Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Tax Rates and Tax Bands) (Scotland) Order 2015 [Draft]

Wednesday 25 February 2015 Finance Committee About 10:30–11:30 Subordinate legislation 101 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

101 contributions
Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

We have another 11 items on our agenda, so let us fire away.

Item 4 is to take evidence on the tax rates and tax bands draft order. I welcome our witnesses, who are Philip Hogg of Homes for Scotland and John Hamilton of the Scottish Property Federation, to the Finance Committee once again.

Committee members have copies of the witnesses’ written submissions. As with the previous session, we will go straight to questions. As the panel will be aware, I always start off, before opening out questions to colleagues round the table.

The Homes for Scotland submission is as good a place as any to start. I notice a comment on the second page:

“An English family moving for work reasons and I guess they are thinking why should they be penalised for moving to Scotland.”

Would they be penalised? The average price of a detached house in Scotland is around £170,000, with the price much the same in England. However, the price in London is £510,000, so you would pay a colossal amount more tax if you lived there. Is it not the case that, under the Scottish Government proposals, anyone buying a house worth less than £392,000 would be paying less tax than they would have paid in December 2014?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

First, our members welcome the new progressive tax system. It is a massive improvement on where we were. I come here today to be complimentary rather than critical. However, we have maintained consistently in our submissions and in oral evidence that we need a fully functioning market that allows movement up and down the scale.

Secondly, Scotland has a housing crisis that no one seems to have taken consideration of. Audit Scotland has said that we need to build 500,000 homes in the next 20 years—that is 25,000 homes each and every year. Last year, we built 15,000, the lowest rate since 1947.

We have a major problem. Although we are today talking about LBTT and addressing the stamp duty levels, we must promote a healthy housing market. Our members have provided me with evidence on that basis. Rather than submit a dry paper, I sought to provide you with unedited and completely authentic feedback that I received from members on the latest announcements. I do not seek to justify each and every sentence in the submission; rather, it is provided to you as is so that you get a sense of what is happening.

As we move up to the prices around the £325,000 to £350,000 level, there is a very steep increase in the amount of tax payable in Scotland compared with south of the border. That is a fact; the figures show that. Our members are saying that it increases too steeply too quickly, and that it would be better evened out were the 5 per cent tax band broadened out a little bit further from where it is. We are calling for that because it would promote a healthier market, it would allow much more movement and fluidity in the market and, all in all, it would provide a better tax system and a better tax break.

The contrary of that is that we have genuine concerns that the market between £350,000 and £500,000—and possibly above that—will start to stagnate. We must bear in mind that moving home in those price brackets is largely a discretionary choice that people make. Many people do not have to move; they could equally not make that decision. We partly had the housing crisis a few years’ back because of that. Yes, mortgages became more difficult to get, but people were also very concerned about taking on bigger commitments, about moving and about their job security.

I mentioned that we must tackle the housing crisis. We need to talk about how we are going to solve that. I have a lot of sympathy with David Stewart from the previous panel, who provided evidence about the need to address mid-market rent as well as all tenures. We should be looking at what we can do to get the housing market back so that we are housing all our population across all tenures. That is the basis of our submission.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I have to say that I do not think that anyone considers that stamp duty was a major factor in the housing market slowdown over the past few years; I do not think that anyone seriously considers that to be the case. There were a variety of reasons for that. We all know what those were, so there is no point going into them in any great detail.

An issue that caused difficulty was house price inflation because, year in, year out, it was much higher than the increase in wages and we ended up with a bubble. One would have thought that any significant tax imposition on the purchase of large houses would in itself have a counter-inflationary impact on house prices. Therefore, as well as bringing in revenue for the Scottish Government, would imposing a reasonable tax on those houses not make houses more affordable overall rather than less? If taxation were, for example, to be removed from those large houses, would that not just lead to greater house prices? No one in the general public would benefit, because they would have to pay more for houses that already, in some parts of Scotland—we will hear a bit more about Aberdeen and Edinburgh—are chronically overpriced already.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

I think that you are absolutely right that housing prices need to be brought back closer to affordability levels. I have no issue with that.

However, the best way of addressing what is a classic supply and demand issue is to resolve the supply situation by adjusting taxation levels, as I have said, with a larger discretionary move. Some people will simply say, “If that means that the price of my property, which I am currently living in, has gone down, I may decide simply not to move.” That creates the stagnation that we are talking about. Unless they are moving for personal reasons or job relocation, many people will simply decide that it is easier for them to stay where they are. If the price of their property has, in theory, devalued, that does not promote the healthy market that we are looking for.

