Official Report · Chamber
Devolution Review
Speakers
Showing Iain Smith only · show everyone- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 18
- Alex Fergusson 15
- Tricia Marwick SNP 11
- Alasdair Morgan SNP 11
- Wendy Alexander Lab 9
- Brian Adam SNP 9
- Annabel Goldie Con 8
- George Foulkes Lab 8
- Jackie Baillie Lab 7
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 7
- Murdo Fraser Con 6
- Iain Smith LD 6
- Trish Godman Lab 6
- Ross Finnie LD 6
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 5
- Rob Gibson SNP 5
- Michael Russell SNP 5
- Sandra White SNP 4
- Elaine Murray Lab 4
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 3
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 3
- Cathy Jamieson Lab 3
- David McLetchie Con 3
- Karen Gillon Lab 3
14 more speakers
- Ian McKee SNP 3
- Alex Neil SNP 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Robert Brown LD 2
- Nicol Stephen LD 2
- Bruce Crawford SNP 2
- Sarah Boyack Lab 2
- Pauline McNeill Lab 2
- Jeremy Purvis LD 2
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 1
- Margaret Curran Lab 1
- Richard Lochhead SNP 1
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
Iain Smith’s contributions
6 contributionsBeing able to speak in this historic debate, which will help to determine the future direction not only of the Parliament but of our country, is a great opportunity for me.
There is a stark choice before us today, between a new constitutional commission to review and renew the devolution settlement and to create a stronger Scottish Parliament within the United Kingdom, and the cul-de-sac or siding of the neverendum and isolation of separation. We can have a genuine debate with civic Scotland and the Scottish people about the powers and responsibilities of the Parliament, or we can talk to ourselves on an internet chat site—the so-called national conversation. At 5 o'clock tonight, the Parliament can take control of the constitutional debate away from the minority Government and take control of our future, killing the national conversation stone dead.
The Government's amendment is wrong in what it aims to do, but it is also factually wrong. I cannot speak for the other parties, but we Liberal Democrats have not changed our position. Like the majority of Scots, we favour a strengthened Scottish Parliament and reject independence. It has been our consistent view that, during the third session of the Scottish Parliament, the devolution settlement should be reviewed in the light of experience. The Liberal Democrats have led the debate on the powers and responsibilities of the Scottish Parliament. For the benefit of Roseanna Cunningham, I say that in our manifesto we called for the establishment of a new Scottish constitutional convention.
In 2006, we published the report of the Steel commission, which sets out the arguments in favour of establishing such a convention. The report identifies areas in which the case for additional powers for the Scottish Parliament is already established and areas in which there is a need for further debate. It makes a clear case for the Parliament to have responsibility for raising most of the money that it spends, shows why it remains in Scotland's interest to be part of the United Kingdom and rejects the case for fiscal autonomy.
There is a stark choice before us today, between a new constitutional commission to review and renew the devolution settlement and to create a stronger Scottish Parliament within the United Kingdom, and the cul-de-sac or siding of the neverendum and isolation of separation. We can have a genuine debate with civic Scotland and the Scottish people about the powers and responsibilities of the Parliament, or we can talk to ourselves on an internet chat site—the so-called national conversation. At 5 o'clock tonight, the Parliament can take control of the constitutional debate away from the minority Government and take control of our future, killing the national conversation stone dead.
The Government's amendment is wrong in what it aims to do, but it is also factually wrong. I cannot speak for the other parties, but we Liberal Democrats have not changed our position. Like the majority of Scots, we favour a strengthened Scottish Parliament and reject independence. It has been our consistent view that, during the third session of the Scottish Parliament, the devolution settlement should be reviewed in the light of experience. The Liberal Democrats have led the debate on the powers and responsibilities of the Scottish Parliament. For the benefit of Roseanna Cunningham, I say that in our manifesto we called for the establishment of a new Scottish constitutional convention.
In 2006, we published the report of the Steel commission, which sets out the arguments in favour of establishing such a convention. The report identifies areas in which the case for additional powers for the Scottish Parliament is already established and areas in which there is a need for further debate. It makes a clear case for the Parliament to have responsibility for raising most of the money that it spends, shows why it remains in Scotland's interest to be part of the United Kingdom and rejects the case for fiscal autonomy.
As the SNP's national conversation wants only one answer, it is not a conversation—I will come on to discuss that later in my speech.
