The next continued petition on our agenda is PE1782, on full consultation on the stocking of salmon rivers, which was lodged by Robert White on behalf of the Scottish Gamekeepers Association’s fishing group. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that a full stakeholder consultation is carried out before Marine Scotland formalises its policy on the stocking of Scotland’s salmon rivers.
The Scottish Government’s submission in April explains the background to the current policy, including who was consulted.
The Scottish Government has contacted the clerks to say that the consultation that is referred to in our committee paper was on a different aspect of salmon conservation—on proposing river gradings for the 2021 fishing season—and was not related to the stocking of rivers. The Scottish Government has also highlighted to the clerks that officials wrote to the petitioner last week, inviting him to an initial meeting in order to hear the views of the Scottish Gamekeepers Association’s fishing group. The intention of that invitation is to help officials to understand the concerns better and to inform a wider consultation on stocking.
The petitioner has questioned Marine Scotland’s approach of gathering evidence and research and then conducting a short, focused consultation. He has said that that
“runs the risk of the consultation being perceived as a fait accompli rather than a genuine”
consultation. The petitioner is also concerned that
“the science which currently influences Marine Scotland policy is ... largely from overseas and this native knowledge gap ought to be part of a wider consultation rather than being the issue around which the consultation is managed.”
I am encouraged by the fact that the Scottish Government has made direct contact with the petitioner and has asked for his involvement. That should help our consideration of the petition.