We need a healthy market. We have an ageing population and there may be older people who have equity in their homes or who are living in larger family homes than they need as they reach later stages of life and who could consider downsizing. If they see property prices declining, they might decide that that is just not palatable.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Hold on a second. Are we not concerned with building homes? If the prices are lower rather than higher, that will make them more affordable.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Sorry, I do not understand.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

You are talking about people deciding not to move, but there are other people who want to enter the market and are aspirational. If the house price that they would have to pay—for a new home, for example—is less because house price inflation is less, would that not boost the industry and indeed help your members?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

The best way of boosting supply is to tackle the lack of land availability in the planning process. The best way to address affordability and pricing is to resolve the supply and demand equation, which, as you can see from the figures that I quoted earlier, is so far out of kilter that fiddling with taxes is not going to have a significant impact on either supply and demand or house prices.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Mark McDonald has a brief supplementary.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

To follow on from what the convener has said, I am struggling with the logic here. You say that you are in agreement that reality needs to be brought into the pricing of housing and that the market needs to be much more affordable. It strikes me that you are saying to the committee that we need to increase the threshold for the 5 per cent band on higher-value properties, while you seem conversely to be arguing for a much greater supply of more affordable properties, probably below the £250,000 band. Those arguments do not seem to match up, given what you seem to be aspiring to. If you are saying that we need to provide more houses below £250,000, where the bandings are set should be of no consequence to that, because those are properties that under LBTT will pay less in tax.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

I did not argue for more properties below £250,000. I said that we need more homes across the board, including more mid-market and more socially rented, as David Stewart was arguing before. We need more homes at all stages and all parts of the market. We simply do not have enough at the moment.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

At the moment, though, there is no part of Scotland where someone buying at the average house price will pay more under LBTT than they would have paid under stamp duty. It is not until the price is way above £300,000 that people will pay more than they would have paid previously. There is nowhere in Scotland that that is the average house price. Again, I am not entirely sure how that meets what you are saying about increasing supply.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

There is one quite large example in our submission, which I think is quite significant and which might help illustrate the point. The majority of new-build housing in Scotland is provided by the large-volume UK-wide home builders, who will typically provide products at the lower entry level of the market at the sort of prices that you might recall.

The small to medium-sized home builders that tend to operate in more rural or secondary locations, outside the big conurbations, have almost halved in number as a result of the recession. We desperately need to encourage such home builders back into the marketplace. I know that some work has been started by the Scottish Government to address that. We welcome the recognition that we need to bring those people back. The smaller home builders will typically be providing higher-value properties, and they operate on a smaller scale. Their operational costs are a lot higher.

The larger example that I provided in our submission was from a smaller home builder, operating in Fife and providing aspirational family homes. I have similar evidence from other firms. Another one in the Borders has just lost a sale. The property was priced at £425,000, which represents 10 per cent of that firm’s turnover.

We are told that those are the discretionary purchases that are now starting to drop away. One sale on that sort of level can make a massive difference to smaller home builders. If we do not get those people back providing capacity in the marketplace, we will increasingly have a smaller supply chain, and we will never get anywhere near the 25,000 homes a year that Audit Scotland tells us we need and we will never have any way of tackling the house price issue. All these things are interconnected.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I point out that, under the Scottish Government proposal, in a given year, £53 million less tax will be recouped than was previously the case. There is a significant reduction in the amount of tax that is going to be paid by people buying houses relative to previous years.

Mr Hamilton, you say that the average price for a detached property in Edinburgh is £394,000, which is £2,000 more than a figure that I quoted under which everyone would be better off. What proportion of houses in Scotland sell for that amount of money or more?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

A key point for us is about the proportion of houses that contribute to the tax that is generated. We have not focused particularly on the average house price across the board, because it gives a slightly distorted picture of the amount of revenue that is generated in any particular sector or category.

We have pointed out that 8 per cent of residential transactions are expected to account for 75 per cent of the revenue. The principle involved is that quite a small proportion of the market contributes a very large proportion of the tax that is generated.

