I hope that it was not Tricia Marwick who had my minute.
Official Report · Chamber
Devolution Review
Speakers
Showing Elaine Murray only · show everyone- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 18
- Alex Fergusson 15
- Tricia Marwick SNP 11
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 11
- Wendy Alexander Lab 9
- Brian Adam SNP 9
- Annabel Goldie Con 8
- George Foulkes Lab 8
- Jackie Baillie Lab 7
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 7
- Murdo Fraser Con 6
- Iain Smith LD 6
- Trish Godman Lab 6
- Ross Finnie LD 6
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 5
- Rob Gibson SNP 5
- Michael Russell SNP 5
- Sandra White SNP 4
- Elaine Murray Lab 4
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 3
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 3
- Cathy Jamieson Lab 3
- David McLetchie Con 3
- Karen Gillon Lab 3
14 more speakers
- Ian McKee SNP 3
- Alex Neil SNP 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Robert Brown LD 2
- Nicol Stephen LD 2
- Bruce Crawford SNP 2
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Pauline McNeill Lab 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 2
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 1
- Margaret Curran Lab 1
- Richard Lochhead SNP 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
Elaine Murray’s contributions
4 contributionsApparently it was.
In his opening speech, Nicol Stephen referred to the situation in Spain. A dozen years or so ago, I had an interesting discussion about national identity with a friend from Madrid, who said that he was perfectly comfortable with his triple identity as a madrileño, a Spaniard and—most important for him—a supporter of Real Madrid.
In the eight years since the advent of the Scottish Parliament, I and—I believe—the majority of the Scottish people are becoming easier with our identity within the UK. Like Annabel Goldie, I have no problem with supporting Scotland at the Commonwealth games and Britain at the Olympic games. I do not believe that patriotism is exclusive.
The relationship between Scotland and the rest of the UK is developing and maturing and we need to move away from acting like a jealous younger sibling, perpetually whingeing and complaining that big brother is bullying him. I am sorry to say that Kenny Gibson exemplified that very attitude in his speech. Scotland is better than that; we can have an adult partnership of equals in respect if not in size. In the same way, the relationship between this Parliament and the UK Parliament must also develop and mature, despite the Scottish Government's propensity for picking fights with Westminster.
If devolution is growing up, it is appropriate for both partners to review progress. As Pauline McNeill pointed out, since 1999, powers have transferred from Westminster to Holyrood without the need for a referendum or a national conversation. However, today's motion, which is supported by three parties in the chamber, proposes the establishment of a commission to reflect on the experience of devolution. The reason why we have not come forward with a series of proposals is that we expect the commission to consider all the possibilities.
However, we must also recognise that any subsequent action must necessarily be a matter for discussion, negotiation and agreement between the partners in the UK. The national conversation, on the other hand, is nothing more than a Trojan horse designed to bring in independence.
As England is Scotland's largest trading partner, our relationship with England is integral to the Scottish economy's performance. However, that relationship is not just about the economy but about people. Two million people of Scottish origin reside south of the border, and half a million English people live in Scotland. As I represent a border constituency, it is not surprising that a significant number of my constituents are English—including, indeed, my own favourite Englishman. I believe that, in the SNP's proposed independence referendum, the treatment of those half a million English people living in Scotland and the 2 million Scots living in England would be seriously asymmetrical. For example, much as I would have liked to, I was unable to vote in the 1979 referendum simply because I was living in Cambridge. However, in a referendum on Scottish independence, my English husband would be able to vote on whether he became a foreigner in his nation of residence, while my Scottish sister, my Scottish aunt and my Scottish second cousin, who all live in England, would be deprived of a vote on their national status.
Changes in the relationship between Scotland and England affect both nations and should be discussed and negotiated between them. [Interruption.]
In his opening speech, Nicol Stephen referred to the situation in Spain. A dozen years or so ago, I had an interesting discussion about national identity with a friend from Madrid, who said that he was perfectly comfortable with his triple identity as a madrileño, a Spaniard and—most important for him—a supporter of Real Madrid.
