Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Sub-sale Development Relief and Multiple Dwellings Relief) (Scotland) Order 2015 [Draft]

Wednesday 25 February 2015 Finance Committee About 09:30–10:30 Subordinate legislation 89 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

89 contributions
Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Our next item of business is to take evidence on a draft order from Isobel d’Inverno of the Law Society of Scotland and David Stewart of the Scottish Federation of Housing Associations. I welcome our witnesses to the meeting.

Members have copies of all the written evidence that the committee has received, so we will go straight to questions from the committee. You have both been at the committee before, so you will know that I usually start off with some questions before opening out the session to colleagues round the table.

My first question is for Isobel d’Inverno. We received a paper from you in which you talk about significant developments and say that you support the revised definition of that. The paper also describes how, if a significant development does not take place within five years, the relief will be withdrawn or partially withdrawn and the tax will become payable. It continues:

“In these cases we would suggest that it should be possible for an extension of the five year period to be made available.”

I am wondering how long the extension would be. Would it go on for years and years? If there is going to be a sacrifice of tax income at the start of the period—the Chartered Institute of Taxation suggests that it would be good if we charged straight off—we could be talking about who knows how many years. Can you put a bit more meat on the bones of your suggestion?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It would be unfortunate if, because of delays in planning or whatever, the development was not able to start until, say, year 6, and the sub-sale development relief was all lost. The period would just need to be reasonable. A reasonable period might need to be decided at the discretion of Revenue Scotland, having regard to the circumstances and what has actually been going on, rather than setting a particular period in stone. That might need to be discussed with others who are involved in the industry to get some idea about it.

I take the point that the extension could not go on for 15 or 20 years, although some developments go on for that long because they have to wait for planning and other things.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

What if someone decides to put in for planning four and a half years into the five-year period, for example? That is hardly the fault of the local authority, but it still has to go through its processes.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It would be unlikely that someone would delay deliberately. There could be some saving in the provision that would say that, if the end purchaser deliberately caused a delay, there would be no extension. Also, if the decision is at Revenue Scotland’s discretion, it could take that into account.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

You suggest what would happen if there was a delay of up to five years, but that might have an impact on revenue coming in to the Scottish Government. Do you have any idea how much that might be if a development was to be late? One would assume that it would be several millions of pounds.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It is very difficult to say. Many of these transactions are structured along the lines that the development will start as soon as possible. That is in everybody’s best interests. The developer who is involved in the development is—obviously—keen to get on with it and the end purchaser does not want to be hanging around for ages, either. I do not think that anybody is out to delay things.

Quite how many projects fall into what sort of timescales, I really cannot say. Other organisations such as the Scottish Property Federation might be able to give some suggestions about how the figures might fall out.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

The CIOT has said:

“The amended relief mechanism poses a higher risk to the public revenue”.

Do you accept that the overall amount that will come in to the Scottish Government will not increase but might decline for all sorts of reasons, such as companies going bust, if the money is not received at the beginning of the five-year period?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It is not my experience from advising on projects that a huge number of developers or end purchasers go bust. That does not happen in most of the transactions that we are involved in, so I do not think that there is a huge risk of the relief being allowed up front and then the development not happening. Revenue Scotland has other mechanisms if people were to try to abuse the relief, such as the general anti-avoidance rule. If people set up fictitious arrangements in order to claim the relief, the GAAR would be one way of attacking that. I do not think that the relief presents a huge risk of loss of revenue.

10:00

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Okay. You also state in your written submission:

“Where development has started but not been completed the tax chargeable is an ‘appropriate proportion’ of the tax which would have been payable without the relief.”

However, if any of us round the table bought a house that cost more than £145,000, we would have to stump up land and buildings transaction tax straight away. Why should only a proportion of the tax be paid? Once work has started on a development and the developer has the money in place to complete it, why should the tax not just be paid?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It comes down to what would be fair and reasonable in the circumstances. I think that the original wording of the regulation said that, if a development had not been completely finished by year 5, there would be no relief. That does not seem proportionate. If a development was all but complete, people would think that they ought to be able to get a proportion of the relief. It is a question of proportionality. It is obviously different from the situation of buying a completed house and having to pay LBTT.

