The next continued petition is PE1784, which was lodged by Gordon Edwards, on a review of the Sheriff Court Fees Order 2018. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to conduct a review of the order to make self-litigation more accessible for disabled people.
Since our previous consideration of the petition, the committee has received submissions from the Scottish Government, the Faculty of Advocates, the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service, the Equality and Human Rights Commission and the petitioner. All the submissions, which are summarised in the clerk’s note, note that personal independence payments are not income-related benefits and, as such, do not provide an exemption from the need to pay court fees. I was struck by the number and quality of submissions and the thoughtfulness with which people addressed the questions that were raised by the petition.
The underpinning idea is that there has to be a recovery of the full costs from those using the courts, as the service has to fund itself. My feeling is that there is some inequality in discrimination cases. When somebody wants to pursue somebody in a civil matter, we can question whether that is a matter for the state. On the other hand, sometimes when a person is discriminated against, they have to take a civil case to court to address it. I wonder—I raise this point only because I am sure that all parties have agreed to it—whether the notion that the service has to fund itself is, in some ways, iniquitous.
I found it difficult to get into this, because there are a lot of technical issues and a lot of concerns. I suppose that the test is whether there is a particular impact on disabled people. My feeling is that we would want to ensure that there was some confidence in that regard.