From the start of our consideration of the new proposals, we understood the need for some neutrality between the revenue that was generated previously and the revenue that will be generated under the new proposals. You have made the point that the estimate under the current proposal is for a slight reduction in revenue. As I understand it, however, that would be expected, and it would be hoped that the difference would be closed in future years, so that there is no long-term shortfall in the revenue that is attracted by the new tax system. If that is not the case, and if part of the market is not operating effectively, there could be a shortfall to the Scottish Government in the revenue that is attracted in the long term.

In a sense, there is an element of our wanting the same thing, which is a stable market that operates effectively at all levels and allows people to sell properties—whether new build or resale—if they are in a position to do so. If someone is in a position where they have to make a choice about selling their property, they may be dissuaded from putting that property on the market.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Sorry, but why would they be? If someone is selling their house, they do not pay any tax. It is only the purchaser who pays it.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

But they may have bought at a certain level and have a high mortgage, and they may get advice that the cost of selling the house to a new purchaser means that the equation just will not work. Therefore, those properties might not come on to the market.

11:00

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Surely the whole market must have been stimulated by the fact that, six months ago, people had to pay £7,500 stamp duty on a £250,000 house, and they will now have to pay £2,200. That is a £5,300 difference.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I am not talking about £250,000 houses.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I am aware of that, but surely the whole market must have been boosted by the fact that, overall, there is to be a £53 million reduction in tax. You are focusing on a very small part of the market. Where is the evidence that there will be a significant reduction in transactions or houses being built at those costs? There is a lot of assertion rather than evidence that that will be the case. I mentioned London, where house prices are sky-high, and I do not see the housing market collapse there. Instead, a lot of people cannot afford to live anywhere, more or less, because of the sky-high prices. If what you suggest was brought in, all that we would have would be higher house price inflation, and fewer people would be able to buy those houses.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

No, that is not the case. We agree that it is not particularly healthy for the UK to have prices that are too high and a market that is too active in London, at the expense of other parts of the country. We would like an improvement in market conditions in Scotland, with more house building and more property transactions generally, so that there is demand for property business to take place in Scotland. London has been referred to quite a lot this morning. To us, too much is happening in that part of the country, and we argue that we need to make Scotland more competitive. In London, there is overdemand for property, but we do not have that in Scotland. We want to create a situation where there is demand in the major cities of Edinburgh, Aberdeen and Glasgow and in the more regional parts of Scotland. Putting a higher burden of tax on all those areas will not improve Scottish competitiveness.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

If your proposals were implemented as you have suggested, what would be the revenue implications? There seems to be a suggestion that they would not impact on revenue because there would be more transactions. Is that your view?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

We were satisfied with the principle of the 5 per cent rate being introduced. We have not suggested quite such a high figure as Homes for Scotland has, but the principle of moving the band up from £325,000 is important because we think that the current band will lead to a distortion in the market as house builders, and for that matter home owners, will be looking at a very narrow band of pricing, and houses will come to the market at the expense of larger properties, which will not. The principle of what we propose is very much the same, although the numbers are slightly different. Although we agree on the rates that have been set, we are slightly at odds on the band. A band of £75,000, between £250,000 and £325,000, in an important part of the market is too narrow.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Mr Hogg, you suggest that the figure should be £500,000 rather than £400,000. Do you have any figures to suggest how that would impact on revenue?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

We have not made any calculations on that. We are all trying to forecast the future, and I make no claims of being any better at doing that than the next person. What we bring to our case is our members’ first-hand experience of dealing with home buyers at the sharp end. We are talking about buyer behaviour and we are all trying to second-guess what might happen in the event of the new rates coming into effect. All that I can bring to you is evidence from our members and from potential home buyers. That is the reason why I provided verbatim comments about what is happening on the ground. We are not economists, but we are telling you what people are saying to us and what their likely actions might be, and our evidence is based on those forecasts.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Before I open up the session, I have one further question for Mr Hamilton, on the non-residential rate. I asked Mr Swinney about the change from 4 per cent to 4.5 per cent, which would represent £10,000 for a £2 million development. His view was that a half per cent would not make any difference to a strategic decision on whether to bring a development to Scotland.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

We covered that in our previous session with the committee, and I gave an example in which the figure was far higher. All large-scale residential developments are now undertaken by the major UK house builders—there are very few small house builders here in Scotland, and it is probably the same in England. As Philip Hogg said, the number of SMEs has dwindled, and the market is now dominated by a relatively small number of UK house builders, virtually all of which, if they have a presence in Scotland, also have a presence in England.