Having said that, it is not impossible for the construction of houses to be done in a different way whereby people would not end up paying LBTT on the whole of the construction costs. That is not uncommon. However, the idea of the relief is to give developers who are setting up projects the same kind of cash-flow advantage that they would get in the rest of the United Kingdom so as to ensure that Scotland is not at a competitive disadvantage with the rest of the UK in forward funding projects.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I just wonder how big an issue that really is.

The Chartered Institute of Taxation’s written submission states that

“Provision could be made to initiate a claw back”

or

“provide security to cover”

that. When a developer plans to build on a site, they often provide a bond to the local authority to pay for street lighting, roads and so on, so that if the company goes bust or whatever, that is covered. What about a clawback, or a kind of indemnity to provide security? Is that something that you think should be considered?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

No. I do not think that that will be necessary. Situations where a development does not happen because the end purchaser has gone bust are not frequent and the commercial arrangements are often such that everything is teed up for the development to go ahead.

It is worth noting that the Chartered Institute of Taxation is the only body that responded to the consultation that thought that the original version of the relief was appropriate. Everybody else who looked at it took the view that, if developers had to pay the tax up front and could reclaim it only when the development was complete, they would say, “This is too uncertain. We’ll have to assume that we’re not going to get this money back, therefore we’ll ignore it in pricing deals.” It would have been a fairly useless relief.

I think that the general consensus now is that, if the developer can claim the relief up front, they can be reasonably certain that it will be available, which means that they will be able to price it into deals.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Surely the public purse has to be protected. I live on a housing development site for which the local authority did not ask for a bond. The developer did go bust and the council had to find £300,000 to put in roads, street lighting and so on. Surely, if we are going to protect the public purse, some kind of bond or whatever should be in place. Otherwise, the taxpayer will ultimately lose out.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

Arranging that sort of bond would introduce unnecessary complications into deals. There is always the possibility of keeping the provision under review and, if it turns out that the public purse has been threatened by projects going belly up, it will be open to the Scottish Government and the Scottish Parliament to remove the relief or amend it in some way. It is not set in stone for ever. It might be appropriate for the Finance Committee to keep it under review and to ask for detailed information on how many times the relief has been granted, what is going on in the projects and so on.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Thank you, Isobel.

David, you have a big focus on mid-tenure homes and you talk about

“Ensuring no tax is paid on properties costing £135,000 or less”,

although I think that that should be £145,000. What do you mean in cost terms by “mid-tenure homes”? I have been looking at your submission and I cannot see any detail on what you mean by that, in financial terms.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I am sorry. I can certainly provide details of the rents that our members charge, but I do not have any figures on that with me at the moment.

Mid-tenure homes are where a housing association or a council provides homes and the rent is set in the middle band between what a socially rented home would cost and what the private rental market would charge. They are aimed at people who are working but are on relatively low incomes, who would struggle to access a home of their own through the private rented market or a mortgage but who are also unlikely to be housed in social housing because of the high levels of waiting lists. Mid-tenure homes look to meet a gap in the market.

Since the financial crash, it has become more difficult for first-time buyers to obtain mortgages. We would argue that mid-tenure homes are increasingly important to help to meet housing needs and to allow young people to leave their parents’ homes or move to a different area in order to take up employment.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Are you talking about homes that cost more than £145,000 for each unit?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

In some cases, homes might cost that to build, but I am probably talking mainly about developments—for example, buying land to build 30 or 40 homes for mid-market rent. Another situation is where, as happened on a number of occasions in Edinburgh following the financial crisis, a housing association subsidiary buys homes from a builder that has decided that it cannot sell them on the market.