The work that the Liberal Democrats have already done through the Steel commission will form the basis of the work of the new constitutional commission, just as it was our work in the Scottish Constitutional Convention that paved the way for the Parliament. While the SNP sat on the sidelines sniping, it was the Liberal Democrats who helped to deliver Scotland's Parliament. Now we will work with the constitutional commission that is proposed in the motion to improve and strengthen the Parliament.
Scottish Liberal Democrats will propose a range of new powers for the Parliament. For example, it is self-evident that the Scottish Parliament should determine the rules on how we operate. We should not need an act of the UK Parliament to decide how many Deputy Presiding Officers we need. Those powers must include the ability to determine the electoral system for elections to the Scottish Parliament—subject to the proviso that it must continue to be a proportional system—and how those elections are run. After the fiasco of May, why should we trust the Scotland Office to run our elections again?
We should have full control over energy policy to enable us fully to develop our renewable energy potential and to resist nuclear power. Although we control our health service, we do not control the contracts of the doctors, nurses, dentists and other health professionals who work in it. We are now surely mature enough to take responsibility for Scotland's civil service.
The Liberal Democrats will ask the commission to look into whether there should also be devolution of powers in areas such as betting and gaming, marine policy and broadcasting. Powers could be shared with the UK Parliament to a greater or lesser extent in a range of other areas, particularly those in which UK-wide powers have a direct impact on devolved services.
The most fundamental area that needs to be addressed is that of the taxation powers of the Scottish Parliament, because the present arrangement is unsatisfactory and unacceptable. No democratically elected body should be wholly reliant on another for its revenue. To have our budget decided elsewhere—in effect, that is what happens—and to be responsible only for decisions on how to spend the money and not for decisions on how to raise it is not acceptable. Incidentally, that is as true of local government as it is of the Scottish Parliament. The SNP Government's decision to remove, in effect, local taxation from local government is wrong in principle and it will be resisted by our party.
To be properly accountable to the people who elect us, we must have responsibility for raising the money that we spend. That is why the Steel commission proposes a radical new fiscal settlement for Scotland that is based on the principles of transparency and accountability; of raising as much of our spending as practical ourselves; of having substantial authority over the levers of power that most affect the Scottish economy and protection of the environment; of having borrowing powers and fiscal responsibility within an agreed UK set-up; and of equalisation on the basis of need across the UK. The Steel commission rejects so-called fiscal autonomy.
I am sure that, in the course of its work, the commission will discuss the role of Scottish MPs at Westminster. I reject the suggestion that MPs who are elected to Westminster from Scotland should be restricted in what they can vote on. It is ultimately for England to determine what type of devolution, if any, it wishes to have. The UK Parliament must be just that—it must not be a hybrid, whereby it is a UK Parliament one minute and a Parliament for England or England and Wales the next.
I turn to the SNP's amendment. Today's debate is the first opportunity that the Parliament has had to pass judgment on the national conversation, which, according to what the minister in charge, Nicola Sturgeon, said in her letter to the European and External Relations Committee, is not a conventional consultation exercise and does not have "a specific end date." Indeed, she went on to say:
"The Government has not set a closing date for the consultation on the form of the conversation".
I ask Tricia Marwick how the Government can have a budget for the national conversation when it does not even know what it is or how long it will last. We are told that it is a two-way conversation with Government, but the truth is exposed on the national conversation blogsite, which states:
"The overall aim of the Government is to gather support for a referendum in the course of this Parliament."
It is not a conversation; it is simply a ruse to prevent debate on a referendum from being held in the Parliament.
The work that the Liberal Democrats have already done through the Steel commission will form the basis of the work of the new constitutional commission, just as it was our work in the Scottish Constitutional Convention that paved the way for the Parliament. While the SNP sat on the sidelines sniping, it was the Liberal Democrats who helped to deliver Scotland's Parliament. Now we will work with the constitutional commission that is proposed in the motion to improve and strengthen the Parliament.
Scottish Liberal Democrats will propose a range of new powers for the Parliament. For example, it is self-evident that the Scottish Parliament should determine the rules on how we operate. We should not need an act of the UK Parliament to decide how many Deputy Presiding Officers we need. Those powers must include the ability to determine the electoral system for elections to the Scottish Parliament—subject to the proviso that it must continue to be a proportional system—and how those elections are run. After the fiasco of May, why should we trust the Scotland Office to run our elections again?