I do not agree that the issue of competitiveness should be ignored. I gave an example in our previous evidence session. The house builders with which my company deals are selling land typically not at £2 million but in the £6 million, £8 million or £10 million price brackets. The people who are making the choices about whether to proceed with those transactions are based largely in England, and I know from personal experience of dealing with those companies that they will make that choice. There is an element of competition among those companies with regard to whether a development proceeds in Edinburgh or Newcastle, for example. There is one very large business located in Newcastle—which I do not have to name here—that makes those choices. The imposition of another half per cent of tax on that land will come into the equation for that company.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Thank you for that. I will now open up the session. John Mason can go first, followed by Mark Griffin.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Mr Hogg, you commented earlier on land not being available. That might apply in some areas, but I do not think that it applies in all areas. In my constituency in the east end of Glasgow, we have a lot of land and no problem with planning permission, but nobody wants to build on it despite the need for housing. At the end of my street, there is an area where the roads are laid out and the street lighting has been on for 25 years, and no one is building there. Do you think that tax could bring about movement on that sort of land?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

I am not a developer, and I will not assess the viability of any piece of land without knowing what it is. I was trying to make the general point that, although we need the tax system to work efficiently, it is only a very small part of a bigger market problem.

As you said, in some parts of Glasgow we do not have the right type of housing. In Aberdeen, we are finding that the market is racing away so affordability is an issue, and planning processes are a major problem. As has been mentioned, the Scottish Government is in the process of finalising a joint housing delivery action plan. I was at a meeting late last night working on some of the land issues that are related to that. The reality is that there simply is not enough land throughout the country to meet Scotland’s housing needs. Even in places where there is enough land, the planning system is so painfully slow and difficult to get through that we cannot progress the development of land at the necessary rate. If we are seeking to tackle issues with house price affordability, that is where we should be directing most of our efforts.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

But you accept that, in some cases, there is land and planning permission and yet no one is building.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Absolutely, and there could be a raft of reasons for that. Perhaps there is no market for housing there, there are constraints on the site, or the financial viability does not stack up—

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

But the tax is probably not the major factor in that situation.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Do you mean LBTT?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

I simply have no idea, but I suspect that it is probably not. It would depend on house prices.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Following on from that, you give some examples in your submission in the form of bullet points with quotes, which is helpful. Referring to the tax, I think, the second one states:

“It is just about to cost me £3,350.”

The example that is given is a house that might have cost £430,000 and has been bargained down to £400,000. The bargaining, therefore, has affected £30,000, which is about 7.5 per cent of the total; I guess that that is not unusual. The tax—the £3,350—is 0.8 per cent of the total.

It suggests that, in that example, the tax is a very small part and is almost irrelevant, and that the big movement comes when someone bargains over a house price. Is that your understanding?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

That example supports John Hamilton’s case that, with such a high proportion of the total tax take under the new scheme being on a very small number of properties or transactions, there is a fragility to be considered. If we suppose that the prices for a good number of those properties are negotiated downwards and the corresponding tax comes from there, that would potentially leave a big hole in the forecast tax take.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Mr Hamilton, Mr Hogg referred to your view that the band from £250,000 to £325,000 is too narrow. If there was going to be a bit of bargaining, would you be happier if the band was wider but the 5 per cent rate went up to 7 per cent?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

As I said before, in terms of the principle we are, to a large extent, looking for the same thing: a stable market that generates revenue. We cannot predict exactly how much business will be done next year or the year after, but we are seeking to maintain the budgetary conditions in which we can all operate our businesses.

To an extent, we overcomplicate the situation again by bringing in yet another proposed tax rate. We have said that we feel that the structure of 0, 2, 5, 10 and 12 per cent is probably now appropriate. However, I still make the point that we should look now at the bands rather than the rates, and ensure that there is enough market activity in each of those bands to generate the amount of revenue year after year in which the Government can see tax revenue being generated and the property and housing industry can see stable business.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

You are in a market in which bargaining is very much part of the equation. You are asking for a wider rate and a reduced tax level. Is there nothing that you are willing to give in return?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

We are asking for a wider band.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

A wider band, which means a reduced tax take. Is there nothing that you are willing to give to balance that out?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I think that we are giving. From the start, the point has been conceded that there must be—or there should be—a similar amount of tax being collected. In a way, we are almost arguing from the Government’s side: we think that there is a risk that the tax will not be collected. That is not good for the industry either, because it will show that part of the market is not functioning correctly and that there is not a choice in the market. Not all our members, and not all Homes for Scotland members, serve the same part of the market.