In the eight years since the advent of the Scottish Parliament, I and—I believe—the majority of the Scottish people are becoming easier with our identity within the UK. Like Annabel Goldie, I have no problem with supporting Scotland at the Commonwealth games and Britain at the Olympic games. I do not believe that patriotism is exclusive.
The relationship between Scotland and the rest of the UK is developing and maturing and we need to move away from acting like a jealous younger sibling, perpetually whingeing and complaining that big brother is bullying him. I am sorry to say that Kenny Gibson exemplified that very attitude in his speech. Scotland is better than that; we can have an adult partnership of equals in respect if not in size. In the same way, the relationship between this Parliament and the UK Parliament must also develop and mature, despite the Scottish Government's propensity for picking fights with Westminster.
If devolution is growing up, it is appropriate for both partners to review progress. As Pauline McNeill pointed out, since 1999, powers have transferred from Westminster to Holyrood without the need for a referendum or a national conversation. However, today's motion, which is supported by three parties in the chamber, proposes the establishment of a commission to reflect on the experience of devolution. The reason why we have not come forward with a series of proposals is that we expect the commission to consider all the possibilities.
However, we must also recognise that any subsequent action must necessarily be a matter for discussion, negotiation and agreement between the partners in the UK. The national conversation, on the other hand, is nothing more than a Trojan horse designed to bring in independence.
As England is Scotland's largest trading partner, our relationship with England is integral to the Scottish economy's performance. However, that relationship is not just about the economy but about people. Two million people of Scottish origin reside south of the border, and half a million English people live in Scotland. As I represent a border constituency, it is not surprising that a significant number of my constituents are English—including, indeed, my own favourite Englishman. I believe that, in the SNP's proposed independence referendum, the treatment of those half a million English people living in Scotland and the 2 million Scots living in England would be seriously asymmetrical. For example, much as I would have liked to, I was unable to vote in the 1979 referendum simply because I was living in Cambridge. However, in a referendum on Scottish independence, my English husband would be able to vote on whether he became a foreigner in his nation of residence, while my Scottish sister, my Scottish aunt and my Scottish second cousin, who all live in England, would be deprived of a vote on their national status.
Changes in the relationship between Scotland and England affect both nations and should be discussed and negotiated between them. [Interruption.]
If there is ever to be a referendum on ending that partnership—
The member's point of order was not the point that I was making. As an Englishman in Scotland, he will get to vote in a referendum on independence, whereas a Scot who lives in England will not.
The history of the nations that make up the UK before and since 1707 is long and complex. It is a history of evolution and devolution. If agreed to, the proposals in this motion will begin the next chapter of the history of both Scotland and the UK.
The history of the nations that make up the UK before and since 1707 is long and complex. It is a history of evolution and devolution. If agreed to, the proposals in this motion will begin the next chapter of the history of both Scotland and the UK.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Dec 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 December 2007 Debate · 1
- Devolution Review Debate · 191
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Schools (Funding) Questions · 10
- Armed Services Veterans Questions · 6
- Broadband Connections Questions · 6
- Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 7
- Railways (Glasgow-Shotts-Edinburgh Line) Questions · 8
- Universities (Funding) Questions · 4
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Trump International Golf Links Project First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Tackling Anti-Semitism First Minister’s Questions · 8
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- National Health Service (Scottish Budget) Questions · 8
- Antidepressants Questions · 10
- Affordable Housing Questions · 9
- National Health Service Dental Care Questions · 11
- Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing (Meetings) Questions · 13
- Central Heating Programme (Additional Funding) Questions · 8
- Health (Consultation) Questions · 10
- Modernising Medical Careers Questions · 4
- Ambulances (Infection Control) Questions · 4
- Osteoporosis (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
- Central Heating Programme (Scottish Gas Contract) Questions · 7
- Summary Justice Reform Debate · 24
- Committee of the Regions and the Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (Membership) Debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Scouting Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.