Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01780 · Session 5

Consultation on the closure of large shops on New Year's Day

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2019 Business & Industry
Signatures
0
2,040 online signatures with a country
Comments
188
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to launch a consultation on implementing legislation already in place to ban large shops from opening on New Year’s Day.

What the petitioner did first

Usdaw has previously written to James Hepburn, Minister for Business, Fair Work and Skills, asking that the Government launch a consultation on the issue.
The organisation has been advised that the Government does not intend to commission research into the impact of trading by large stores on New Year’s Day.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 20 Feb 2020
    1 mention
  2. 8 Oct 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 16 Dec 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,040 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,408 69%
  2. United Kingdom575 28.2%
  3. England49 2.4%
  4. Northern Ireland2 0.1%
  5. France1 0%
  6. Greece1 0%
  7. Netherlands1 0%
  8. New Zealand1 0%
  9. Wales1 0%
  10. Germany1 0%

Comments

188 comments, oldest first
188 comments · showing 151–188
  1. Michael C Donaldson 20 Jan 2020
    All shops should be closed, to spend time with family and friends
  2. Helen McMunn 20 Jan 2020
    Family member has to work on New Years Day as they runs a big store. Would rather they were home with their family.
  3. Marion mcgovern 20 Jan 2020
    Only 2 days a year ,they are taking it away from us ,people in the past fought for these holidays,also not good for those who drive as they cannot celebrate the night before .
  4. Mrs judith page 20 Jan 2020
    100% agree
  5. Heather Turner 20 Jan 2020
    This should be family time. My family are off 2 weeks through Christmas and new year and we hardly have time together over this period as I have to work. Smaller corner shops stay open. We wont starve.
  6. Wendy Anderson 20 Jan 2020
    Convenience store I work in opens please change this
    ..
  7. Carole-Anne paterson 20 Jan 2020
    I worked a 8 hour shift this past new year & had to deal with verbal abuse for refusing someone who was very drunk, shiplifters & moans & complaints that we never had fresh bread delivery etc. Yep happy new year to us shop workers huh!!
  8. Carole-Anne paterson 20 Jan 2020
    I worked a 8 hour shift this past new year & had to deal with verbal abuse for refusing someone who was very drunk, shiplifters & moans & complaints that we never had fresh bread delivery etc. Yep happy new year to us shop workers huh!!
  9. Daniel Boyle 20 Jan 2020
    we should have 2 days off at Xmas and new year one day off should not be described, as the holiday's in my book it's a day off, no more .
  10. Stephen Foster 20 Jan 2020
    Totally agree against all holiday opening nit fair on families
  11. Patricia Dorsett 20 Jan 2020
    Iive been in retail for many years since I was 16 years old, I'm now 54 and seen many many changes in how consumer greed is the main reason that large retail outlets and convenience stores have to open on boxing day and new years day it's totally unnecessary, and unfair to those of us who are employed in these positions. There was a time that shops shut for a whole week so it was a proper Christmas holiday, gone are those days but I wish it could be brought back, consumers aren't going to starve just because the shops are shut for one extra day, greed and selfishness is what forces retailers to bow to the consumers demands.
    This whole situation seriously needs an overhaul.
  12. Jill McDonald 20 Jan 2020
    Keep hearing about family values then through greed be expected to work over special holidays and then we are not missing time with our families no special memories apart from exhaustion through over worked
  13. SHIRLEY MCLAUGHLAN 20 Jan 2020
    100% close all stores and spend quality time with our family
  14. Margaret Hamilton 20 Jan 2020
    Let people spend more quality family time
  15. Anne McGuire 20 Jan 2020
    100% agree. Everyone should be able to spend quality time with family and friends at this time of year. Life is too short.
  16. Graham Gardner 20 Jan 2020
    Well if this works itll be the first thing usdaw has done that's good for me.
  17. Azam Goodarzy 20 Jan 2020
    These few years were not like Xmas or New year at all with shops being open on Boxing day and New years day. We would like to spend time with our family with out any stress , is it to much to ask?
  18. Calum Boydon 20 Jan 2020
    There is not enough holiday entitlement
    I retail sector
  19. Alistair Pollock 20 Jan 2020
    New year is a family time, to be spent with family and loved ones, visiting those no longer with us and making plans for the year to come. NOT WORKING
  20. linda mcilwraith 20 Jan 2020
    Xmas day, boxing day, 1st and 2nd jan all shops should be shut so people can spend time with their families
  21. Atis KUKURS 20 Jan 2020
    In most of Europe everything is closed for Christmas and New Year. Why to create a new wheel if it works in many other countries? Business is not going down but many people are more happy to be relaxed and together with their loved ones.
  22. Louisa McNeill 21 Jan 2020
    100 percent should be closed
  23. Claire Davies 21 Jan 2020
    I agree
  24. Sandra Ferguson 21 Jan 2020
    Spend more time with family.
  25. Franco Barbato 21 Jan 2020
    Totally agree

    Totally agree
  26. John Allan 21 Jan 2020
    Thank you Usdaw for organising against the bullying and threatening of some companies who are only interested in money and couldn't care or even think about the folk who produce the profit they enjoy . I bet you they make sure they get there holiday when they want it .
  27. Amelia Mains 21 Jan 2020
    Shops should be closed on new years day and the 2nd so shop workers can spend time with their families and friends.
  28. Sheila Robertson 21 Jan 2020
    Would love to spend time with family & friends at New year
  29. William Keogh 21 Jan 2020
    We don't open on new years day,but I don't think any shop should be open on this day.
  30. Alison Gow 21 Jan 2020
    All shops should be closed on new years day staff need time to spend with family
  31. John Revie 21 Jan 2020
    Make time for families instead of making more profits for capitalists.
  32. Julie Lofthouse 22 Jan 2020
    We should also have 1-2 week breaks for holidays with our children in summer to co inside with school holidays like we used to have.
  33. David Stevenson 22 Jan 2020
    Everyone deserves a decent break.
  34. Tracey Collison 22 Jan 2020
    Having worked in retail for over 17 years it would be amazing to have time off with my grandchildren as I missed out so much with my own children
  35. Joe Passmore 22 Jan 2020
    Working people are the reason that we have commerce. They are the main commodity that businesses cannot do without. Respect your workers, respect their families and the will respect you.
  36. Jo Fisk 22 Jan 2020
    New Year is a splendid tradition in Scotland and should be upheld for family and friends to gather together.
  37. Jo Crumplin 22 Jan 2020
    Solidarity with my colleagues in Scotland. Staff deserve a decent break, and time with thier families.
  38. Ann Morgan 22 Jan 2020
    Just a personal comment that I am sure can be replicated. A family member had worked 10 days in a row during the festive period. They were unable to join a family gathering. Their retail job is demanding.Its time to look at pay and conditions and holidays for retail workers.