I will give you one extreme example. We have members in the Aberdeen area who have very difficult trading conditions in front of them, and the changes in legislation that are ahead are making that situation worse. It results from the combination of an unforeseen drop in oil revenues, which had not been factored in when the proposals were introduced, and the new tax rates themselves, which make it extremely difficult for those businesses to survive.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

On the other side there are constituents like mine, who think that if someone has spent more than £750,000 on a house, they are fabulously rich, and that 12 per cent is too low and we should go to 20 per cent. Are you not willing to concede on a wider band, a higher rate or anything like that?

11:15

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

As I said, I think that the rates are probably set pretty much in the right place now. There might be some debate about whether the rate should be 5 or 6 per cent, or 5.5 per cent. There is often discussion about the housing ladder, and the important point is that the steps on the ladder have to be manageable. People must have the ability to make those steps; if they do not, they can be stuck for a long time and the market will not operate effectively.

We do not have a great issue with the rates, but we concede that there could be room for negotiation around the mid rate at 5 or 6 per cent.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

I am interested in particular in paragraph 2 of your paper, in which you refer at least twice to detached properties in Edinburgh and elsewhere. There are very few detached properties in my constituency. A detached property is, per se, a luxury. Do you accept that? Nobody needs a detached property.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

It is not a necessity. I have lived in all sorts of properties in my lifetime. The housing market tends to address wherever the demand for housing is. The demand has to exist across the market. As Philip Hogg said, that applies to all levels of the housing market, whether mixed tenure, social rent, mid-market rent or private rent.

The issue is still what part of the market is making the biggest tax contribution. I do not want to overegg that point, but if we put so much of the burden on one particular tenure and house type, we have to give some consideration to the ability to sell the property. If the property does not sell, there is an implication for the tax that is generated.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

The other side to that is that the people who need the tax are at the bottom end.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

Yes.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Is your submission and your organisation basically arguing for the richer part of society?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

No, not at all. The welcome element of the proposals is that a larger part of the housing market has been removed from tax. I welcome the changes that have been made in that respect. However, that does not detract from the point that that is a larger market. We do not feel that it is a case of penalising one part of the market at the expense of other parts. We would like to see a fair tax system. Fairness always comes into the question of tax. We do not believe that the levels that we are talking about are fair. We do not believe that it is appropriate for such a burden to be carried by a small element of the tenure and house types that will be sold.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

The other day, a friend of mine shared on Facebook a four-bedroom, semi-detached family property in Bridge of Don in my constituency, which is located quite close to a local primary school. It is obviously a very desirable property at offers over £250,000. It is important to put that example on the record, because I think that we are straying into the realms of assuming that it is not possible to buy a family-sized property in my constituency, or in Aberdeen, at such a price.

I am struggling with some of the evidence that we are hearing. Mr Hamilton, you seem to be suggesting that the rates that we have been discussing, which nobody is paying yet, are creating great difficulties for businesses in the north-east of Scotland.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

No. I have not said that.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

You mentioned it in combination with other factors.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I mentioned the bands.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I presume then that you would advise your members to build properties at £250,000 or below. If you are telling us that house purchase prices will be driven by the rates that will be paid under the bandings, there will be a rush of people seeking to purchase properties that, as the convener highlighted, they will pay significantly less for than they would have paid under stamp duty.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

Yes. I agree with that.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Technically, however, nobody will pay more or pay less, because stamp duty or LBTT is paid only at the point of purchase—it is not an on-going tax. For example, I paid stamp duty when I bought my house but I have not paid it since. I am not paying that tax at present and I will pay it only if I decide that I want to buy another property. It is not an on-going tax like income tax, so surely it is misleading to portray it in those terms and say that people will pay more or pay less; people will pay the tax only at the point of purchase.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I am struggling to see the point.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

In the grand scheme of what drives the behaviour of house purchasers, I am struggling to conceive that the tax is the primary motivation. That is the point. If people are looking to upscale to a larger property, that is driven by a range of factors. Most people who will buy properties that will attract LBTT will have the ability to pay the tax as part of the purchase, particularly if, as the Homes for Scotland submission highlights, they have negotiated a £30,000 reduction in the purchase price in some cases because the seller is making—

