The next continued petition is PE1786, which was lodged by Andrew Muir. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to investigate why there have been no prosecutions under either section 315 or section 318 of the Mental Health (Care and Treatment) (Scotland) Act 2003.
Since our last consideration of the petition, the committee has received submissions from the Scottish Government and the Mental Welfare Commission, and two from the petitioner. The commission’s submission notes that deaths of individuals who are the subject of compulsory treatment does not mean that those patients were ill treated, because the cause of death might be natural reasons, such as a pre-existing physical health condition. However, some of those deaths will be due to suicide. The commission also advises that there might be a variety of reasons behind consent not being obtained from a mental health officer.
10:30
The Scottish Government’s submission advises that during the period 2008 to 2020 Police Scotland reported one case to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service in which the charge was contrary to section 318 of the 2003 act. It further notes that court proceedings under section 315 were taken in respect of 69 charges that were reported to COPFS from 2007-08 until 2018-19. The petitioner believes that insufficient attention has been paid to the importance of ensuring that no one was improperly deprived of their liberty.
This is an important issue. There is a balance to be struck in such judgments between protecting a person and supporting their needs, and not infringing on people’s human rights. There are a lot of issues, but one that struck me is that it seems that the role of a mental health officers in signing off decisions varies in different parts of the country. I am not satisfied as to why that would be the case and why what the legislation says should happen does not happen, although an argument was given for why that might be the case. There is a question about how we take the issue forward: is there more the committee can do? I think that we recognise that there are important issues.
