I have a slight difficulty with that. Ultimately, the buck stops with us—we are the law makers in Scotland. For any minister in any department to say to any committee of this Parliament that information cannot be supplied to it is very dangerous. If the matter is sensitive, we should see the information and hear evidence in camera. There is an important principle at stake. I am not as well acquainted as are members across the table with the issue in question—if I see a football, I run—but this is where I pop my head above the parapet.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Jamie Stone only · show everyone- Mary Mulligan Lab 37
- Michael Russell SNP 23
- Ian Welsh Lab 14
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 12
- Jamie Stone LD 8
- Brian Monteith Con 7
- Fiona McLeod SNP 7
- Ken Macintosh Lab 5
- Cathy Peattie Lab 3
- Ian Jenkins LD 3
- Gillian Baxendine Clerk to the Committee 2
- Karen Gillon Lab 1
- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 1
Jamie Stone’s contributions
8 contributionsI echo what Mike Russell has said. He has given an incisive view of the role of this committee and we should take that up and run with it. As both Mike and Nicola have said, we have asked about infrastructure before; Sam Galbraith himself responded by saying that the issue should be considered. Nicola talked about rural schools. In Highland region, we have been through a tortuous process in recent years, as it became almost an annual fixture to shut a number of schools. Last time, thank goodness, we saw off that threat, but for the sake of children and their parents and communities this committee must make a contribution to solving the problem. The system simply cannot go on. Not only does it cause huge upset, but the removal of a school can gut a small rural community. When a little place such as Drumbeg loses its school, it is in trouble.I do not know whether we should change the powers that the Secretary of State for Scotland used to have or whether we should legislate to give different pointers to councils. I would like some advice about that. The process of closing rural schools may have stopped in Highland, but it is still going on in Argyll. If we believe in education in its broadest sense, I urge committee members to make the closure of rural schools a priority issue. It matters a great deal in my part of the world.
Sure, I guess that Fiona and I would be equally interested in that.I want to emphasise a point that Karen Gillon made. This is the Education, Culture and Sport Committee and part of the solution to the problem of rural school closures would be to push together the different aspects of our committee to create units with many uses in communities. We should remember our wider responsibility. Lots of councils missed the opportunity to work together and pool their budgets. The consultation document is called "Improving our Schools", but it deals only with education and ignores the opportunities to link in with other areas.
Does that mean that Mike can do us a film for free?
A delegation would take up more committee time.
I agree.
I have a question for Gillian. What Mike says about infrastructure is correct, although I suspect that we are going to travel around looking at holes in roofs and speaking to directors of education who say that their revenue budgets are not big enough. What are we going to do about the Treasury side of the matter? Ultimately, it comes down to the public sector borrowing requirement, or private finance initiatives, or both. I suspect that we will need to have some financial input on the subject and I want to know how we go about getting that.
We could go to Thurso.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Nov 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Education, Culture and Sport Committee Wednesday 3 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 123
- Visits Committee business · 1
- Improvement in Scottish Education Bill Bill debate · 32
- Petition Petitions · 10
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
- Invitations Committee business · 23
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.