The primary purpose of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Sub-sale Development Relief and Multiple Dwellings Relief) (Scotland) Order 2015 is to provide for a relief from land and buildings transaction tax in relation to a land transaction involving sub-sale arrangements, but only where development of the land in question is in prospect.
The work to develop the provisions in the order followed a number of meetings of a working group that involved industry professionals and tax specialists, which was convened to explore the issues associated with a sub-sale development relief. I place on record my thanks to those who participated in the exercise.
Given the experiences of sub-sale rules applicable to stamp duty land tax, my core considerations in the design of the relief have been to ensure that it supports economic activity in the form of property development while not supporting land speculation and minimising any risk of tax avoidance. Members may recall that I made those points during passage of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Bill and placed my position on the subject on record during the stage 3 debate on 25 June 2013.
To achieve those aims, a consultation paper was published in June 2014 seeking views on draft regulations that would introduce a sub-sale development relief under which the first buyer in a sub-sale arrangement would pay the full tax due and then, provided significant development of the site had taken place within five years, the relief would be claimed and the tax returned by Revenue Scotland on receipt of a tax return.
However, the consensus of the responses to the consultation was that, to help with cash flow in development transactions, the relief should be available at the outset. If development was not completed within the five-year period, the relief could be clawed back. Otherwise, the industry argued, developers in Scotland would be placed at a disadvantage in terms of cash flow in comparison with their competitors in other parts of the United Kingdom.
That issue has been addressed in the revised regulations that are now before Parliament and are the subject of the committee’s discussions. The order provides for a relief which has a number of features.
First, the relief will be available only to the first buyer in a transaction that involves sub-sale arrangements where “significant development” is in prospect. The order defines “significant development”.
As has always been envisaged, the relief will be available to the first buyer when the whole site is sold to a second buyer. Partial relief is available if the first buyer retains part of the site and the remainder is sold to a second buyer or further partitioned to other buyers. To be clear, no relief is available for the proportion of the site that the first buyer retains.
The relief is restricted to the first buyer only; it is not available to a second or subsequent buyer where a series of sub-sale arrangements is in place. That reduces the risk of tax avoidance and is an improvement on the corresponding arrangements relating to stamp duty land tax.
In recognition of the development industry’s concerns, the relief is to be claimed and granted at the point when the first buyer submits the land transaction return. Revenue Scotland may request that the first buyer provide specific evidence that the claim is valid—for example, that there are firm plans to undertake significant development.
Lastly, if significant development does not take place within five years, the relief will be withdrawn or partially withdrawn. The tax that should have been paid will then become repayable.
I am confident that the relief will provide a robust mechanism that balances appropriate safeguards to the property development industry in Scotland with the need to protect revenue and maintain a firm position on tax avoidance.
In addition, the relief has been discussed in detail with Revenue Scotland. Administration of the relief will have implications in terms of checking that significant development has indeed taken place and recovering the relief where that is not the case, which will increase administrative costs for Revenue Scotland in due course. Taken in the round, though, my view is that the relief represents an appropriate balance between equity, collection of revenue and administrative effort.
Finally, the order also amends paragraphs 11 and 12 of schedule 5 to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013 for multiple developments relief, to ensure that the calculation using the minimum prescribed amount of 25 per cent applies only to the acquisition of multiple dwellings, not multiple dwellings and other property. Under the drafting as enacted, it was felt that there might be ambiguity on that important point, which was undesirable and which, subject to Parliament’s agreement, will now be clarified.
The order also makes a consequential change to provide that the minimum proportion prescribed in the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Prescribed Proportions) (Scotland) Order 2014, which has already been considered by committee, stays in force on the amended basis.
I move now to the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Order 2015. The primary purpose of the order is to set tax bands and percentage tax rates for land transactions that will be subject to land and buildings transaction tax. The instrument sets the rates and bands for residential property transactions and for non-residential property transactions and, with respect to leases, it sets the tax rates for each band applicable to chargeable consideration that consists of rent.
The Scottish Parliament legislated for a marginal progressive rate structure for LBTT back in 2013. That was intended to replace the much criticised slab structure of stamp duty land tax, which was shown to cause distortions in the housing market around the tax thresholds. The reform was recently replicated across the United Kingdom, although for residential transactions only, following the reforms to SDLT that the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced in the autumn statement.
I set out the Scottish Government’s proposed rates and bands for LBTT in the budget last October, and I updated Parliament on planned residential rates and bands during the stage 1 debate on the Budget (Scotland) (No 4) Bill in January.
I made it clear to Parliament last October that I intended the devolved taxes to be revenue neutral in their first year of operation. The Government did not want to raise any more or less from the two devolved taxes than would have been raised had the UK taxes remained in place, and we wished to maintain devolved spending at planned levels.
Of course, at the time of the draft budget, we had still to reach agreement with the UK Government on the block grant adjustment for the devolved taxes, despite two years of effort in that respect. The LBTT rates and bands presented in the order, taken with the proposed rates of Scottish landfill tax, are designed to be revenue neutral against the block grant adjustment in aggregate, as I set out to the committee in my letter of 22 January and in the chamber on 4 February.
The Scottish Government forecasts that we will generate revenue of £381 million from LBTT in 2015-16, of which £235 million will come from residential property transactions and £146 million from non-residential property transactions, including the taxation of leases. Those forecasts have been endorsed as reasonable by the Scottish Fiscal Commission. As the committee is aware, work is continuing on the estimation of the revenue losses arising from forestalling, and the Scottish Government’s estimates will be subject to review by the commission. The impact of forestalling on the block grant adjustment also remains to be agreed with the UK Government.
I will now turn to the policy objectives underlying the decisions that I have taken on the three sets of LBTT rates and bands presented in the order. In setting the rates and bands of tax payable on residential property transactions, I have sought to prioritise support for first-time buyers and those progressing through the housing market by redistributing the tax burden from lower to higher-value transactions. Those rates are consistent with the principle that taxes should be proportionate to the taxpayer’s ability to pay.
The nil rate threshold is set at £145,000, which will take around 50 per cent of house purchases out of tax altogether—10,000 more purchases than under the new rates of UK SDLT. The marginal rate of 5 per cent, which I announced in January and which is to apply to the value of a purchase between £250,000 and £325,000, also ensures that the tax due on more than 90 per cent of transactions will either be less than the UK charge or will be zero.
For non-residential property transactions, the rates and bands are designed to ensure that Scotland remains an attractive location for business investment. They will reduce the tax charge for the majority of transactions below £2 million, ensuring that the tax due on around 95 per cent of transactions will be the same or lower than the SDLT charge.
Finally, the rates and bands for non-residential leases are set to ensure parity with the UK rates, which are also set on a progressive basis.
I consider that the rates and bands demonstrate clearly that the Scottish Government has placed fairness, equity and the ability to pay at the very heart of the first decisions that we have taken on national tax rates.