In our written submission, I talk about the fact that housing associations can then get caught up in paying reasonable sums of tax. Given that they are providing a service that the market does not provide and they tend to need grants from the Scottish Government or to acquire land at nil value from the local authority to make the scheme stack up, we argue that it does not make sense for the Government then to draw a tax on that.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Are you saying that, if 50 houses were to be built on a site in Edinburgh and it was going to cost something like £8 million, they should not be subject to LBTT at all, even after five years, because of the type of people for whom you are providing housing?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes—that is the argument that we are making. Although it is not a tiny part of the market, it is quite small. The case that I would make for it being excluded from the tax is, first, that it would not have a significant impact on the overall tax take—I note that the Scottish Government is keen to ensure that it draws in the same amount of tax from LBTT that it would have drawn in under stamp duty—and secondly that we are talking about housing people whose needs are not met by the market. In effect, it is something that needs to be subsidised, albeit to a lesser extent than social rent.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

To go back to the example that I gave earlier, if there are 50 houses on an £8 million site, the average cost per unit would be £160,000. We could argue that that is above the threshold that many people would pay. A lot of people buy houses for a lot less than that. My mum’s house is on sale for £58,000, and it is beautiful. There is a lot of low-cost private housing. My assistant bought an absolutely lovely flat for £43,000. You are talking about a significant scale of development. Where would this apply? Would it impact across Scotland or is it an issue only in specific areas such as Edinburgh and Aberdeen?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I think that it would impact across Scotland. Previously, the view was always that housing for mid-market rent really only worked in pressured areas where housing for sale was expensive and there was a lack of social rented housing. Traditionally, most mid-market rent was in Edinburgh, with pockets in places such as Aberdeen and Glasgow. However, I spoke to a couple of housing associations recently that have developed units for mid-market rent—Loretto Housing Association, which has provided units in Springburn, and Shettleston Housing Association—and both said that, because it has become difficult for many people to access housing for sale, there is now a market for mid-market rent in such areas. The people who are being housed are mainly, I suppose, adults who were staying at home with their families and who were looking to move into a house.

The issue is probably not so much the tax on the overall cost of the property but the fact that the association would have to pay a tax on the cumulative cost of land for, say, 20 or 30 units and on the cumulative cost of development. That is probably not what the tax aims to do. We are talking about people who might, 10 years ago, have bought a relatively low-value property in the Scottish market but who now struggle to access a mortgage.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Do you have any idea how much the tax will cost housing associations each year if there is no change to the current position?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I do not have that global figure—I would need to research it—but I do not think that it would be an enormous amount. However, it could be significant for individual developments. Given that, in the Scottish Government’s refresh of its housing policy, it sees mid-market rent as a potentially significant element and it is building that into its joint delivery plan, anything that can be done to make it easier for association subsidiaries to provide mid-market rent to help to meet the need in the housing market and deliver the Scottish Government’s aims would be helpful.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

You are saying that there is no real contradiction, as it is not a significant amount for the Scottish Government but it could be for individual associations.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes, and it could make it more difficult for schemes to stack up. As I said, for the schemes to work, they need either grants or land to be transferred to the subsidiary at below-market or nil value. In a way, a tax would just be moving public money about.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

Yes. You are saying that, in effect, a larger grant would be required if the tax has to be paid.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

I now open out the session to colleagues.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Ms d’Inverno, in answering the convener’s questions, used the term “competitive disadvantage”, which I assume is in relation to building in Scotland compared to building down south. How much of an issue is that? If somebody wants to live in a place, a thousand pounds or two here or there will not make a difference. People still want to be in London, despite the fact that there is a huge competitive disadvantage. Does that amount of money really make a difference?

