I disagree—
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Ian Welsh only · show everyone- Mary Mulligan Lab 37
- Michael Russell SNP 23
- Ian Welsh Lab 14
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 12
- Jamie Stone LD 8
- Brian Monteith Con 7
- Fiona McLeod SNP 7
- Ken Macintosh Lab 5
- Cathy Peattie Lab 3
- Ian Jenkins LD 3
- Gillian Baxendine Clerk to the Committee 2
- Karen Gillon Lab 1
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 1
Ian Welsh’s contributions
14 contributionsNicola's approach is much more sensible, with respect. I would be happy to see a briefing note or statement prepared by the Executive, to show the extent to which there is a move towards a conclusion in the negotiations on what is clearly a package to rescue the project. I am very unhappy, however, about our levering ourselves into what may be delicate negotiations at this stage. I am perfectly happy to have a view taken on the matter at the appropriate time, but I do not think that this is the appropriate time. However, it is the appropriate time for the minister to give us a full and clear briefing on progress to date. I concur with Nicola to that extent.
I want to reiterate that I do not think that we should attempt to lever ourselves into the delicate negotiations that might still be going on. Irrespective of what Fiona says about the need for information—I am as pleased as the next person to receive information—I would prefer a resolution of the Hampden situation without further undue controversy.
I will concentrate on special needs. I am wary of waiting for the Executive to respond on special needs. My experience is that Governments talk up the issue but deliver at a very low level. We cannot yet judge whether this Executive will deliver more than any previous Government.I would be concerned about restricting ourselves to considering the Riddell report, important though it is. There is a broader issue about the integration of children with special educational needs. I am concerned that we do not take a top-down approach. The matter concerns families, school adaptations, auxiliary support, additional teaching support, teacher training, school ethos indicators and a range of other factors. The basic issue, as I have indicated before, concerns human rights. Some of the smaller, curricular issues do not concern me. However, we should treat the strategic issues seriously. For me, they will be an indicator of whether the Scottish Executive is serious about social inclusion. That would be a major inquiry and, if I had to plump for any, that is the one that I would plump for.
It might be helpful if we were to crystallise the discussion. I have jotted down an idea and I wonder whether the committee would like to take a view on it.I think that national companies, school infrastructure and special educational needs are issues that the committee should examine in depth. To try to reflect the balance of the committee, three reporters could produce a report each. For example, one could be on sport in schools, one on Scottish film and one on consulting young people. In view of the range of issues that we have to deal with, it would be useful to deal with things in bite-sized chunks.
Before we make a decision on a rapporteur for Scottish history, I would like us to invite a delegation from the organisation responsible for the delivery of history teaching in Scottish schools to tell us what goes on.
Yes, but it would be an interesting conversation for those who do not know what is taught in history in Scottish schools to have before we took a decision—I speak as a trained history teacher.
I would prefer to hear what the professionals have to say about the issue first. Afterwards, the committee can take a view as to whether the teaching of history is inadequate or not.
I suggested three issues that rapporteurs could examine: sports in schools, Scottish film and consultation, which you picked up on. I had forgotten that Children in Scotland was coming back to the committee. The bigger issues were special educational needs, national companies and school infrastructure.
I disagree with Nicola. I think that we will have substantial agreement on the McCrone submission. However, that is a matter for another day.Presumably the report will have two consultation phases. The Education, Culture and Sport Committee could invite a range of interested parties to a day session—perhaps on a Saturday and perhaps not here. We could then submit the record of those events to the McCrone committee. That would be a productive way to engage in the debate and it would allow the community to participate in the process.
Nicola and I obviously disagree on that point.
The session could take place on any day.
My point is that there would be no duplication.
So that we do not focus too narrowly on whether there is a hole in the roof—although that is important—we must bear in mind what constitutes an adequate school. That relates to car parking, up-to-date technology resources, libraries and other issues.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Nov 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 3 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 123
- Visits Committee business · 1
- Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 32
- Petition Petitions · 10
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
- Invitations Committee business · 23
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.