Parliament Workbench
Data: Motions & questions to 26 Nov 2026 · Votes to 19 Nov 2026

Amendment · S7M-02089.3 · Session 7

Prevention and Preventative Budgeting

Defeated Lodged by David Smith Reform Lodged 18 Nov 2026 Debate 19 Nov 2026

Amendment to S7M-02089 Prevention and Preventative Budgeting

The amendment

As an amendment to motion S7M-02089 in the name of Ivan McKee (Prevention and Preventative Budgeting), leave out from first "welcomes" to end, and insert "recognises the good intentions behind the Scottish Government's prevention and preventative budgeting proposals, but expresses concern that there are no published outcomes against which progress can be assessed; agrees that effective scrutiny requires benchmarks for success to be defined in advance, and not subsequently and selectively choosing comparators that might only show an unduly positive outcome; recognises that, for preventative measures to be effective, measures that bring stability to services also need to be implemented; acknowledges that requiring frontline workers to follow additional new processes while they are working through a service crisis could be counterproductive, and further acknowledges that the current environment created by the cost of living crisis has a negative impact on mental and physical health in the workplace, and that measures to tackle the cost of living crisis can themselves constitute preventative measures that could reduce demand on public services."

Vote

1 division
  1. 19 Nov 2026
    Defeated
    12 for, 102 against

Other amendments

3
  1. Carried
    93 for, 21 against
  2. Carried
    93 for, 21 against
  3. Defeated
    29 for, 84 against

Supporters

No MSP has added their name to this amendment.

In the Official Report

4 contributions mention S7M-02089.3
  1. 19 Nov 2026
    Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
    Katy Clark Lab Meeting of the Parliament

    I remind members who wish to speak that they should press their request-to-speak buttons.I call David Smith to move and speak to amendment S7M-02089.3.15:21

  2. 19 Nov 2026
    Prevention and Preventative Budgeting
    David Smith Reform Meeting of the Parliament

    I start by recognising the good intent behind the cabinet secretary’s motion. That prevention is better than cure is a principle that is very easy for everyone to understand and one that the whole Parliament can get behind. In her report f…

  3. 19 Nov 2026
    Decision Time
    Kenneth Gibson Meeting of the Parliament

    The next question is, that amendment S7M-02089.3, in the name of David Smith, which seeks to amend motion S7M-02089, in the name of Ivan McKee, on prevention and preventative budgeting, be agreed to. Are we agreed?Members: No.

  4. 19 Nov 2026
    Decision Time
    Kenneth Gibson Meeting of the Parliament

    The result of the division on amendment S7M-02089.3, in the name of David Smith, is: For 12, Against 102, Abstentions 0.Amendment disagreed to.