Conceptually, this is a worthwhile debate, and I welcome the Government’s renewed focus on prevention. However, that will happen only if the SNP Government now commits to accelerating, in hard cash terms, the spending shift towards prevention. It is crystal clear that the Government faces a tricky budget, so it will be interesting to see whether the minister’s influence over the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government is sufficient for there to be a real pivot towards preventative spending now.
I say at the outset that I do not believe that welfare in its truest form is preventative spending. It may or may not be effective—that is a debate for another day—but it is not preventative, because it deals with the consequences of a problem that already exists, be that child poverty, the poor mental health of thousands of Scotland’s young people or the growing problem of economic inactivity. As Alan Milburn identified this week, welfare is, in effect, a sticking plaster and not a long-term solution to the significant underlying social and economic problems that have been allowed to fester and that, in many cases, have got worse under the SNP Government.
The SNP’s motion states that
“prevention is essential to improving outcomes for people and communities and securing the long-term sustainability of public services in Scotland”.
However, with a £5 billion budget black hole of the Government’s own making, its back is against the wall.
As Lorna Slater said, we know that the returns on preventative spending are often measured over years and not months. The SNP evangelises about prevention, but let us consider some of the recent spending decisions that it has made, because history repeats itself and past performance is the best predictor of future performance.
Here is the recent record. In 2024-25, the affordable housing budget was slashed by 26 per cent, and police numbers in Scotland have fallen by roughly 1,000 since 2018. Now, there is a warning from the Scottish Police Federation that a flat-cash settlement next year could potentially result in a further reduction in the number of police officers by 1,000. That would undoubtedly have an impact on preventative policing.
Again in 2024-25, there were nearly £20 million of cuts to mental health services in Scotland. NHS Lothian is now reporting a reduction of £250,000 in psychology and a £400,000 reduction in the child and adult mental health services budget. Also in 2024-25, the flexible workforce development fund was withdrawn and totally unfunded, meaning that there was £10 million less to help employers to retain staff, to tackle skills shortages and to support people to remain in work or return to work.
This year, more than £7 million-worth of preventative services face cuts as integration joint boards come under intense pressure due to the SNP’s funding settlement. Health and Social Care Scotland has warned that removing those services risks increasing demand for more expensive crisis interventions. As our amendment makes clear, the Government has repeatedly reduced financial support for services that are intended to prevent problems from becoming crises.
In closing, I will mention at greater length the issue with commissioned services, which are often delivered by the third sector with local government funding. Each and every single year, those organisations that are, in effect, providing public services face financial challenges, and they often repeatedly have to put their own staff on redundancy alert. I believe that that is because ministers, who are always on the lookout for a press release or a cheap headline, often respond to failure with new strategies and spending commitments instead of looking at the ground level and at those who deliver such important projects and programmes.
If there is to be a step change, I welcome that, because a commitment to concrete and genuine prevention would mean stronger families and safer and healthier communities. What would that look like in this year’s budget? It would mean more resources for councils that have been forced to close community centres and shut down youth projects that prevent young people from falling through the cracks in life. It would mean restoring the colleges budget, so that young people get the skills to give them the best start in life. It would mean providing the police with the right resources to deter crime, deliver safer streets and tackle the social and economic costs of antisocial behaviour. It would also mean a commitment in the short and long terms to reducing the welfare bill, so that more money could flow into our NHS and other front-line services.
In recent budgets, ministers have pointed to the fact that they are pivoting to preventative spend and tagging budget lines accordingly. It is easy to label certain aspects of public expenditure as preventative, but the money must then be invested in them year in and year out. Audit Scotland has also raised concerns about one-off funding streams and a here today, gone tomorrow approach to funding and defunding vital areas of spend—for example, social housing.
Ministers are also presiding over declining capital budgets in health, and waiting times are a problem. I ask the minister what the point of having more doctors and better-paid nurses is if the operating theatre capacity is not there in our NHS. Ultimately, the old adage applies: a small saving today could reduce significant cost pressures tomorrow.
The Government is good at talking the talk, but is the minister really committed to walking the walk? As the other amendments make clear, the Government may be full of good intentions, but if the benchmarks are not clear and the outcomes are not identifiable, that will ultimately be no more than an exercise in budget window dressing. As the budget approaches, we must see a clear, visible and determined effort by ministers to prioritise proven early intervention that will reduce the pressure on our public services and public finances.
I move amendment S7M-02089.4, to leave out from the first “welcomes” to end and insert:
“regrets that the Scottish Government has still not clearly defined 'preventative spend' and has repeatedly reduced financial support for services intended to stop problems from becoming crises; believes that ministers too often respond to failure with new strategies and spending commitments rather than tackling rising demand; considers that genuine prevention means stronger families and safer, healthier communities, helping more people into work and supporting effective local services; notes Audit Scotland’s concerns regarding one-off funding streams, declining health capital budgets and difficulties tagging complex social care versus health spending, which collectively undermine efforts to achieve a whole-system shift, and calls on the Scottish Government to prioritise proven early intervention that reduces future pressure on public services and the public finances.”
15:40