10:15

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

In respect of the sorts of transactions that we are talking about, many developers operate throughout the UK. They might have a choice between doing a project in Newcastle and doing one in Edinburgh or Glasgow. If there is an extra tax cost for the developer in putting the project together, given the time that the projects take and the fact that the margins are not incredibly high, if the developer does not get the relief, it might decide to do the project in Newcastle, which would mean that it would not happen in Scotland. That is one of the reasons why most people were keen to have the development sub-sale relief available in Scotland.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Clearly, developers want to pay no tax and want everything to be as cheap as possible. However, by your logic, no one would be developing in London, but I thought that there were developments going ahead in London.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

Throughout the UK at the moment, there is sub-sale relief for such transactions, because stamp duty land tax has sub-sale relief across the board for all types of sub-sales. Obviously, in LBTT that does not exist, so we are looking at a targeted relief for transactions involving development. Once we get past 1 April, if the relief is not introduced, a developer will see that it will cost more to do a project in Scotland and that the margin would be lower than it would be if it were done in Newcastle. That could well lead to the developer deciding to do the project in Newcastle.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

However, in the scheme of things, is that not quite a small factor? I presume that the first issue is demand—developers want to build where there is demand, which is why people keep building in London despite the fact that the costs are absolutely huge. Would it be the case that demand is the most important thing and that the issue of tax is pretty minimal?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

That is not necessarily the case—not in the way that the costings for such projects work. The imposition of a tax charge in Scotland that does not exist in England could mean that a project in Scotland would not be viable whereas a project in England would be. It is a simple sum: the developer adds in a tax charge that is not there in the other location, looks at the numbers and says, “Well, I’ll go for the one in Newcastle rather than the one in Scotland.” That would be a shame, which is why we are extremely encouraged by the fact that the Scottish Government proposes to introduce the sub-sale development relief to address that possibility.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

I still feel that you have not answered my question about the relative importance of the tax, but I cannot force you to do that if you do not want to.

The other subject concerns the term “significant development”. As a layperson, that seems vague to me, but your response suggests that you are quite comfortable with that.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

The problem with the previous iteration of the proposal was that it was too rigid. It said that planning permission was required, whereas, in fact, a lot of development activities do not need planning permission. It needs to be one of those tests that are a bit like the elephant test—you can recognise one when you see it, but it is quite hard to describe it. That is a bit unsatisfactory because it is a bit subjective, but most of the time it will be possible to see whether there is significant development.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Will we end up with a lot of wrangles in which developers say that something is significant but Revenue Scotland says that it is not?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

I would not have thought so; I hope that there will be detailed guidance. Time will tell, once we have some experience of what view Revenue Scotland will take of these things. In many projects, it will be obvious that there is going to be significant development; there will be an enormous development agreement that has been negotiated and a plan to build an office building, a hotel or whatever.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Following on from what the convener was saying, at a previous meeting it was suggested to the committee that mid-market rent is often about 80 per cent of private rent—I do not know whether that is a figure that you are comfortable with. It strikes me that, although it is called mid-market rent, it is really just a slightly cheaper version of private rent. It can be compared with social rent, which is heavily subsidised. Do you see it in that way?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I am not sure that I entirely agree with that; the rent differences can be significant. I think that 80 per cent would be the maximum that might be charged as a proportion of private rent, but it really can make a big difference.

To go back to the examples in Glasgow that I talked about, we are talking about providing quality housing that people have security around. That housing is well managed, and people would not be able to access it otherwise. Therefore, it would be unfair to characterise mid-market rent as being virtually the same as private rent. It has a distinctly different market. As I said in my answers to the convener, it cannot be achieved without either land at nil value or the provision of subsidy.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

I presume that, in a sense, it does not really matter whether you get away with paying a lot less tax or get a bit of a grant or a subsidy. I take it that you will look at the net figures.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I suppose that that is true, but I also argue that there will always be pressures on the level of grants that are available to subsidise new-build council housing, new-build affordable rent by associations and mid-market rents, so anything that can be done to keep the costs down and make the grants go further would be the best approach. However, I take your point that, if the scheme goes ahead and gets the grant—

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

There is a fear for the committee, which we have faced with the question whether we should have relief for eco-friendly houses, or whatever they were called in the past. As soon as we bring in a relief, somebody out there will start to try to use it as a loophole; they will pretend that they are a housing association or something else. However, we can target a grant or a subsidy—we can say that only SFHA members or whoever will get it. I would see that approach as being more effective, but maybe it does matter too much from your point of view.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I take your point, but I cannot really comment on it. I am not an expert on taxation or the dangers of creating loopholes, but I hope that it would be possible to frame a relief in such a way that it clearly specified what rent could be charged in order to be eligible for it and who could provide the housing. Therefore, I would have thought that that situation could be avoided. However, I take your point. The committee and the Government must absolutely be wary of introducing any reliefs that could be used as loopholes.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

Thank you.

