Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Devolution Review

Thursday 6 December 2007 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 191 contributions · 38 speakers

Speakers

Showing David McLetchie only · show everyone
14 more speakers

David McLetchie’s contributions

3 contributions
David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link
This important debate is firmly focused on improving the government of Scotland, in the context of our partnership within the United Kingdom. That is what distinguishes Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat members from the separatists of the SNP, whose nationalist conversation—otherwise known as wee Eck's big blether—is firmly focused on the goal of independence. I put on record, for the benefit of Tricia Marwick, that if we need money to fund our commission, which the Parliament will have sanctioned and approved, we can fund it from her nationalist conversation, which the Parliament has not sanctioned or approved.

Independence is a perfectly honourable position, for which some people have argued with passion and conviction in the past. However, the same cannot be said of the timorous faint hearts in the modern SNP, for whom demonstrating competence in devolved Government is apparently a precondition of independence. For them, the long march to independence and freedom depends on how many potholes they can fill in on the road along the way. That is a strategy known as William Wallace meets Clarence.

One of the big problems with the constitutional debate is the language in which it is often conducted, which plays into a nationalist agenda. A prime example is the notion of "unfinished business", which encourages the view that, incrementally and inexorably, we are on a road to independence. However, from all tests of public opinion, not least this year's election to the Parliament, we know that that view is not shared by the overwhelming majority of our fellow Scots, who instinctively believe in and appreciate the value of the union and of being both Scottish and British. It is time that we spoke up for them, by defining the limits of devolution, the essence of the United Kingdom as a nation state and how that impacts on the division of competences and responsibilities between the Westminster Parliament and this Parliament.

I have no hesitation in saying that among the fundamental characteristics of the union are a constitutional monarchy; a united, democratically elected Government and Parliament; common defence and security arrangements; a common citizenship; a common currency; a UK central bank; a UK single market; common taxes to fund the responsibilities of national Government; and social security and welfare programmes that promote cohesion and unity and ensure equitable treatment across the nation as a whole. I do not pretend that that is a definitive list, but the principle behind my comments is that we need to demarcate the red, white and blue lines, because they define the essence of the united nation. If we do that, we achieve two highly desirable objectives. First, we define the essential difference between unionism and nationalism, and what that means in modern Scotland. Secondly, we are able to have a sensible debate about the distribution of competencies and responsibilities up to that line.

Another area that has been bedevilled by sloppy thinking is the assertion in the claim of right that Scotland has the unilateral right to determine its form of government. On that, I beg to differ. All peoples have the right of self-determination, and Scotland has the right, if it so decides, to choose independence. However, anything short of independence implies the continuance of a partnership with the other countries in the United Kingdom, as part of a unitary British state. It is an elementary principle that no one partner can dictate the terms of a partnership, which require the common consent of all parties. Let us recognise that the future government of Scotland is not a matter for simple assertion by Scots, but a matter for determination by all of us in the United Kingdom. That is why the commission to which the motion refers should be established by Her Majesty's Government, as part of a wider constitutional review that properly considers our neighbours' interests, as well as our own.

Another sloppy notion that should be banished forthwith is the concept of fiscal autonomy. As some have noted, that is an excellent name for an Irish folk singer but a wholly inappropriate description of the financial arrangements that should apply to a devolved or semi-federal system of government such as that which we have in the United Kingdom today. In principle, I think that we should have responsibility for raising a higher proportion of the revenues that we spend on devolved services, but let us recognise that the tartan tax is a dead letter. Only one party in one election since 1999 has been daft enough to propose increasing the rate of income tax in Scotland. That party was the Scottish National Party, with its ill-fated penny for Scotland policy, which was dreamed up in the happy days when Michael Russell ran SNP election campaigns.

The tartan tax should be finally and decently interred, and we should look to other taxes that might more appropriately be assigned to the Parliament—for example, taxes that are more likely to be decreased than increased. One such tax is stamp duty, a reduction in which would support our desire to help people on to the rungs of the home ownership ladder. Another is excise duties, as there is little prospect of a Scottish Government of any complexion increasing the taxes on whisky and petrol—it is far more likely to reduce them.

All the issues that I have raised are matters for consultation and careful consideration. Let us work with the mainstream of public opinion, not at its margins, and consider all these matters in partnership with our friends, neighbours and fellow citizens in the United Kingdom. That is the sensible way in which to proceed.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link
I thought that I had explained it. With the approval of Parliament, we can assign to the commission all the money that the SNP is spending on its nationalist conversation, which has no approval from the Parliament. There is more than enough money to do the job.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 6 December 2007 Debate · 1
  2. Devolution Review Debate · 191
  3. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  4. Schools (Funding) Questions · 10
  5. Armed Services Veterans Questions · 6
  6. Broadband Connections Questions · 6
  7. Edinburgh South Suburban Railway Questions · 7
  8. Railways (Glasgow-Shotts-Edinburgh Line) Questions · 8
  9. Universities (Funding) Questions · 4
  10. First Minister's Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
  14. Trump International Golf Links Project First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Council Tax Freeze First Minister’s Questions · 14
  16. Tackling Anti-Semitism First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  18. National Health Service (Scottish Budget) Questions · 8
  19. Antidepressants Questions · 10
  20. Affordable Housing Questions · 9
  21. National Health Service Dental Care Questions · 11
  22. Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing (Meetings) Questions · 13
  23. Central Heating Programme (Additional Funding) Questions · 8
  24. Health (Consultation) Questions · 10
  25. Modernising Medical Careers Questions · 4
  26. Ambulances (Infection Control) Questions · 4
  27. Osteoporosis (Ayrshire and Arran) Questions · 6
  28. Central Heating Programme (Scottish Gas Contract) Questions · 7
  29. Summary Justice Reform Debate · 24
  30. Committee of the Regions and the Regional Chamber of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe (Membership) Debate · 4
  31. Decision Time Decision time · 26
  32. Scouting Members’ business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.