Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Devolution Review

Thursday 6 December 2007 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 191 contributions · 38 speakers

Speakers

Showing Michael Russell only · show everyone
14 more speakers

Michael Russell’s contributions

5 contributions
Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link
The debate has clearly been more about heat than light. I was entertained, however, by the vying for who was one's favourite Englishman. I am sure that Elaine Murray's husband, whom I know, is an effective councillor. He would be on my shortlist. Members of my family would be on my shortlist. However, I will be voting for Cathy Jamieson's nomination. As you know, Presiding Officer, when I hum along to my favourite songs, I often hum along to this particular verse from Billy Bragg:

"Britain isn't cool you know, it's really not that great.
It's not a proper country, it doesn't even have a patron saint.
It's just an economic union that's passed its sell-by date."

Those are the words of my favourite Englishman.

Time is short, and I want to mention two speeches in particular. George Foulkes made the best speech that I have heard him make in this chamber.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link
That is indeed not much, as the Deputy First Minister says, but it was a good speech. If I may use this term kindly, it was the bellowing of a devolutionist mammoth. George Foulkes has a long history in the movement to move Scotland forward. He has given distinguished service. Obviously, however, he represents part of the Labour Party that is deeply uncomfortable with continued change.

I enjoyed the contribution from Kenny Gibson. If I am to call George Foulkes a mammoth, I should probably call Kenny Gibson a tyrannosaurus rex. He made an important point about scaremongering, which has dragged the debate down from time to time. Members should remember the reality of modern Europe, as Kenny Gibson said. This March, I travelled from Copenhagen to Malmö by train in 45 minutes. There were no border guards; there was no need for us to show our passports. People commute from one country to another. That is modern Europe, and modern Europe needs a modern Scotland as an independent country.

Like the Deputy First Minister, I am delighted that other parties are converted to the Parliament's having more powers. I acknowledge that there are members, not just in the SNP, who have always fought for more powers in the Parliament. Some of us were converted to supporting more powers for the Parliament even before it existed. I was converted in February 1974, when I joined the SNP. Others are even longer in the tooth in their support for more powers for this Parliament.

If members are genuinely in favour of more powers for the Parliament, they must be converted to another concept as well: the primacy of the Scottish people to decide their future. Those two things go hand in hand. The real problem with the motion is that it has no place for the Scottish people. It has a place for the great and the good, and a place for the independent expert, but it has no place for the voters of Scotland. If members believe in the primacy of the Scottish people, they cannot vote for the motion.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link
I am sorry, but I want to make progress.

There is a substantial difference between the content of the motion and the national conversation. The motion would set up a commission with no public involvement. Let me tell members about the public involvement to date in the national conversation: 43,734 hits, 245,567 hits on the theme pages, 20,993 call-ups for the white paper and 6,999 downloads. There have even been 2,639 comments on the ministers' blogs. This morning I noticed six on mine.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link
Only one comment was from Mr Fraser.

Failure to recognise the fact of democracy holes the motion below the waterline. Its programme, when it is examined in the cold democratic light of day, fails. It fails in another light, too. Presiding Officer, I know that you are familiar with the concept of Occam's razor: all things being equal, the simplest solution is often the best. If we pare down the motion, we find that what it offers is far from being the best solution.

First, the motion's content fails. It proposes a commission. For how long? The motion does not say. How many members should it have? How will we choose them? It does not say. How much will it cost? It does not say. Where will the money come from? It does not say. What will the role of Westminster be? It does not say. At the end of the process, to whom will the commission report? The motion does not say. What mechanism exists to translate any conclusions into law? It does not say. The only thing that the motion tells us is that the Scottish people will have no role in the process.

Michael Russell SNP The Minister for Environment · South of Scotland
link
I suggest that Mr Smith add that to our blog, and we will give him an answer.

The motion fails the test of Occam's razor in another, very significant way. If I may introduce another medieval philosopher to the discussion, the motion is the equivalent of angels dancing on the head of a pin. There is no logic or sense in what it proposes. The simplest and best solution to the problems that Scotland faces is not another commission, nor is it a debate on devolution. The simplest and best solution is independence, and that is the choice that the Scottish people should be asked to make. That is the time-honoured, tried and tested way in which nations throughout the world go about their business. The mental contortions that we have heard from other parties prove that independence is the best way forward. Independence is about freeing Scotland, but it is also about freeing the minds of the people of Scotland and freeing the democratic potential of the people of Scotland.

I invite the parties behind the motion to think again. If they can come up with a genuine way of discussing Scotland's future, this party will take part in that. We invite them to take part in and contribute to the national conversation. We invite them to move out of the cloudy valleys of constitutional guddling that they are locked into and to come up on to the heights, where they can see a real vision for Scotland.

What we have heard today has been deeply disappointing. The motion contains another trap for the Scottish people. The only way that the Scottish people move forward is to vote. They voted on 3 May and chose a new Government. They will vote to choose a new nation.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 December 2007 Debate · 1
  2. Devolution Review Debate · 191
  3. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  4. Schools (Funding) Questions · 10
  5. Armed Services Veterans Questions · 6
  6. Broadband Connections Questions · 6
  7. Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 7
  8. Railways (Glasgow-Shotts-Edinburgh Line) Questions · 8
  9. Universities (Funding) Questions · 4
  10. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  14. Trump International Golf Links Project First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 14
  16. Tackling Anti-Semitism First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  18. National Health Service (Scottish Budget) Questions · 8
  19. Antidepressants Questions · 10
  20. Affordable Housing Questions · 9
  21. National Health Service Dental Care Questions · 11
  22. Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing (Meetings) Questions · 13
  23. Central Heating Programme (Additional Funding) Questions · 8
  24. Health (Consultation) Questions · 10
  25. Modernising Medical Careers Questions · 4
  26. Ambulances (Infection Control) Questions · 4
  27. Osteoporosis (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
  28. Central Heating Programme (Scottish Gas Contract) Questions · 7
  29. Summary Justice Reform Debate · 24
  30. Committee of the Regions and the Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (Membership) Debate · 4
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 26
  32. Scouting Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.