Paragraph 5 of your paper talks about back-to-back land sales. I think that that is where we are with sub-sale relief. You say:

“It is our understanding”—

it is mine, too—

“that while the SSI has introduced a new schedule which provides that a developer purchasing land ... will get relief from LBTT, the purchasing association or subsidiary would still have to pay LBTT”.

I think that, instead of two people paying tax, only one will.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

However, you are arguing that nobody should pay it.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I agree that the change is an improvement on the previous situation, but my argument is consistent with my other argument. Mid-market rent is a provision that needs subsidy that would not be provided for the market, so I am arguing that it should have relief from tax. However, I fully take your point that the change is an improvement on the previous position. That is the case from our members’ point of view.

John Mason SNP Glasgow Shettleston
link

In the annex on the last page of your submission, you give an example that relates to multiple dwellings relief. If I am reading the figures correctly, we are talking about a purchase of £4 million, and the extra tax is £2,562. By my calculation, that is 0.064 per cent. That is not significant, is it?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

No. It is similar to the previous question. The situation now is a big improvement, from the point of view of mid-market rent, on the situation that existed when I came to speak to the committee before Christmas. To go back to my previous answer, I suppose that what I am arguing is that, given that it is a form of housing development that needs subsidy, mid-market rent housing should be exempt from tax. However, I take your point that the increase is not significant.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

My questions are for Mr Stewart, on relief on multiple property acquisitions. The convener mentioned buyers of properties costing under £160,000. In Aberdeen, in my region of North East Scotland, that would be significantly below mid-market, so for us it is a significant issue. Can you clarify, beyond any argument over an exemption, whether the current proposals would be financially detrimental compared with stamp duty in terms of developing such properties?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes, they are detrimental. They are not so significantly detrimental as the proposals were prior to the introduction of the Scottish statutory instrument that we are discussing, but they would still be marginally detrimental. For areas such as Aberdeen or Edinburgh, anything that can be done to reduce costs and allow mid-market provision would be a good thing.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

In places like Aberdeen, a saving of 20 or 30 per cent is 20 or 30 per cent of a very high rent and can make a huge difference. Is it fair to say that you do not think that an exemption would place a significant financial burden on the Scottish Government, but that it could be of real benefit in pursuing more of those mid-market schemes?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes—very much so. On the scale of mid-market rent, the most significant provider in Scotland is, as far as I am aware, Dunedin Canmore Housing Association, which has provided several hundred such properties over about 10 years. By comparison with the numbers of homes that have been developed for sale, or even for social rent, annually by associations and councils, we are not talking about a huge number. However, to answer the second part of your question, it could make a difference by making a scheme affordable and workable in a place such as Aberdeen or Edinburgh.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

John Mason mentioned potential misuse of an exemption. I presume that it is, given the regulation of housing associations, quite hard to pretend to be a housing association.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Something could be written in to say that the body must, for example, be a subsidiary of a charitable association. The sector is quite strictly regulated by the Scottish Housing Regulator and by the Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator, so I hope that it would be possible to draft legislation that would make it impossible for that to happen.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

You mentioned issues regarding the development of housing association homes by their non-charitable subsidiaries. How does that work in practice? How many housing associations have such subsidiaries?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Quite a few do, and the number is increasing. Development of homes by non-charitable subsidiaries happens because housing associations are largely charities and have strict rules and are strictly regulated, so it is generally not possible for them to provide homes for sale for shared ownership or homes for mid-market rent, because that would not meet their charitable objective of housing those who are in greatest housing need. As far as mid-market rent goes, the developer has to be the non-charitable subsidiary of an association that provides and manages such properties, and that is where they get caught up in the tax.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

In dialogue and negotiation with the Scottish Government, why has it not been more receptive to the proposal for an exemption, or at least to ensuring that the proposal is not financially detrimental?

