Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Devolution Review

Thursday 6 December 2007 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 191 contributions · 38 speakers

Speakers

Showing Pauline McNeill only · show everyone
14 more speakers

Pauline McNeill’s contributions

2 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
I have supported home rule for Scotland for most of my adult life. I believe in and campaigned for devolution for Scotland. I never wavered from the idea that Scotland should be responsible for some of its affairs and that the best deal for Scots involves sharing some powers with the UK.

To listen to SNP members' speeches in the debate, we might think that that party is the only one that has a conviction about Scotland's future. Members of the Labour Party—indeed, members of all other parties—disagree. The parties that support devolution firmly believe in the devolved settlement. We have made it work and we want to make it better. That is why we are debating the motion.

Like other Labour Party members, I joined the Labour Party to bring about social change, not to fight for the constitution. However, when I was a student I volunteered to sit on the campaign for a Scottish assembly, which George Foulkes mentioned. The Parliament should honour the many people who contributed to that campaign and to the devolution settlement who are not often talked about—people such as Bob MacLean, Jim Boyack and Brian Duncan. I firmly believed then, as I do now, that devolution would improve the lives of Scots.

The campaign for a Scottish assembly did the groundwork for the establishment of the Scottish Constitutional Convention, which brought together political parties and organisations that had an interest in developing a blueprint for a framework that could be incorporated into an act of Parliament. It is to the credit of the political parties, churches, trade unions and people involved in civic life who participated in the convention that full agreement was reached. Those people ensured that there was a big difference between the 1979 proposal and the 1997 proposal, which became the Scotland Act 1998. It is incredible that the 1998 act adopted most of the convention's framework and that the Labour Government moved to a referendum within five months of coming into power. Of course, the Labour Government had the support of the people in holding a referendum—that is the difference. As members said, all that work took place without the involvement of the SNP, which stood on the sidelines. However, SNP members are patronising us about our conversion to the cause. What a cheek.

The debate is about the view of the vast majority of Scots, who support the devolution settlement but think that perhaps we should refine it. The real debate is how we can do that. The issue is too important to be reduced to a slagging match. The three main Opposition parties need to take on the real debate, which is how we respond to the people of Scotland and the improvements that they want in their lives. The motion sets out a position that I think the vast majority of Scots will support.

We cannot take new powers just for the sake of it; we must find out what changes would benefit Scotland, and we need a mechanism that can do that. The proposed commission would be such a mechanism and there is no reason why there could not be a mature discussion among participants, in partnership with the UK Government. If the Parliament agrees to set up a commission, we will enter a new phase of the devolution settlement, because there will be a review of the Constitutional Convention's blueprint, 20 years on. That seems to be the right direction of travel, but we should not get carried away with the idea that we should review the settlement every 10 or 20 years; we need to ensure that we get it permanently right.

The work of the leaders of Scottish political parties who have a mature relationship with their UK counterparts led to the lodging of the motion. We do not support the establishment of a commission for the sake of it; the approach is the right way forward. Devolution has changed along the way and we have transferred powers from the UK to Scotland without the need to use a mechanism such as a commission. At times we have thought it appropriate for the UK to legislate for Scotland.

I agree with Annabel Goldie that it is about time that we reclaimed the notion that the SNP has a monopoly on securing Scotland's future. The SNP is not good at sharing and does not want to do so in this debate. The introduction to the national conversation document gives the impression that there was no constitutional debate before the advent of the SNP Government. Scots are invited to support independence, although the SNP knows that they do not do so and that support for independence is falling dramatically.

We must start from the premise that devolution works and can work better and we should not collect powers from the UK for the sake of it. We must ascertain the best way forward.

We have been charged with proposing an uncosted commitment in the motion. Is that the best that the SNP can do? Cannot SNP members debate the politics—[Interruption.] Tricia Marwick is interrupting. She thinks that the Parliament's IT budget is more important than the constitution—such was the level of her contribution to the debate—

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow Kelvin
link
We should continue to improve the lives of the people of Scotland, tackling poverty and addressing the issues that people care about. The best way of doing that is by supporting the motion.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 December 2007 Debate · 1
  2. Devolution Review Debate · 191
  3. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  4. Schools (Funding) Questions · 10
  5. Armed Services Veterans Questions · 6
  6. Broadband Connections Questions · 6
  7. Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 7
  8. Railways (Glasgow-Shotts-Edinburgh Line) Questions · 8
  9. Universities (Funding) Questions · 4
  10. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  14. Trump International Golf Links Project First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 14
  16. Tackling Anti-Semitism First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  18. National Health Service (Scottish Budget) Questions · 8
  19. Antidepressants Questions · 10
  20. Affordable Housing Questions · 9
  21. National Health Service Dental Care Questions · 11
  22. Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing (Meetings) Questions · 13
  23. Central Heating Programme (Additional Funding) Questions · 8
  24. Health (Consultation) Questions · 10
  25. Modernising Medical Careers Questions · 4
  26. Ambulances (Infection Control) Questions · 4
  27. Osteoporosis (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
  28. Central Heating Programme (Scottish Gas Contract) Questions · 7
  29. Summary Justice Reform Debate · 24
  30. Committee of the Regions and the Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (Membership) Debate · 4
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 26
  32. Scouting Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.