link
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what action it is taking to support MSP staff, in light of reported concerns regarding an increase in the number of artificial intelligence-generated casework requests. (S7O-00554)
Official Report · Chamber
Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Question Time
link
To ask the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body what action it is taking to support MSP staff, in light of reported concerns regarding an increase in the number of artificial intelligence-generated casework requests. (S7O-00554)
link
The corporate body recognises that increasing volumes of digitally generated and AI-assisted correspondence can place additional pressure on already busy members and their teams. In particular, high-volume digital campaigns can make it more difficult for offices to identify and prioritise urgent individual casework. The casework system that is provided by the Parliament includes functionality to help members’ offices to manage high-volume campaign correspondence, and training on that functionality is available to members and their staff through the Parliament’s learning and development programme.
Officials are also working with the system supplier as it develops new AI-supported functionality. Alongside that work, officials will continue to assess what further guidance, training and technical improvements could safely reduce the administrative burden on members’ offices, while ensuring that genuine constituent correspondence is handled appropriately.
link
As the member noted, the rise of generative AI has led to a massive upsurge in the volume of casework that members receive, which includes pages and pages of legal citations and references to often obscure standards and practice. I know that other members are concerned about the issue on behalf of their staff. As caseworkers are not lawyers, they do not have the requisite expertise to be able to provide responses to questions of so many pages in a timely manner, even assuming that the citations are correct—and, in many cases, we have found that they are not.
In no way do I wish to limit democratic engagement, but what can be done to streamline requests and ensure that constituents are well informed about the inevitable delays that such lengthy requests lead to?
link
I recognise the concerns that the member raises. Generative AI has made it much easier to produce lengthy and highly technical correspondence, which can include legal citations and references that may not always be accurate. That is not unique to MSP casework. The Information Commissioner’s Office has reported increasing volumes of complex, AI-generated information requests, including requests that misquote legislation, while the Financial Ombudsman Service has highlighted needlessly long submissions containing fabricated laws, misquoted regulations and invented previous decisions.
I think that there is a practical role for the corporate body here. We can look at whether clearer guidance and standard responses could help members’ offices to explain what an MSP can and cannot reasonably do and to manage constituents’ expectations about response times when correspondence is particularly lengthy or complex. Alongside that, we will continue working with the casework system supplier on ways in which technology and training can help offices to manage increasing volumes efficiently while ensuring that genuine constituent concerns continue to receive appropriate attention.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.