10:30

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I cannot be certain, but associations and subsidiaries being quite negatively impacted by the initial proposals would be an unintended consequence of the fact that the tax aims to move the burden of taxation from higher-value properties to lower-value properties. Because associations and subsidiaries might be developing groups of properties or buying significant pieces of land, there might be a detrimental impact. The Scottish Government has responded by introducing the sub-sale relief, which means that the detriment would not be so great, but it is a service that meets a need that is not met by the market, so it should be exempt.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

You said that the Scottish Government is trying to shift the burden from higher to lower-priced properties; did you mean to say it the other way around?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I am sorry. Yes—that was a slip of the tongue. I meant quite the opposite to what I said.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

I will continue on the same theme. Edinburgh has similar housing problems to Aberdeen, perhaps; there is not a lot of social rented housing and people cannot afford private rents or to buy. Mid-market rent is therefore very important in Edinburgh, so I was initially attracted to your proposal, although we will obviously have to interrogate it a bit. Many people have done that so there might not be much for us to do, to be honest.

The comparison with stamp duty land tax did not come to a large differential but I presume that a total exemption would mean a much bigger benefit.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Yes—absolutely.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

If we do not get that, would the supply of mid-market houses for rent be affected or could it mean that the mid-market rents would be slightly higher than they would otherwise be? What do you think the effect would be? In other words what would the effect of an exemption be? Will it affect supply or rents or both?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

It will probably affect supply. Mid-market rent can really work only within a parameter and it cannot really be raised above that otherwise it will not meet the distinct need. It will almost become a slightly cheaper private rent.

There would be a benefit in that it might enable certain schemes to go ahead that might not otherwise have happened and that would increase supply. Alternatively—I do not think that this would be a huge impact—it would mean that the amount of grant that is available to fund mid-market rent or socially rented housing would go slightly further.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

We will certainly raise those points with the cabinet secretary in a little while. Stated policy is, particularly in places such as Edinburgh and Aberdeen, to increase the number of homes for mid-market rent, so we will put it to him that the supply might be affected as an unintended consequence. He might have some response to that that we cannot anticipate, but I do not think that there would be a great deal of scope for loopholes. We will wait to see what the cabinet secretary says. Thank you for drawing it to our attention.

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Thank you.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

In case the witnesses were wondering, Gavin Brown has left because has been taken unwell.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

As Malcolm Chisholm has said, we have given the issue quite a good go but there is something that I would like you to clarify about your proposals. Have you calculated how much revenue would not be realised as a consequence of this decision? LBTT was introduced as a revenue-neutral scheme, and any exemptions or otherwise that might impact on income would affect that neutrality. Have you done any calculations or educated guesswork on what the results of an exemption would be?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Not as yet. As I have said in response to previous questions, mid-market rent is a relatively niche provision at the moment. That is not to say that it is not important; it just does not constitute a high proportion of new-build housing developments in Scotland. If time allows, I am happy to look into the issue with member housing associations and, indeed, the Scottish Government, which I am sure will be able to provide statistical returns and will know how many mid-market rent schemes or properties were developed in the past financial year. I do not think that it would be difficult to go beyond that and work out broadly what tax would have been paid or lost. All that I can say is that I do not think that it would be a significant proportion of the tax, but I am happy, if time allows, to interrogate the matter further.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Richard Baker spoke about the situation in Aberdeen, which I represent, and Malcolm Chisholm mentioned the situation in Edinburgh. Have you had any direct representations from your members about specific developments that they have in the pipeline that they might put on hold or might not be able to proceed with, or on which they think there might be an impact?

