Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Wednesday 3 November 1999 Education, Culture and Sport Committee Procedure 123 contributions · 13 speakers

Speakers

Showing Nicola Sturgeon only · show everyone

Nicola Sturgeon’s contributions

12 contributions
Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Fiona is right to press the matter. The situation has been going on for some time and, for a variety of reasons, we have continued to put the matter back. There might be a compromise. The Deputy Minister for Culture and Sport is coming next week. If we take on board one or two suggestions, we can probably find a way forward. Could we ask the minister or the Executive to provide us with certain pieces of information prior to the minister's appearance next week, so that we know what questions are pertinent and how to ensure that we get the answers? It would be good to have a section in next week's meeting, after the minister's evidence—timetabled on the agenda—to discuss what action, if any, the committee wants to take, so that, if we decide that the minister's answers have not satisfied our concerns, we can make progress on the matter. Fiona's two suggestions provide us with a way forward.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Fiona has made the case well, and she is absolutely right. At this meeting, the committee should make it clear to Rhona Brankin what information we expect to be provided with. If the minister does not supply us with that information, we as a committee will have to make our views known. We cannot get any further by discussing the issue today, but we must make it clear that we expect the information to be provided in advance of her appearance next week.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

The paper on the work programme is extremely good. It focuses attention on some areas of priority and gives us a clear idea of the direction in which we are heading. I suggested two additional areas under "Topics for major inquiries", which are not in my version of the paper, although I think that Gillian Baxendine included them in a revised version of the paper. For members who have an old version of the paper, those topics were: the role and operation of Her Majesty's inspectorate of schools and an examination of the further protection that can be given to small and rural schools. With those two additions, the paper is on the right lines. I want to make some suggestions about the areas that we should prioritise. It is estimated that we could handle two short inquiries—perhaps three at most. We already agreed the subject of the funding of the national arts companies, but I would suggest another two subjects, which are, in order of priority, a report on special educational needs, which is an extremely important subject, and the response to the Executive's cultural strategy, which is a pressing matter. I have three suggestions for "Topics for reporters", although there might be some discussion about how much work is possible. Those suggestions are: consultation with young people, which we have discussed on a number of occasions, the Scottish film industry and rural schools. While I suggested rural schools under "Topics for major inquiries", I doubt that we will have time to undertake that as a major inquiry in the forthcoming parliamentary year. It might be appropriate to start that work with an initial examination by a reporter, with a view to having a major inquiry later. Finally, under "Topics for major inquiries", I suggest that the most important issue is school infrastructure, given the scale of the problem. I suggest that that should be our first major inquiry, which might involve taking evidence outwith Edinburgh. As part of the overall investigation, I wish to suggest another subject that we should examine—I make this suggestion from an educational point of view, not from a party political point of view. At an appropriate point during that inquiry, we should examine and report on the Glasgow schools private finance initiative and its impact on education. We must decide how we will deal with a couple of other issues, such as the McCrone committee. I note that the paper says that the Scottish Joint Negotiating Committee will come up in the context of the education bill. However, as far as I can gather, that is not certain. Although the minister has said that he intends to make proposals on the abolition of the SJNC, he has yet to say when he will do that. The consultation process on the education bill has now finished and there is a question mark over how SJNC reform is to be factored into that bill.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I am aware that the discussion is beginning to become rather wide-ranging again. I reiterate Mike Russell's point. We need to focus on the issues outlined in the paper. We have had umpteen stabs at it and we have all had our say, but we are not here to decide what we find interesting as individuals. If we want to do that, perhaps we should go away and do a PhD on some of the subjects that have been mentioned. Mike was right to outline our roles and we must focus on our priorities. If we were to set our priorities outwith the confines of the paper, I would be worried.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

There are all sorts of things that we should do, but we do not have time to do them all. This meeting is about pinning down priorities. The issue of being school focused is important; indeed, the SNP has made that point in relation to the education bill.Performance indicators represent a big part of the bill's proposals, so we have an opportunity to examine that issue. All Karen's points are valid and we would tackle them all if we had all the time in the world, but we do not have that time and I think that we should start to pin down our priorities.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Obviously, Scottish history is an important topic, but I suggest that we leave a major inquiry into it until the next parliamentary year, possibly taking the Scottish Consultative Council on the Curriculum report on culture and history in the curriculum as a starting point.A major inquiry into infrastructure is very important. I want to record my desire to include a purely objective examination of the educational impact of the private finance initiative deal in Glasgow as part of that inquiry.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

We will get a stab at some of the issues when we consider the bill.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

We have a straight choice regarding the McCrone committee. Either we make a submission to it—although the chances of the two committees agreeing are probably quite slim—or we ask the minister to ensure that a copy of the McCrone report comes to this committee at the same time as he and the other parties involved receive the document, so that we can examine it properly. That is probably the appropriate way to proceed.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I disagree with Ian. I was very critical about the establishment of the McCrone committee and still have deep reservations about its chances of success. Ian's suggestion would only duplicate the committee's work and probably would not add much value to the process. It would be far more constructive for the committee to comment on the McCrone report when it is submitted.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

If I can be helpful for the umpteenth time today, might I suggest a compromise? If the McCrone committee follows the same pattern as the Cubie committee—we do not know if it will—and has two stages in its consultation process, we could reconsider the matter at the end of the first stage and decide whether we want to have an input at that time.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

As part of the investigation into infrastructure, can we ask for permission to go outside Edinburgh to take evidence in different parts of the country?

  1. Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 3 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Work Programme Procedure · 123
  3. Visits Committee business · 1
  4. Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 32
  5. Petition Petitions · 10
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  7. Invitations Committee business · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.