Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 3 November 1999 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 123 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Showing Mary Mulligan only · show everyone

Mary Mulligan’s contributions

37 contributions
Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

The first item on the agenda is the committee's work programme, which has proved difficult to work on, and on which I have received some comments. Do members who have not commented wish to do so?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Cathy, do you wish to expand on that?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We can take that on board later on, when we are looking at items for future discussion and inquiry. With regard to the national companies, members will be aware that the time that will be available to us at the end of November and the beginning of December will be curtailed by our involvement with the forthcoming education bill. I suggest that we hold a short inquiry—only a couple of meetings—to investigate the present situation of the national companies.Members will be consulted about people whom it would be appropriate to invite to answer questions and discuss the situation. We will probably set aside two meetings to conduct that inquiry. The committee will then put together a report giving our views and recommendations.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I am aware of that difficulty. We will provide members with the relevant information. That does not preclude them from raising points with the minister next week, as a meeting with her is also on the agenda.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I am sorry, Fiona. Is what we said on the national companies agreed?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

That is important. I think that everybody is agreed.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

The committee is aware that the Deputy Minister for Culture and Sport will attend the meeting next week. We have agreed that that meeting will examine the cultural strategy, but that the minister should also be asked to address the issue of Hampden. More information has come to light since we agreed that. Getting the relevant information at that meeting will be an important starting point, from which we can decide how to proceed. The difficulty will be how we timetable two inquiries at the same time.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I will bring you in shortly, Ian.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I have no doubt that we can ask the right questions. I will now say something on what I was going to ask Fiona originally: I am not sure that, at this stage, we could have a constructive discussion on what is going on, because we do not have all the information. I accept that the committee has been patient in trying to get questions answered and to obtain information. There are sensitive questions, which should be answered. Nicola's suggestions are about preparing the questions and information on which we would like to be briefed before next week's meeting. We could then put questions that would extract the information that we need. That is probably the most sensible way to go.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Some issues are so sensitive that it would not be appropriate to publish information. However, the minister would have to explain that to the satisfaction of the committee. Obviously, that will be her decision.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We wish that the Scotland team would do that.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

It is quite clear that it is the job of the Executive to sort out the matter. The committee's task is to ensure that the Executive does the job in the public interest. I think that we can strike a balance between those things; it is to be hoped that that will bring about a resolution of the situation. We will ask the questions and seek to provide the information before next week's meeting.We do not seem to have got very far. There is on-going discussion of our work plan. The intention is to identify one major area for investigation. We have agreed on one short, sharp inquiry, into the national companies, and we are looking for guidance from the committee on a longer inquiry, bearing in mind the role that we will be playing in scrutinising the improvement in Scottish education bill.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I am happy to record that comment.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

The time scale, which was not very clear, seems to be slipping. Committee members have flagged up special educational needs a number of times as an area of interest. There was nothing specific on it in the draft bill, but the Executive has indicated that it might consider it further. I am not sure whether we should start an inquiry on that issue, or whether we should wait to see what the Executive proposes, following the consultation process, before we decide whether we want to proceed with such an inquiry. I am happy to take members' views on that. We should not duplicate that work, given that we have several other issues to consider, but I feel strongly that we must tackle it. Several members wish to speak; I suggest that everyone be given an opportunity to comment on the revised work programme, following which we will try to order our priorities.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Mike was right to point out that there must be a purpose to any inquiries or evidence sessions. There must be a reason for the committee to conduct such exercises and we must be clear about what we want to achieve. We should bear that in mind when considering how to plan our work programme.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

My understanding of the standing orders is that they say that members can indicate whether they wish to attend committees of which they are not members. If that is the case, the member is entitled to take part in the discussions. It is not necessarily for us to decide on how that is operated. Your point has been recorded, Mike, and the appropriate place in which to take it up is the bureau.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

The interpretation of the rule has to be discussed by the bureau and some guidance has to be given to the committees.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I agree that special education and school infrastructure are the two things that people have identified as needing to be investigated. I said at the beginning that I was not sure how to deal with the issue of special education because we do not know what the outcome of the Executive's consultation process will be. However, I take on board the points that have been made about the committee's responsibility to dictate the agenda.I disagree with Ian Welsh about the use of individual reporters to make the reports. We have already taken evidence on consultation with children and Children in Scotland is preparing a report on that—I thought that Fiona McLeod might want to do some work on that, given her interest in the subject. A reporter could start the discussions on rural schools, as Nicola suggested, and if the issue becomes bigger, the committee could return to it later in the year. Jamie, would you like to do that?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Before we move on, can you remind me, Ian, of the other topics that you suggested?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

We will want to consider all aspects of infrastructure. The aspect that you mention is topical and we will want to pick up on it.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

It is an issue that needs to be given a bit more time. We may want to consider it once we have examined special educational needs and infrastructure. I am trying to restrict our programme of work so that we can focus on what we are doing.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I agree totally that your second suggestion is the best way forward.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

The committee will want to examine new ways of tackling subjects and perhaps we will follow Ian's suggestion in future inquiries. However, I tend to agree with Nicola that we should not duplicate the work that is going on. Perhaps it would be better to wait until we have a report to discuss.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I do not think that we need to make a decision on that just yet. We can ask exactly what the process will be and, if there are two stages, we might get involved after the first one. Do we agree that the two items on which we wish to proceed are special education and infrastructure?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Yes. The reporter on rural schools will be Jamie Stone. Fiona McLeod will report on consultation with children. I do not know whether Mike said yes or no to Scottish film.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Keenness is what we want. It was suggested that Karen Gillon should report on sport in school.Is there anything else that anyone was desperate to do? I ask you to bear in mind that you will be doing this alongside a large amount of other work.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Let us not get bogged down just yet in what we will be investigating. All those things are important and we must give them some time.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

That point was mentioned during our visit last week.

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

I have a final question before we round off this part of the meeting. Sylvia Jackson said that the Equal Opportunities Committee is also looking into special educational needs. Gillian, could we obtain the information that it has, rather than duplicate the effort? How could we ask that committee for it?

Mary Mulligan Lab The Convener · Linlithgow
link

Yes. That is important. Thank you for that information.

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 3 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 123
  3. Visits Committee business · 1
  4. Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 32
  5. Petition Petitions · 10
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  7. Invitations Committee business · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.