As deputy convener, I am pleased to close this important debate on behalf of the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee, and I thank colleagues across the chamber for their contributions this afternoon. I also offer my thanks to the committee clerks and to the Scottish Parliament information centre for their assistance along the way. Our inquiry was in-depth and it involved a number of complex issues, and their contributions to the process were invaluable, as always. Thanks must also be given to everyone who took the time to give evidence to the committee, including individuals, organisations, community councils, cabinet secretaries and former First Ministers. All those submissions were key to helping to inform our work and scrutiny.
The A9 is a key arterial route that is often referred to as Scotland’s spine, as it links the Highlands with the rest of the country. In addition to being a popular tourist route, this trunk road is a key economic route that helps to ensure the delivery of essential supplies to rural communities. It is likely to see a further increase in the volume of traffic as investment and growth, particularly that which is aligned to our national transition to net zero, continues in the region.
I speak as someone who regularly travels on the A9, though perhaps not as often as colleagues including Emma Roddick, Fergus Ewing, Murdo Fraser, Edward Mountain and Jamie Halcro Johnston, who have shared their experiences and those of their constituents of tragic and terrifying collisions on the route. Like others, I commend the petitioner, Laura Hansler, for her pragmatic and persistent approach to pursuing this important matter.
Over the course of the debate, we have heard about the impact that the failure to dual the A9 has had on communities across the Highlands and rural Perthshire. That frequently occurs in the form of long diversions and delays each time the road is closed to allow emergency services to respond to an incident. Those situations are not only frustrating for those relying on the road to get around but, as others have highlighted, now spark a sense of dread among those living closest to the road that the sound of the sirens means that another life may have been lost.
Although much of our inquiry and the contributions that we have heard in the debate have focused on the practicalities of the dualling programme, it is also important to reflect on the petition’s call for a national memorial. Paragraph 160 of the committee’s report states:
“The Committee recommends that the Scottish Government consult on the proposal for a national memorial”.
The primary motivation for dualling the A9 has always been to address road safety concerns on a route that has developed a reputation as one of Scotland’s most dangerous roads, and we heard today from Emma Harper, Maurice Golden and Mark Ruskell about that.
Since the A9 opened to traffic in the late 1970s, more than 330 people have died on the section between Perth and Inverness, and the majority of those fatalities involved a head-on collision of vehicles. We heard from road safety experts that dual carriageway roads can vastly reduce the risk of head-on collisions because they tend to involve the use of barriers, which prevent crossover, and the configuration of junctions to allow traffic to more safely join and exit the road.
During the course of our inquiry, 11 people lost their lives in incidents on the A9—a powerful reminder to all of us of how essential it is that the dualling be completed. On behalf of the committee, I extend my condolences to all those who have been impacted by fatalities on that route, and I urge the Government to work with Laura Hansler on the proposal for a lasting memorial to those who have been injured or killed on the A9.
We have also heard that completing the dualling programme as quickly as possible would be a fitting tribute to those who have lost their lives on the route. Without repeating the points that many colleagues, such as Foysol Choudhury and Emma Roddick, have made this afternoon, I will focus the remainder of my remarks on a key theme that ran throughout our inquiry—how the programme is funded.
The evidence that we heard indicated that, from the outset, there had always been an expectation that a mix of capital and private finance would be used to deliver the dualling programme. A key difficulty arose in 2014, when the non-profit distribution model was reclassified as public rather than private finance, and, although the progress on statutory process at that stage meant that no immediate decision on procurement was required, documents that we received indicated that, by 2017, officials were impressing on ministers the need to agree a procurement approach that would ensure that the 2025 target date would remain achievable.
By 2018, the options that were being presented to ministers indicated that, without a readily available alternative to NPD, a fully capitally funded approach would be required to ensure that the programme remained on track for completion in 2025. Of course, we now know that a combination of issues—including challenging financial circumstances, delays to agreeing a suitable procurement option and the availability of up-front capital to progress the dualling—resulted in the admission from the Scottish Government that the 2025 target was no longer achievable.
As other members have commented, the Government has now published a revised delivery plan that suggests that A9 dualling will be delivered within the original estimate of £3 billion. The cabinet secretary has spoken of a Cabinet decision to prioritise completion of the dualling programme within the Scottish Government budget.
The committee has tentatively welcomed that information. I say “tentatively” because, although the Scottish Government refers to “certainty” in response to our recommendations for clarity on the funding for A9 dualling, we are aware that procurement of the north and central sections, using mutual investment model contracts, is subject to on-going due diligence and further decision making, which is expected later this year.
As our report set out, we remain concerned about what will happen should that due diligence determine that MIM contracts are not suitable, and we continue to seek clarity from the Government on what contingency plans are being put in place to ensure that funding will be available when it needs to be and that the 2035 completion date will not be negatively impacted by a change in approach to procurement of the remaining sections.
The cabinet secretary also referred to the need to follow annual budget practices, which we acknowledge, but she can be left in little doubt, following the contributions from Fergus Ewing, Murdo Fraser, Rhoda Grant and Emma Roddick, that members across the Parliament will be knocking on her and the finance secretary’s doors if funding is not in place to deliver the swift completion of the A9 dualling programme.
As the convener, Maurice Golden and many other speakers have said this afternoon, we believe that transparency is essential to rebuilding public confidence in the programme. I very much welcome the commitment from Transport Scotland to provide six-monthly updates on the progress of the dualling programme to the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee and to other interested members of the Scottish Parliament. As was the commitment from current and former members of the Scottish Government with regard to the importance of parliamentary scrutiny, routine and regular sharing of information is key to addressing concerns about the transparency of decision making on major projects such as those. To enable that scrutiny to take place, we recommend that, in addition to six-monthly updates from Transport Scotland, the Cabinet Secretary for Transport provide statements to Parliament at key milestones that are aligned to the delivery plan that was published in December 2023.
No one wants to be standing here in 10 years’ time, still discussing this issue. Members have heard from the convener and me that we strongly believe that enhanced parliamentary scrutiny has an important role to play in driving momentum on the programme. The level of engagement with our report and today’s debate demonstrates the appetite of members to undertake that scrutiny, and I look forward to working with colleagues throughout the remainder of this parliamentary session, and perhaps the next, to support the effort and ensure that the commitment to fully dual the A9 between Perth and Inverness is successfully delivered.