First, our members welcome the new progressive tax system. It is a massive improvement on where we were. I come here today to be complimentary rather than critical. However, we have maintained consistently in our submissions and in oral evidence that we need a fully functioning market that allows movement up and down the scale.
Secondly, Scotland has a housing crisis that no one seems to have taken consideration of. Audit Scotland has said that we need to build 500,000 homes in the next 20 years—that is 25,000 homes each and every year. Last year, we built 15,000, the lowest rate since 1947.
We have a major problem. Although we are today talking about LBTT and addressing the stamp duty levels, we must promote a healthy housing market. Our members have provided me with evidence on that basis. Rather than submit a dry paper, I sought to provide you with unedited and completely authentic feedback that I received from members on the latest announcements. I do not seek to justify each and every sentence in the submission; rather, it is provided to you as is so that you get a sense of what is happening.
As we move up to the prices around the £325,000 to £350,000 level, there is a very steep increase in the amount of tax payable in Scotland compared with south of the border. That is a fact; the figures show that. Our members are saying that it increases too steeply too quickly, and that it would be better evened out were the 5 per cent tax band broadened out a little bit further from where it is. We are calling for that because it would promote a healthier market, it would allow much more movement and fluidity in the market and, all in all, it would provide a better tax system and a better tax break.
The contrary of that is that we have genuine concerns that the market between £350,000 and £500,000—and possibly above that—will start to stagnate. We must bear in mind that moving home in those price brackets is largely a discretionary choice that people make. Many people do not have to move; they could equally not make that decision. We partly had the housing crisis a few years’ back because of that. Yes, mortgages became more difficult to get, but people were also very concerned about taking on bigger commitments, about moving and about their job security.
I mentioned that we must tackle the housing crisis. We need to talk about how we are going to solve that. I have a lot of sympathy with David Stewart from the previous panel, who provided evidence about the need to address mid-market rent as well as all tenures. We should be looking at what we can do to get the housing market back so that we are housing all our population across all tenures. That is the basis of our submission.