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I am struggling with the idea that people have no concern about paying tax.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I did not say that they have no concern about paying tax.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

No matter whether the tax is paid once or annually—no matter its frequency—it will have an influence on people’s choice about what type of property to buy and on the type of property that is brought to the market.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Mr Hogg, are you detecting a change in market behaviour currently because of the future introduction of the bands?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

When you say “market behaviour”, who are you referring to?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Yes.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

To the extent that, from the anecdotal feedback that I have, the market has slowed down significantly for the higher-priced properties since the rates were announced.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

That is interesting. The rates are not yet active, but surely if behaviour was driven by them we would expect to see sales taking place in advance of the rates being introduced and other sales being brought forward as a consequence.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

As you know, the process of moving house is not the sort of thing that happens over a weekend. Realistically, anyone who makes a decision today to purchase a new home is probably in for a three to six-month process. Anyone who decides today that they want to purchase a new home has virtually no chance of doing that before the new tax rates are introduced—

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Forgive me for interrupting, but the previous rates, in terms of the initial consultation, were announced in November, which was about six months before they would have become live. Did you notice anything then?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

At that point, we saw an acceleration of people wanting to conclude sales; they were people who would have been disadvantaged from April. A rush of people wanted to conclude sales early. However, on this side of the financial year, no one who set out on a purchase from January on would have been likely to complete it before April. Since January, the market has gone a lot quieter—we are told—on the higher-value properties.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

My concern is around how the issue is being portrayed. For example, your submission states that a developer suggested that people are being penalised for moving to Scotland. I do not think that that kind of language is helpful. Presumably, by the same token, if I were a first-time buyer and went south of the border to purchase, I would be penalised for moving to England, because I would pay a higher rate under stamp duty than I would pay under LBTT. If you anticipate a lack of people moving to Scotland at the higher end because they would pay more in tax, do you anticipate a greater number of people moving to Scotland at the lower end because they will pay less?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

As I mentioned, the comments in our submission are verbatim, so whether or not you like what people are saying, that is how they feel; that is people’s experience. I make no apology for giving you verbatim comments rather than couching it in terms of what I think our members are saying.

A factor that you perhaps need to take into consideration is that people who are purchasing higher-value properties have more mobile careers; that is not always the case, but it is a general rule. Those at more senior levels have the opportunity to move around and relocate a bit more. We have heard examples in which senior people are not only looking to move, but looking to bring colleagues with them to set up new departments, divisions and businesses. The main person could decide that they will not move or, to use the example that has been mentioned, they may say that they will move to Newcastle rather than to Edinburgh. In that case not only does that person not move, with all the corresponding tax benefits, but their colleagues who they would have subsequently employed do not follow them. There is quite a long chain of events that happen.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

As you said, you are not economists, but what is your best estimate of the likely impact on the Scottish housing market after 1 April if the regulation is passed and the rates and bands in it take effect?

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

We will see a prolonged period of below-average activity in that section of the market. That is not say to say that activity will stop—it will not, because some people will have to move. We will see suppressed levels of activity. As I said, it is generally discretionary movement at that level, so people will say, “If that’s what it means, I’ll choose to stay where I am.”

As I have tried to explain, we will also see a disproportionate effect on small and medium-sized home builders who are more likely to build at those higher prices because they cannot compete with the larger volume home builders as they do not have the economies of scale.

As you will see in the examples in the submission, one person said that he aims at that market. That small, Fife-based company probably builds 20 homes a year or something of that scale. He will be disproportionately hit because he cannot compete with the larger volume guys on the entry-level products, which is the market below £250,000. That impact will take more capacity out the marketplace; it will take homes away. Therefore, those people who might have bought at the £400,000 level might decide to stay where they are, so a more entry-level property would not be released.

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

I agree. It is important to see the differentiation between the new-build market and the existing sales market. Most sales, and therefore tax revenue, are generated from the sale of existing property. However, the new-build market’s importance to the economy cannot be ignored, because of the massive shortfall in the number of houses that are being built, the wider economic implications of that and the lack of business activity in that gap. We should be aiming to build 25,000 to 30,000 houses a year, but we are struggling to build somewhere between 11,000 and 12,000 houses.