We should have full control over energy policy to enable us fully to develop our renewable energy potential and to resist nuclear power. Although we control our health service, we do not control the contracts of the doctors, nurses, dentists and other health professionals who work in it. We are now surely mature enough to take responsibility for Scotland's civil service.
The Liberal Democrats will ask the commission to look into whether there should also be devolution of powers in areas such as betting and gaming, marine policy and broadcasting. Powers could be shared with the UK Parliament to a greater or lesser extent in a range of other areas, particularly those in which UK-wide powers have a direct impact on devolved services.
The most fundamental area that needs to be addressed is that of the taxation powers of the Scottish Parliament, because the present arrangement is unsatisfactory and unacceptable. No democratically elected body should be wholly reliant on another for its revenue. To have our budget decided elsewhere—in effect, that is what happens—and to be responsible only for decisions on how to spend the money and not for decisions on how to raise it is not acceptable. Incidentally, that is as true of local government as it is of the Scottish Parliament. The SNP Government's decision to remove, in effect, local taxation from local government is wrong in principle and it will be resisted by our party.
To be properly accountable to the people who elect us, we must have responsibility for raising the money that we spend. That is why the Steel commission proposes a radical new fiscal settlement for Scotland that is based on the principles of transparency and accountability; of raising as much of our spending as practical ourselves; of having substantial authority over the levers of power that most affect the Scottish economy and protection of the environment; of having borrowing powers and fiscal responsibility within an agreed UK set-up; and of equalisation on the basis of need across the UK. The Steel commission rejects so-called fiscal autonomy.
I am sure that, in the course of its work, the commission will discuss the role of Scottish MPs at Westminster. I reject the suggestion that MPs who are elected to Westminster from Scotland should be restricted in what they can vote on. It is ultimately for England to determine what type of devolution, if any, it wishes to have. The UK Parliament must be just that—it must not be a hybrid, whereby it is a UK Parliament one minute and a Parliament for England or England and Wales the next.
I turn to the SNP's amendment. Today's debate is the first opportunity that the Parliament has had to pass judgment on the national conversation, which, according to what the minister in charge, Nicola Sturgeon, said in her letter to the European and External Relations Committee, is not a conventional consultation exercise and does not have "a specific end date." Indeed, she went on to say:
"The Government has not set a closing date for the consultation on the form of the conversation".
I ask Tricia Marwick how the Government can have a budget for the national conversation when it does not even know what it is or how long it will last. We are told that it is a two-way conversation with Government, but the truth is exposed on the national conversation blogsite, which states:
"The overall aim of the Government is to gather support for a referendum in the course of this Parliament."
It is not a conversation; it is simply a ruse to prevent debate on a referendum from being held in the Parliament.
The motion's proposal for a constitutional commission is the most significant proposal since the Scotland Act 1998. The national conversation, on the other hand, is a farce that should be kicked into touch.
Despite the fact that the member is talking absolute nonsense about the Scottish people not having a role in the proposed commission—they will have—could he tell us—[Interruption.] This is about the remit of the commission, not how it will work. How can the member possibly say all that when, even after all these months, the Government has still not set a closing date for the consultation on the form of national conversation, let alone said what the national conversation will do and how much it will cost?
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Dec 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 December 2007 Debate · 1
- Devolution Review Debate · 191
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Schools (Funding) Questions · 10
- Armed Services Veterans Questions · 6
- Broadband Connections Questions · 6
- Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 7
- Railways (Glasgow-Shotts-Edinburgh Line) Questions · 8
- Universities (Funding) Questions · 4
- First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Trump International Golf Links Project First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Tackling Anti-Semitism First Minister’s Questions · 8
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- National Health Service (Scottish Budget) Questions · 8
- Antidepressants Questions · 10
- Affordable Housing Questions · 9
- National Health Service Dental Care Questions · 11
- Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing (Meetings) Questions · 13
- Central Heating Programme (Additional Funding) Questions · 8
- Health (Consultation) Questions · 10
- Modernising Medical Careers Questions · 4
- Ambulances (Infection Control) Questions · 4
- Osteoporosis (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
- Central Heating Programme (Scottish Gas Contract) Questions · 7
- Summary Justice Reform Debate · 24
- Committee of the Regions and the Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (Membership) Debate · 4
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Scouting Members’ business · 10
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.