Former MSP
Malcolm Chisholm
Previously: Minister for Communities (2004–06) · Minister for Health and Community Care (2001–04) · +1 more
At a glance
7,733 contributions in debates and committees 196 motions lodged 362 questions asked 85 oral questions
Co-signing and interests
Session 4 (2011–2016)Most often on the same motions as: Iain Gray Lab (352), Sarah Boyack Lab (512), Neil Findlay Lab (589).
Distinctive phrases
All speeches →- public involvement 173
- leith 245
- community care 367
- health community 243
- primary care 346
- patient focus 56
- health improvement 143
- health council 101
Words and pairs this MSP uses far more than other members do (TF-IDF over their Official Report contributions), with mention counts.
How they voted on key votes
All key votes →- 17 Mar 2016✓ For Carried
- 16 Mar 2016✓ For Carried
- 8 Mar 2016✓ For Carried
- 25 Feb 2016✓ For Defeated
- 25 Feb 2016✗ Against Carried
How this is worked out
Vote type, bill stage, free votes and key votes are worked out by this site from titles, dates and how each party split. They are not the Parliament’s own classification.
- Votes and motions are linked to this bill when the motion title names it and the date falls within the bill’s passage.
- Stage comes from the motion title or, failing that, the bill’s stage dates.
- Free vote means two or more parties each split by 15% or more, with ten or more MSPs off their party line. It is a likely sign, not a record of a free vote being declared.
- Key vote means a bill’s Stage 1 or final vote, a budget vote, a likely free vote, or a margin of three or fewer.
Broke with their party
4 times →- 20 Jan 2015✗ Against Defeated
- 24 May 2012✓ For Carried
- 14 Mar 2012✓ For Carried
Latest in the chamber
All 7,733 →-
Burial and Cremation (Scotland) Bill
I pay tribute to Nanette Milne for the massive contribution that she has made on health and other issues during her 13 years in the Parliament. I have enjoyed working with her for…
-
Burial and Cremation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3
At stage 1, the minister said—and I totally agreed with her—that “In setting out what will happen after a pregnancy loss, the bill ensures that the woman who has experienced the l…
-
Abusive Behaviour and Sexual Harm (Scotland) Bill
I do not want to fall out with the Presiding Officer on my second last day, but is not one of the great advantages of having the same committee carrying out inquiries and scrutini…
Works with
Backs their motions most
- Tom McCabe Lab 55
- Mary Mulligan Lab 52
- Jackie Baillie Lab 39
- Johann Lamont Lab 35
- Hugh Henry Lab 32
Whose motions they back most
- Sarah Boyack Lab 96
- Jackie Baillie Lab 72
- Neil Findlay Lab 70
- Christina McKelvie SNP 44
- Elaine Smith Lab 44
Most similar sitting MSPs
- Jackie Baillie Lab 62% similar
- Mark Griffin Lab 57% similar
- Claire Baker Lab 56% similar
- Neil Bibby Lab 55% similar
- Liam McArthur LD 38% similar
Similarity blends voting record, motion support and topics.
Career
Full career →- Seats
- Edinburgh Northern and Leith (constituency) 2011–16 · Edinburgh North and Leith (constituency) 1999–2011
- Government
- Minister for Communities 2004–06 · Minister for Health and Community Care 2001–04 · Deputy Minister for Health and Community Care 2000–01