David Stewart Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Not as such. The representations that I have had have been mainly from Dunedin Canmore, which sees mid-market rent as an important part of its business and an important part of the service that it provides to the community. It has looked at what the difference would be between developments built under stamp duty land tax and developments under the new tax.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I would like to pose the same question to Isobel d’Inverno, who spoke about development choices and used an example involving Newcastle and Edinburgh. I am not sure that that is always the calculation that is made by a developer, because most developers look at the need and demand in individual areas. Have you had any representations from developers or members of the Law Society of Scotland to the effect that this is a real situation as opposed to a hypothetical one?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

In relation to sub-sale development relief, lots and lots of developers have raised concerns about the fact that there is no general sub-sale relief under LBTT.

Mark McDonald SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I appreciate that they have raised that concern, but you have raised the prospect of a developer choosing to develop south of the border as opposed to north of the border. Is that a real concern? Have developers said that they would make such a decision, or is it just a hypothetical scenario that you have come up with on the basis of differentials?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

It is a real concern that has been raised by developers. The Newcastle example is obviously hypothetical, but developers have asked how the system works in Scotland and how it works in the rest of the UK, and they have mentioned the possibility of doing projects outside Scotland because of the additional cost of doing them in Scotland. That is not a hypothetical scenario. Many organisations, including the SPF, have raised the same concerns.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

I should also say that although the relief for mid-market rent that is being discussed is not something that the Law Society has considered in any great detail, we can see that it certainly deserves to be looked at further. One would imagine that it would be possible to design a relief that could not be claimed by those who did not really deserve it. There are plenty of reliefs that are focused on bodies such as housing associations, so it should not be too difficult to make it foolproof.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

I want to continue with the comparison between Newcastle and Edinburgh, albeit a slight variation on the theme. It seems to me that when developers decide where to develop they look at a large range of issues. For example, the price of land must be a consideration. It is inevitable that that will vary across the country, whether someone is developing in Shetland or Dumfries, or Newcastle or Edinburgh. On top of that, there is the cost of building materials, transport and so on. Many factors must be taken into consideration. Anyone listening to the discussion might think that the tax relief that is available is the only important issue but surely it cannot be such a big consideration in the greater scheme of things if all the other ducks are in a row.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

I believe that the issue comes down to the margins. Although the land might be cheaper in one location than in another, that is factored into the model and the price at which the finished development is sold takes that into account. However, if a tax charge is introduced in one jurisdiction that does not exist in another, that eats up the margin and means that the playing field is not level. That is why there was such concern among developers about the removal across the board of sub-sale relief from LBTT, even though people appreciated the reasons for such a move.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

Do you accept that there was also a lot of concern on the part of HM Revenue and Customs, which wanted to redesign SDLT because this issue was one of the biggest loopholes in tax avoidance?

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

Yes.

Jean Urquhart Ind Highlands and Islands
link

Tightening up those loopholes was seen as being of key importance.

Given that Westminster seems to have followed the changes that the Scottish Government has made in certain areas, this situation, too, could change elsewhere. In other words, sub-sale relief might not be available in Newcastle in due course.

Isobel d’Inverno Law Society of Scotland
link

The thing is that the UK Government considered sub-sale relief in relation to SDLT and even after taking into account everything that it knew about avoidance, it decided to continue it under SDLT. Under SDLT, sub-sale relief is available for any sub-sale transaction. The rules have been tightened up, in that it is now necessary to claim the relief, but it is available for all transactions. There is quite a difference between LBTT and SDLT in that respect. After April, people will pay LBTT on these transactions in Scotland, but they will not pay SDLT on the same transactions in the rest of the UK. As a result, it is important that we put in place a sub-sale development relief that is targeted at transactions for which such relief is terribly important—but without creating a vehicle for avoidance, which I am sure we will not have done, assuming that the order is passed.

Kenneth Gibson SNP The Convener · Cunninghame North
link

That concludes the committee’s deliberations. I thank the witnesses very much for their evidence.

We will have a one-minute suspension to allow for a change of witnesses.

10:42 Meeting suspended.

10:44 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 89
  3. 10:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 101
  4. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  5. 12:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.