Generally, the implication of making it less attractive for a house builder to look at the full range of new housing that he might bring to the market would be a detriment to that position. It would not generate more house-building activity, which is key to the wider economy.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

Let us assume, Mr Hogg, that your best estimate comes to pass and, to use your words, there are “suppressed levels of activity” in that section of the market. I think that you were referring specifically to the £325,000 to £500,000 level, but presumably it could apply to properties above that value as well. Does that market section exist in a vacuum, or would there be an impact on other parts of the market and those houses that are below the £325,000 value?

11:30

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

We often refer to the concept of the housing ladder. As a generalisation, people move in their different life stages. Perhaps they will move from their family home to their first one-bedroom flat and look for something a little bigger when their new family comes along. That is a well-proven path, albeit that it is not scientifically accurate for everyone. However, we talk about progression.

If we find that there is a lack of suitable products available at the higher levels, it is clear that that will mean that those who can and want to move upwards will have fewer opportunities to do so. Again, we come back to classic supply and demand. If only one four-bedroom property in a certain price range is available that suits a purchaser, the seller will have the opportunity to bargain on the price. Having a market that does not move fluidly will not help to tackle house price inflation.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

Okay. Does Mr Hamilton share that view? What are his thoughts?

John Hamilton Scottish Property Federation
link

Yes. We have certainly come back to that point more than once. The market operates most effectively where there is fair demand that is generated by the wider attractiveness of living and working in the area. Fundamentally, we do not think that it is helpful to have more severe differentiation or too severe differentiation. We accept the point that, in general, people who buy more expensive houses should be able to afford them, but people are often heavily mortgaged. In many cases on that side of the market, people are starting businesses and making contributions to the economy. That applies specifically to the tax that we are discussing, which has been generated in that part of the housing market, and to people who will make contributions to the business economy.

Gavin Brown Con Lothian
link

Okay. So in your respective views, the way to get a better functioning or optimal functioning housing market is to make the changes to the bands that you have submitted in your written evidence.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Yes, I believe so. I reiterate my opening comments. I welcome the new system and where we are compared with where we were at this time last year. We came here today to genuinely provide our advice. The committee invited us here to provide our advice based on our members’ experience and the market, and we are genuinely bringing that to the committee. We think that, if the 5 per cent band were extended up to circa £500,000, that would go a long way to creating a better and more robust tax system.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

I want a wee bit of explanation, Mr Hogg. I think that I will be quoting correctly; I am sure that the clerks will tell me if I have not done so. You said that

“there simply is not enough land”

across all of Scotland to satisfy housing needs.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Yes.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Every local authority has to provide an effective five-year land supply. I will not bore you with the intricate details, but only a handful of local authorities have an effective five-year land supply. That was discussed at a meeting that I was at late last night. We have long argued that a shortage of land and raw materials will drive prices upwards; any basic economics will tell you that. We have to ensure that there is enough effective land where people want to live that can be developed. That will start to tackle the housing shortage and then impact on house prices.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

But you would say that it is not a shortage of land for house building that is holding up house building at the moment.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

I would say that there is a shortage. Because there is not enough land, that affects its price and availability.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Yes. I fully recognise that home building can be very contentious and difficult at the local level. It is interesting that the UK political parties are talking in the run-up to the general election about building 200,000 or 300,000 homes. It is great that it is recognised that more home building is needed, but there is the issue of translating the top target and saying, “Oh, and by the way, we’re now going to build 50 of those just around the corner.” All of a sudden, it is then a little bit difficult for everyone who has signed up to that need.

The issue will not go away. We have a growing and ageing population, and we are simply not building enough homes to house our population. That is a sad reflection. Successive Governments—I am making no political point—have failed to recognise and grasp that issue. We are spending two hours here talking about tweaks to a tax system; I would welcome much more spending two hours talking about how we will address the housing crisis in Scotland. We are not having that discussion, but we should really be spending two hours talking about that.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

So the problems are much bigger than the tax and the tax bands.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

Absolutely.

Philip Hogg Homes for Scotland
link

It pales into insignificance.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I thank John Hamilton and Philip Hogg for coming along again and thank them very much for their evidence, which is very much appreciated.

As we have been in session for more than two hours, we will have a break until 11.45. That will give members a natural break, as we still have another 10 items on our agenda.

11:36 Meeting suspended.

11:45 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 89
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 101
  4. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  5. 12:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.