee. That is the purpose of a rapporteur: to inform the committee without tying up all its time. There are some items on this list for which that would be helpful.I plead with you, convener, and with the committee, for the clearest and most rigorous timetable for the things that we know that we have to do. If we occasionally interview people whose evidence seems to be of interest at the time, or if we take endless briefings from people who simply want to put their spin on things, we will be wasting our precious time. Rigour must be brought to bear now.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I agree with Sylvia, but she raises an issue relating to standing orders. Any member is entitled to attend this committee—Sylvia is very welcome to attend on each occasion that this committee meets. There is, however, meant to be a political balance on the committees—that has been agreed by the bureau. There is now regularly an additional member at meetings who has—properly—speaking rights. That diminishes the time available for other members of the committee.I respect Sylvia's interest in this and I think that she would be a valuable member of the committee, but if the Labour party wants her to be a member, the quid pro quo is that someone else from another party should also be a member. That would leave those charged with membership of the committee with a reduced role.I say that for the record so that the parties will consider it, and not to Sylvia personally, for whom I have great respect and whose contribution I am glad to hear.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I raised the point so that it would be recorded. There is an issue regarding the operation of committees. The standing orders, as I understand them, were designed to allow any member to address an issue in a committee. They were not designed to allow for additional full-time members. I welcome Sylvia's contribution, but we do not want to end up with the balance of committees being disrupted.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Ian has moved us on substantially, which is valuable.As Nicola Sturgeon pointed out, we need a focus and a timetable. We must leave this meeting with an absolutely clear idea of what we are doing. There is broad agreement that school infrastructure and special educational needs should be investigated first and that we should continue to take evidence on the bill. Jamie should be the reporter on rural schools. The purpose of a rapporteur is not to end the discussion on a subject but to begin it. A rapporteur on Scottish film could identify the issues that needed to be discussed.I mention one final point on the curriculum, because curriculum issues are important. The teaching of Scottish history is an issue that concerns all parties. Reports on the issue have become politicised. It would be interesting to have a report, perhaps from a member who has not shown great enthusiasm for the matter, on whether we should consider the issue. I chaired a book launch for Tom Devine in Edinburgh where the teaching of Scottish history became the main topic of discussion. It was raised by a range of people, some of whom were in favour and some of whom were against. The committee needs a report on whether it is an issue that we should consider and whether there should be a rapporteur. It would not be impossible to have five rapporteurs working during the winter and giving reports successively during the spring.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

The rapporteur on Scottish history would do that job for the committee.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

That also works the other way, Kenny. Our consideration of the bill may spin off issues into which we will want to inquire, but that will happen only if we allow flexibility for the process to feed either way. That seems to have been other committees' experience.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Reviews such as the national cultural strategy and the McCrone inquiry have been carried out or commissioned by the Government and we might want to comment on the recommendations of those reviews before they are implemented, or have some input into them. Nicola is right. As it is highly unlikely that we will agree with the McCrone committee, we will want to comment on its conclusions. On the other hand, we can have input into the national cultural strategy as ministers decide on the strategy's terms.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

There is a standing orders difficulty with meeting on a Saturday.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I know that there is going to be an increasing demand on resources for committee travel. There are resources this year. We will need to make an early decision about the programme of the infrastructure inquiry and a series of visits for the inquiry on special educational needs. It is very important that we have the chance to consider rural Scotland as well as the central belt when we investigate infrastructure.Rapporteurs also have the opportunity to apply for committee travel money—I know that Jamie will want to do so. Money is also available for advisers to the committee on key issues. We can put a convincing case for an adviser on either special educational needs or infrastructure—not for both. There is a lot of interest in special educational needs and a special adviser to the committee could undertake a survey of provision and give the committee specialist advice. I am happy to work with Mary and Gillian to organise that, because I have had some experience of that process.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

We could call officials and ministers responsible for spending money on infrastructure to give evidence. The inquiry is about finding out the present state of the infrastructure. It would be appropriate to take evidence on that in rural Scotland and outside Edinburgh. We could have an evidence session in Inverness or Oban.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

We can take evidence from people who have designed award-winning schools. Schools that are well designed and meet pupils' needs can give us a template on which to measure provision elsewhere. Lionacleit school in Benbecula is, by all accounts, one of the finest schools in Scotland in terms of facilities. Why does that school work and other schools do not? That relates to Cathy Peattie's point about community schools. What makes a good school?

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

I think that we should wait until later on. I thought that the committee was content with that.

Michael Russell SNP South of Scotland
link

Several committees are taking evidence on the Abolition of Poindings and Warrant Sales Bill and they are keeping each other informed so that members of all committees can attend. The conveners are also liaising. I propose that you liaise with the convener of the Equal Opportunities Committee on the matter.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 3 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 123
  3. Visits Committee business · 1
  4. Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 32
  5. Petition Petitions · 10
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  7. Invitations Committee business · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.