The next item on our agenda is consideration of continued petitions. The first continued petition is PE1740, on improving the handling of complaints about public services, which was lodged by Rachel Lowther on behalf of Accountability Scotland. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to improve complaints handling in the following ways: by allowing the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman to take complaints in any format and by requiring bodies under SPSO jurisdiction—BUJs—and the SPSO to permit complainants to audio record meetings and phone calls and to use the recordings as evidence in any subsequent complaints.
The Information Commissioner’s submission advises:
“Where audio recordings are being made and used by individuals acting in their personal capacity regarding their own or a proxy’s personal interests, they are unlikely to be Data Controllers for the purposes of data protection. As such, the obligations of data protection law would not apply to them and their use of such data.”
It further advises that
“there is nothing to stop individuals from making such recordings at the moment in these circumstances.”
The Scottish Government previously advised the committee that it had had discussions with the SPSO about mainly technical amendments to the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman Act 2002. Although the Scottish Government was supportive of the majority of proposed changes, it noted that, due to competing demands and current pressures, it had no plans to progress matters at this time.
A new submission from the Scottish Government confirms that it is not able to advise when it will be able to bring the requested amendments forward. It also advises that it can now not support the proposal to permit complainants to audio record meetings and phone calls and use that evidence in subsequent complaints.
I ask any members who wish to comment on the petition to do so. I think that there is an issue about accessibility in relation to the opportunity for people to engage in the complaints process, as they may be inhibited by the fact that they have to provide everything in writing.
A slightly different issue is that, although a complainant is entitled to record for their own benefit, the question is whether those recordings can then be used as evidence in pursuing a complaint—I think that that is what the petitioner is looking to establish. The Scottish Government seems to be more ambivalent on that point. It does, however, recognise that there are technical amendments that can be made, and it will progress those in the future.
I am not sure that there is any more that we can do at this point, but we may want to flag up the issue to somebody else in the parliamentary process who could look at it in the future. I would be interested in hearing the views of committee members.
