The Scottish Government is currently implementing reforms of public service pension schemes that are required by the United Kingdom Parliament’s Public Service Pensions Act 2013. The changes in the instruments that the committee is considering today form part of those reforms. The Scottish ministers have executively devolved responsibility for the schemes. Overall, occupational pension policy remains reserved. The key terms of the reforms and the timetable for them were set out by the UK Government in the 2013 act. That act also requires instruments that amend primary legislation to be considered under the affirmative procedure.
As the committee knows, in effect, the reforms will close the existing pension schemes on 31 March 2015. That means that the new schemes and important transitional protections for pension rights that have already been built up to that point need to be in place from 1 April 2015.
The instruments before the committee make necessary consequential modifications to the Pension Schemes Act 1993 and the Finance Act 2004 to ensure that the national health service, teachers, police and firefighters pension schemes work as intended within the complex wider framework of pensions and tax law, and that pension scheme members who transfer to the new schemes retain accrued pension rights.
In brief, the proposed modifications that are set out in parts 2 to 4 of each set of regulations are common to each of the four schemes. Additional provisions are set out in part 5 of the relevant instruments for the teachers, police and firefighters schemes.
Under part 2 of each of the instruments, modifications are made to regulations that govern the contracting-out of the additional state pension. Although contracting out will end in April 2016, the new schemes remain contracted out until then. The changes that are introduced in part 2 reflect the UK Government’s simplified contracting-out election process for the new schemes for this financial year.
Part 3 makes modifications to the 1993 act, so that members who move from the current schemes to the 2015 schemes are not wrongly treated as deferred members of their existing schemes. Modifications under part 3 ensure that pension benefits that scheme members have accrued to date are revalued correctly, and not as if those individuals were deferred members. A scheme member’s right to a cash-equivalent transfer value, to a refund of contributions or to a cash transfer sum applies only when they leave the new scheme. Guaranteed minimum pension safeguards operate as intended, by modifying anti-franking provisions. Those modifications mean that, for those purposes, such individuals do not cease to be active members of their existing scheme until they leave their new scheme.
Part 4 makes modifications to the 2004 act to ensure that members with service in both pre-2015 and post-2015 pension schemes who retire with an ill-health pension do not face unintended tax consequences.
Part 5 of the instruments that deal with the police and firefighters schemes modifies the 1993 act in line with the requirements of the 2013 act to permit active and deferred scheme members to have different pension ages. Part 5 of the regulations that deal with the teachers scheme is designed to reflect, in the short-service provisions of the 1993 act, that different rates of actuarial reduction for active and deferred members are provided for members with a normal pension age above 65.
The changes are very technical modifications to wider pensions legislation. They seek to ensure that teachers, NHS workers, police officers and firefighters get the pensions that they expect without any unexpected effects as a result of potential conflicts with wider pensions and tax law.